{
  "arguments": [
    {
      "citationRefs": [
        "cit-baladhuri-chain-matn",
        "cit-salim-hukm-irsal"
      ],
      "evidenceRefs": [
        "cit-baladhuri-chain-matn",
        "cit-salim-hukm-irsal"
      ],
      "id": "arg-irsal-verdict",
      "illaRefs": [
        "illa-salim-irsal"
      ],
      "kind": "isnad",
      "limitations": "خريطة شرح لطريق واحد، لا استقصاء. لا تعين واضعاً، ولا تحكم بوقوع تدليس الأعمش في هذا الفرد. شريط الكوفة نسبة بلد في الترجمة، لا مكان أداء معين. لم يستكمل توثيق مصر أبي عوانة وخلف أو الحكم عليهما في هذه الحزمة؛ تركا غير معينين، والإطار الرمادي ليس جرحاً.",
      "riwayaRefs": [
        "riwaya-baladhuri-5-136"
      ],
      "scope": "sample",
      "statement": "لا يثبت الرفع بهذا الطريق عند اشتراط الاتصال؛ فتوثيق المسمين لا يزيل الإرسال فوق سالم.",
      "target": "verdict"
    }
  ],
  "citations": [
    {
      "attribution": null,
      "cardRef": null,
      "discovery": null,
      "id": "cit-baladhuri-chain-matn",
      "kind": "evidence",
      "label": "حدثني خلف بن هشام البزاز حدثنا أبو عوانة عن الأعمش عن سالم بن أبي الجعد قال، قال رسول الله ﷺ: «معاوية في تابوت مقفل عليه في جهنم».",
      "limitations": null,
      "locator": {
        "display": "البلاذري، أنساب الأشراف، تحقيق زكار وزركلي، ط1،1417هـ/1996م، ج5، ص136؛ المتسلسل1980"
      },
      "mode": "quoted",
      "note": "النص المقابل على الصفحة؛ لا يتضمن حكم تصحيح من البلاذري.",
      "quote": "حدثني خلف بن هشام البزاز حدثنا أبو عوانة عن الأعمش عن سالم بن أبي الجعد قال، قال رسول الله ﷺ: «معاوية في تابوت مقفل عليه في جهنم».",
      "sourceId": "source-muawiya-tabut-amash-scans",
      "sourceRef": "source-muawiya-tabut-amash-scans",
      "speaker": null,
      "summary": null,
      "url": null,
      "verification": "verified_scan",
      "verificationLimits": null
    },
    {
      "attribution": null,
      "cardRef": null,
      "discovery": null,
      "id": "cit-salim-identity",
      "kind": "evidence",
      "label": "سالم بن أبي الجعد: رافع الغطفاني الأشجعي مولاهم، الكوفي",
      "limitations": null,
      "locator": {
        "display": "ابن حجر، تقريب التهذيب، تحقيق عوامة، دار الرشيد، ط3 المصححة،1411هـ/1991م، ص226، ت2170",
        "item": "2170"
      },
      "mode": "quoted",
      "note": "مقابل على صورة ص226 من طبعة عوامة الثالثة المصححة1411هـ/1991م؛ سالم بن أبي الجعد غير سالم بن أبي حفصة.",
      "quote": "سالم بن أبي الجعد: رافع الغطفاني الأشجعي مولاهم، الكوفي",
      "sourceId": "source-muawiya-tabut-amash-scans",
      "sourceRef": "source-muawiya-tabut-amash-scans",
      "speaker": null,
      "summary": null,
      "url": null,
      "verification": "verified_scan",
      "verificationLimits": null
    },
    {
      "attribution": null,
      "cardRef": null,
      "discovery": null,
      "id": "cit-salim-hukm-irsal",
      "kind": "evidence",
      "label": "ثقة وكان يرسل كثيراً، من الثالثة",
      "limitations": null,
      "locator": {
        "display": "ابن حجر، تقريب التهذيب، تحقيق عوامة، دار الرشيد، ط3 المصححة،1411هـ/1991م، ص226، ت2170",
        "item": "2170"
      },
      "mode": "quoted",
      "note": "هذا توثيق للراوي مع وصف إرساله؛ لا تصحيح لهذا الخبر.",
      "quote": "ثقة وكان يرسل كثيراً، من الثالثة",
      "sourceId": "source-muawiya-tabut-amash-scans",
      "sourceRef": "source-muawiya-tabut-amash-scans",
      "speaker": null,
      "summary": null,
      "url": null,
      "verification": "verified_scan",
      "verificationLimits": null
    },
    {
      "attribution": null,
      "cardRef": null,
      "discovery": null,
      "id": "cit-salim-city",
      "kind": "evidence",
      "label": "الكوفي",
      "limitations": null,
      "locator": {
        "display": "ابن حجر، تقريب التهذيب، تحقيق عوامة، دار الرشيد، ط3 المصححة،1411هـ/1991م، ص226، ت2170",
        "item": "2170"
      },
      "mode": "quoted",
      "note": "نسبة البلد في الترجمة؛ مكان أداء هذا الخبر غير معين. لا تثبت انحصار إنشاء المتن في الكوفة.",
      "quote": "الكوفي",
      "sourceId": "source-muawiya-tabut-amash-scans",
      "sourceRef": "source-muawiya-tabut-amash-scans",
      "speaker": null,
      "summary": null,
      "url": null,
      "verification": "verified_scan",
      "verificationLimits": null
    },
    {
      "attribution": null,
      "cardRef": null,
      "discovery": null,
      "id": "cit-amash-identity",
      "kind": "evidence",
      "label": "سليمان بن مهران الأسدي الكاهلي أبو محمد الكوفي الأعمش",
      "limitations": null,
      "locator": {
        "display": "ابن حجر، تقريب التهذيب، ط3 المصححة،1411هـ/1991م، ص254، ت2615",
        "item": "2615"
      },
      "mode": "quoted",
      "note": "التعريف بالاسم من الترجمة المقابلة، وصيغة الاسم في إسناد البلاذري «الأعمش».",
      "quote": "سليمان بن مهران الأسدي الكاهلي أبو محمد الكوفي الأعمش",
      "sourceId": "source-amash-bukhari-usul-mutabaat-scans",
      "sourceRef": "source-amash-bukhari-usul-mutabaat-scans",
      "speaker": null,
      "summary": null,
      "url": null,
      "verification": "verified_scan",
      "verificationLimits": null
    },
    {
      "attribution": null,
      "cardRef": null,
      "discovery": null,
      "id": "cit-amash-city",
      "kind": "evidence",
      "label": "الكوفي",
      "limitations": null,
      "locator": {
        "display": "ابن حجر، تقريب التهذيب، ط3 المصححة،1411هـ/1991م، ص254، ت2615",
        "item": "2615"
      },
      "mode": "quoted",
      "note": "نسبة البلد في الترجمة؛ مكان أداء هذا الخبر غير معين. لا تثبت انحصار إنشاء المتن في الكوفة.",
      "quote": "الكوفي",
      "sourceId": "source-amash-bukhari-usul-mutabaat-scans",
      "sourceRef": "source-amash-bukhari-usul-mutabaat-scans",
      "speaker": null,
      "summary": null,
      "url": null,
      "verification": "verified_scan",
      "verificationLimits": null
    },
    {
      "attribution": null,
      "cardRef": null,
      "discovery": null,
      "id": "cit-amash-hukm",
      "kind": "evidence",
      "label": "ثقة حافظ عارف بالقراءات ورع لكنه يدلس",
      "limitations": null,
      "locator": {
        "display": "ابن حجر، تقريب التهذيب، ط3 المصححة،1411هـ/1991م، ص254، ت2615",
        "item": "2615"
      },
      "mode": "quoted",
      "note": "الرتبة العامة ووصف التدليس لا يثبتان اتصال هذا الفرد ولا تعمد وضعه.",
      "quote": "ثقة حافظ عارف بالقراءات ورع لكنه يدلس",
      "sourceId": "source-amash-bukhari-usul-mutabaat-scans",
      "sourceRef": "source-amash-bukhari-usul-mutabaat-scans",
      "speaker": null,
      "summary": null,
      "url": null,
      "verification": "verified_scan",
      "verificationLimits": null
    }
  ],
  "dependencyHash": "edf3097366287400",
  "diagnostics": {
    "errors": [],
    "warnings": [
      "evidenceStatus=incomplete: 2/24 hotspots تحتاج تعيين المصدر والموضع"
    ]
  },
  "evidenceStatus": "incomplete",
  "illal": [
    {
      "citationRefs": [
        "cit-baladhuri-chain-matn",
        "cit-salim-hukm-irsal"
      ],
      "evidenceRefs": [
        "cit-baladhuri-chain-matn",
        "cit-salim-hukm-irsal"
      ],
      "id": "illa-salim-irsal",
      "kind": "irsal",
      "label": "إرسال سالم",
      "matnRefs": [],
      "riwayaRefs": [
        "riwaya-baladhuri-5-136"
      ],
      "subject": {
        "id": "irsal_gap",
        "kind": "node"
      },
      "target": "node:irsal_gap",
      "text": "سالم بن أبي الجعد من طبقة التابعين، ويقول هنا: قال رسول الله؛ لم تسم الواسطة أو الوسائط. هذا تحليل للصيغة المصورة مع ترجمته، لا نقل لحكم ناقد على هذا الفرد بعينه."
    }
  ],
  "interactionIndex": {
    "hotspots": {
      "argument:arg-irsal-verdict": {
        "argumentRefs": [
          "arg-irsal-verdict"
        ],
        "cardRefs": [],
        "citationRefs": [
          "cit-baladhuri-chain-matn",
          "cit-salim-hukm-irsal"
        ],
        "evidenceRefs": [
          "cit-baladhuri-chain-matn",
          "cit-salim-hukm-irsal"
        ],
        "icon": {
          "kindLabel": "حجة الدراسة",
          "meaning": "الدعوى وأدلتها وحدودها",
          "status": "documented",
          "statusLabel": "إحالة موضعية مقابلة",
          "summary": "لا يثبت الرفع بهذا الطريق عند اشتراط الاتصال؛ فتوثيق المسمين لا يزيل الإرسال فوق سالم. — خريطة شرح لطريق واحد، لا استقصاء. لا تعين واضعاً، ولا تحكم بوقوع تدليس الأعمش في هذا الفرد. شريط الكوفة نسبة بلد في الترجمة، لا مكان أداء معين. لم يستكمل توثيق مصر أبي عوانة وخلف أو الحكم عليهما في هذه الحزمة؛ تركا غير معينين، والإطار الرمادي ليس جرحاً."
        },
        "id": "argument:arg-irsal-verdict",
        "illaRefs": [],
        "kind": "argument",
        "label": "لا يثبت الرفع بهذا الطريق عند اشتراط الاتصال؛ فتوثيق المسمين لا يزيل الإرسال فوق سالم.",
        "matnRefs": [],
        "rendered": true,
        "requiresPinpoint": false,
        "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [
          "cit-baladhuri-chain-matn",
          "cit-salim-hukm-irsal"
        ],
        "riwayaRefs": [
          "riwaya-baladhuri-5-136"
        ],
        "sourceRefs": [
          "source-muawiya-tabut-amash-scans"
        ],
        "supportLevel": "exact",
        "target": {
          "argumentId": "arg-irsal-verdict"
        },
        "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": []
      },
      "city:abu_awana": {
        "argumentRefs": [],
        "cardRefs": [],
        "citationRefs": [],
        "evidenceRefs": [],
        "icon": {
          "kindLabel": "مصر النقل",
          "meaning": "المصر المسجل ومرجعه؛ البيئة وحدها ليست جرحاً",
          "status": "missing",
          "statusLabel": "لم تسجل إحالة موضعية لهذا الحقل",
          "summary": "أبو عوانة: غير معيّن"
        },
        "id": "city:abu_awana",
        "illaRefs": [],
        "kind": "city",
        "label": "أبو عوانة: غير معيّن",
        "matnRefs": [],
        "rendered": true,
        "requiresPinpoint": true,
        "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [],
        "riwayaRefs": [],
        "sourceRefs": [],
        "supportLevel": "unresolved",
        "target": {
          "field": "city",
          "nodeId": "abu_awana"
        },
        "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": []
      },
      "city:amash": {
        "argumentRefs": [],
        "cardRefs": [],
        "citationRefs": [
          "cit-amash-city"
        ],
        "evidenceRefs": [
          "cit-amash-city"
        ],
        "icon": {
          "kindLabel": "مصر النقل",
          "meaning": "المصر المسجل ومرجعه؛ البيئة وحدها ليست جرحاً",
          "status": "documented",
          "statusLabel": "إحالة موضعية مقابلة",
          "summary": "الأعمش: سليمان بن مهران: الكوفة"
        },
        "id": "city:amash",
        "illaRefs": [],
        "kind": "city",
        "label": "الأعمش: سليمان بن مهران: الكوفة",
        "matnRefs": [],
        "rendered": true,
        "requiresPinpoint": false,
        "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [
          "cit-amash-city"
        ],
        "riwayaRefs": [],
        "sourceRefs": [
          "source-amash-bukhari-usul-mutabaat-scans"
        ],
        "supportLevel": "exact",
        "target": {
          "field": "city",
          "nodeId": "amash"
        },
        "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": []
      },
      "city:khalaf": {
        "argumentRefs": [],
        "cardRefs": [],
        "citationRefs": [],
        "evidenceRefs": [],
        "icon": {
          "kindLabel": "مصر النقل",
          "meaning": "المصر المسجل ومرجعه؛ البيئة وحدها ليست جرحاً",
          "status": "missing",
          "statusLabel": "لم تسجل إحالة موضعية لهذا الحقل",
          "summary": "خلف بن هشام البزاز: غير معيّن"
        },
        "id": "city:khalaf",
        "illaRefs": [],
        "kind": "city",
        "label": "خلف بن هشام البزاز: غير معيّن",
        "matnRefs": [],
        "rendered": true,
        "requiresPinpoint": true,
        "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [],
        "riwayaRefs": [],
        "sourceRefs": [],
        "supportLevel": "unresolved",
        "target": {
          "field": "city",
          "nodeId": "khalaf"
        },
        "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": []
      },
      "city:salim": {
        "argumentRefs": [],
        "cardRefs": [],
        "citationRefs": [
          "cit-salim-city"
        ],
        "evidenceRefs": [
          "cit-salim-city"
        ],
        "icon": {
          "kindLabel": "مصر النقل",
          "meaning": "المصر المسجل ومرجعه؛ البيئة وحدها ليست جرحاً",
          "status": "documented",
          "statusLabel": "إحالة موضعية مقابلة",
          "summary": "سالم بن أبي الجعد: الكوفة"
        },
        "id": "city:salim",
        "illaRefs": [],
        "kind": "city",
        "label": "سالم بن أبي الجعد: الكوفة",
        "matnRefs": [],
        "rendered": true,
        "requiresPinpoint": false,
        "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [
          "cit-salim-city"
        ],
        "riwayaRefs": [],
        "sourceRefs": [
          "source-muawiya-tabut-amash-scans"
        ],
        "supportLevel": "exact",
        "target": {
          "field": "city",
          "nodeId": "salim"
        },
        "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": []
      },
      "edge:edge-abu_awana-khalaf": {
        "argumentRefs": [],
        "cardRefs": [],
        "citationRefs": [
          "cit-baladhuri-chain-matn"
        ],
        "evidenceRefs": [
          "cit-baladhuri-chain-matn"
        ],
        "icon": {
          "kindLabel": "حلقة الرواية",
          "meaning": "صلة النقل بين طرفي السهم والروايات التي تحملها",
          "status": "documented",
          "statusLabel": "إحالة موضعية مقابلة",
          "summary": "حدثنا"
        },
        "id": "edge:edge-abu_awana-khalaf",
        "illaRefs": [],
        "kind": "edge",
        "label": "حدثنا",
        "matnRefs": [],
        "rendered": true,
        "requiresPinpoint": false,
        "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [
          "cit-baladhuri-chain-matn"
        ],
        "riwayaRefs": [
          "riwaya-baladhuri-5-136"
        ],
        "sourceRefs": [
          "source-muawiya-tabut-amash-scans"
        ],
        "supportLevel": "exact",
        "target": {
          "edgeId": "edge-abu_awana-khalaf",
          "from": "abu_awana",
          "to": "khalaf"
        },
        "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": []
      },
      "edge:edge-amash-abu_awana": {
        "argumentRefs": [],
        "cardRefs": [],
        "citationRefs": [
          "cit-baladhuri-chain-matn"
        ],
        "evidenceRefs": [
          "cit-baladhuri-chain-matn"
        ],
        "icon": {
          "kindLabel": "حلقة الرواية",
          "meaning": "صلة النقل بين طرفي السهم والروايات التي تحملها",
          "status": "documented",
          "statusLabel": "إحالة موضعية مقابلة",
          "summary": "عن"
        },
        "id": "edge:edge-amash-abu_awana",
        "illaRefs": [],
        "kind": "edge",
        "label": "عن",
        "matnRefs": [],
        "rendered": true,
        "requiresPinpoint": false,
        "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [
          "cit-baladhuri-chain-matn"
        ],
        "riwayaRefs": [
          "riwaya-baladhuri-5-136"
        ],
        "sourceRefs": [
          "source-muawiya-tabut-amash-scans"
        ],
        "supportLevel": "exact",
        "target": {
          "edgeId": "edge-amash-abu_awana",
          "from": "amash",
          "to": "abu_awana"
        },
        "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": []
      },
      "edge:edge-irsal_gap-salim": {
        "argumentRefs": [],
        "cardRefs": [],
        "citationRefs": [
          "cit-baladhuri-chain-matn",
          "cit-salim-hukm-irsal"
        ],
        "evidenceRefs": [
          "cit-baladhuri-chain-matn",
          "cit-salim-hukm-irsal"
        ],
        "icon": {
          "kindLabel": "حلقة الرواية",
          "meaning": "صلة النقل بين طرفي السهم والروايات التي تحملها",
          "status": "documented",
          "statusLabel": "إحالة موضعية مقابلة",
          "summary": "«قال: قال رسول الله»"
        },
        "id": "edge:edge-irsal_gap-salim",
        "illaRefs": [
          "illa-salim-irsal"
        ],
        "kind": "edge",
        "label": "«قال: قال رسول الله»",
        "matnRefs": [],
        "rendered": true,
        "requiresPinpoint": false,
        "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [
          "cit-baladhuri-chain-matn",
          "cit-salim-hukm-irsal"
        ],
        "riwayaRefs": [
          "riwaya-baladhuri-5-136"
        ],
        "sourceRefs": [
          "source-muawiya-tabut-amash-scans"
        ],
        "supportLevel": "exact",
        "target": {
          "edgeId": "edge-irsal_gap-salim",
          "from": "irsal_gap",
          "to": "salim"
        },
        "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": []
      },
      "edge:edge-khalaf-baladhuri": {
        "argumentRefs": [],
        "cardRefs": [],
        "citationRefs": [
          "cit-baladhuri-chain-matn"
        ],
        "evidenceRefs": [
          "cit-baladhuri-chain-matn"
        ],
        "icon": {
          "kindLabel": "حلقة الرواية",
          "meaning": "صلة النقل بين طرفي السهم والروايات التي تحملها",
          "status": "documented",
          "statusLabel": "إحالة موضعية مقابلة",
          "summary": "حدثني"
        },
        "id": "edge:edge-khalaf-baladhuri",
        "illaRefs": [],
        "kind": "edge",
        "label": "حدثني",
        "matnRefs": [],
        "rendered": true,
        "requiresPinpoint": false,
        "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [
          "cit-baladhuri-chain-matn"
        ],
        "riwayaRefs": [
          "riwaya-baladhuri-5-136"
        ],
        "sourceRefs": [
          "source-muawiya-tabut-amash-scans"
        ],
        "supportLevel": "exact",
        "target": {
          "edgeId": "edge-khalaf-baladhuri",
          "from": "khalaf",
          "to": "baladhuri"
        },
        "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": []
      },
      "edge:edge-nabi-irsal_gap": {
        "argumentRefs": [],
        "cardRefs": [],
        "citationRefs": [
          "cit-baladhuri-chain-matn",
          "cit-salim-hukm-irsal"
        ],
        "evidenceRefs": [
          "cit-baladhuri-chain-matn",
          "cit-salim-hukm-irsal"
        ],
        "icon": {
          "kindLabel": "حلقة الرواية",
          "meaning": "صلة النقل بين طرفي السهم والروايات التي تحملها",
          "status": "documented",
          "statusLabel": "إحالة موضعية مقابلة",
          "summary": "إرسال"
        },
        "id": "edge:edge-nabi-irsal_gap",
        "illaRefs": [
          "illa-salim-irsal"
        ],
        "kind": "edge",
        "label": "إرسال",
        "matnRefs": [],
        "rendered": true,
        "requiresPinpoint": false,
        "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [
          "cit-baladhuri-chain-matn",
          "cit-salim-hukm-irsal"
        ],
        "riwayaRefs": [
          "riwaya-baladhuri-5-136"
        ],
        "sourceRefs": [
          "source-muawiya-tabut-amash-scans"
        ],
        "supportLevel": "exact",
        "target": {
          "edgeId": "edge-nabi-irsal_gap",
          "from": "nabi",
          "to": "irsal_gap"
        },
        "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": []
      },
      "edge:edge-salim-amash": {
        "argumentRefs": [],
        "cardRefs": [],
        "citationRefs": [
          "cit-baladhuri-chain-matn"
        ],
        "evidenceRefs": [
          "cit-baladhuri-chain-matn"
        ],
        "icon": {
          "kindLabel": "حلقة الرواية",
          "meaning": "صلة النقل بين طرفي السهم والروايات التي تحملها",
          "status": "documented",
          "statusLabel": "إحالة موضعية مقابلة",
          "summary": "عن"
        },
        "id": "edge:edge-salim-amash",
        "illaRefs": [],
        "kind": "edge",
        "label": "عن",
        "matnRefs": [],
        "rendered": true,
        "requiresPinpoint": false,
        "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [
          "cit-baladhuri-chain-matn"
        ],
        "riwayaRefs": [
          "riwaya-baladhuri-5-136"
        ],
        "sourceRefs": [
          "source-muawiya-tabut-amash-scans"
        ],
        "supportLevel": "exact",
        "target": {
          "edgeId": "edge-salim-amash",
          "from": "salim",
          "to": "amash"
        },
        "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": []
      },
      "flag:amash:tadlis": {
        "argumentRefs": [],
        "cardRefs": [],
        "citationRefs": [
          "cit-amash-hukm"
        ],
        "evidenceRefs": [
          "cit-amash-hukm"
        ],
        "icon": {
          "kindLabel": "وصف الراوي",
          "meaning": "الوصف الخاص المسجل ومصدر نسبته؛ لا يستنتج من القبيلة أو المصر",
          "status": "documented",
          "statusLabel": "إحالة موضعية مقابلة",
          "summary": "الأعمش: سليمان بن مهران: تدليس"
        },
        "id": "flag:amash:tadlis",
        "illaRefs": [],
        "kind": "flag",
        "label": "الأعمش: سليمان بن مهران: تدليس",
        "matnRefs": [],
        "rendered": true,
        "requiresPinpoint": false,
        "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [
          "cit-amash-hukm"
        ],
        "riwayaRefs": [],
        "sourceRefs": [
          "source-amash-bukhari-usul-mutabaat-scans"
        ],
        "supportLevel": "exact",
        "target": {
          "field": "flags",
          "flag": "tadlis",
          "nodeId": "amash"
        },
        "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": []
      },
      "hukm:amash": {
        "argumentRefs": [],
        "cardRefs": [],
        "citationRefs": [
          "cit-amash-hukm"
        ],
        "evidenceRefs": [
          "cit-amash-hukm"
        ],
        "icon": {
          "kindLabel": "حكم الراوي",
          "meaning": "الحكم المنسوب إلى ناقد؛ لا يدل لون الأيقونة على رتبة الراوي",
          "status": "documented",
          "statusLabel": "إحالة موضعية مقابلة",
          "summary": "الأعمش: سليمان بن مهران: ثقة"
        },
        "id": "hukm:amash",
        "illaRefs": [],
        "kind": "hukm",
        "label": "الأعمش: سليمان بن مهران: ثقة",
        "matnRefs": [],
        "rendered": true,
        "requiresPinpoint": false,
        "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [
          "cit-amash-hukm"
        ],
        "riwayaRefs": [],
        "sourceRefs": [
          "source-amash-bukhari-usul-mutabaat-scans"
        ],
        "supportLevel": "exact",
        "target": {
          "field": "hukm",
          "nodeId": "amash"
        },
        "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": []
      },
      "hukm:salim": {
        "argumentRefs": [],
        "cardRefs": [],
        "citationRefs": [
          "cit-salim-hukm-irsal"
        ],
        "evidenceRefs": [
          "cit-salim-hukm-irsal"
        ],
        "icon": {
          "kindLabel": "حكم الراوي",
          "meaning": "الحكم المنسوب إلى ناقد؛ لا يدل لون الأيقونة على رتبة الراوي",
          "status": "documented",
          "statusLabel": "إحالة موضعية مقابلة",
          "summary": "سالم بن أبي الجعد: ثقة"
        },
        "id": "hukm:salim",
        "illaRefs": [],
        "kind": "hukm",
        "label": "سالم بن أبي الجعد: ثقة",
        "matnRefs": [],
        "rendered": true,
        "requiresPinpoint": false,
        "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [
          "cit-salim-hukm-irsal"
        ],
        "riwayaRefs": [],
        "sourceRefs": [
          "source-muawiya-tabut-amash-scans"
        ],
        "supportLevel": "exact",
        "target": {
          "field": "hukm",
          "nodeId": "salim"
        },
        "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": []
      },
      "illa:illa-salim-irsal": {
        "argumentRefs": [],
        "cardRefs": [],
        "citationRefs": [
          "cit-baladhuri-chain-matn",
          "cit-salim-hukm-irsal"
        ],
        "evidenceRefs": [
          "cit-baladhuri-chain-matn",
          "cit-salim-hukm-irsal"
        ],
        "icon": {
          "kindLabel": "مسألة نقدية",
          "meaning": "العلة أو الاعتراض بنطاقه ومصدره",
          "status": "documented",
          "statusLabel": "إحالة موضعية مقابلة",
          "summary": "سالم بن أبي الجعد من طبقة التابعين، ويقول هنا: قال رسول الله؛ لم تسم الواسطة أو الوسائط. هذا تحليل للصيغة المصورة مع ترجمته، لا نقل لحكم ناقد على هذا الفرد بعينه."
        },
        "id": "illa:illa-salim-irsal",
        "illaRefs": [
          "illa-salim-irsal"
        ],
        "kind": "illa",
        "label": "إرسال سالم",
        "matnRefs": [],
        "rendered": true,
        "requiresPinpoint": false,
        "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [
          "cit-baladhuri-chain-matn",
          "cit-salim-hukm-irsal"
        ],
        "riwayaRefs": [
          "riwaya-baladhuri-5-136"
        ],
        "sourceRefs": [
          "source-muawiya-tabut-amash-scans"
        ],
        "supportLevel": "exact",
        "target": {
          "id": "irsal_gap",
          "kind": "node"
        },
        "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": []
      },
      "matn:matn-tabut-short": {
        "argumentRefs": [],
        "cardRefs": [],
        "citationRefs": [
          "cit-baladhuri-chain-matn"
        ],
        "evidenceRefs": [
          "cit-baladhuri-chain-matn"
        ],
        "icon": {
          "kindLabel": "لفظ المتن",
          "meaning": "النص أو الزيادة بلفظها وموضعها",
          "status": "documented",
          "statusLabel": "إحالة موضعية مقابلة",
          "summary": "معاوية في تابوت مقفل عليه في جهنم — اللفظ القصير وحده في هذه الخريطة؛ لا تدمج فيه صيغة لسان الميزان الأطول."
        },
        "id": "matn:matn-tabut-short",
        "illaRefs": [],
        "kind": "matn",
        "label": "معاوية في تابوت مقفل عليه في جهنم",
        "matnRefs": [
          "matn-tabut-short"
        ],
        "rendered": true,
        "requiresPinpoint": false,
        "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [
          "cit-baladhuri-chain-matn"
        ],
        "riwayaRefs": [
          "riwaya-baladhuri-5-136"
        ],
        "sourceRefs": [
          "source-muawiya-tabut-amash-scans"
        ],
        "supportLevel": "exact",
        "target": {
          "id": "baladhuri",
          "kind": "node"
        },
        "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": []
      },
      "node:abu_awana": {
        "argumentRefs": [],
        "cardRefs": [],
        "citationRefs": [
          "cit-baladhuri-chain-matn"
        ],
        "evidenceRefs": [
          "cit-baladhuri-chain-matn"
        ],
        "icon": {
          "kindLabel": "الراوي أو العقدة",
          "meaning": "تعريف العنصر ونص بياناته",
          "status": "documented",
          "statusLabel": "إحالة موضعية مقابلة",
          "summary": "أبو عوانة"
        },
        "id": "node:abu_awana",
        "illaRefs": [],
        "kind": "node",
        "label": "أبو عوانة",
        "matnRefs": [],
        "rendered": true,
        "requiresPinpoint": false,
        "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [
          "cit-baladhuri-chain-matn"
        ],
        "riwayaRefs": [],
        "sourceRefs": [
          "source-muawiya-tabut-amash-scans"
        ],
        "supportLevel": "exact",
        "target": {
          "field": "identity",
          "nodeId": "abu_awana"
        },
        "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": []
      },
      "node:amash": {
        "argumentRefs": [],
        "cardRefs": [],
        "citationRefs": [
          "cit-amash-identity",
          "cit-amash-hukm"
        ],
        "evidenceRefs": [
          "cit-amash-identity",
          "cit-amash-hukm"
        ],
        "icon": {
          "kindLabel": "الراوي أو العقدة",
          "meaning": "تعريف العنصر ونص بياناته",
          "status": "documented",
          "statusLabel": "إحالة موضعية مقابلة",
          "summary": "الأعمش: سليمان بن مهران — «ثقة حافظ… لكنه يدلس»"
        },
        "id": "node:amash",
        "illaRefs": [],
        "kind": "node",
        "label": "الأعمش: سليمان بن مهران",
        "matnRefs": [],
        "rendered": true,
        "requiresPinpoint": false,
        "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [
          "cit-amash-identity",
          "cit-amash-hukm"
        ],
        "riwayaRefs": [],
        "sourceRefs": [
          "source-amash-bukhari-usul-mutabaat-scans"
        ],
        "supportLevel": "exact",
        "target": {
          "field": "identity",
          "nodeId": "amash"
        },
        "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": []
      },
      "node:baladhuri": {
        "argumentRefs": [],
        "cardRefs": [],
        "citationRefs": [
          "cit-baladhuri-chain-matn"
        ],
        "evidenceRefs": [
          "cit-baladhuri-chain-matn"
        ],
        "icon": {
          "kindLabel": "الراوي أو العقدة",
          "meaning": "تعريف العنصر ونص بياناته",
          "status": "documented",
          "statusLabel": "إحالة موضعية مقابلة",
          "summary": "البلاذري — أنساب الأشراف — «معاوية في تابوت مقفل عليه في جهنم»"
        },
        "id": "node:baladhuri",
        "illaRefs": [],
        "kind": "node",
        "label": "البلاذري — أنساب الأشراف",
        "matnRefs": [],
        "rendered": true,
        "requiresPinpoint": false,
        "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [
          "cit-baladhuri-chain-matn"
        ],
        "riwayaRefs": [],
        "sourceRefs": [
          "source-muawiya-tabut-amash-scans"
        ],
        "supportLevel": "exact",
        "target": {
          "field": "identity",
          "nodeId": "baladhuri"
        },
        "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": []
      },
      "node:irsal_gap": {
        "argumentRefs": [],
        "cardRefs": [],
        "citationRefs": [
          "cit-baladhuri-chain-matn",
          "cit-salim-hukm-irsal"
        ],
        "evidenceRefs": [
          "cit-baladhuri-chain-matn",
          "cit-salim-hukm-irsal"
        ],
        "icon": {
          "kindLabel": "الراوي أو العقدة",
          "meaning": "تعريف العنصر ونص بياناته",
          "status": "documented",
          "statusLabel": "إحالة موضعية مقابلة",
          "summary": "واسطة أو أكثر غير مسماة — سالم يرفع الخبر بلا تسمية الواسطة"
        },
        "id": "node:irsal_gap",
        "illaRefs": [
          "illa-salim-irsal"
        ],
        "kind": "node",
        "label": "واسطة أو أكثر غير مسماة",
        "matnRefs": [],
        "rendered": true,
        "requiresPinpoint": false,
        "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [
          "cit-baladhuri-chain-matn",
          "cit-salim-hukm-irsal"
        ],
        "riwayaRefs": [],
        "sourceRefs": [
          "source-muawiya-tabut-amash-scans"
        ],
        "supportLevel": "exact",
        "target": {
          "field": "identity",
          "nodeId": "irsal_gap"
        },
        "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": []
      },
      "node:khalaf": {
        "argumentRefs": [],
        "cardRefs": [],
        "citationRefs": [
          "cit-baladhuri-chain-matn"
        ],
        "evidenceRefs": [
          "cit-baladhuri-chain-matn"
        ],
        "icon": {
          "kindLabel": "الراوي أو العقدة",
          "meaning": "تعريف العنصر ونص بياناته",
          "status": "documented",
          "statusLabel": "إحالة موضعية مقابلة",
          "summary": "خلف بن هشام البزاز"
        },
        "id": "node:khalaf",
        "illaRefs": [],
        "kind": "node",
        "label": "خلف بن هشام البزاز",
        "matnRefs": [],
        "rendered": true,
        "requiresPinpoint": false,
        "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [
          "cit-baladhuri-chain-matn"
        ],
        "riwayaRefs": [],
        "sourceRefs": [
          "source-muawiya-tabut-amash-scans"
        ],
        "supportLevel": "exact",
        "target": {
          "field": "identity",
          "nodeId": "khalaf"
        },
        "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": []
      },
      "node:nabi": {
        "argumentRefs": [],
        "cardRefs": [],
        "citationRefs": [
          "cit-baladhuri-chain-matn"
        ],
        "evidenceRefs": [
          "cit-baladhuri-chain-matn"
        ],
        "icon": {
          "kindLabel": "الراوي أو العقدة",
          "meaning": "تعريف العنصر ونص بياناته",
          "status": "documented",
          "statusLabel": "إحالة موضعية مقابلة",
          "summary": "النبي ﷺ"
        },
        "id": "node:nabi",
        "illaRefs": [],
        "kind": "node",
        "label": "النبي ﷺ",
        "matnRefs": [],
        "rendered": true,
        "requiresPinpoint": false,
        "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [
          "cit-baladhuri-chain-matn"
        ],
        "riwayaRefs": [],
        "sourceRefs": [
          "source-muawiya-tabut-amash-scans"
        ],
        "supportLevel": "exact",
        "target": {
          "field": "identity",
          "nodeId": "nabi"
        },
        "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": []
      },
      "node:salim": {
        "argumentRefs": [],
        "cardRefs": [],
        "citationRefs": [
          "cit-salim-identity",
          "cit-salim-hukm-irsal"
        ],
        "evidenceRefs": [
          "cit-salim-identity",
          "cit-salim-hukm-irsal"
        ],
        "icon": {
          "kindLabel": "الراوي أو العقدة",
          "meaning": "تعريف العنصر ونص بياناته",
          "status": "documented",
          "statusLabel": "إحالة موضعية مقابلة",
          "summary": "سالم بن أبي الجعد — «ثقة وكان يرسل كثيراً»"
        },
        "id": "node:salim",
        "illaRefs": [],
        "kind": "node",
        "label": "سالم بن أبي الجعد",
        "matnRefs": [],
        "rendered": true,
        "requiresPinpoint": false,
        "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [
          "cit-salim-identity",
          "cit-salim-hukm-irsal"
        ],
        "riwayaRefs": [],
        "sourceRefs": [
          "source-muawiya-tabut-amash-scans"
        ],
        "supportLevel": "exact",
        "target": {
          "field": "identity",
          "nodeId": "salim"
        },
        "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": []
      },
      "verdict": {
        "argumentRefs": [
          "arg-irsal-verdict"
        ],
        "cardRefs": [],
        "citationRefs": [
          "cit-baladhuri-chain-matn",
          "cit-salim-hukm-irsal"
        ],
        "evidenceRefs": [
          "cit-baladhuri-chain-matn",
          "cit-salim-hukm-irsal"
        ],
        "icon": {
          "kindLabel": "خلاصة الدراسة",
          "meaning": "النتيجة المنسوبة إلى الدراسة وحدود الاستدلال",
          "status": "documented",
          "statusLabel": "إحالة موضعية مقابلة",
          "summary": "لا يثبت الرفع بهذا الطريق عند اشتراط الاتصال؛ فتوثيق المسمين لا يزيل الإرسال فوق سالم. — خريطة شرح لطريق واحد، لا استقصاء. لا تعين واضعاً، ولا تحكم بوقوع تدليس الأعمش في هذا الفرد. شريط الكوفة نسبة بلد في الترجمة، لا مكان أداء معين. لم يستكمل توثيق مصر أبي عوانة وخلف أو الحكم عليهما في هذه الحزمة؛ تركا غير معينين، والإطار الرمادي ليس جرحاً."
        },
        "id": "verdict",
        "illaRefs": [],
        "kind": "verdict",
        "label": "طريق مرسل؛ لا يثبت به الرفع",
        "matnRefs": [],
        "rendered": true,
        "requiresPinpoint": false,
        "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [
          "cit-baladhuri-chain-matn",
          "cit-salim-hukm-irsal"
        ],
        "riwayaRefs": [],
        "sourceRefs": [
          "source-muawiya-tabut-amash-scans"
        ],
        "supportLevel": "exact",
        "target": {
          "field": "verdict"
        },
        "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": []
      }
    },
    "order": [
      "node:nabi",
      "node:irsal_gap",
      "node:salim",
      "hukm:salim",
      "city:salim",
      "node:amash",
      "hukm:amash",
      "city:amash",
      "flag:amash:tadlis",
      "node:abu_awana",
      "city:abu_awana",
      "node:khalaf",
      "city:khalaf",
      "node:baladhuri",
      "edge:edge-nabi-irsal_gap",
      "edge:edge-irsal_gap-salim",
      "edge:edge-salim-amash",
      "edge:edge-amash-abu_awana",
      "edge:edge-abu_awana-khalaf",
      "edge:edge-khalaf-baladhuri",
      "illa:illa-salim-irsal",
      "matn:matn-tabut-short",
      "verdict",
      "argument:arg-irsal-verdict"
    ]
  },
  "map": {
    "chapter": "02_manuscript/bab_08_al_mawsuaa_al_hadithiyya/01b_ilm_al_rijal_wa_tahqiq_al_jarh_wa_al_tadil.md",
    "dependencyHash": "edf3097366287400",
    "id": "muawiya_tabut_salim_mursal",
    "ref": "isnad:muawiya_tabut_salim_mursal@v2",
    "sourceFile": "08_assets/isnad/muawiya_tabut_salim_mursal.json",
    "sourceHash": "a336535527e3bd0b",
    "version": 2
  },
  "matnVariants": [
    {
      "citationRefs": [
        "cit-baladhuri-chain-matn"
      ],
      "evidenceRefs": [
        "cit-baladhuri-chain-matn"
      ],
      "id": "matn-tabut-short",
      "note": "اللفظ القصير وحده في هذه الخريطة؛ لا تدمج فيه صيغة لسان الميزان الأطول.",
      "riwayaRefs": [
        "riwaya-baladhuri-5-136"
      ],
      "role": "nawa",
      "subject": {
        "id": "baladhuri",
        "kind": "node"
      },
      "text": "معاوية في تابوت مقفل عليه في جهنم"
    }
  ],
  "narrators": [
    {
      "card": null,
      "city": null,
      "coverage": {
        "applicableFields": 1,
        "exactFields": 1,
        "status": "complete",
        "unresolvedFields": 0
      },
      "death": null,
      "evidenceRefs": {
        "identity": [
          "cit-baladhuri-chain-matn"
        ]
      },
      "fieldCoverage": {
        "card": {
          "cardRefs": [],
          "citationRefs": [],
          "evidenceRefs": [],
          "requiresPinpoint": false,
          "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [],
          "sourceRefs": [],
          "state": "not_applicable",
          "supportLevel": null,
          "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": []
        },
        "city": {
          "cardRefs": [],
          "citationRefs": [],
          "evidenceRefs": [],
          "requiresPinpoint": false,
          "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [],
          "sourceRefs": [],
          "state": "not_applicable",
          "supportLevel": null,
          "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": []
        },
        "death": {
          "cardRefs": [],
          "citationRefs": [],
          "evidenceRefs": [],
          "requiresPinpoint": false,
          "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [],
          "sourceRefs": [],
          "state": "not_applicable",
          "supportLevel": null,
          "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": []
        },
        "flags": {
          "cardRefs": [],
          "citationRefs": [],
          "evidenceRefs": [],
          "items": {},
          "requiresPinpoint": false,
          "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [],
          "sourceRefs": [],
          "state": "not_applicable",
          "supportLevel": null,
          "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": []
        },
        "hukm": {
          "cardRefs": [],
          "citationRefs": [],
          "evidenceRefs": [],
          "requiresPinpoint": false,
          "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [],
          "sourceRefs": [],
          "state": "not_applicable",
          "supportLevel": null,
          "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": []
        },
        "label": {
          "cardRefs": [],
          "citationRefs": [
            "cit-baladhuri-chain-matn"
          ],
          "evidenceRefs": [
            "cit-baladhuri-chain-matn"
          ],
          "requiresPinpoint": false,
          "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [
            "cit-baladhuri-chain-matn"
          ],
          "sourceRefs": [
            "source-muawiya-tabut-amash-scans"
          ],
          "state": "exact",
          "supportLevel": "exact",
          "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": []
        },
        "sub": {
          "cardRefs": [],
          "citationRefs": [],
          "evidenceRefs": [],
          "requiresPinpoint": false,
          "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [],
          "sourceRefs": [],
          "state": "not_applicable",
          "supportLevel": null,
          "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": []
        }
      },
      "flags": [],
      "hukm": null,
      "id": "nabi",
      "kind": "nabi",
      "label": "النبي ﷺ",
      "sub": null
    },
    {
      "card": "05_cards/evidences/muawiya_tabut_amash_rule_application.md",
      "city": "kufa",
      "coverage": {
        "applicableFields": 5,
        "exactFields": 4,
        "status": "partial",
        "unresolvedFields": 1
      },
      "death": null,
      "evidenceRefs": {
        "city": [
          "cit-salim-city"
        ],
        "hukm": [
          "cit-salim-hukm-irsal"
        ],
        "identity": [
          "cit-salim-identity"
        ],
        "sub": [
          "cit-salim-hukm-irsal"
        ]
      },
      "fieldCoverage": {
        "card": {
          "cardRefs": [],
          "citationRefs": [],
          "evidenceRefs": [],
          "requiresPinpoint": true,
          "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [],
          "sourceRefs": [],
          "state": "unresolved",
          "supportLevel": "unresolved",
          "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": []
        },
        "city": {
          "cardRefs": [],
          "citationRefs": [
            "cit-salim-city"
          ],
          "evidenceRefs": [
            "cit-salim-city"
          ],
          "requiresPinpoint": false,
          "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [
            "cit-salim-city"
          ],
          "sourceRefs": [
            "source-muawiya-tabut-amash-scans"
          ],
          "state": "exact",
          "supportLevel": "exact",
          "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": []
        },
        "death": {
          "cardRefs": [],
          "citationRefs": [],
          "evidenceRefs": [],
          "requiresPinpoint": false,
          "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [],
          "sourceRefs": [],
          "state": "not_applicable",
          "supportLevel": null,
          "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": []
        },
        "flags": {
          "cardRefs": [],
          "citationRefs": [],
          "evidenceRefs": [],
          "items": {},
          "requiresPinpoint": false,
          "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [],
          "sourceRefs": [],
          "state": "not_applicable",
          "supportLevel": null,
          "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": []
        },
        "hukm": {
          "cardRefs": [],
          "citationRefs": [
            "cit-salim-hukm-irsal"
          ],
          "evidenceRefs": [
            "cit-salim-hukm-irsal"
          ],
          "requiresPinpoint": false,
          "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [
            "cit-salim-hukm-irsal"
          ],
          "sourceRefs": [
            "source-muawiya-tabut-amash-scans"
          ],
          "state": "exact",
          "supportLevel": "exact",
          "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": []
        },
        "label": {
          "cardRefs": [],
          "citationRefs": [
            "cit-salim-identity"
          ],
          "evidenceRefs": [
            "cit-salim-identity"
          ],
          "requiresPinpoint": false,
          "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [
            "cit-salim-identity"
          ],
          "sourceRefs": [
            "source-muawiya-tabut-amash-scans"
          ],
          "state": "exact",
          "supportLevel": "exact",
          "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": []
        },
        "sub": {
          "cardRefs": [],
          "citationRefs": [
            "cit-salim-hukm-irsal"
          ],
          "evidenceRefs": [
            "cit-salim-hukm-irsal"
          ],
          "requiresPinpoint": false,
          "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [
            "cit-salim-hukm-irsal"
          ],
          "sourceRefs": [
            "source-muawiya-tabut-amash-scans"
          ],
          "state": "exact",
          "supportLevel": "exact",
          "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": []
        }
      },
      "flags": [],
      "hukm": "thiqa",
      "id": "salim",
      "kind": "rawi",
      "label": "سالم بن أبي الجعد",
      "sub": "«ثقة وكان يرسل كثيراً»"
    },
    {
      "card": "05_cards/evidences/muawiya_tabut_amash_rule_application.md",
      "city": "kufa",
      "coverage": {
        "applicableFields": 6,
        "exactFields": 5,
        "status": "partial",
        "unresolvedFields": 1
      },
      "death": null,
      "evidenceRefs": {
        "city": [
          "cit-amash-city"
        ],
        "flags": {
          "tadlis": [
            "cit-amash-hukm"
          ]
        },
        "hukm": [
          "cit-amash-hukm"
        ],
        "identity": [
          "cit-amash-identity"
        ],
        "sub": [
          "cit-amash-hukm"
        ]
      },
      "fieldCoverage": {
        "card": {
          "cardRefs": [],
          "citationRefs": [],
          "evidenceRefs": [],
          "requiresPinpoint": true,
          "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [],
          "sourceRefs": [],
          "state": "unresolved",
          "supportLevel": "unresolved",
          "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": []
        },
        "city": {
          "cardRefs": [],
          "citationRefs": [
            "cit-amash-city"
          ],
          "evidenceRefs": [
            "cit-amash-city"
          ],
          "requiresPinpoint": false,
          "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [
            "cit-amash-city"
          ],
          "sourceRefs": [
            "source-amash-bukhari-usul-mutabaat-scans"
          ],
          "state": "exact",
          "supportLevel": "exact",
          "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": []
        },
        "death": {
          "cardRefs": [],
          "citationRefs": [],
          "evidenceRefs": [],
          "requiresPinpoint": false,
          "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [],
          "sourceRefs": [],
          "state": "not_applicable",
          "supportLevel": null,
          "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": []
        },
        "flags": {
          "cardRefs": [],
          "citationRefs": [
            "cit-amash-hukm"
          ],
          "evidenceRefs": [
            "cit-amash-hukm"
          ],
          "items": {
            "tadlis": {
              "cardRefs": [],
              "citationRefs": [
                "cit-amash-hukm"
              ],
              "evidenceRefs": [
                "cit-amash-hukm"
              ],
              "requiresPinpoint": false,
              "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [
                "cit-amash-hukm"
              ],
              "sourceRefs": [
                "source-amash-bukhari-usul-mutabaat-scans"
              ],
              "state": "exact",
              "supportLevel": "exact",
              "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": []
            }
          },
          "requiresPinpoint": false,
          "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [
            "cit-amash-hukm"
          ],
          "sourceRefs": [
            "source-amash-bukhari-usul-mutabaat-scans"
          ],
          "state": "exact",
          "supportLevel": "exact",
          "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": []
        },
        "hukm": {
          "cardRefs": [],
          "citationRefs": [
            "cit-amash-hukm"
          ],
          "evidenceRefs": [
            "cit-amash-hukm"
          ],
          "requiresPinpoint": false,
          "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [
            "cit-amash-hukm"
          ],
          "sourceRefs": [
            "source-amash-bukhari-usul-mutabaat-scans"
          ],
          "state": "exact",
          "supportLevel": "exact",
          "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": []
        },
        "label": {
          "cardRefs": [],
          "citationRefs": [
            "cit-amash-identity"
          ],
          "evidenceRefs": [
            "cit-amash-identity"
          ],
          "requiresPinpoint": false,
          "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [
            "cit-amash-identity"
          ],
          "sourceRefs": [
            "source-amash-bukhari-usul-mutabaat-scans"
          ],
          "state": "exact",
          "supportLevel": "exact",
          "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": []
        },
        "sub": {
          "cardRefs": [],
          "citationRefs": [
            "cit-amash-hukm"
          ],
          "evidenceRefs": [
            "cit-amash-hukm"
          ],
          "requiresPinpoint": false,
          "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [
            "cit-amash-hukm"
          ],
          "sourceRefs": [
            "source-amash-bukhari-usul-mutabaat-scans"
          ],
          "state": "exact",
          "supportLevel": "exact",
          "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": []
        }
      },
      "flags": [
        "tadlis"
      ],
      "hukm": "thiqa",
      "id": "amash",
      "kind": "rawi",
      "label": "الأعمش: سليمان بن مهران",
      "sub": "«ثقة حافظ… لكنه يدلس»"
    },
    {
      "card": null,
      "city": null,
      "coverage": {
        "applicableFields": 2,
        "exactFields": 1,
        "status": "partial",
        "unresolvedFields": 1
      },
      "death": null,
      "evidenceRefs": {
        "city": [],
        "hukm": [],
        "identity": [
          "cit-baladhuri-chain-matn"
        ]
      },
      "fieldCoverage": {
        "card": {
          "cardRefs": [],
          "citationRefs": [],
          "evidenceRefs": [],
          "requiresPinpoint": false,
          "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [],
          "sourceRefs": [],
          "state": "not_applicable",
          "supportLevel": null,
          "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": []
        },
        "city": {
          "cardRefs": [],
          "citationRefs": [],
          "evidenceRefs": [],
          "requiresPinpoint": true,
          "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [],
          "sourceRefs": [],
          "state": "missing_value",
          "supportLevel": "unresolved",
          "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": []
        },
        "death": {
          "cardRefs": [],
          "citationRefs": [],
          "evidenceRefs": [],
          "requiresPinpoint": false,
          "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [],
          "sourceRefs": [],
          "state": "not_applicable",
          "supportLevel": null,
          "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": []
        },
        "flags": {
          "cardRefs": [],
          "citationRefs": [],
          "evidenceRefs": [],
          "items": {},
          "requiresPinpoint": false,
          "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [],
          "sourceRefs": [],
          "state": "not_applicable",
          "supportLevel": null,
          "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": []
        },
        "hukm": {
          "cardRefs": [],
          "citationRefs": [],
          "evidenceRefs": [],
          "requiresPinpoint": false,
          "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [],
          "sourceRefs": [],
          "state": "not_applicable",
          "supportLevel": null,
          "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": []
        },
        "label": {
          "cardRefs": [],
          "citationRefs": [
            "cit-baladhuri-chain-matn"
          ],
          "evidenceRefs": [
            "cit-baladhuri-chain-matn"
          ],
          "requiresPinpoint": false,
          "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [
            "cit-baladhuri-chain-matn"
          ],
          "sourceRefs": [
            "source-muawiya-tabut-amash-scans"
          ],
          "state": "exact",
          "supportLevel": "exact",
          "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": []
        },
        "sub": {
          "cardRefs": [],
          "citationRefs": [],
          "evidenceRefs": [],
          "requiresPinpoint": false,
          "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [],
          "sourceRefs": [],
          "state": "not_applicable",
          "supportLevel": null,
          "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": []
        }
      },
      "flags": [],
      "hukm": null,
      "id": "abu_awana",
      "kind": "rawi",
      "label": "أبو عوانة",
      "sub": null
    },
    {
      "card": null,
      "city": null,
      "coverage": {
        "applicableFields": 2,
        "exactFields": 1,
        "status": "partial",
        "unresolvedFields": 1
      },
      "death": null,
      "evidenceRefs": {
        "city": [],
        "hukm": [],
        "identity": [
          "cit-baladhuri-chain-matn"
        ]
      },
      "fieldCoverage": {
        "card": {
          "cardRefs": [],
          "citationRefs": [],
          "evidenceRefs": [],
          "requiresPinpoint": false,
          "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [],
          "sourceRefs": [],
          "state": "not_applicable",
          "supportLevel": null,
          "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": []
        },
        "city": {
          "cardRefs": [],
          "citationRefs": [],
          "evidenceRefs": [],
          "requiresPinpoint": true,
          "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [],
          "sourceRefs": [],
          "state": "missing_value",
          "supportLevel": "unresolved",
          "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": []
        },
        "death": {
          "cardRefs": [],
          "citationRefs": [],
          "evidenceRefs": [],
          "requiresPinpoint": false,
          "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [],
          "sourceRefs": [],
          "state": "not_applicable",
          "supportLevel": null,
          "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": []
        },
        "flags": {
          "cardRefs": [],
          "citationRefs": [],
          "evidenceRefs": [],
          "items": {},
          "requiresPinpoint": false,
          "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [],
          "sourceRefs": [],
          "state": "not_applicable",
          "supportLevel": null,
          "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": []
        },
        "hukm": {
          "cardRefs": [],
          "citationRefs": [],
          "evidenceRefs": [],
          "requiresPinpoint": false,
          "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [],
          "sourceRefs": [],
          "state": "not_applicable",
          "supportLevel": null,
          "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": []
        },
        "label": {
          "cardRefs": [],
          "citationRefs": [
            "cit-baladhuri-chain-matn"
          ],
          "evidenceRefs": [
            "cit-baladhuri-chain-matn"
          ],
          "requiresPinpoint": false,
          "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [
            "cit-baladhuri-chain-matn"
          ],
          "sourceRefs": [
            "source-muawiya-tabut-amash-scans"
          ],
          "state": "exact",
          "supportLevel": "exact",
          "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": []
        },
        "sub": {
          "cardRefs": [],
          "citationRefs": [],
          "evidenceRefs": [],
          "requiresPinpoint": false,
          "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [],
          "sourceRefs": [],
          "state": "not_applicable",
          "supportLevel": null,
          "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": []
        }
      },
      "flags": [],
      "hukm": null,
      "id": "khalaf",
      "kind": "rawi",
      "label": "خلف بن هشام البزاز",
      "sub": null
    }
  ],
  "pipelineVersion": 7,
  "provenanceCoverage": {
    "arguments": 1,
    "citations": 7,
    "dependencyHash": "edf3097366287400",
    "exactHotspots": 22,
    "illal": 1,
    "matnVariants": 1,
    "missingCards": [],
    "missingSources": [],
    "narrators": 5,
    "percentExact": 91.7,
    "riwayat": 1,
    "status": "incomplete",
    "totalHotspots": 24,
    "transmissions": 6,
    "unresolvedHotspots": 2
  },
  "provenanceStatus": "draft",
  "provenanceVersion": 2,
  "records": {
    "cards": [
      {
        "contentHash": "d8be07e8e920c2aa",
        "exists": true,
        "id": "evidence-muawiya-tabut-amash-rule-application",
        "path": "05_cards/evidences/muawiya_tabut_amash_rule_application.md",
        "status": "verified_with_limits",
        "title": "خبر التابوت عن الأعمش: الإرسال وحدود تطبيق قاعدة موافقة البدعة"
      }
    ],
    "sources": [
      {
        "author": null,
        "authorDeathHijri": null,
        "contentHash": "f7f37d5911968684",
        "exists": true,
        "id": "source-muawiya-tabut-amash-scans",
        "path": "04_source_bank/source-muawiya-tabut-amash-scans.md",
        "status": "verified_with_limits",
        "title": "خبر التابوت: مصور البلاذري ونقد ابن حجر وترجمة سالم وسياق الجوزجاني"
      },
      {
        "author": null,
        "authorDeathHijri": null,
        "contentHash": "0e62dd803521cb5e",
        "exists": true,
        "id": "source-amash-bukhari-usul-mutabaat-scans",
        "path": "04_source_bank/source-amash-bukhari-usul-mutabaat-scans.md",
        "status": "verified_with_limits",
        "title": "صور الأعمش في أصول البخاري ومتابعاته: ثلاثة أمثلة ونصوص النقاد"
      }
    ]
  },
  "riwayat": [
    {
      "chain": [
        "nabi",
        "irsal_gap",
        "salim",
        "amash",
        "abu_awana",
        "khalaf",
        "baladhuri"
      ],
      "citationRefs": [
        "cit-baladhuri-chain-matn"
      ],
      "evidenceRefs": [
        "cit-baladhuri-chain-matn"
      ],
      "familyId": "family-salim-amash-abu-awana-khalaf",
      "hukmCitationRefs": [],
      "hukmEvidenceRefs": [],
      "id": "riwaya-baladhuri-5-136",
      "illaRefs": [],
      "label": "البلاذري، أنساب الأشراف5/136",
      "limits": "موضع واحد؛ عقدة الفراغ تمثل واسطة أو أكثر غير مسماة، وليست راوياً مكتشفاً. اتجاه الرسم من المروي عنه إلى الراوي، وصيغ الأداء مأخوذة من المصنف ولا تمنح حكماً مستقلاً باتصال السند.",
      "matnRefs": [
        "matn-tabut-short"
      ],
      "nodePath": [
        "nabi",
        "irsal_gap",
        "salim",
        "amash",
        "abu_awana",
        "khalaf",
        "baladhuri"
      ]
    }
  ],
  "schemaVersion": 2,
  "transmissions": [
    {
      "cardRefs": [],
      "citationRefs": [
        "cit-baladhuri-chain-matn",
        "cit-salim-hukm-irsal"
      ],
      "evidenceRefs": {
        "note": [
          "cit-baladhuri-chain-matn",
          "cit-salim-hukm-irsal"
        ],
        "status": [
          "cit-baladhuri-chain-matn",
          "cit-salim-hukm-irsal"
        ]
      },
      "from": "nabi",
      "id": "edge-nabi-irsal_gap",
      "illaRefs": [
        "illa-salim-irsal"
      ],
      "matnRefs": [],
      "note": "إرسال",
      "requiresPinpoint": false,
      "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [
        "cit-baladhuri-chain-matn",
        "cit-salim-hukm-irsal"
      ],
      "riwayaRefs": [
        "riwaya-baladhuri-5-136"
      ],
      "sourceRefs": [
        "source-muawiya-tabut-amash-scans"
      ],
      "status": "munqati",
      "supportLevel": "exact",
      "to": "irsal_gap",
      "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": []
    },
    {
      "cardRefs": [],
      "citationRefs": [
        "cit-baladhuri-chain-matn",
        "cit-salim-hukm-irsal"
      ],
      "evidenceRefs": {
        "note": [
          "cit-baladhuri-chain-matn",
          "cit-salim-hukm-irsal"
        ],
        "status": [
          "cit-baladhuri-chain-matn",
          "cit-salim-hukm-irsal"
        ]
      },
      "from": "irsal_gap",
      "id": "edge-irsal_gap-salim",
      "illaRefs": [
        "illa-salim-irsal"
      ],
      "matnRefs": [],
      "note": "«قال: قال رسول الله»",
      "requiresPinpoint": false,
      "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [
        "cit-baladhuri-chain-matn",
        "cit-salim-hukm-irsal"
      ],
      "riwayaRefs": [
        "riwaya-baladhuri-5-136"
      ],
      "sourceRefs": [
        "source-muawiya-tabut-amash-scans"
      ],
      "status": "munqati",
      "supportLevel": "exact",
      "to": "salim",
      "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": []
    },
    {
      "cardRefs": [],
      "citationRefs": [
        "cit-baladhuri-chain-matn"
      ],
      "evidenceRefs": {
        "note": [
          "cit-baladhuri-chain-matn"
        ]
      },
      "from": "salim",
      "id": "edge-salim-amash",
      "illaRefs": [],
      "matnRefs": [],
      "note": "عن",
      "requiresPinpoint": false,
      "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [
        "cit-baladhuri-chain-matn"
      ],
      "riwayaRefs": [
        "riwaya-baladhuri-5-136"
      ],
      "sourceRefs": [
        "source-muawiya-tabut-amash-scans"
      ],
      "status": "mahfuz",
      "supportLevel": "exact",
      "to": "amash",
      "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": []
    },
    {
      "cardRefs": [],
      "citationRefs": [
        "cit-baladhuri-chain-matn"
      ],
      "evidenceRefs": {
        "note": [
          "cit-baladhuri-chain-matn"
        ]
      },
      "from": "amash",
      "id": "edge-amash-abu_awana",
      "illaRefs": [],
      "matnRefs": [],
      "note": "عن",
      "requiresPinpoint": false,
      "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [
        "cit-baladhuri-chain-matn"
      ],
      "riwayaRefs": [
        "riwaya-baladhuri-5-136"
      ],
      "sourceRefs": [
        "source-muawiya-tabut-amash-scans"
      ],
      "status": "mahfuz",
      "supportLevel": "exact",
      "to": "abu_awana",
      "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": []
    },
    {
      "cardRefs": [],
      "citationRefs": [
        "cit-baladhuri-chain-matn"
      ],
      "evidenceRefs": {
        "note": [
          "cit-baladhuri-chain-matn"
        ]
      },
      "from": "abu_awana",
      "id": "edge-abu_awana-khalaf",
      "illaRefs": [],
      "matnRefs": [],
      "note": "حدثنا",
      "requiresPinpoint": false,
      "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [
        "cit-baladhuri-chain-matn"
      ],
      "riwayaRefs": [
        "riwaya-baladhuri-5-136"
      ],
      "sourceRefs": [
        "source-muawiya-tabut-amash-scans"
      ],
      "status": "mahfuz",
      "supportLevel": "exact",
      "to": "khalaf",
      "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": []
    },
    {
      "cardRefs": [],
      "citationRefs": [
        "cit-baladhuri-chain-matn"
      ],
      "evidenceRefs": {
        "note": [
          "cit-baladhuri-chain-matn"
        ]
      },
      "from": "khalaf",
      "id": "edge-khalaf-baladhuri",
      "illaRefs": [],
      "matnRefs": [],
      "note": "حدثني",
      "requiresPinpoint": false,
      "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [
        "cit-baladhuri-chain-matn"
      ],
      "riwayaRefs": [
        "riwaya-baladhuri-5-136"
      ],
      "sourceRefs": [
        "source-muawiya-tabut-amash-scans"
      ],
      "status": "mahfuz",
      "supportLevel": "exact",
      "to": "baladhuri",
      "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": []
    }
  ]
}