{ "arguments": [ { "citationRefs": [ "cit-musannaf-37771", "cit-abdrahman-dhakhira-4409", "cit-card-analysis" ], "evidenceRefs": [ "cit-musannaf-37771", "cit-abdrahman-dhakhira-4409", "cit-card-analysis" ], "id": "arg-qays-family-independence", "illaRefs": [], "kind": "isnad", "limitations": "الاستقلال هنا هندسي داخل العينة المصورة؛ لا يحسم صحة أصل قيس ولا يجرد جميع طرق الباب.", "riwayaRefs": [ "riwaya-abu-usama-37771", "riwaya-abdrahman-1420-4409" ], "statement": "فرع أبي أسامة لا يمر بعبد الرحمن بن صالح، لكنه يلتقي بفرع عبد الرحمن عند إسماعيل ثم قيس؛ فهو يمنع تعميم جرح عبد الرحمن ولا ينشئ أصلاً صحابياً ثانياً.", "targets": [ "riwaya:riwaya-abu-usama-37771", "riwaya:riwaya-abdrahman-1420-4409", "node:ismail", "node:qays" ] }, { "citationRefs": [ "cit-musannaf-37771", "cit-abdrahman-jawzi-1420", "cit-card-analysis" ], "evidenceRefs": [ "cit-musannaf-37771", "cit-abdrahman-jawzi-1420", "cit-card-analysis" ], "id": "arg-rudduni-layer-lock", "illaRefs": [], "kind": "matn", "limitations": "إثبات فرق اللفظ لا يثبت أن عبد الرحمن أنشأه؛ ولا تُجعل واقعة صفية شاهداً لهذا الخبر.", "riwayaRefs": [ "riwaya-abu-usama-37771", "riwaya-abdrahman-1420-4409" ], "statement": "صيغة «ردوني» مثبتة في فرع عبد الرحمن في العينة، ولا تظهر في صورة أبي أسامة؛ وهي غير قول صفية للأشتر «ردوني لا يفضحني هذا الكلب». معنى الرجوع قائم أيضاً في فرع أبي أسامة بلفظ «ما أظنني إلا راجعة».", "targets": [ "matn:matn-abdrahman-rudduni", "matn:matn-abu-usama-context" ] }, { "citationRefs": [ "cit-qays-specific-criticism", "cit-qays-profile-jamal", "cit-card-analysis" ], "evidenceRefs": [ "cit-qays-specific-criticism", "cit-qays-profile-jamal", "cit-card-analysis" ], "id": "arg-qays-criticism-mirror", "illaRefs": [], "kind": "illa", "limitations": "تطبق معايير الاتصال والنقد الخاص والمخالفة نفسها في خبر سهم مروان؛ تسمية القطان للحوأب لا تنقل حكمه إلى السهم ولا تفرض درجة واحدة على المتنين.", "riwayaRefs": [ "riwaya-abu-usama-37771", "riwaya-abdrahman-1420-4409" ], "statement": "نقد القطان موجه إلى هذا الفرد من حديث قيس، لا إلى عدالته كلها؛ وتوثيق قيس لا يمحو النقد الخاص.", "targets": [ "node:qays", "riwaya:riwaya-abu-usama-37771", "riwaya:riwaya-abdrahman-1420-4409" ] }, { "citationRefs": [ "cit-qays-profile-jamal", "cit-abdrahman-dhakhira-4409", "cit-card-analysis" ], "evidenceRefs": [ "cit-qays-profile-jamal", "cit-abdrahman-dhakhira-4409", "cit-card-analysis" ], "id": "arg-tribe-environment-madhhab-mirror", "illaRefs": [], "kind": "geography", "limitations": "لا يثبت الموصوف في عبد الرحمن وضع هذا الخبر، ولا تشغّل قاعدة موافقة البدعة حتى يحرر وجه الموافقة العقدية؛ لذلك يبقى HOLD_MADHHAB_CONGRUENCE، وتطبق المرآة على القناتين العثمانية والعلوية.", "riwayaRefs": [], "scope": "sample", "statement": "في العينة قيس كوفي عثماني يحمل خبراً استعمل في نقد مسير عائشة، وعبد الرحمن أزدي كوفي موصوف بالتشيع الغالي يحمل فرع «ردوني»؛ فالبيئة والموقف يرفعان الفحص ولا يقومان وحدهما مقام الجرح أو التصحيح.", "targets": [ "node:qays", "node:abd_al_rahman_ibn_salih", "matn:matn-abdrahman-rudduni" ] }, { "citationRefs": [ "cit-ibnabbas-ilal-2787", "cit-ibn-abd-barr-reception" ], "evidenceRefs": [ "cit-ibnabbas-ilal-2787", "cit-ibn-abd-barr-reception" ], "id": "arg-ibnabbas-independent-but-munkar", "illaRefs": [], "kind": "isnad", "limitations": "الحكم مقيد بهذا الطريق ومتنه الموسع، ولا ينقل آلياً إلى كل ما ورد في باب الحوأب.", "riwayaRefs": [ "riwaya-ibnabbas-2787" ], "statement": "طريق ابن عباس مستقل اسماً عن قيس، لكن أبا حاتم وأبا زرعة أنكراه ونصا على تفرد عصام؛ فالاستقلال الهندسي لا يساوي التقوية. وفي الحاشية قبول مقابل عن ابن عبد البر لم يقابل أصله بعد.", "targets": [ "riwaya:riwaya-ibnabbas-2787", "node:isam_ibn_qudama" ] }, { "citationRefs": [ "cit-musannaf-37771", "cit-abdrahman-jawzi-1420", "cit-ibnabbas-ilal-2787", "cit-witnesses-ibn-arabi", "cit-card-holds" ], "evidenceRefs": [ "cit-musannaf-37771", "cit-abdrahman-jawzi-1420", "cit-ibnabbas-ilal-2787", "cit-witnesses-ibn-arabi", "cit-card-holds" ], "id": "arg-witnesses-extra-layer", "illaRefs": [], "kind": "matn", "limitations": "عدم ثبوتها في هذه الحزمة ليس نفياً تاريخياً قطعياً؛ يبقى أقدم إسناد لها ديناً مستقلاً.", "riwayaRefs": [], "statement": "قصة الأربعين أو الخمسين وتغيير اسم الماء ليست في النصوص الثلاثة المطابقة، ولم يثبت لها في المادة إسناد مستقل؛ وإنكار ابن العربي شاهد تلقي جدلي لا إسناداً مضاداً.", "targets": [ "node:witnesses_void", "node:witnesses_story" ] }, { "citationRefs": [ "cit-musannaf-37771", "cit-card-analysis" ], "evidenceRefs": [ "cit-musannaf-37771", "cit-card-analysis" ], "id": "arg-prophecy-not-camp-verdict", "illaRefs": [], "kind": "matn", "limitations": "الحكم على القرار السياسي والقتال يحتاج أدلة مستقلة؛ وتحسين سند لا يصحح كل دلالة استخرجها التلقي.", "riwayaRefs": [], "statement": "حتى ثبوت نواة نباح كلاب الحوأب لا ينتج وحده حكماً فقهياً على المسير، ولا مسؤولية جماعية لمعسكر، ولا صحة قصة الشهود.", "targets": [ "matn:matn-qays-nucleus", "matn:matn-ibnabbas-expansion" ] }, { "citationRefs": [ "cit-correction-2788", "cit-card-analysis" ], "evidenceRefs": [ "cit-correction-2788", "cit-card-analysis" ], "id": "arg-correction-unrelated-2788", "illaRefs": [], "kind": "isnad", "limitations": "استكملت المقابلة المصورة لهوية2788 والأمالي وحقوق1416/1995؛ لا تعني استيعاب جميع طرق الحوأب ولا تصحيح خبر الوالي أو حسم اختلاف الرفع والوقف.", "riwayaRefs": [], "statement": "أزيل فرع أبي نصيرة عن أبي رجاء من الحوأب لأن تمام المسألة2788 خبر الوالي العادل، لا لأنه ضعيف أو غريب؛ حكم ابن حجر لا ينتقل بين المتنين.", "targets": [] } ], "citations": [ { "attribution": "أبو بكر ابن أبي شيبة (ت235هـ)", "cardRef": null, "discovery": null, "id": "cit-musannaf-37771", "kind": "isnad_matn", "label": "فرع أبي أسامة عن إسماعيل عن قيس", "limitations": null, "locator": { "display": "مصنف ابن أبي شيبة، تحقيق كمال يوسف الحوت، دار التاج، ج7، ص536، ح37771", "hadithNo": 37771, "page": 536, "volume": 7 }, "mode": "quoted", "note": null, "quote": "حدثنا أبو أسامة قال حدثنا إسماعيل عن قيس قال: لما بلغت عائشة بعض مياه بني عامر ليلاً نبحت الكلاب عليها، فقالت: أي ماء هذا؟ قالوا: ماء الحوأب، فوقفت فقالت: ما أظنني إلا راجعة، فقال لها طلحة والزبير: مهلاً رحمك الله، بل تقدمين فيراك المسلمون فيصلح الله ذات بينهم، قالت: ما أظنني إلا راجعة، إني سمعت رسول الله صلى الله عليه وسلم قال لنا ذات يوم: كيف بإحداكن تنبح عليها كلاب الحوأب", "sourceId": "source-musannaf-ibn-abi-shayba-hawab-37771", "sourceRef": "source-musannaf-ibn-abi-shayba-hawab-37771", "speaker": null, "summary": "طريق أبي أسامة عن إسماعيل بن أبي خالد عن قيس، وفيه بلوغ ماء بني عامر، وقول عائشة «ما أظنني إلا راجعة»، ثم إنذار كلاب الحوأب؛ وليس فيه لفظ «ردوني».", "url": null, "verification": "verified_scan", "verificationLimits": null }, { "attribution": "يحيى بن سعيد القطان، برواية علي بن المديني", "cardRef": null, "discovery": null, "id": "cit-qays-specific-criticism", "kind": "rijal_hukm", "label": "نقد يحيى القطان لحديث الحوأب من أفراد قيس", "limitations": null, "locator": { "display": "الدوسيه المصور، ص2-3 وص7؛ تهذيب التهذيب 5/359 وتهذيب الكمال 24/15" }, "mode": "quoted", "note": null, "quote": "قيس بن أبي حازم منكر الحديث، ثم ذكر له يحيى أحاديث مناكير منها حديث كلاب الحوأب", "sourceId": "source-dossier-scans-tadif-hawab-20p", "sourceRef": "source-dossier-scans-tadif-hawab-20p", "speaker": null, "summary": null, "url": null, "verification": "verified_scan", "verificationLimits": null }, { "attribution": "نقول الترجمة؛ وعلي بن المديني", "cardRef": null, "discovery": null, "id": "cit-qays-profile-jamal", "kind": "rijal_context", "label": "توثيق قيس وكوفيته وعدم شهوده الجمل وعثمانيته", "limitations": null, "locator": { "display": "الدوسيه المصور، ص2-3 وص13-14؛ تهذيب التهذيب 5/359، وعلل علي بن المديني، ط2، ص50" }, "mode": "derived", "note": null, "quote": null, "sourceId": "source-dossier-scans-tadif-hawab-20p", "sourceRef": "source-dossier-scans-tadif-hawab-20p", "speaker": null, "summary": "تنقل الترجمة توثيق ابن معين وأبي داود وابن خراش ووصفه بالكوفي، وفي العلل: «شهد الجمل؟ قال: لا، كان عثمانياً».", "url": null, "verification": "verified_scan", "verificationLimits": null }, { "attribution": "أبو الفرج ابن الجوزي (ت597هـ)", "cardRef": null, "discovery": null, "id": "cit-abdrahman-jawzi-1420", "kind": "isnad_matn_hukm", "label": "فرع عبد الرحمن بن صالح بلفظ «ردوني»", "limitations": null, "locator": { "display": "الدوسيه المصور، ص11؛ العلل المتناهية، ابن الجوزي، تحقيق خليل الميس، دار الكتب العلمية، ج2، ص849، ح1420" }, "mode": "derived", "note": null, "quote": null, "sourceId": "source-dossier-scans-tadif-hawab-20p", "sourceRef": "source-dossier-scans-tadif-hawab-20p", "speaker": null, "summary": "يحفظ الفرع لفظ «ردوني»، وينقل عن موسى بن هارون أن عبد الرحمن يروي أحاديث سوء في مثالب الصحابة، وعن ابن عدي: «احترق بالتشيع».", "url": null, "verification": "verified_scan", "verificationLimits": null }, { "attribution": "ابن القيسراني (ت507هـ)", "cardRef": null, "discovery": null, "id": "cit-abdrahman-dhakhira-4409", "kind": "isnad_rijal", "label": "سياقة فرع عبد الرحمن ووصف تشيعه الغالي", "limitations": null, "locator": { "display": "الدوسيه المصور، ص12؛ ذخيرة الحفاظ، ابن القيسراني، تحقيق حامد عبد الله المحلاوي التميمي، دار الكتب العلمية، ج4، ص201، ح4409" }, "mode": "quoted", "note": null, "quote": "عبد الرحمن بن صالح عن محمد بن فضيل عن إسماعيل بن أبي خالد عن قيس", "sourceId": "source-dossier-scans-tadif-hawab-20p", "sourceRef": "source-dossier-scans-tadif-hawab-20p", "speaker": null, "summary": "عبد الرحمن بن صالح عن محمد بن فضيل عن إسماعيل بن أبي خالد عن قيس؛ وعبد الرحمن «مشهور في الكوفيين بالتشيع الغالي».", "url": null, "verification": "verified_scan", "verificationLimits": null }, { "attribution": "أبو حاتم الرازي وأبو زرعة الرازي", "cardRef": null, "discovery": null, "id": "cit-ibnabbas-ilal-2787", "kind": "isnad_matn_hukm", "label": "طريق ابن عباس وحكم أبي حاتم وأبي زرعة", "limitations": null, "locator": { "display": "الدوسيه المصور، ص9-10؛ علل ابن أبي حاتم، إشراف سعد الحميد وخالد الجريسي، ج6، ص589-590، س2787" }, "mode": "quoted", "note": null, "quote": "وسألت أبي عن حديث رواه الأشج، عن عقبة بن خالد، عن ابن قدامة — يعني: عصاماً — عن عكرمة، عن ابن عباس؛ قال: قال رسول الله لبعض نسائه: ليت شعري! أيتكن صاحبة الجمل الأدبب...؟ وذكر الحديث", "sourceId": "source-dossier-scans-tadif-hawab-20p", "sourceRef": "source-dossier-scans-tadif-hawab-20p", "speaker": null, "summary": "الأشج عن عقبة بن خالد عن عصام بن قدامة عن عكرمة عن ابن عباس؛ متنه يضيف الجمل والقتلى والنجاة. قال أبو حاتم وأبو زرعة: «حديث منكر»، ونصا على تفرد هذا الوجه. لفظ الصورة «الأديب» بين معقوفين في موضع الأدبب مع ضبط المحقق في الحاشية؛ التتمة الموسعة من حاشية4.", "url": null, "verification": "verified_scan", "verificationLimits": null }, { "attribution": "أبو بكر ابن العربي المالكي (ت543هـ)", "cardRef": null, "discovery": null, "id": "cit-witnesses-ibn-arabi", "kind": "reception", "label": "إنكار ابن العربي لقصة الشهادة", "limitations": null, "locator": { "display": "الدوسيه المصور، ص6؛ العواصم من القواصم، ابن العربي، تحقيق عمار طالبي، مكتبة دار التراث، ص305" }, "mode": "derived", "note": null, "quote": null, "sourceId": "source-dossier-scans-tadif-hawab-20p", "sourceRef": "source-dossier-scans-tadif-hawab-20p", "speaker": null, "summary": "ينكر قصة الشهادة على ماء الحوأب؛ وهو شاهد تلقي جدلي متأخر، لا إسناداً للقصة ولا دليلاً معاصراً على وقوعها أو نفيها.", "url": null, "verification": "verified_scan", "verificationLimits": null }, { "attribution": null, "cardRef": "05_cards/evidences/hadith-hawab-tabaqat-al-khabar-wa-ziyadat-al-idana.md", "discovery": null, "id": "cit-card-analysis", "kind": "analytical_limit", "label": "طبقات الخبر والمرآة وقفل «ردوني»", "limitations": null, "locator": { "display": "بطاقة حديث الحوأب: الطرق المفحوصة، استدراك أبي نصيرة، قفل ردوني ومعنى الرجوع، المرآة وحكم البطاقة" }, "mode": "derived", "note": null, "quote": null, "sourceId": null, "sourceRef": null, "speaker": null, "summary": "تفصل البطاقة فرع أبي أسامة عن فرع عبد الرحمن، وتمنع نقل الجرح بينهما أو خلط «ردوني» الحوأب بقول صفية للأشتر، وتطبق قرينة البيئة بالمرآة.", "url": null, "verification": "unverified", "verificationLimits": null }, { "attribution": null, "cardRef": "05_cards/evidences/hawab-qabul-shuhud-wa-matn-thalith-hold.md", "discovery": null, "id": "cit-card-holds", "kind": "research_debt", "label": "ديون كفة التصحيح والشهود وسماع قيس، واستدراك خبر الوالي", "limitations": null, "locator": { "display": "بطاقة المواد الموقوفة: §§ قرار الحجر، قفل عدم الخلط، شروط رفع الحجر" }, "mode": "derived", "note": null, "quote": null, "sourceId": null, "sourceRef": null, "speaker": null, "summary": "لم تطابق بعد مواضع المصححين الأصلية ولا إسناد قصة الشهود ولا نص يحسم سماع قيس؛ أزيل دين الطريق الثالثة بعد اكتشاف أنها في خبر الوالي العادل.", "url": null, "verification": "unverified", "verificationLimits": null }, { "attribution": "ابن أبي حاتم؛ ابن حجر", "cardRef": null, "discovery": null, "id": "cit-correction-2788", "kind": "source_correction", "label": "المسألة2788 خبر الوالي العادل، لا الحوأب", "limitations": null, "locator": { "display": "العلل6/590–591،س2788،إشراف سعد الحميد وخالد الجريسي؛ الأمالي المطلقة،تحقيق حمدي السلفي،المكتب الإسلامي،ط1،1416/1995،ص115–116،مجلس105؛ مصورات B02-evidence وبصماتها في cycle-02/C02-B02/repair.json" }, "mode": "quoted", "note": null, "quote": "أبي بكر الصديق، عن النبي قال: الوالي العادل المتواضع ظل الله ورمحه في أرضه", "sourceId": "source-dossier-scans-tadif-hawab-20p", "sourceRef": "source-dossier-scans-tadif-hawab-20p", "speaker": null, "summary": "قوبلت صور590–591 والأمالي115–116 وعنوان الأمالي وحقوقه؛2788 خبر الوالي العادل لا الحوأب. يذكر العلل الرفع ويقف نص الأمالي على أبي بكر؛ لا تحسم هذه المقابلة اختلافهما أو صحة الطريق. بيانات طبع مجلد العلل التفصيلية باقية.", "url": null, "verification": "verified_scan", "verificationLimits": null }, { "attribution": "ابن عبد البر بواسطة حاشية المحققين", "cardRef": null, "discovery": null, "id": "cit-ibn-abd-barr-reception", "kind": "reception", "label": "كفة ابن عبد البر كما نقلها محققو العلل", "limitations": null, "locator": { "display": "علل ابن أبي حاتم6/590، حاشية المسألة2787، الدوسيه ص10" }, "mode": "quoted", "note": null, "quote": "وهذا الحديث من أعلام نبوته", "sourceId": "source-dossier-scans-tadif-hawab-20p", "sourceRef": "source-dossier-scans-tadif-hawab-20p", "speaker": null, "summary": "نقلت الحاشية قبول ابن عبد البر وتوثيق عصام. تحققت صورة النقل، لا أصل الاستيعاب؛ بقيت موازنة الحكم مع النقد ديناً مستقلاً.", "url": null, "verification": "verified_scan", "verificationLimits": null } ], "dependencyHash": "de53a054445e4c9e", "diagnostics": { "errors": [], "warnings": [ "evidenceStatus=incomplete: 27/64 hotspots تحتاج تعيين المصدر والموضع" ] }, "evidenceStatus": "incomplete", "illal": [ { "citationRefs": [ "cit-qays-specific-criticism", "cit-qays-profile-jamal" ], "evidenceRefs": [ "cit-qays-specific-criticism", "cit-qays-profile-jamal" ], "id": "illa-qays-specific-criticism", "kind": "naqd_fard", "matnRefs": [], "riwayaRefs": [ "riwaya-abu-usama-37771" ], "subject": { "id": "qays", "kind": "node" }, "target": "node:qays", "text": "عد يحيى بن سعيد القطان حديث كلاب الحوأب من مناكير قيس، مع بقاء توثيق قيس في عامة حديثه." }, { "citationRefs": [ "cit-musannaf-37771", "cit-qays-profile-jamal", "cit-card-holds" ], "evidenceRefs": [ "cit-musannaf-37771", "cit-qays-profile-jamal", "cit-card-holds" ], "id": "illa-qays-source-unresolved", "kind": "ittisal_hold", "matnRefs": [], "riwayaRefs": [ "riwaya-abu-usama-37771" ], "subject": { "id": "edge-aisha-qays", "kind": "edge" }, "target": "edge:edge-aisha-qays", "text": "الصيغة المطابقة تجعل قيس يحكي المشهد ولا يصرح «سمعت عائشة»؛ وعدم شهوده الجمل لا يكفي وحده للجزم بالإرسال." }, { "citationRefs": [ "cit-abdrahman-jawzi-1420", "cit-abdrahman-dhakhira-4409", "cit-card-analysis" ], "evidenceRefs": [ "cit-abdrahman-jawzi-1420", "cit-abdrahman-dhakhira-4409", "cit-card-analysis" ], "id": "illa-abdrahman-specific-branch", "kind": "jarh", "matnRefs": [], "riwayaRefs": [ "riwaya-abdrahman-1420-4409" ], "subject": { "id": "abd_al_rahman_ibn_salih", "kind": "node" }, "target": "node:abd_al_rahman_ibn_salih", "text": "الجرح المسمى والتشيع الغالي موثقان في عبد الرحمن، فيقيدان فرعه ولا ينتقلان إلى فرع أبي أسامة." }, { "citationRefs": [ "cit-ibnabbas-ilal-2787" ], "evidenceRefs": [ "cit-ibnabbas-ilal-2787" ], "id": "illa-isam-tafarrud", "kind": "tafarrud", "matnRefs": [], "riwayaRefs": [ "riwaya-ibnabbas-2787" ], "subject": { "id": "isam_ibn_qudama", "kind": "node" }, "target": "node:isam_ibn_qudama", "text": "قال أبو حاتم: لم يرو هذا الحديث غير عصام؛ وقال أبو زرعة: لا يروى من طريق غيره." } ], "interactionIndex": { "hotspots": { "argument:arg-correction-unrelated-2788": { "argumentRefs": [ "arg-correction-unrelated-2788" ], "cardRefs": [ "05_cards/evidences/hadith-hawab-tabaqat-al-khabar-wa-ziyadat-al-idana.md" ], "citationRefs": [ "cit-correction-2788", "cit-card-analysis" ], "evidenceRefs": [ "cit-correction-2788", "cit-card-analysis" ], "icon": { "kindLabel": "حجة الدراسة", "meaning": "الدعوى وأدلتها وحدودها", "status": "needs_review", "statusLabel": "الإحالة موجودة؛ توثيق الحقل يحتاج استكمالاً", "summary": "أزيل فرع أبي نصيرة عن أبي رجاء من الحوأب لأن تمام المسألة2788 خبر الوالي العادل، لا لأنه ضعيف أو غريب؛ حكم ابن حجر لا ينتقل بين المتنين. — استكملت المقابلة المصورة لهوية2788 والأمالي وحقوق1416/1995؛ لا تعني استيعاب جميع طرق الحوأب ولا تصحيح خبر الوالي أو حسم اختلاف الرفع والوقف." }, "id": "argument:arg-correction-unrelated-2788", "illaRefs": [], "kind": "argument", "label": "أزيل فرع أبي نصيرة عن أبي رجاء من الحوأب لأن تمام المسألة2788 خبر الوالي العادل، لا لأنه ضعيف أو غريب؛ حكم ابن حجر لا ينتقل بين المتنين.", "matnRefs": [], "rendered": true, "requiresPinpoint": true, "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [ "cit-correction-2788", "cit-card-analysis" ], "riwayaRefs": [], "sourceRefs": [ "source-dossier-scans-tadif-hawab-20p" ], "supportLevel": "card_scope", "target": { "argumentId": "arg-correction-unrelated-2788" }, "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": [] }, "argument:arg-ibnabbas-independent-but-munkar": { "argumentRefs": [ "arg-ibnabbas-independent-but-munkar" ], "cardRefs": [], "citationRefs": [ "cit-ibnabbas-ilal-2787", "cit-ibn-abd-barr-reception" ], "evidenceRefs": [ "cit-ibnabbas-ilal-2787", "cit-ibn-abd-barr-reception" ], "icon": { "kindLabel": "حجة الدراسة", "meaning": "الدعوى وأدلتها وحدودها", "status": "documented", "statusLabel": "إحالة موضعية مقابلة", "summary": "طريق ابن عباس مستقل اسماً عن قيس، لكن أبا حاتم وأبا زرعة أنكراه ونصا على تفرد عصام؛ فالاستقلال الهندسي لا يساوي التقوية. وفي الحاشية قبول مقابل عن ابن عبد البر لم يقابل أصله بعد. — الحكم مقيد بهذا الطريق ومتنه الموسع، ولا ينقل آلياً إلى كل ما ورد في باب الحوأب." }, "id": "argument:arg-ibnabbas-independent-but-munkar", "illaRefs": [], "kind": "argument", "label": "طريق ابن عباس مستقل اسماً عن قيس، لكن أبا حاتم وأبا زرعة أنكراه ونصا على تفرد عصام؛ فالاستقلال الهندسي لا يساوي التقوية. وفي الحاشية قبول مقابل عن ابن عبد البر لم يقابل أصله بعد.", "matnRefs": [], "rendered": true, "requiresPinpoint": false, "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [ "cit-ibnabbas-ilal-2787", "cit-ibn-abd-barr-reception" ], "riwayaRefs": [ "riwaya-ibnabbas-2787" ], "sourceRefs": [ "source-dossier-scans-tadif-hawab-20p" ], "supportLevel": "exact", "target": { "argumentId": "arg-ibnabbas-independent-but-munkar" }, "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": [] }, "argument:arg-prophecy-not-camp-verdict": { "argumentRefs": [ "arg-prophecy-not-camp-verdict" ], "cardRefs": [ "05_cards/evidences/hadith-hawab-tabaqat-al-khabar-wa-ziyadat-al-idana.md" ], "citationRefs": [ "cit-musannaf-37771", "cit-card-analysis" ], "evidenceRefs": [ "cit-musannaf-37771", "cit-card-analysis" ], "icon": { "kindLabel": "حجة الدراسة", "meaning": "الدعوى وأدلتها وحدودها", "status": "needs_review", "statusLabel": "الإحالة موجودة؛ توثيق الحقل يحتاج استكمالاً", "summary": "حتى ثبوت نواة نباح كلاب الحوأب لا ينتج وحده حكماً فقهياً على المسير، ولا مسؤولية جماعية لمعسكر، ولا صحة قصة الشهود. — الحكم على القرار السياسي والقتال يحتاج أدلة مستقلة؛ وتحسين سند لا يصحح كل دلالة استخرجها التلقي." }, "id": "argument:arg-prophecy-not-camp-verdict", "illaRefs": [], "kind": "argument", "label": "حتى ثبوت نواة نباح كلاب الحوأب لا ينتج وحده حكماً فقهياً على المسير، ولا مسؤولية جماعية لمعسكر، ولا صحة قصة الشهود.", "matnRefs": [], "rendered": true, "requiresPinpoint": true, "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [ "cit-musannaf-37771", "cit-card-analysis" ], "riwayaRefs": [], "sourceRefs": [ "source-musannaf-ibn-abi-shayba-hawab-37771" ], "supportLevel": "card_scope", "target": { "argumentId": "arg-prophecy-not-camp-verdict" }, "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": [] }, "argument:arg-qays-criticism-mirror": { "argumentRefs": [ "arg-qays-criticism-mirror" ], "cardRefs": [ "05_cards/evidences/hadith-hawab-tabaqat-al-khabar-wa-ziyadat-al-idana.md" ], "citationRefs": [ "cit-qays-specific-criticism", "cit-qays-profile-jamal", "cit-card-analysis" ], "evidenceRefs": [ "cit-qays-specific-criticism", "cit-qays-profile-jamal", "cit-card-analysis" ], "icon": { "kindLabel": "حجة الدراسة", "meaning": "الدعوى وأدلتها وحدودها", "status": "needs_review", "statusLabel": "الإحالة موجودة؛ توثيق الحقل يحتاج استكمالاً", "summary": "نقد القطان موجه إلى هذا الفرد من حديث قيس، لا إلى عدالته كلها؛ وتوثيق قيس لا يمحو النقد الخاص. — تطبق معايير الاتصال والنقد الخاص والمخالفة نفسها في خبر سهم مروان؛ تسمية القطان للحوأب لا تنقل حكمه إلى السهم ولا تفرض درجة واحدة على المتنين." }, "id": "argument:arg-qays-criticism-mirror", "illaRefs": [], "kind": "argument", "label": "نقد القطان موجه إلى هذا الفرد من حديث قيس، لا إلى عدالته كلها؛ وتوثيق قيس لا يمحو النقد الخاص.", "matnRefs": [], "rendered": true, "requiresPinpoint": true, "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [ "cit-qays-specific-criticism", "cit-qays-profile-jamal", "cit-card-analysis" ], "riwayaRefs": [ "riwaya-abu-usama-37771", "riwaya-abdrahman-1420-4409" ], "sourceRefs": [ "source-dossier-scans-tadif-hawab-20p" ], "supportLevel": "card_scope", "target": { "argumentId": "arg-qays-criticism-mirror" }, "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": [] }, "argument:arg-qays-family-independence": { "argumentRefs": [ "arg-qays-family-independence" ], "cardRefs": [ "05_cards/evidences/hadith-hawab-tabaqat-al-khabar-wa-ziyadat-al-idana.md" ], "citationRefs": [ "cit-musannaf-37771", "cit-abdrahman-dhakhira-4409", "cit-card-analysis" ], "evidenceRefs": [ "cit-musannaf-37771", "cit-abdrahman-dhakhira-4409", "cit-card-analysis" ], "icon": { "kindLabel": "حجة الدراسة", "meaning": "الدعوى وأدلتها وحدودها", "status": "needs_review", "statusLabel": "الإحالة موجودة؛ توثيق الحقل يحتاج استكمالاً", "summary": "فرع أبي أسامة لا يمر بعبد الرحمن بن صالح، لكنه يلتقي بفرع عبد الرحمن عند إسماعيل ثم قيس؛ فهو يمنع تعميم جرح عبد الرحمن ولا ينشئ أصلاً صحابياً ثانياً. — الاستقلال هنا هندسي داخل العينة المصورة؛ لا يحسم صحة أصل قيس ولا يجرد جميع طرق الباب." }, "id": "argument:arg-qays-family-independence", "illaRefs": [], "kind": "argument", "label": "فرع أبي أسامة لا يمر بعبد الرحمن بن صالح، لكنه يلتقي بفرع عبد الرحمن عند إسماعيل ثم قيس؛ فهو يمنع تعميم جرح عبد الرحمن ولا ينشئ أصلاً صحابياً ثانياً.", "matnRefs": [], "rendered": true, "requiresPinpoint": true, "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [ "cit-musannaf-37771", "cit-abdrahman-dhakhira-4409", "cit-card-analysis" ], "riwayaRefs": [ "riwaya-abu-usama-37771", "riwaya-abdrahman-1420-4409" ], "sourceRefs": [ "source-musannaf-ibn-abi-shayba-hawab-37771", "source-dossier-scans-tadif-hawab-20p" ], "supportLevel": "card_scope", "target": { "argumentId": "arg-qays-family-independence" }, "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": [] }, "argument:arg-rudduni-layer-lock": { "argumentRefs": [ "arg-rudduni-layer-lock" ], "cardRefs": [ "05_cards/evidences/hadith-hawab-tabaqat-al-khabar-wa-ziyadat-al-idana.md" ], "citationRefs": [ "cit-musannaf-37771", "cit-abdrahman-jawzi-1420", "cit-card-analysis" ], "evidenceRefs": [ "cit-musannaf-37771", "cit-abdrahman-jawzi-1420", "cit-card-analysis" ], "icon": { "kindLabel": "حجة الدراسة", "meaning": "الدعوى وأدلتها وحدودها", "status": "needs_review", "statusLabel": "الإحالة موجودة؛ توثيق الحقل يحتاج استكمالاً", "summary": "صيغة «ردوني» مثبتة في فرع عبد الرحمن في العينة، ولا تظهر في صورة أبي أسامة؛ وهي غير قول صفية للأشتر «ردوني لا يفضحني هذا الكلب». معنى الرجوع قائم أيضاً في فرع أبي أسامة بلفظ «ما أظنني إلا راجعة». — إثبات فرق اللفظ لا يثبت أن عبد الرحمن أنشأه؛ ولا تُجعل واقعة صفية شاهداً لهذا الخبر." }, "id": "argument:arg-rudduni-layer-lock", "illaRefs": [], "kind": "argument", "label": "صيغة «ردوني» مثبتة في فرع عبد الرحمن في العينة، ولا تظهر في صورة أبي أسامة؛ وهي غير قول صفية للأشتر «ردوني لا يفضحني هذا الكلب». معنى الرجوع قائم أيضاً في فرع أبي أسامة بلفظ «ما أظنني إلا راجعة».", "matnRefs": [], "rendered": true, "requiresPinpoint": true, "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [ "cit-musannaf-37771", "cit-abdrahman-jawzi-1420", "cit-card-analysis" ], "riwayaRefs": [ "riwaya-abu-usama-37771", "riwaya-abdrahman-1420-4409" ], "sourceRefs": [ "source-musannaf-ibn-abi-shayba-hawab-37771", "source-dossier-scans-tadif-hawab-20p" ], "supportLevel": "card_scope", "target": { "argumentId": "arg-rudduni-layer-lock" }, "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": [] }, "argument:arg-tribe-environment-madhhab-mirror": { "argumentRefs": [ "arg-tribe-environment-madhhab-mirror" ], "cardRefs": [ "05_cards/evidences/hadith-hawab-tabaqat-al-khabar-wa-ziyadat-al-idana.md" ], "citationRefs": [ "cit-qays-profile-jamal", "cit-abdrahman-dhakhira-4409", "cit-card-analysis" ], "evidenceRefs": [ "cit-qays-profile-jamal", "cit-abdrahman-dhakhira-4409", "cit-card-analysis" ], "icon": { "kindLabel": "حجة الدراسة", "meaning": "الدعوى وأدلتها وحدودها", "status": "needs_review", "statusLabel": "الإحالة موجودة؛ توثيق الحقل يحتاج استكمالاً", "summary": "في العينة قيس كوفي عثماني يحمل خبراً استعمل في نقد مسير عائشة، وعبد الرحمن أزدي كوفي موصوف بالتشيع الغالي يحمل فرع «ردوني»؛ فالبيئة والموقف يرفعان الفحص ولا يقومان وحدهما مقام الجرح أو التصحيح. — لا يثبت الموصوف في عبد الرحمن وضع هذا الخبر، ولا تشغّل قاعدة موافقة البدعة حتى يحرر وجه الموافقة العقدية؛ لذلك يبقى HOLD_MADHHAB_CONGRUENCE، وتطبق المرآة على القناتين العثمانية والعلوية." }, "id": "argument:arg-tribe-environment-madhhab-mirror", "illaRefs": [], "kind": "argument", "label": "في العينة قيس كوفي عثماني يحمل خبراً استعمل في نقد مسير عائشة، وعبد الرحمن أزدي كوفي موصوف بالتشيع الغالي يحمل فرع «ردوني»؛ فالبيئة والموقف يرفعان الفحص ولا يقومان وحدهما مقام الجرح أو التصحيح.", "matnRefs": [], "rendered": true, "requiresPinpoint": true, "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [ "cit-qays-profile-jamal", "cit-abdrahman-dhakhira-4409", "cit-card-analysis" ], "riwayaRefs": [], "sourceRefs": [ "source-dossier-scans-tadif-hawab-20p" ], "supportLevel": "card_scope", "target": { "argumentId": "arg-tribe-environment-madhhab-mirror" }, "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": [] }, "argument:arg-witnesses-extra-layer": { "argumentRefs": [ "arg-witnesses-extra-layer" ], "cardRefs": [ "05_cards/evidences/hawab-qabul-shuhud-wa-matn-thalith-hold.md" ], "citationRefs": [ "cit-musannaf-37771", "cit-abdrahman-jawzi-1420", "cit-ibnabbas-ilal-2787", "cit-witnesses-ibn-arabi", "cit-card-holds" ], "evidenceRefs": [ "cit-musannaf-37771", "cit-abdrahman-jawzi-1420", "cit-ibnabbas-ilal-2787", "cit-witnesses-ibn-arabi", "cit-card-holds" ], "icon": { "kindLabel": "حجة الدراسة", "meaning": "الدعوى وأدلتها وحدودها", "status": "needs_review", "statusLabel": "الإحالة موجودة؛ توثيق الحقل يحتاج استكمالاً", "summary": "قصة الأربعين أو الخمسين وتغيير اسم الماء ليست في النصوص الثلاثة المطابقة، ولم يثبت لها في المادة إسناد مستقل؛ وإنكار ابن العربي شاهد تلقي جدلي لا إسناداً مضاداً. — عدم ثبوتها في هذه الحزمة ليس نفياً تاريخياً قطعياً؛ يبقى أقدم إسناد لها ديناً مستقلاً." }, "id": "argument:arg-witnesses-extra-layer", "illaRefs": [], "kind": "argument", "label": "قصة الأربعين أو الخمسين وتغيير اسم الماء ليست في النصوص الثلاثة المطابقة، ولم يثبت لها في المادة إسناد مستقل؛ وإنكار ابن العربي شاهد تلقي جدلي لا إسناداً مضاداً.", "matnRefs": [], "rendered": true, "requiresPinpoint": true, "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [ "cit-musannaf-37771", "cit-abdrahman-jawzi-1420", "cit-ibnabbas-ilal-2787", "cit-witnesses-ibn-arabi", "cit-card-holds" ], "riwayaRefs": [], "sourceRefs": [ "source-musannaf-ibn-abi-shayba-hawab-37771", "source-dossier-scans-tadif-hawab-20p" ], "supportLevel": "card_scope", "target": { "argumentId": "arg-witnesses-extra-layer" }, "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": [] }, "city:abd_al_rahman_ibn_salih": { "argumentRefs": [], "cardRefs": [], "citationRefs": [ "cit-abdrahman-jawzi-1420", "cit-abdrahman-dhakhira-4409" ], "evidenceRefs": [ "cit-abdrahman-jawzi-1420", "cit-abdrahman-dhakhira-4409" ], "icon": { "kindLabel": "مصر النقل", "meaning": "المصر المسجل ومرجعه؛ البيئة وحدها ليست جرحاً", "status": "documented", "statusLabel": "إحالة موضعية مقابلة", "summary": "عبد الرحمن بن صالح الأزدي: الكوفة" }, "id": "city:abd_al_rahman_ibn_salih", "illaRefs": [], "kind": "city", "label": "عبد الرحمن بن صالح الأزدي: الكوفة", "matnRefs": [], "rendered": true, "requiresPinpoint": false, "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [ "cit-abdrahman-jawzi-1420", "cit-abdrahman-dhakhira-4409" ], "riwayaRefs": [], "sourceRefs": [ "source-dossier-scans-tadif-hawab-20p" ], "supportLevel": "exact", "target": { "field": "city", "nodeId": "abd_al_rahman_ibn_salih" }, "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": [] }, "city:abu_usama": { "argumentRefs": [], "cardRefs": [], "citationRefs": [], "evidenceRefs": [], "icon": { "kindLabel": "مصر النقل", "meaning": "المصر المسجل ومرجعه؛ البيئة وحدها ليست جرحاً", "status": "missing", "statusLabel": "لم تسجل إحالة موضعية لهذا الحقل", "summary": "أبو أسامة: غير معيّن" }, "id": "city:abu_usama", "illaRefs": [], "kind": "city", "label": "أبو أسامة: غير معيّن", "matnRefs": [], "rendered": true, "requiresPinpoint": true, "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [], "riwayaRefs": [], "sourceRefs": [], "supportLevel": "unresolved", "target": { "field": "city", "nodeId": "abu_usama" }, "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": [] }, "city:al_ashajj": { "argumentRefs": [], "cardRefs": [], "citationRefs": [], "evidenceRefs": [], "icon": { "kindLabel": "مصر النقل", "meaning": "المصر المسجل ومرجعه؛ البيئة وحدها ليست جرحاً", "status": "missing", "statusLabel": "لم تسجل إحالة موضعية لهذا الحقل", "summary": "الأشج: غير معيّن" }, "id": "city:al_ashajj", "illaRefs": [], "kind": "city", "label": "الأشج: غير معيّن", "matnRefs": [], "rendered": true, "requiresPinpoint": true, "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [], "riwayaRefs": [], "sourceRefs": [], "supportLevel": "unresolved", "target": { "field": "city", "nodeId": "al_ashajj" }, "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": [] }, "city:ikrima": { "argumentRefs": [], "cardRefs": [], "citationRefs": [], "evidenceRefs": [], "icon": { "kindLabel": "مصر النقل", "meaning": "المصر المسجل ومرجعه؛ البيئة وحدها ليست جرحاً", "status": "missing", "statusLabel": "لم تسجل إحالة موضعية لهذا الحقل", "summary": "عكرمة: غير معيّن" }, "id": "city:ikrima", "illaRefs": [], "kind": "city", "label": "عكرمة: غير معيّن", "matnRefs": [], "rendered": true, "requiresPinpoint": true, "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [], "riwayaRefs": [], "sourceRefs": [], "supportLevel": "unresolved", "target": { "field": "city", "nodeId": "ikrima" }, "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": [] }, "city:isam_ibn_qudama": { "argumentRefs": [], "cardRefs": [], "citationRefs": [], "evidenceRefs": [], "icon": { "kindLabel": "مصر النقل", "meaning": "المصر المسجل ومرجعه؛ البيئة وحدها ليست جرحاً", "status": "missing", "statusLabel": "لم تسجل إحالة موضعية لهذا الحقل", "summary": "عصام بن قدامة: غير معيّن" }, "id": "city:isam_ibn_qudama", "illaRefs": [], "kind": "city", "label": "عصام بن قدامة: غير معيّن", "matnRefs": [], "rendered": true, "requiresPinpoint": true, "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [], "riwayaRefs": [], "sourceRefs": [], "supportLevel": "unresolved", "target": { "field": "city", "nodeId": "isam_ibn_qudama" }, "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": [] }, "city:ismail": { "argumentRefs": [], "cardRefs": [], "citationRefs": [], "evidenceRefs": [], "icon": { "kindLabel": "مصر النقل", "meaning": "المصر المسجل ومرجعه؛ البيئة وحدها ليست جرحاً", "status": "missing", "statusLabel": "لم تسجل إحالة موضعية لهذا الحقل", "summary": "إسماعيل بن أبي خالد: غير معيّن" }, "id": "city:ismail", "illaRefs": [], "kind": "city", "label": "إسماعيل بن أبي خالد: غير معيّن", "matnRefs": [], "rendered": true, "requiresPinpoint": true, "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [], "riwayaRefs": [], "sourceRefs": [], "supportLevel": "unresolved", "target": { "field": "city", "nodeId": "ismail" }, "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": [] }, "city:muhammad_ibn_fudayl": { "argumentRefs": [], "cardRefs": [], "citationRefs": [], "evidenceRefs": [], "icon": { "kindLabel": "مصر النقل", "meaning": "المصر المسجل ومرجعه؛ البيئة وحدها ليست جرحاً", "status": "missing", "statusLabel": "لم تسجل إحالة موضعية لهذا الحقل", "summary": "محمد بن فضيل: غير معيّن" }, "id": "city:muhammad_ibn_fudayl", "illaRefs": [], "kind": "city", "label": "محمد بن فضيل: غير معيّن", "matnRefs": [], "rendered": true, "requiresPinpoint": true, "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [], "riwayaRefs": [], "sourceRefs": [], "supportLevel": "unresolved", "target": { "field": "city", "nodeId": "muhammad_ibn_fudayl" }, "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": [] }, "city:qays": { "argumentRefs": [], "cardRefs": [], "citationRefs": [ "cit-qays-profile-jamal" ], "evidenceRefs": [ "cit-qays-profile-jamal" ], "icon": { "kindLabel": "مصر النقل", "meaning": "المصر المسجل ومرجعه؛ البيئة وحدها ليست جرحاً", "status": "documented", "statusLabel": "إحالة موضعية مقابلة", "summary": "قيس بن أبي حازم: الكوفة" }, "id": "city:qays", "illaRefs": [], "kind": "city", "label": "قيس بن أبي حازم: الكوفة", "matnRefs": [], "rendered": true, "requiresPinpoint": false, "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [ "cit-qays-profile-jamal" ], "riwayaRefs": [], "sourceRefs": [ "source-dossier-scans-tadif-hawab-20p" ], "supportLevel": "exact", "target": { "field": "city", "nodeId": "qays" }, "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": [] }, "city:uqba_ibn_khalid": { "argumentRefs": [], "cardRefs": [], "citationRefs": [], "evidenceRefs": [], "icon": { "kindLabel": "مصر النقل", "meaning": "المصر المسجل ومرجعه؛ البيئة وحدها ليست جرحاً", "status": "missing", "statusLabel": "لم تسجل إحالة موضعية لهذا الحقل", "summary": "عقبة بن خالد: غير معيّن" }, "id": "city:uqba_ibn_khalid", "illaRefs": [], "kind": "city", "label": "عقبة بن خالد: غير معيّن", "matnRefs": [], "rendered": true, "requiresPinpoint": true, "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [], "riwayaRefs": [], "sourceRefs": [], "supportLevel": "unresolved", "target": { "field": "city", "nodeId": "uqba_ibn_khalid" }, "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": [] }, "edge:edge-abdrahman-books": { "argumentRefs": [], "cardRefs": [ "05_cards/evidences/hadith-hawab-tabaqat-al-khabar-wa-ziyadat-al-idana.md" ], "citationRefs": [ "cit-abdrahman-jawzi-1420", "cit-abdrahman-dhakhira-4409", "cit-card-analysis" ], "evidenceRefs": [ "cit-abdrahman-jawzi-1420", "cit-abdrahman-dhakhira-4409", "cit-card-analysis" ], "icon": { "kindLabel": "حلقة الرواية", "meaning": "صلة النقل بين طرفي السهم والروايات التي تحملها", "status": "needs_review", "statusLabel": "الإحالة موجودة؛ توثيق الحقل يحتاج استكمالاً", "summary": "إحالة تخريج؛ طبقات عليا مطوية" }, "id": "edge:edge-abdrahman-books", "illaRefs": [ "illa-abdrahman-specific-branch" ], "kind": "edge", "label": "إحالة تخريج؛ طبقات عليا مطوية", "matnRefs": [ "matn-abdrahman-rudduni" ], "rendered": true, "requiresPinpoint": true, "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [ "cit-abdrahman-jawzi-1420", "cit-abdrahman-dhakhira-4409", "cit-card-analysis" ], "riwayaRefs": [ "riwaya-abdrahman-1420-4409" ], "sourceRefs": [ "source-dossier-scans-tadif-hawab-20p" ], "supportLevel": "card_scope", "target": { "edgeId": "edge-abdrahman-books", "from": "abd_al_rahman_ibn_salih", "to": "jawzi_dhakhira" }, "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": [] }, "edge:edge-abu-usama-musannaf": { "argumentRefs": [], "cardRefs": [], "citationRefs": [ "cit-musannaf-37771" ], "evidenceRefs": [ "cit-musannaf-37771" ], "icon": { "kindLabel": "حلقة الرواية", "meaning": "صلة النقل بين طرفي السهم والروايات التي تحملها", "status": "documented", "statusLabel": "إحالة موضعية مقابلة", "summary": "حدثنا أبو أسامة" }, "id": "edge:edge-abu-usama-musannaf", "illaRefs": [], "kind": "edge", "label": "حدثنا أبو أسامة", "matnRefs": [ "matn-qays-nucleus", "matn-abu-usama-context" ], "rendered": true, "requiresPinpoint": false, "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [ "cit-musannaf-37771" ], "riwayaRefs": [ "riwaya-abu-usama-37771" ], "sourceRefs": [ "source-musannaf-ibn-abi-shayba-hawab-37771" ], "supportLevel": "exact", "target": { "edgeId": "edge-abu-usama-musannaf", "from": "abu_usama", "to": "musannaf_37771" }, "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": [] }, "edge:edge-aisha-qays": { "argumentRefs": [], "cardRefs": [ "05_cards/evidences/hawab-qabul-shuhud-wa-matn-thalith-hold.md" ], "citationRefs": [ "cit-musannaf-37771", "cit-qays-specific-criticism", "cit-card-holds", "cit-qays-profile-jamal", "cit-abdrahman-jawzi-1420", "cit-abdrahman-dhakhira-4409" ], "evidenceRefs": [ "cit-musannaf-37771", "cit-qays-specific-criticism", "cit-card-holds", "cit-qays-profile-jamal", "cit-abdrahman-jawzi-1420", "cit-abdrahman-dhakhira-4409" ], "icon": { "kindLabel": "حلقة الرواية", "meaning": "صلة النقل بين طرفي السهم والروايات التي تحملها", "status": "needs_review", "statusLabel": "الإحالة موجودة؛ توثيق الحقل يحتاج استكمالاً", "summary": "قال: لما بلغت عائشة — حكاية بلا تصريح بالسماع" }, "id": "edge:edge-aisha-qays", "illaRefs": [ "illa-qays-source-unresolved" ], "kind": "edge", "label": "قال: لما بلغت عائشة — حكاية بلا تصريح بالسماع", "matnRefs": [ "matn-qays-nucleus", "matn-abu-usama-context", "matn-abdrahman-rudduni" ], "rendered": true, "requiresPinpoint": true, "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [ "cit-musannaf-37771", "cit-qays-specific-criticism", "cit-card-holds", "cit-qays-profile-jamal", "cit-abdrahman-jawzi-1420", "cit-abdrahman-dhakhira-4409" ], "riwayaRefs": [ "riwaya-abu-usama-37771", "riwaya-abdrahman-1420-4409" ], "sourceRefs": [ "source-musannaf-ibn-abi-shayba-hawab-37771", "source-dossier-scans-tadif-hawab-20p" ], "supportLevel": "card_scope", "target": { "edgeId": "edge-aisha-qays", "from": "aisha", "to": "qays" }, "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": [] }, "edge:edge-ashajj-ilal2787": { "argumentRefs": [], "cardRefs": [], "citationRefs": [ "cit-ibnabbas-ilal-2787" ], "evidenceRefs": [ "cit-ibnabbas-ilal-2787" ], "icon": { "kindLabel": "حلقة الرواية", "meaning": "صلة النقل بين طرفي السهم والروايات التي تحملها", "status": "documented", "statusLabel": "إحالة موضعية مقابلة", "summary": "موضع سؤال ابن أبي حاتم عن الحديث" }, "id": "edge:edge-ashajj-ilal2787", "illaRefs": [], "kind": "edge", "label": "موضع سؤال ابن أبي حاتم عن الحديث", "matnRefs": [ "matn-ibnabbas-expansion" ], "rendered": true, "requiresPinpoint": false, "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [ "cit-ibnabbas-ilal-2787" ], "riwayaRefs": [ "riwaya-ibnabbas-2787" ], "sourceRefs": [ "source-dossier-scans-tadif-hawab-20p" ], "supportLevel": "exact", "target": { "edgeId": "edge-ashajj-ilal2787", "from": "al_ashajj", "to": "ilal_2787" }, "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": [] }, "edge:edge-ibnabbas-ikrima": { "argumentRefs": [], "cardRefs": [], "citationRefs": [ "cit-ibnabbas-ilal-2787" ], "evidenceRefs": [ "cit-ibnabbas-ilal-2787" ], "icon": { "kindLabel": "حلقة الرواية", "meaning": "صلة النقل بين طرفي السهم والروايات التي تحملها", "status": "documented", "statusLabel": "إحالة موضعية مقابلة", "summary": "عن ابن عباس" }, "id": "edge:edge-ibnabbas-ikrima", "illaRefs": [], "kind": "edge", "label": "عن ابن عباس", "matnRefs": [ "matn-ibnabbas-expansion" ], "rendered": true, "requiresPinpoint": false, "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [ "cit-ibnabbas-ilal-2787" ], "riwayaRefs": [ "riwaya-ibnabbas-2787" ], "sourceRefs": [ "source-dossier-scans-tadif-hawab-20p" ], "supportLevel": "exact", "target": { "edgeId": "edge-ibnabbas-ikrima", "from": "ibn_abbas", "to": "ikrima" }, "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": [] }, "edge:edge-ikrima-isam": { "argumentRefs": [], "cardRefs": [], "citationRefs": [ "cit-ibnabbas-ilal-2787" ], "evidenceRefs": [ "cit-ibnabbas-ilal-2787" ], "icon": { "kindLabel": "حلقة الرواية", "meaning": "صلة النقل بين طرفي السهم والروايات التي تحملها", "status": "documented", "statusLabel": "إحالة موضعية مقابلة", "summary": "عن عكرمة" }, "id": "edge:edge-ikrima-isam", "illaRefs": [ "illa-isam-tafarrud" ], "kind": "edge", "label": "عن عكرمة", "matnRefs": [ "matn-ibnabbas-expansion" ], "rendered": true, "requiresPinpoint": false, "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [ "cit-ibnabbas-ilal-2787" ], "riwayaRefs": [ "riwaya-ibnabbas-2787" ], "sourceRefs": [ "source-dossier-scans-tadif-hawab-20p" ], "supportLevel": "exact", "target": { "edgeId": "edge-ikrima-isam", "from": "ikrima", "to": "isam_ibn_qudama" }, "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": [] }, "edge:edge-isam-uqba": { "argumentRefs": [], "cardRefs": [], "citationRefs": [ "cit-ibnabbas-ilal-2787" ], "evidenceRefs": [ "cit-ibnabbas-ilal-2787" ], "icon": { "kindLabel": "حلقة الرواية", "meaning": "صلة النقل بين طرفي السهم والروايات التي تحملها", "status": "documented", "statusLabel": "إحالة موضعية مقابلة", "summary": "عن ابن قدامة — يعني عصاماً" }, "id": "edge:edge-isam-uqba", "illaRefs": [], "kind": "edge", "label": "عن ابن قدامة — يعني عصاماً", "matnRefs": [ "matn-ibnabbas-expansion" ], "rendered": true, "requiresPinpoint": false, "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [ "cit-ibnabbas-ilal-2787" ], "riwayaRefs": [ "riwaya-ibnabbas-2787" ], "sourceRefs": [ "source-dossier-scans-tadif-hawab-20p" ], "supportLevel": "exact", "target": { "edgeId": "edge-isam-uqba", "from": "isam_ibn_qudama", "to": "uqba_ibn_khalid" }, "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": [] }, "edge:edge-ismail-abu-usama": { "argumentRefs": [], "cardRefs": [], "citationRefs": [ "cit-musannaf-37771" ], "evidenceRefs": [ "cit-musannaf-37771" ], "icon": { "kindLabel": "حلقة الرواية", "meaning": "صلة النقل بين طرفي السهم والروايات التي تحملها", "status": "documented", "statusLabel": "إحالة موضعية مقابلة", "summary": "حدثنا إسماعيل" }, "id": "edge:edge-ismail-abu-usama", "illaRefs": [], "kind": "edge", "label": "حدثنا إسماعيل", "matnRefs": [ "matn-qays-nucleus", "matn-abu-usama-context" ], "rendered": true, "requiresPinpoint": false, "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [ "cit-musannaf-37771" ], "riwayaRefs": [ "riwaya-abu-usama-37771" ], "sourceRefs": [ "source-musannaf-ibn-abi-shayba-hawab-37771" ], "supportLevel": "exact", "target": { "edgeId": "edge-ismail-abu-usama", "from": "ismail", "to": "abu_usama" }, "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": [] }, "edge:edge-ismail-muhammad-fudayl": { "argumentRefs": [], "cardRefs": [], "citationRefs": [ "cit-abdrahman-dhakhira-4409", "cit-abdrahman-jawzi-1420" ], "evidenceRefs": [ "cit-abdrahman-dhakhira-4409", "cit-abdrahman-jawzi-1420" ], "icon": { "kindLabel": "حلقة الرواية", "meaning": "صلة النقل بين طرفي السهم والروايات التي تحملها", "status": "documented", "statusLabel": "إحالة موضعية مقابلة", "summary": "محمد بن فضيل عن إسماعيل" }, "id": "edge:edge-ismail-muhammad-fudayl", "illaRefs": [], "kind": "edge", "label": "محمد بن فضيل عن إسماعيل", "matnRefs": [ "matn-abdrahman-rudduni" ], "rendered": true, "requiresPinpoint": false, "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [ "cit-abdrahman-dhakhira-4409", "cit-abdrahman-jawzi-1420" ], "riwayaRefs": [ "riwaya-abdrahman-1420-4409" ], "sourceRefs": [ "source-dossier-scans-tadif-hawab-20p" ], "supportLevel": "exact", "target": { "edgeId": "edge-ismail-muhammad-fudayl", "from": "ismail", "to": "muhammad_ibn_fudayl" }, "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": [] }, "edge:edge-muhammad-fudayl-abdrahman": { "argumentRefs": [], "cardRefs": [ "05_cards/evidences/hadith-hawab-tabaqat-al-khabar-wa-ziyadat-al-idana.md" ], "citationRefs": [ "cit-abdrahman-jawzi-1420", "cit-abdrahman-dhakhira-4409", "cit-card-analysis" ], "evidenceRefs": [ "cit-abdrahman-jawzi-1420", "cit-abdrahman-dhakhira-4409", "cit-card-analysis" ], "icon": { "kindLabel": "حلقة الرواية", "meaning": "صلة النقل بين طرفي السهم والروايات التي تحملها", "status": "needs_review", "statusLabel": "الإحالة موجودة؛ توثيق الحقل يحتاج استكمالاً", "summary": "عن محمد بن فضيل" }, "id": "edge:edge-muhammad-fudayl-abdrahman", "illaRefs": [ "illa-abdrahman-specific-branch" ], "kind": "edge", "label": "عن محمد بن فضيل", "matnRefs": [ "matn-abdrahman-rudduni" ], "rendered": true, "requiresPinpoint": true, "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [ "cit-abdrahman-jawzi-1420", "cit-abdrahman-dhakhira-4409", "cit-card-analysis" ], "riwayaRefs": [ "riwaya-abdrahman-1420-4409" ], "sourceRefs": [ "source-dossier-scans-tadif-hawab-20p" ], "supportLevel": "card_scope", "target": { "edgeId": "edge-muhammad-fudayl-abdrahman", "from": "muhammad_ibn_fudayl", "to": "abd_al_rahman_ibn_salih" }, "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": [] }, "edge:edge-nabi-aisha": { "argumentRefs": [], "cardRefs": [], "citationRefs": [ "cit-musannaf-37771", "cit-abdrahman-jawzi-1420", "cit-abdrahman-dhakhira-4409" ], "evidenceRefs": [ "cit-musannaf-37771", "cit-abdrahman-jawzi-1420", "cit-abdrahman-dhakhira-4409" ], "icon": { "kindLabel": "حلقة الرواية", "meaning": "صلة النقل بين طرفي السهم والروايات التي تحملها", "status": "documented", "statusLabel": "إحالة موضعية مقابلة", "summary": "إني سمعت رسول الله — داخل كلام عائشة" }, "id": "edge:edge-nabi-aisha", "illaRefs": [], "kind": "edge", "label": "إني سمعت رسول الله — داخل كلام عائشة", "matnRefs": [ "matn-qays-nucleus", "matn-abu-usama-context", "matn-abdrahman-rudduni" ], "rendered": true, "requiresPinpoint": false, "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [ "cit-musannaf-37771", "cit-abdrahman-jawzi-1420", "cit-abdrahman-dhakhira-4409" ], "riwayaRefs": [ "riwaya-abu-usama-37771", "riwaya-abdrahman-1420-4409" ], "sourceRefs": [ "source-musannaf-ibn-abi-shayba-hawab-37771", "source-dossier-scans-tadif-hawab-20p" ], "supportLevel": "exact", "target": { "edgeId": "edge-nabi-aisha", "from": "nabi", "to": "aisha" }, "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": [] }, "edge:edge-nabi-ibnabbas": { "argumentRefs": [], "cardRefs": [], "citationRefs": [ "cit-ibnabbas-ilal-2787" ], "evidenceRefs": [ "cit-ibnabbas-ilal-2787" ], "icon": { "kindLabel": "حلقة الرواية", "meaning": "صلة النقل بين طرفي السهم والروايات التي تحملها", "status": "documented", "statusLabel": "إحالة موضعية مقابلة", "summary": "قال لبعض نسائه، من رواية ابن عباس" }, "id": "edge:edge-nabi-ibnabbas", "illaRefs": [], "kind": "edge", "label": "قال لبعض نسائه، من رواية ابن عباس", "matnRefs": [ "matn-ibnabbas-expansion" ], "rendered": true, "requiresPinpoint": false, "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [ "cit-ibnabbas-ilal-2787" ], "riwayaRefs": [ "riwaya-ibnabbas-2787" ], "sourceRefs": [ "source-dossier-scans-tadif-hawab-20p" ], "supportLevel": "exact", "target": { "edgeId": "edge-nabi-ibnabbas", "from": "nabi", "to": "ibn_abbas" }, "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": [] }, "edge:edge-qays-ismail": { "argumentRefs": [], "cardRefs": [], "citationRefs": [ "cit-musannaf-37771", "cit-abdrahman-dhakhira-4409", "cit-abdrahman-jawzi-1420", "cit-qays-specific-criticism", "cit-qays-profile-jamal" ], "evidenceRefs": [ "cit-musannaf-37771", "cit-abdrahman-dhakhira-4409", "cit-abdrahman-jawzi-1420", "cit-qays-specific-criticism", "cit-qays-profile-jamal" ], "icon": { "kindLabel": "حلقة الرواية", "meaning": "صلة النقل بين طرفي السهم والروايات التي تحملها", "status": "documented", "statusLabel": "إحالة موضعية مقابلة", "summary": "عن قيس" }, "id": "edge:edge-qays-ismail", "illaRefs": [ "illa-qays-specific-criticism" ], "kind": "edge", "label": "عن قيس", "matnRefs": [ "matn-qays-nucleus", "matn-abu-usama-context", "matn-abdrahman-rudduni" ], "rendered": true, "requiresPinpoint": false, "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [ "cit-musannaf-37771", "cit-abdrahman-dhakhira-4409", "cit-abdrahman-jawzi-1420", "cit-qays-specific-criticism", "cit-qays-profile-jamal" ], "riwayaRefs": [ "riwaya-abu-usama-37771", "riwaya-abdrahman-1420-4409" ], "sourceRefs": [ "source-musannaf-ibn-abi-shayba-hawab-37771", "source-dossier-scans-tadif-hawab-20p" ], "supportLevel": "exact", "target": { "edgeId": "edge-qays-ismail", "from": "qays", "to": "ismail" }, "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": [] }, "edge:edge-uqba-ashajj": { "argumentRefs": [], "cardRefs": [], "citationRefs": [ "cit-ibnabbas-ilal-2787" ], "evidenceRefs": [ "cit-ibnabbas-ilal-2787" ], "icon": { "kindLabel": "حلقة الرواية", "meaning": "صلة النقل بين طرفي السهم والروايات التي تحملها", "status": "documented", "statusLabel": "إحالة موضعية مقابلة", "summary": "عن عقبة بن خالد" }, "id": "edge:edge-uqba-ashajj", "illaRefs": [], "kind": "edge", "label": "عن عقبة بن خالد", "matnRefs": [ "matn-ibnabbas-expansion" ], "rendered": true, "requiresPinpoint": false, "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [ "cit-ibnabbas-ilal-2787" ], "riwayaRefs": [ "riwaya-ibnabbas-2787" ], "sourceRefs": [ "source-dossier-scans-tadif-hawab-20p" ], "supportLevel": "exact", "target": { "edgeId": "edge-uqba-ashajj", "from": "uqba_ibn_khalid", "to": "al_ashajj" }, "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": [] }, "edge:edge-witnesses-unresolved": { "argumentRefs": [], "cardRefs": [ "05_cards/evidences/hawab-qabul-shuhud-wa-matn-thalith-hold.md" ], "citationRefs": [ "cit-card-holds", "cit-witnesses-ibn-arabi" ], "evidenceRefs": [ "cit-card-holds", "cit-witnesses-ibn-arabi" ], "icon": { "kindLabel": "حلقة الرواية", "meaning": "صلة النقل بين طرفي السهم والروايات التي تحملها", "status": "needs_review", "statusLabel": "الإحالة موجودة؛ توثيق الحقل يحتاج استكمالاً", "summary": "إحالة بحثية؛ لا طريق مثبت في المادة" }, "id": "edge:edge-witnesses-unresolved", "illaRefs": [], "kind": "edge", "label": "إحالة بحثية؛ لا طريق مثبت في المادة", "matnRefs": [], "rendered": true, "requiresPinpoint": true, "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [ "cit-card-holds", "cit-witnesses-ibn-arabi" ], "riwayaRefs": [], "sourceRefs": [ "source-dossier-scans-tadif-hawab-20p" ], "supportLevel": "card_scope", "target": { "edgeId": "edge-witnesses-unresolved", "from": "witnesses_void", "to": "witnesses_story" }, "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": [] }, "flag:abd_al_rahman_ibn_salih:ghuluw": { "argumentRefs": [], "cardRefs": [], "citationRefs": [ "cit-abdrahman-dhakhira-4409" ], "evidenceRefs": [ "cit-abdrahman-dhakhira-4409" ], "icon": { "kindLabel": "وصف الراوي", "meaning": "الوصف الخاص المسجل ومصدر نسبته؛ لا يستنتج من القبيلة أو المصر", "status": "documented", "statusLabel": "إحالة موضعية مقابلة", "summary": "عبد الرحمن بن صالح الأزدي: غلو" }, "id": "flag:abd_al_rahman_ibn_salih:ghuluw", "illaRefs": [], "kind": "flag", "label": "عبد الرحمن بن صالح الأزدي: غلو", "matnRefs": [], "rendered": true, "requiresPinpoint": false, "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [ "cit-abdrahman-dhakhira-4409" ], "riwayaRefs": [], "sourceRefs": [ "source-dossier-scans-tadif-hawab-20p" ], "supportLevel": "exact", "target": { "field": "flags", "flag": "ghuluw", "nodeId": "abd_al_rahman_ibn_salih" }, "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": [] }, "flag:abd_al_rahman_ibn_salih:jarh": { "argumentRefs": [], "cardRefs": [], "citationRefs": [ "cit-abdrahman-jawzi-1420", "cit-abdrahman-dhakhira-4409" ], "evidenceRefs": [ "cit-abdrahman-jawzi-1420", "cit-abdrahman-dhakhira-4409" ], "icon": { "kindLabel": "وصف الراوي", "meaning": "الوصف الخاص المسجل ومصدر نسبته؛ لا يستنتج من القبيلة أو المصر", "status": "documented", "statusLabel": "إحالة موضعية مقابلة", "summary": "عبد الرحمن بن صالح الأزدي: تجريح صريح" }, "id": "flag:abd_al_rahman_ibn_salih:jarh", "illaRefs": [], "kind": "flag", "label": "عبد الرحمن بن صالح الأزدي: تجريح صريح", "matnRefs": [], "rendered": true, "requiresPinpoint": false, "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [ "cit-abdrahman-jawzi-1420", "cit-abdrahman-dhakhira-4409" ], "riwayaRefs": [], "sourceRefs": [ "source-dossier-scans-tadif-hawab-20p" ], "supportLevel": "exact", "target": { "field": "flags", "flag": "jarh", "nodeId": "abd_al_rahman_ibn_salih" }, "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": [] }, "flag:qays:jarh": { "argumentRefs": [], "cardRefs": [], "citationRefs": [ "cit-qays-specific-criticism" ], "evidenceRefs": [ "cit-qays-specific-criticism" ], "icon": { "kindLabel": "وصف الراوي", "meaning": "الوصف الخاص المسجل ومصدر نسبته؛ لا يستنتج من القبيلة أو المصر", "status": "documented", "statusLabel": "إحالة موضعية مقابلة", "summary": "قيس بن أبي حازم: تجريح صريح" }, "id": "flag:qays:jarh", "illaRefs": [], "kind": "flag", "label": "قيس بن أبي حازم: تجريح صريح", "matnRefs": [], "rendered": true, "requiresPinpoint": false, "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [ "cit-qays-specific-criticism" ], "riwayaRefs": [], "sourceRefs": [ "source-dossier-scans-tadif-hawab-20p" ], "supportLevel": "exact", "target": { "field": "flags", "flag": "jarh", "nodeId": "qays" }, "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": [] }, "geography": { "argumentRefs": [ "arg-tribe-environment-madhhab-mirror" ], "cardRefs": [ "05_cards/evidences/hadith-hawab-tabaqat-al-khabar-wa-ziyadat-al-idana.md" ], "citationRefs": [ "cit-qays-profile-jamal", "cit-abdrahman-dhakhira-4409", "cit-card-analysis" ], "evidenceRefs": [ "cit-qays-profile-jamal", "cit-abdrahman-dhakhira-4409", "cit-card-analysis" ], "icon": { "kindLabel": "قراءة جغرافية", "meaning": "الحجة الجغرافية ونطاق العينة وحدودها", "status": "needs_review", "statusLabel": "الإحالة موجودة؛ توثيق الحقل يحتاج استكمالاً", "summary": "في العينة قيس كوفي عثماني يحمل خبراً استعمل في نقد مسير عائشة، وعبد الرحمن أزدي كوفي موصوف بالتشيع الغالي يحمل فرع «ردوني»؛ فالبيئة والموقف يرفعان الفحص ولا يقومان وحدهما مقام الجرح أو التصحيح. — لا يثبت الموصوف في عبد الرحمن وضع هذا الخبر، ولا تشغّل قاعدة موافقة البدعة حتى يحرر وجه الموافقة العقدية؛ لذلك يبقى HOLD_MADHHAB_CONGRUENCE، وتطبق المرآة على القناتين العثمانية والعلوية." }, "id": "geography", "illaRefs": [], "kind": "geography", "label": "الحجة الجغرافية", "matnRefs": [], "rendered": true, "requiresPinpoint": true, "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [ "cit-qays-profile-jamal", "cit-abdrahman-dhakhira-4409", "cit-card-analysis" ], "riwayaRefs": [], "sourceRefs": [ "source-dossier-scans-tadif-hawab-20p" ], "supportLevel": "card_scope", "target": { "field": "geographyArgument" }, "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": [] }, "hukm:qays": { "argumentRefs": [], "cardRefs": [], "citationRefs": [ "cit-qays-profile-jamal" ], "evidenceRefs": [ "cit-qays-profile-jamal" ], "icon": { "kindLabel": "حكم الراوي", "meaning": "الحكم المنسوب إلى ناقد؛ لا يدل لون الأيقونة على رتبة الراوي", "status": "documented", "statusLabel": "إحالة موضعية مقابلة", "summary": "قيس بن أبي حازم: ثقة" }, "id": "hukm:qays", "illaRefs": [], "kind": "hukm", "label": "قيس بن أبي حازم: ثقة", "matnRefs": [], "rendered": true, "requiresPinpoint": false, "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [ "cit-qays-profile-jamal" ], "riwayaRefs": [], "sourceRefs": [ "source-dossier-scans-tadif-hawab-20p" ], "supportLevel": "exact", "target": { "field": "hukm", "nodeId": "qays" }, "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": [] }, "illa:illa-abdrahman-specific-branch": { "argumentRefs": [], "cardRefs": [ "05_cards/evidences/hadith-hawab-tabaqat-al-khabar-wa-ziyadat-al-idana.md" ], "citationRefs": [ "cit-abdrahman-jawzi-1420", "cit-abdrahman-dhakhira-4409", "cit-card-analysis" ], "evidenceRefs": [ "cit-abdrahman-jawzi-1420", "cit-abdrahman-dhakhira-4409", "cit-card-analysis" ], "icon": { "kindLabel": "مسألة نقدية", "meaning": "العلة أو الاعتراض بنطاقه ومصدره", "status": "needs_review", "statusLabel": "الإحالة موجودة؛ توثيق الحقل يحتاج استكمالاً", "summary": "الجرح المسمى والتشيع الغالي موثقان في عبد الرحمن، فيقيدان فرعه ولا ينتقلان إلى فرع أبي أسامة." }, "id": "illa:illa-abdrahman-specific-branch", "illaRefs": [ "illa-abdrahman-specific-branch" ], "kind": "illa", "label": "الجرح المسمى والتشيع الغالي موثقان في عبد الرحمن، فيقيدان فرعه ولا ينتقلان إلى فرع أبي أسامة.", "matnRefs": [], "rendered": true, "requiresPinpoint": true, "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [ "cit-abdrahman-jawzi-1420", "cit-abdrahman-dhakhira-4409", "cit-card-analysis" ], "riwayaRefs": [ "riwaya-abdrahman-1420-4409" ], "sourceRefs": [ "source-dossier-scans-tadif-hawab-20p" ], "supportLevel": "card_scope", "target": { "id": "abd_al_rahman_ibn_salih", "kind": "node" }, "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": [] }, "illa:illa-isam-tafarrud": { "argumentRefs": [], "cardRefs": [], "citationRefs": [ "cit-ibnabbas-ilal-2787" ], "evidenceRefs": [ "cit-ibnabbas-ilal-2787" ], "icon": { "kindLabel": "مسألة نقدية", "meaning": "العلة أو الاعتراض بنطاقه ومصدره", "status": "documented", "statusLabel": "إحالة موضعية مقابلة", "summary": "قال أبو حاتم: لم يرو هذا الحديث غير عصام؛ وقال أبو زرعة: لا يروى من طريق غيره." }, "id": "illa:illa-isam-tafarrud", "illaRefs": [ "illa-isam-tafarrud" ], "kind": "illa", "label": "قال أبو حاتم: لم يرو هذا الحديث غير عصام؛ وقال أبو زرعة: لا يروى من طريق غيره.", "matnRefs": [], "rendered": true, "requiresPinpoint": false, "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [ "cit-ibnabbas-ilal-2787" ], "riwayaRefs": [ "riwaya-ibnabbas-2787" ], "sourceRefs": [ "source-dossier-scans-tadif-hawab-20p" ], "supportLevel": "exact", "target": { "id": "isam_ibn_qudama", "kind": "node" }, "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": [] }, "illa:illa-qays-source-unresolved": { "argumentRefs": [], "cardRefs": [ "05_cards/evidences/hawab-qabul-shuhud-wa-matn-thalith-hold.md" ], "citationRefs": [ "cit-musannaf-37771", "cit-qays-profile-jamal", "cit-card-holds" ], "evidenceRefs": [ "cit-musannaf-37771", "cit-qays-profile-jamal", "cit-card-holds" ], "icon": { "kindLabel": "مسألة نقدية", "meaning": "العلة أو الاعتراض بنطاقه ومصدره", "status": "needs_review", "statusLabel": "الإحالة موجودة؛ توثيق الحقل يحتاج استكمالاً", "summary": "الصيغة المطابقة تجعل قيس يحكي المشهد ولا يصرح «سمعت عائشة»؛ وعدم شهوده الجمل لا يكفي وحده للجزم بالإرسال." }, "id": "illa:illa-qays-source-unresolved", "illaRefs": [ "illa-qays-source-unresolved" ], "kind": "illa", "label": "الصيغة المطابقة تجعل قيس يحكي المشهد ولا يصرح «سمعت عائشة»؛ وعدم شهوده الجمل لا يكفي وحده للجزم بالإرسال.", "matnRefs": [], "rendered": true, "requiresPinpoint": true, "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [ "cit-musannaf-37771", "cit-qays-profile-jamal", "cit-card-holds" ], "riwayaRefs": [ "riwaya-abu-usama-37771" ], "sourceRefs": [ "source-musannaf-ibn-abi-shayba-hawab-37771", "source-dossier-scans-tadif-hawab-20p" ], "supportLevel": "card_scope", "target": { "id": "edge-aisha-qays", "kind": "edge" }, "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": [] }, "illa:illa-qays-specific-criticism": { "argumentRefs": [], "cardRefs": [], "citationRefs": [ "cit-qays-specific-criticism", "cit-qays-profile-jamal" ], "evidenceRefs": [ "cit-qays-specific-criticism", "cit-qays-profile-jamal" ], "icon": { "kindLabel": "مسألة نقدية", "meaning": "العلة أو الاعتراض بنطاقه ومصدره", "status": "documented", "statusLabel": "إحالة موضعية مقابلة", "summary": "عد يحيى بن سعيد القطان حديث كلاب الحوأب من مناكير قيس، مع بقاء توثيق قيس في عامة حديثه." }, "id": "illa:illa-qays-specific-criticism", "illaRefs": [ "illa-qays-specific-criticism" ], "kind": "illa", "label": "عد يحيى بن سعيد القطان حديث كلاب الحوأب من مناكير قيس، مع بقاء توثيق قيس في عامة حديثه.", "matnRefs": [], "rendered": true, "requiresPinpoint": false, "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [ "cit-qays-specific-criticism", "cit-qays-profile-jamal" ], "riwayaRefs": [ "riwaya-abu-usama-37771" ], "sourceRefs": [ "source-dossier-scans-tadif-hawab-20p" ], "supportLevel": "exact", "target": { "id": "qays", "kind": "node" }, "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": [] }, "matn:matn-abdrahman-rudduni": { "argumentRefs": [], "cardRefs": [], "citationRefs": [ "cit-abdrahman-jawzi-1420" ], "evidenceRefs": [ "cit-abdrahman-jawzi-1420" ], "icon": { "kindLabel": "لفظ المتن", "meaning": "النص أو الزيادة بلفظها وموضعها", "status": "documented", "statusLabel": "إحالة موضعية مقابلة", "summary": "فقالت: ردوني؛ فإني سمعت رسول الله ﷺ يقول: كيف بإحداكن إذا نبحت عليها كلاب الحوأب" }, "id": "matn:matn-abdrahman-rudduni", "illaRefs": [], "kind": "matn", "label": "فقالت: ردوني؛ فإني سمعت رسول الله ﷺ يقول: كيف بإحداكن إذا نبحت عليها كلاب الحوأب", "matnRefs": [ "matn-abdrahman-rudduni" ], "rendered": true, "requiresPinpoint": false, "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [ "cit-abdrahman-jawzi-1420" ], "riwayaRefs": [ "riwaya-abdrahman-1420-4409" ], "sourceRefs": [ "source-dossier-scans-tadif-hawab-20p" ], "supportLevel": "exact", "target": { "matnId": "matn-abdrahman-rudduni" }, "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": [] }, "matn:matn-abu-usama-context": { "argumentRefs": [], "cardRefs": [], "citationRefs": [ "cit-musannaf-37771" ], "evidenceRefs": [ "cit-musannaf-37771" ], "icon": { "kindLabel": "لفظ المتن", "meaning": "النص أو الزيادة بلفظها وموضعها", "status": "documented", "statusLabel": "إحالة موضعية مقابلة", "summary": "أي ماء هذا؟ قالوا: ماء الحوأب ... ما أظنني إلا راجعة ... بل تقدمين فيراك المسلمون فيصلح الله ذات بينهم" }, "id": "matn:matn-abu-usama-context", "illaRefs": [], "kind": "matn", "label": "أي ماء هذا؟ قالوا: ماء الحوأب ... ما أظنني إلا راجعة ... بل تقدمين فيراك المسلمون فيصلح الله ذات بينهم", "matnRefs": [ "matn-abu-usama-context" ], "rendered": true, "requiresPinpoint": false, "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [ "cit-musannaf-37771" ], "riwayaRefs": [ "riwaya-abu-usama-37771" ], "sourceRefs": [ "source-musannaf-ibn-abi-shayba-hawab-37771" ], "supportLevel": "exact", "target": { "matnId": "matn-abu-usama-context" }, "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": [] }, "matn:matn-ibnabbas-expansion": { "argumentRefs": [], "cardRefs": [], "citationRefs": [ "cit-ibnabbas-ilal-2787" ], "evidenceRefs": [ "cit-ibnabbas-ilal-2787" ], "icon": { "kindLabel": "لفظ المتن", "meaning": "النص أو الزيادة بلفظها وموضعها", "status": "documented", "statusLabel": "إحالة موضعية مقابلة", "summary": "أيتكن صاحبة الجمل الأدبب، تنبحها كلاب الحوأب، يقتل عن يمينها وشمالها قتلى كثير، ثم تنجو بعدما قد كادت" }, "id": "matn:matn-ibnabbas-expansion", "illaRefs": [], "kind": "matn", "label": "أيتكن صاحبة الجمل الأدبب، تنبحها كلاب الحوأب، يقتل عن يمينها وشمالها قتلى كثير، ثم تنجو بعدما قد كادت", "matnRefs": [ "matn-ibnabbas-expansion" ], "rendered": true, "requiresPinpoint": false, "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [ "cit-ibnabbas-ilal-2787" ], "riwayaRefs": [ "riwaya-ibnabbas-2787" ], "sourceRefs": [ "source-dossier-scans-tadif-hawab-20p" ], "supportLevel": "exact", "target": { "matnId": "matn-ibnabbas-expansion" }, "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": [] }, "matn:matn-qays-nucleus": { "argumentRefs": [], "cardRefs": [], "citationRefs": [ "cit-musannaf-37771" ], "evidenceRefs": [ "cit-musannaf-37771" ], "icon": { "kindLabel": "لفظ المتن", "meaning": "النص أو الزيادة بلفظها وموضعها", "status": "documented", "statusLabel": "إحالة موضعية مقابلة", "summary": "كيف بإحداكن تنبح عليها كلاب الحوأب" }, "id": "matn:matn-qays-nucleus", "illaRefs": [], "kind": "matn", "label": "كيف بإحداكن تنبح عليها كلاب الحوأب", "matnRefs": [ "matn-qays-nucleus" ], "rendered": true, "requiresPinpoint": false, "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [ "cit-musannaf-37771" ], "riwayaRefs": [ "riwaya-abu-usama-37771" ], "sourceRefs": [ "source-musannaf-ibn-abi-shayba-hawab-37771" ], "supportLevel": "exact", "target": { "matnId": "matn-qays-nucleus" }, "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": [] }, "matn:witnesses_story": { "argumentRefs": [], "cardRefs": [ "05_cards/evidences/hawab-qabul-shuhud-wa-matn-thalith-hold.md" ], "citationRefs": [ "cit-card-holds", "cit-witnesses-ibn-arabi" ], "evidenceRefs": [ "cit-card-holds", "cit-witnesses-ibn-arabi" ], "icon": { "kindLabel": "لفظ المتن", "meaning": "النص أو الزيادة بلفظها وموضعها", "status": "needs_review", "statusLabel": "الإحالة موجودة؛ توثيق الحقل يحتاج استكمالاً", "summary": "أربعون أو خمسون يشهدون باسم الماء أو يغيرونه" }, "id": "matn:witnesses_story", "illaRefs": [], "kind": "matn", "label": "أربعون أو خمسون يشهدون باسم الماء أو يغيرونه", "matnRefs": [], "rendered": true, "requiresPinpoint": true, "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [ "cit-card-holds", "cit-witnesses-ibn-arabi" ], "riwayaRefs": [], "sourceRefs": [ "source-dossier-scans-tadif-hawab-20p" ], "supportLevel": "card_scope", "target": { "field": "matn", "nodeId": "witnesses_story" }, "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": [] }, "node:abd_al_rahman_ibn_salih": { "argumentRefs": [], "cardRefs": [ "05_cards/evidences/hadith-hawab-tabaqat-al-khabar-wa-ziyadat-al-idana.md" ], "citationRefs": [ "cit-abdrahman-jawzi-1420", "cit-abdrahman-dhakhira-4409", "cit-card-analysis" ], "evidenceRefs": [ "cit-abdrahman-jawzi-1420", "cit-abdrahman-dhakhira-4409", "cit-card-analysis" ], "icon": { "kindLabel": "الراوي أو العقدة", "meaning": "تعريف العنصر ونص بياناته", "status": "needs_review", "statusLabel": "الإحالة موجودة؛ توثيق الحقل يحتاج استكمالاً", "summary": "عبد الرحمن بن صالح الأزدي — كوفي؛ جرحه موسى بن هارون وابن عدي، ووصفه ابن القيسراني بالتشيع الغالي" }, "id": "node:abd_al_rahman_ibn_salih", "illaRefs": [ "illa-abdrahman-specific-branch" ], "kind": "node", "label": "عبد الرحمن بن صالح الأزدي", "matnRefs": [], "rendered": true, "requiresPinpoint": true, "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [ "cit-abdrahman-jawzi-1420", "cit-abdrahman-dhakhira-4409", "cit-card-analysis" ], "riwayaRefs": [], "sourceRefs": [ "source-dossier-scans-tadif-hawab-20p" ], "supportLevel": "card_scope", "target": { "field": "identity", "nodeId": "abd_al_rahman_ibn_salih" }, "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": [] }, "node:abu_usama": { "argumentRefs": [], "cardRefs": [ "05_cards/evidences/hadith-hawab-tabaqat-al-khabar-wa-ziyadat-al-idana.md" ], "citationRefs": [ "cit-musannaf-37771", "cit-card-analysis" ], "evidenceRefs": [ "cit-musannaf-37771", "cit-card-analysis" ], "icon": { "kindLabel": "الراوي أو العقدة", "meaning": "تعريف العنصر ونص بياناته", "status": "needs_review", "statusLabel": "الإحالة موجودة؛ توثيق الحقل يحتاج استكمالاً", "summary": "أبو أسامة — فرعه لا يمر بعبد الرحمن بن صالح" }, "id": "node:abu_usama", "illaRefs": [], "kind": "node", "label": "أبو أسامة", "matnRefs": [], "rendered": true, "requiresPinpoint": true, "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [ "cit-musannaf-37771", "cit-card-analysis" ], "riwayaRefs": [], "sourceRefs": [ "source-musannaf-ibn-abi-shayba-hawab-37771" ], "supportLevel": "card_scope", "target": { "field": "identity", "nodeId": "abu_usama" }, "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": [] }, "node:aisha": { "argumentRefs": [], "cardRefs": [], "citationRefs": [ "cit-musannaf-37771", "cit-abdrahman-jawzi-1420" ], "evidenceRefs": [ "cit-musannaf-37771", "cit-abdrahman-jawzi-1420" ], "icon": { "kindLabel": "الراوي أو العقدة", "meaning": "تعريف العنصر ونص بياناته", "status": "documented", "statusLabel": "إحالة موضعية مقابلة", "summary": "أم المؤمنين عائشة — ينسب إليها السماع داخل حكاية قيس" }, "id": "node:aisha", "illaRefs": [], "kind": "node", "label": "أم المؤمنين عائشة", "matnRefs": [], "rendered": true, "requiresPinpoint": false, "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [ "cit-musannaf-37771", "cit-abdrahman-jawzi-1420" ], "riwayaRefs": [], "sourceRefs": [ "source-musannaf-ibn-abi-shayba-hawab-37771", "source-dossier-scans-tadif-hawab-20p" ], "supportLevel": "exact", "target": { "field": "identity", "nodeId": "aisha" }, "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": [] }, "node:al_ashajj": { "argumentRefs": [], "cardRefs": [], "citationRefs": [ "cit-ibnabbas-ilal-2787" ], "evidenceRefs": [ "cit-ibnabbas-ilal-2787" ], "icon": { "kindLabel": "الراوي أو العقدة", "meaning": "تعريف العنصر ونص بياناته", "status": "documented", "statusLabel": "إحالة موضعية مقابلة", "summary": "الأشج" }, "id": "node:al_ashajj", "illaRefs": [], "kind": "node", "label": "الأشج", "matnRefs": [], "rendered": true, "requiresPinpoint": false, "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [ "cit-ibnabbas-ilal-2787" ], "riwayaRefs": [], "sourceRefs": [ "source-dossier-scans-tadif-hawab-20p" ], "supportLevel": "exact", "target": { "field": "identity", "nodeId": "al_ashajj" }, "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": [] }, "node:ibn_abbas": { "argumentRefs": [], "cardRefs": [], "citationRefs": [ "cit-ibnabbas-ilal-2787" ], "evidenceRefs": [ "cit-ibnabbas-ilal-2787" ], "icon": { "kindLabel": "الراوي أو العقدة", "meaning": "تعريف العنصر ونص بياناته", "status": "documented", "statusLabel": "إحالة موضعية مقابلة", "summary": "عبد الله بن عباس — أصل صحابي مستقل اسماً في الطريق المنكر" }, "id": "node:ibn_abbas", "illaRefs": [], "kind": "node", "label": "عبد الله بن عباس", "matnRefs": [], "rendered": true, "requiresPinpoint": false, "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [ "cit-ibnabbas-ilal-2787" ], "riwayaRefs": [], "sourceRefs": [ "source-dossier-scans-tadif-hawab-20p" ], "supportLevel": "exact", "target": { "field": "identity", "nodeId": "ibn_abbas" }, "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": [] }, "node:ikrima": { "argumentRefs": [], "cardRefs": [], "citationRefs": [ "cit-ibnabbas-ilal-2787" ], "evidenceRefs": [ "cit-ibnabbas-ilal-2787" ], "icon": { "kindLabel": "الراوي أو العقدة", "meaning": "تعريف العنصر ونص بياناته", "status": "documented", "statusLabel": "إحالة موضعية مقابلة", "summary": "عكرمة" }, "id": "node:ikrima", "illaRefs": [], "kind": "node", "label": "عكرمة", "matnRefs": [], "rendered": true, "requiresPinpoint": false, "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [ "cit-ibnabbas-ilal-2787" ], "riwayaRefs": [], "sourceRefs": [ "source-dossier-scans-tadif-hawab-20p" ], "supportLevel": "exact", "target": { "field": "identity", "nodeId": "ikrima" }, "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": [] }, "node:ilal_2787": { "argumentRefs": [], "cardRefs": [], "citationRefs": [ "cit-ibnabbas-ilal-2787", "cit-ibn-abd-barr-reception" ], "evidenceRefs": [ "cit-ibnabbas-ilal-2787", "cit-ibn-abd-barr-reception" ], "icon": { "kindLabel": "الراوي أو العقدة", "meaning": "تعريف العنصر ونص بياناته", "status": "documented", "statusLabel": "إحالة موضعية مقابلة", "summary": "علل ابن أبي حاتم س2787 — موضع السؤال؛ وفي الحاشية قبول مقابل عن ابن عبد البر" }, "id": "node:ilal_2787", "illaRefs": [], "kind": "node", "label": "علل ابن أبي حاتم س2787", "matnRefs": [], "rendered": true, "requiresPinpoint": false, "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [ "cit-ibnabbas-ilal-2787", "cit-ibn-abd-barr-reception" ], "riwayaRefs": [], "sourceRefs": [ "source-dossier-scans-tadif-hawab-20p" ], "supportLevel": "exact", "target": { "field": "identity", "nodeId": "ilal_2787" }, "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": [] }, "node:isam_ibn_qudama": { "argumentRefs": [], "cardRefs": [], "citationRefs": [ "cit-ibnabbas-ilal-2787" ], "evidenceRefs": [ "cit-ibnabbas-ilal-2787" ], "icon": { "kindLabel": "الراوي أو العقدة", "meaning": "تعريف العنصر ونص بياناته", "status": "documented", "statusLabel": "إحالة موضعية مقابلة", "summary": "عصام بن قدامة — مدار الطريق؛ نص الناقدان على تفرد هذا الوجه ونكارته" }, "id": "node:isam_ibn_qudama", "illaRefs": [ "illa-isam-tafarrud" ], "kind": "node", "label": "عصام بن قدامة", "matnRefs": [], "rendered": true, "requiresPinpoint": false, "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [ "cit-ibnabbas-ilal-2787" ], "riwayaRefs": [], "sourceRefs": [ "source-dossier-scans-tadif-hawab-20p" ], "supportLevel": "exact", "target": { "field": "identity", "nodeId": "isam_ibn_qudama" }, "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": [] }, "node:ismail": { "argumentRefs": [], "cardRefs": [], "citationRefs": [ "cit-musannaf-37771", "cit-abdrahman-dhakhira-4409" ], "evidenceRefs": [ "cit-musannaf-37771", "cit-abdrahman-dhakhira-4409" ], "icon": { "kindLabel": "الراوي أو العقدة", "meaning": "تعريف العنصر ونص بياناته", "status": "documented", "statusLabel": "إحالة موضعية مقابلة", "summary": "إسماعيل بن أبي خالد — ملتقى فرعي أبي أسامة ومحمد بن فضيل" }, "id": "node:ismail", "illaRefs": [], "kind": "node", "label": "إسماعيل بن أبي خالد", "matnRefs": [], "rendered": true, "requiresPinpoint": false, "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [ "cit-musannaf-37771", "cit-abdrahman-dhakhira-4409" ], "riwayaRefs": [], "sourceRefs": [ "source-musannaf-ibn-abi-shayba-hawab-37771", "source-dossier-scans-tadif-hawab-20p" ], "supportLevel": "exact", "target": { "field": "identity", "nodeId": "ismail" }, "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": [] }, "node:jawzi_dhakhira": { "argumentRefs": [], "cardRefs": [], "citationRefs": [ "cit-abdrahman-jawzi-1420", "cit-abdrahman-dhakhira-4409" ], "evidenceRefs": [ "cit-abdrahman-jawzi-1420", "cit-abdrahman-dhakhira-4409" ], "icon": { "kindLabel": "الراوي أو العقدة", "meaning": "تعريف العنصر ونص بياناته", "status": "documented", "statusLabel": "إحالة موضعية مقابلة", "summary": "العلل المتناهية 1420 / ذخيرة الحفاظ 4409 — حفظ فرع عبد الرحمن ونقده؛ طبقات شيوخ المصنفين مطوية في العرض" }, "id": "node:jawzi_dhakhira", "illaRefs": [], "kind": "node", "label": "العلل المتناهية 1420 / ذخيرة الحفاظ 4409", "matnRefs": [], "rendered": true, "requiresPinpoint": false, "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [ "cit-abdrahman-jawzi-1420", "cit-abdrahman-dhakhira-4409" ], "riwayaRefs": [], "sourceRefs": [ "source-dossier-scans-tadif-hawab-20p" ], "supportLevel": "exact", "target": { "field": "identity", "nodeId": "jawzi_dhakhira" }, "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": [] }, "node:muhammad_ibn_fudayl": { "argumentRefs": [], "cardRefs": [], "citationRefs": [ "cit-abdrahman-dhakhira-4409" ], "evidenceRefs": [ "cit-abdrahman-dhakhira-4409" ], "icon": { "kindLabel": "الراوي أو العقدة", "meaning": "تعريف العنصر ونص بياناته", "status": "documented", "statusLabel": "إحالة موضعية مقابلة", "summary": "محمد بن فضيل — عن إسماعيل، وعنه عبد الرحمن في هذا الفرع" }, "id": "node:muhammad_ibn_fudayl", "illaRefs": [], "kind": "node", "label": "محمد بن فضيل", "matnRefs": [], "rendered": true, "requiresPinpoint": false, "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [ "cit-abdrahman-dhakhira-4409" ], "riwayaRefs": [], "sourceRefs": [ "source-dossier-scans-tadif-hawab-20p" ], "supportLevel": "exact", "target": { "field": "identity", "nodeId": "muhammad_ibn_fudayl" }, "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": [] }, "node:musannaf_37771": { "argumentRefs": [], "cardRefs": [], "citationRefs": [ "cit-musannaf-37771" ], "evidenceRefs": [ "cit-musannaf-37771" ], "icon": { "kindLabel": "الراوي أو العقدة", "meaning": "تعريف العنصر ونص بياناته", "status": "documented", "statusLabel": "إحالة موضعية مقابلة", "summary": "مصنف ابن أبي شيبة ح37771 — فرع أبي أسامة؛ «ما أظنني إلا راجعة» بلا «ردوني»" }, "id": "node:musannaf_37771", "illaRefs": [], "kind": "node", "label": "مصنف ابن أبي شيبة ح37771", "matnRefs": [], "rendered": true, "requiresPinpoint": false, "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [ "cit-musannaf-37771" ], "riwayaRefs": [], "sourceRefs": [ "source-musannaf-ibn-abi-shayba-hawab-37771" ], "supportLevel": "exact", "target": { "field": "identity", "nodeId": "musannaf_37771" }, "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": [] }, "node:nabi": { "argumentRefs": [], "cardRefs": [], "citationRefs": [ "cit-musannaf-37771", "cit-abdrahman-jawzi-1420", "cit-ibnabbas-ilal-2787" ], "evidenceRefs": [ "cit-musannaf-37771", "cit-abdrahman-jawzi-1420", "cit-ibnabbas-ilal-2787" ], "icon": { "kindLabel": "الراوي أو العقدة", "meaning": "تعريف العنصر ونص بياناته", "status": "documented", "statusLabel": "إحالة موضعية مقابلة", "summary": "رسول الله ﷺ" }, "id": "node:nabi", "illaRefs": [], "kind": "node", "label": "رسول الله ﷺ", "matnRefs": [], "rendered": true, "requiresPinpoint": false, "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [ "cit-musannaf-37771", "cit-abdrahman-jawzi-1420", "cit-ibnabbas-ilal-2787" ], "riwayaRefs": [], "sourceRefs": [ "source-musannaf-ibn-abi-shayba-hawab-37771", "source-dossier-scans-tadif-hawab-20p" ], "supportLevel": "exact", "target": { "field": "identity", "nodeId": "nabi" }, "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": [] }, "node:qays": { "argumentRefs": [], "cardRefs": [], "citationRefs": [ "cit-musannaf-37771", "cit-qays-profile-jamal", "cit-qays-specific-criticism" ], "evidenceRefs": [ "cit-musannaf-37771", "cit-qays-profile-jamal", "cit-qays-specific-criticism" ], "icon": { "kindLabel": "الراوي أو العقدة", "meaning": "تعريف العنصر ونص بياناته", "status": "documented", "statusLabel": "إحالة موضعية مقابلة", "summary": "قيس بن أبي حازم — مدار العنقود؛ موثق في عامة حديثه، والقطان عد هذا الفرد من مناكيره؛ عثماني لم يشهد الجمل" }, "id": "node:qays", "illaRefs": [ "illa-qays-specific-criticism" ], "kind": "node", "label": "قيس بن أبي حازم", "matnRefs": [], "rendered": true, "requiresPinpoint": false, "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [ "cit-musannaf-37771", "cit-qays-profile-jamal", "cit-qays-specific-criticism" ], "riwayaRefs": [], "sourceRefs": [ "source-musannaf-ibn-abi-shayba-hawab-37771", "source-dossier-scans-tadif-hawab-20p" ], "supportLevel": "exact", "target": { "field": "identity", "nodeId": "qays" }, "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": [] }, "node:uqba_ibn_khalid": { "argumentRefs": [], "cardRefs": [], "citationRefs": [ "cit-ibnabbas-ilal-2787" ], "evidenceRefs": [ "cit-ibnabbas-ilal-2787" ], "icon": { "kindLabel": "الراوي أو العقدة", "meaning": "تعريف العنصر ونص بياناته", "status": "documented", "statusLabel": "إحالة موضعية مقابلة", "summary": "عقبة بن خالد" }, "id": "node:uqba_ibn_khalid", "illaRefs": [], "kind": "node", "label": "عقبة بن خالد", "matnRefs": [], "rendered": true, "requiresPinpoint": false, "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [ "cit-ibnabbas-ilal-2787" ], "riwayaRefs": [], "sourceRefs": [ "source-dossier-scans-tadif-hawab-20p" ], "supportLevel": "exact", "target": { "field": "identity", "nodeId": "uqba_ibn_khalid" }, "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": [] }, "node:witnesses_story": { "argumentRefs": [], "cardRefs": [ "05_cards/evidences/hawab-qabul-shuhud-wa-matn-thalith-hold.md" ], "citationRefs": [ "cit-card-holds", "cit-witnesses-ibn-arabi" ], "evidenceRefs": [ "cit-card-holds", "cit-witnesses-ibn-arabi" ], "icon": { "kindLabel": "الراوي أو العقدة", "meaning": "تعريف العنصر ونص بياناته", "status": "needs_review", "statusLabel": "الإحالة موجودة؛ توثيق الحقل يحتاج استكمالاً", "summary": "أربعون أو خمسون يشهدون باسم الماء أو يغيرونه — طبقة زائدة محل فحص؛ أنكرها ابن العربي لاحقاً" }, "id": "node:witnesses_story", "illaRefs": [], "kind": "node", "label": "أربعون أو خمسون يشهدون باسم الماء أو يغيرونه", "matnRefs": [], "rendered": true, "requiresPinpoint": true, "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [ "cit-card-holds", "cit-witnesses-ibn-arabi" ], "riwayaRefs": [], "sourceRefs": [ "source-dossier-scans-tadif-hawab-20p" ], "supportLevel": "card_scope", "target": { "field": "identity", "nodeId": "witnesses_story" }, "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": [] }, "node:witnesses_void": { "argumentRefs": [], "cardRefs": [ "05_cards/evidences/hawab-qabul-shuhud-wa-matn-thalith-hold.md" ], "citationRefs": [ "cit-card-holds" ], "evidenceRefs": [ "cit-card-holds" ], "icon": { "kindLabel": "الراوي أو العقدة", "meaning": "تعريف العنصر ونص بياناته", "status": "needs_review", "statusLabel": "الإحالة موجودة؛ توثيق الحقل يحتاج استكمالاً", "summary": "لا إسناد مستقل مثبت للشهود — في المادة المطابقة الحالية" }, "id": "node:witnesses_void", "illaRefs": [], "kind": "node", "label": "لا إسناد مستقل مثبت للشهود", "matnRefs": [], "rendered": true, "requiresPinpoint": true, "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [ "cit-card-holds" ], "riwayaRefs": [], "sourceRefs": [], "supportLevel": "card_scope", "target": { "field": "identity", "nodeId": "witnesses_void" }, "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": [] }, "verdict": { "argumentRefs": [], "cardRefs": [ "05_cards/evidences/hawab-qabul-shuhud-wa-matn-thalith-hold.md" ], "citationRefs": [ "cit-musannaf-37771", "cit-qays-specific-criticism", "cit-abdrahman-jawzi-1420", "cit-abdrahman-dhakhira-4409", "cit-ibnabbas-ilal-2787", "cit-card-holds", "cit-correction-2788" ], "evidenceRefs": [ "cit-musannaf-37771", "cit-qays-specific-criticism", "cit-abdrahman-jawzi-1420", "cit-abdrahman-dhakhira-4409", "cit-ibnabbas-ilal-2787", "cit-card-holds", "cit-correction-2788" ], "icon": { "kindLabel": "خلاصة الدراسة", "meaning": "النتيجة المنسوبة إلى الدراسة وحدود الاستدلال", "status": "needs_review", "statusLabel": "الإحالة موجودة؛ توثيق الحقل يحتاج استكمالاً", "summary": "في العينة عنقود قيس وطريق ابن عباس؛ النقد الخاص لا يمحو توثيق الراوي ولا ينتقل إلى غير متنه. معنى الرجوع في فرعي قيس، وخبر أبي نصيرة ليس من الحوأب. كفة القبول والشهود والسماع قيد التحقيق." }, "id": "verdict", "illaRefs": [], "kind": "verdict", "label": "في العينة عنقود قيس وطريق ابن عباس؛ النقد الخاص لا يمحو توثيق الراوي ولا ينتقل إلى غير متنه. معنى الرجوع في فرعي قيس، وخبر أبي نصيرة ليس من الحوأب. كفة القبول والشهود والسماع قيد التحقيق.", "matnRefs": [], "rendered": true, "requiresPinpoint": true, "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [ "cit-musannaf-37771", "cit-qays-specific-criticism", "cit-abdrahman-jawzi-1420", "cit-abdrahman-dhakhira-4409", "cit-ibnabbas-ilal-2787", "cit-card-holds", "cit-correction-2788" ], "riwayaRefs": [], "sourceRefs": [ "source-musannaf-ibn-abi-shayba-hawab-37771", "source-dossier-scans-tadif-hawab-20p" ], "supportLevel": "card_scope", "target": { "field": "verdict" }, "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": [] } }, "order": [ "node:nabi", "node:aisha", "node:ibn_abbas", "node:qays", "hukm:qays", "city:qays", "flag:qays:jarh", "node:ismail", "city:ismail", "node:abu_usama", "city:abu_usama", "node:muhammad_ibn_fudayl", "city:muhammad_ibn_fudayl", "node:abd_al_rahman_ibn_salih", "city:abd_al_rahman_ibn_salih", "flag:abd_al_rahman_ibn_salih:jarh", "flag:abd_al_rahman_ibn_salih:ghuluw", "node:ikrima", "city:ikrima", "node:isam_ibn_qudama", "city:isam_ibn_qudama", "node:uqba_ibn_khalid", "city:uqba_ibn_khalid", "node:al_ashajj", "city:al_ashajj", "node:witnesses_void", "node:witnesses_story", "matn:witnesses_story", "node:musannaf_37771", "node:jawzi_dhakhira", "node:ilal_2787", "edge:edge-nabi-aisha", "edge:edge-aisha-qays", "edge:edge-qays-ismail", "edge:edge-ismail-abu-usama", "edge:edge-abu-usama-musannaf", "edge:edge-ismail-muhammad-fudayl", "edge:edge-muhammad-fudayl-abdrahman", "edge:edge-abdrahman-books", "edge:edge-nabi-ibnabbas", "edge:edge-ibnabbas-ikrima", "edge:edge-ikrima-isam", "edge:edge-isam-uqba", "edge:edge-uqba-ashajj", "edge:edge-ashajj-ilal2787", "edge:edge-witnesses-unresolved", "illa:illa-qays-specific-criticism", "illa:illa-qays-source-unresolved", "illa:illa-abdrahman-specific-branch", "illa:illa-isam-tafarrud", "matn:matn-qays-nucleus", "matn:matn-abu-usama-context", "matn:matn-abdrahman-rudduni", "matn:matn-ibnabbas-expansion", "verdict", "geography", "argument:arg-qays-family-independence", "argument:arg-rudduni-layer-lock", "argument:arg-qays-criticism-mirror", "argument:arg-tribe-environment-madhhab-mirror", "argument:arg-ibnabbas-independent-but-munkar", "argument:arg-witnesses-extra-layer", "argument:arg-prophecy-not-camp-verdict", "argument:arg-correction-unrelated-2788" ] }, "map": { "chapter": "02_manuscript/bab_04_factory_riwaya/13d_hadith_al_hawab_isqat_istirjai.md", "dependencyHash": "de53a054445e4c9e", "id": "hadith_hawab", "ref": "isnad:hadith_hawab@v5", "sourceFile": "08_assets/isnad/hadith_hawab.json", "sourceHash": "4e02869a745c025a", "version": 5 }, "matnVariants": [ { "citationRefs": [ "cit-musannaf-37771" ], "evidenceRefs": [ "cit-musannaf-37771" ], "id": "matn-qays-nucleus", "riwayaRefs": [ "riwaya-abu-usama-37771" ], "role": "nawa", "subject": null, "text": "كيف بإحداكن تنبح عليها كلاب الحوأب" }, { "citationRefs": [ "cit-musannaf-37771" ], "evidenceRefs": [ "cit-musannaf-37771" ], "id": "matn-abu-usama-context", "riwayaRefs": [ "riwaya-abu-usama-37771" ], "role": "context", "subject": null, "text": "أي ماء هذا؟ قالوا: ماء الحوأب ... ما أظنني إلا راجعة ... بل تقدمين فيراك المسلمون فيصلح الله ذات بينهم" }, { "citationRefs": [ "cit-abdrahman-jawzi-1420" ], "evidenceRefs": [ "cit-abdrahman-jawzi-1420" ], "id": "matn-abdrahman-rudduni", "riwayaRefs": [ "riwaya-abdrahman-1420-4409" ], "role": "variant", "subject": null, "text": "فقالت: ردوني؛ فإني سمعت رسول الله ﷺ يقول: كيف بإحداكن إذا نبحت عليها كلاب الحوأب" }, { "citationRefs": [ "cit-ibnabbas-ilal-2787" ], "evidenceRefs": [ "cit-ibnabbas-ilal-2787" ], "id": "matn-ibnabbas-expansion", "riwayaRefs": [ "riwaya-ibnabbas-2787" ], "role": "ziyadah", "subject": null, "text": "أيتكن صاحبة الجمل الأدبب، تنبحها كلاب الحوأب، يقتل عن يمينها وشمالها قتلى كثير، ثم تنجو بعدما قد كادت" } ], "narrators": [ { "card": null, "city": null, "coverage": { "applicableFields": 1, "exactFields": 1, "status": "complete", "unresolvedFields": 0 }, "death": null, "evidenceRefs": { "identity": [ "cit-musannaf-37771", "cit-abdrahman-jawzi-1420", "cit-ibnabbas-ilal-2787" ] }, "fieldCoverage": { "card": { "cardRefs": [], "citationRefs": [], "evidenceRefs": [], "requiresPinpoint": false, "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [], "sourceRefs": [], "state": "not_applicable", "supportLevel": null, "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": [] }, "city": { "cardRefs": [], "citationRefs": [], "evidenceRefs": [], "requiresPinpoint": false, "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [], "sourceRefs": [], "state": "not_applicable", "supportLevel": null, "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": [] }, "death": { "cardRefs": [], "citationRefs": [], "evidenceRefs": [], "requiresPinpoint": false, "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [], "sourceRefs": [], "state": "not_applicable", "supportLevel": null, "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": [] }, "flags": { "cardRefs": [], "citationRefs": [], "evidenceRefs": [], "items": {}, "requiresPinpoint": false, "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [], "sourceRefs": [], "state": "not_applicable", "supportLevel": null, "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": [] }, "hukm": { "cardRefs": [], "citationRefs": [], "evidenceRefs": [], "requiresPinpoint": false, "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [], "sourceRefs": [], "state": "not_applicable", "supportLevel": null, "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": [] }, "label": { "cardRefs": [], "citationRefs": [ "cit-musannaf-37771", "cit-abdrahman-jawzi-1420", "cit-ibnabbas-ilal-2787" ], "evidenceRefs": [ "cit-musannaf-37771", "cit-abdrahman-jawzi-1420", "cit-ibnabbas-ilal-2787" ], "requiresPinpoint": false, "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [ "cit-musannaf-37771", "cit-abdrahman-jawzi-1420", "cit-ibnabbas-ilal-2787" ], "sourceRefs": [ "source-musannaf-ibn-abi-shayba-hawab-37771", "source-dossier-scans-tadif-hawab-20p" ], "state": "exact", "supportLevel": "exact", "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": [] }, "sub": { "cardRefs": [], "citationRefs": [], "evidenceRefs": [], "requiresPinpoint": false, "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [], "sourceRefs": [], "state": "not_applicable", "supportLevel": null, "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": [] } }, "flags": [], "hukm": null, "id": "nabi", "kind": "nabi", "label": "رسول الله ﷺ", "sub": null }, { "card": null, "city": null, "coverage": { "applicableFields": 2, "exactFields": 2, "status": "complete", "unresolvedFields": 0 }, "death": null, "evidenceRefs": { "identity": [ "cit-musannaf-37771", "cit-abdrahman-jawzi-1420" ], "sub": [ "cit-musannaf-37771", "cit-abdrahman-jawzi-1420" ] }, "fieldCoverage": { "card": { "cardRefs": [], "citationRefs": [], "evidenceRefs": [], "requiresPinpoint": false, "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [], "sourceRefs": [], "state": "not_applicable", "supportLevel": null, "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": [] }, "city": { "cardRefs": [], "citationRefs": [], "evidenceRefs": [], "requiresPinpoint": false, "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [], "sourceRefs": [], "state": "not_applicable", "supportLevel": null, "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": [] }, "death": { "cardRefs": [], "citationRefs": [], "evidenceRefs": [], "requiresPinpoint": false, "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [], "sourceRefs": [], "state": "not_applicable", "supportLevel": null, "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": [] }, "flags": { "cardRefs": [], "citationRefs": [], "evidenceRefs": [], "items": {}, "requiresPinpoint": false, "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [], "sourceRefs": [], "state": "not_applicable", "supportLevel": null, "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": [] }, "hukm": { "cardRefs": [], "citationRefs": [], "evidenceRefs": [], "requiresPinpoint": false, "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [], "sourceRefs": [], "state": "not_applicable", "supportLevel": null, "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": [] }, "label": { "cardRefs": [], "citationRefs": [ "cit-musannaf-37771", "cit-abdrahman-jawzi-1420" ], "evidenceRefs": [ "cit-musannaf-37771", "cit-abdrahman-jawzi-1420" ], "requiresPinpoint": false, "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [ "cit-musannaf-37771", "cit-abdrahman-jawzi-1420" ], "sourceRefs": [ "source-musannaf-ibn-abi-shayba-hawab-37771", "source-dossier-scans-tadif-hawab-20p" ], "state": "exact", "supportLevel": "exact", "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": [] }, "sub": { "cardRefs": [], "citationRefs": [ "cit-musannaf-37771", "cit-abdrahman-jawzi-1420" ], "evidenceRefs": [ "cit-musannaf-37771", "cit-abdrahman-jawzi-1420" ], "requiresPinpoint": false, "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [ "cit-musannaf-37771", "cit-abdrahman-jawzi-1420" ], "sourceRefs": [ "source-musannaf-ibn-abi-shayba-hawab-37771", "source-dossier-scans-tadif-hawab-20p" ], "state": "exact", "supportLevel": "exact", "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": [] } }, "flags": [], "hukm": null, "id": "aisha", "kind": "sahabi", "label": "أم المؤمنين عائشة", "sub": "ينسب إليها السماع داخل حكاية قيس" }, { "card": null, "city": null, "coverage": { "applicableFields": 2, "exactFields": 2, "status": "complete", "unresolvedFields": 0 }, "death": null, "evidenceRefs": { "identity": [ "cit-ibnabbas-ilal-2787" ], "sub": [ "cit-ibnabbas-ilal-2787" ] }, "fieldCoverage": { "card": { "cardRefs": [], "citationRefs": [], "evidenceRefs": [], "requiresPinpoint": false, "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [], "sourceRefs": [], "state": "not_applicable", "supportLevel": null, "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": [] }, "city": { "cardRefs": [], "citationRefs": [], "evidenceRefs": [], "requiresPinpoint": false, "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [], "sourceRefs": [], "state": "not_applicable", "supportLevel": null, "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": [] }, "death": { "cardRefs": [], "citationRefs": [], "evidenceRefs": [], "requiresPinpoint": false, "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [], "sourceRefs": [], "state": "not_applicable", "supportLevel": null, "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": [] }, "flags": { "cardRefs": [], "citationRefs": [], "evidenceRefs": [], "items": {}, "requiresPinpoint": false, "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [], "sourceRefs": [], "state": "not_applicable", "supportLevel": null, "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": [] }, "hukm": { "cardRefs": [], "citationRefs": [], "evidenceRefs": [], "requiresPinpoint": false, "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [], "sourceRefs": [], "state": "not_applicable", "supportLevel": null, "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": [] }, "label": { "cardRefs": [], "citationRefs": [ "cit-ibnabbas-ilal-2787" ], "evidenceRefs": [ "cit-ibnabbas-ilal-2787" ], "requiresPinpoint": false, "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [ "cit-ibnabbas-ilal-2787" ], "sourceRefs": [ "source-dossier-scans-tadif-hawab-20p" ], "state": "exact", "supportLevel": "exact", "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": [] }, "sub": { "cardRefs": [], "citationRefs": [ "cit-ibnabbas-ilal-2787" ], "evidenceRefs": [ "cit-ibnabbas-ilal-2787" ], "requiresPinpoint": false, "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [ "cit-ibnabbas-ilal-2787" ], "sourceRefs": [ "source-dossier-scans-tadif-hawab-20p" ], "state": "exact", "supportLevel": "exact", "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": [] } }, "flags": [], "hukm": null, "id": "ibn_abbas", "kind": "sahabi", "label": "عبد الله بن عباس", "sub": "أصل صحابي مستقل اسماً في الطريق المنكر" }, { "card": "05_cards/evidences/hadith-hawab-tabaqat-al-khabar-wa-ziyadat-al-idana.md", "city": "kufa", "coverage": { "applicableFields": 6, "exactFields": 5, "status": "partial", "unresolvedFields": 1 }, "death": null, "evidenceRefs": { "card": [ "cit-card-analysis" ], "city": [ "cit-qays-profile-jamal" ], "flags": { "jarh": [ "cit-qays-specific-criticism" ] }, "hukm": [ "cit-qays-profile-jamal" ], "identity": [ "cit-musannaf-37771", "cit-qays-profile-jamal" ], "sub": [ "cit-qays-specific-criticism", "cit-qays-profile-jamal" ] }, "fieldCoverage": { "card": { "cardRefs": [ "05_cards/evidences/hadith-hawab-tabaqat-al-khabar-wa-ziyadat-al-idana.md" ], "citationRefs": [ "cit-card-analysis" ], "evidenceRefs": [ "cit-card-analysis" ], "requiresPinpoint": true, "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [ "cit-card-analysis" ], "sourceRefs": [], "state": "incomplete", "supportLevel": "card_scope", "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": [] }, "city": { "cardRefs": [], "citationRefs": [ "cit-qays-profile-jamal" ], "evidenceRefs": [ "cit-qays-profile-jamal" ], "requiresPinpoint": false, "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [ "cit-qays-profile-jamal" ], "sourceRefs": [ "source-dossier-scans-tadif-hawab-20p" ], "state": "exact", "supportLevel": "exact", "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": [] }, "death": { "cardRefs": [], "citationRefs": [], "evidenceRefs": [], "requiresPinpoint": false, "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [], "sourceRefs": [], "state": "not_applicable", "supportLevel": null, "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": [] }, "flags": { "cardRefs": [], "citationRefs": [ "cit-qays-specific-criticism" ], "evidenceRefs": [ "cit-qays-specific-criticism" ], "items": { "jarh": { "cardRefs": [], "citationRefs": [ "cit-qays-specific-criticism" ], "evidenceRefs": [ "cit-qays-specific-criticism" ], "requiresPinpoint": false, "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [ "cit-qays-specific-criticism" ], "sourceRefs": [ "source-dossier-scans-tadif-hawab-20p" ], "state": "exact", "supportLevel": "exact", "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": [] } }, "requiresPinpoint": false, "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [ "cit-qays-specific-criticism" ], "sourceRefs": [ "source-dossier-scans-tadif-hawab-20p" ], "state": "exact", "supportLevel": "exact", "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": [] }, "hukm": { "cardRefs": [], "citationRefs": [ "cit-qays-profile-jamal" ], "evidenceRefs": [ "cit-qays-profile-jamal" ], "requiresPinpoint": false, "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [ "cit-qays-profile-jamal" ], "sourceRefs": [ "source-dossier-scans-tadif-hawab-20p" ], "state": "exact", "supportLevel": "exact", "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": [] }, "label": { "cardRefs": [], "citationRefs": [ "cit-musannaf-37771", "cit-qays-profile-jamal" ], "evidenceRefs": [ "cit-musannaf-37771", "cit-qays-profile-jamal" ], "requiresPinpoint": false, "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [ "cit-musannaf-37771", "cit-qays-profile-jamal" ], "sourceRefs": [ "source-musannaf-ibn-abi-shayba-hawab-37771", "source-dossier-scans-tadif-hawab-20p" ], "state": "exact", "supportLevel": "exact", "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": [] }, "sub": { "cardRefs": [], "citationRefs": [ "cit-qays-specific-criticism", "cit-qays-profile-jamal" ], "evidenceRefs": [ "cit-qays-specific-criticism", "cit-qays-profile-jamal" ], "requiresPinpoint": false, "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [ "cit-qays-specific-criticism", "cit-qays-profile-jamal" ], "sourceRefs": [ "source-dossier-scans-tadif-hawab-20p" ], "state": "exact", "supportLevel": "exact", "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": [] } }, "flags": [ "jarh" ], "hukm": "thiqa", "id": "qays", "kind": "madar", "label": "قيس بن أبي حازم", "sub": "مدار العنقود؛ موثق في عامة حديثه، والقطان عد هذا الفرد من مناكيره؛ عثماني لم يشهد الجمل" }, { "card": null, "city": null, "coverage": { "applicableFields": 3, "exactFields": 2, "status": "partial", "unresolvedFields": 1 }, "death": null, "evidenceRefs": { "identity": [ "cit-musannaf-37771", "cit-abdrahman-dhakhira-4409" ], "sub": [ "cit-musannaf-37771", "cit-abdrahman-dhakhira-4409" ] }, "fieldCoverage": { "card": { "cardRefs": [], "citationRefs": [], "evidenceRefs": [], "requiresPinpoint": false, "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [], "sourceRefs": [], "state": "not_applicable", "supportLevel": null, "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": [] }, "city": { "cardRefs": [], "citationRefs": [], "evidenceRefs": [], "requiresPinpoint": true, "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [], "sourceRefs": [], "state": "missing_value", "supportLevel": "unresolved", "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": [] }, "death": { "cardRefs": [], "citationRefs": [], "evidenceRefs": [], "requiresPinpoint": false, "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [], "sourceRefs": [], "state": "not_applicable", "supportLevel": null, "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": [] }, "flags": { "cardRefs": [], "citationRefs": [], "evidenceRefs": [], "items": {}, "requiresPinpoint": false, "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [], "sourceRefs": [], "state": "not_applicable", "supportLevel": null, "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": [] }, "hukm": { "cardRefs": [], "citationRefs": [], "evidenceRefs": [], "requiresPinpoint": false, "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [], "sourceRefs": [], "state": "not_applicable", "supportLevel": null, "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": [] }, "label": { "cardRefs": [], "citationRefs": [ "cit-musannaf-37771", "cit-abdrahman-dhakhira-4409" ], "evidenceRefs": [ "cit-musannaf-37771", "cit-abdrahman-dhakhira-4409" ], "requiresPinpoint": false, "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [ "cit-musannaf-37771", "cit-abdrahman-dhakhira-4409" ], "sourceRefs": [ "source-musannaf-ibn-abi-shayba-hawab-37771", "source-dossier-scans-tadif-hawab-20p" ], "state": "exact", "supportLevel": "exact", "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": [] }, "sub": { "cardRefs": [], "citationRefs": [ "cit-musannaf-37771", "cit-abdrahman-dhakhira-4409" ], "evidenceRefs": [ "cit-musannaf-37771", "cit-abdrahman-dhakhira-4409" ], "requiresPinpoint": false, "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [ "cit-musannaf-37771", "cit-abdrahman-dhakhira-4409" ], "sourceRefs": [ "source-musannaf-ibn-abi-shayba-hawab-37771", "source-dossier-scans-tadif-hawab-20p" ], "state": "exact", "supportLevel": "exact", "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": [] } }, "flags": [], "hukm": null, "id": "ismail", "kind": "madar", "label": "إسماعيل بن أبي خالد", "sub": "ملتقى فرعي أبي أسامة ومحمد بن فضيل" }, { "card": null, "city": null, "coverage": { "applicableFields": 3, "exactFields": 1, "status": "partial", "unresolvedFields": 2 }, "death": null, "evidenceRefs": { "identity": [ "cit-musannaf-37771" ], "sub": [ "cit-musannaf-37771", "cit-card-analysis" ] }, "fieldCoverage": { "card": { "cardRefs": [], "citationRefs": [], "evidenceRefs": [], "requiresPinpoint": false, "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [], "sourceRefs": [], "state": "not_applicable", "supportLevel": null, "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": [] }, "city": { "cardRefs": [], "citationRefs": [], "evidenceRefs": [], "requiresPinpoint": true, "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [], "sourceRefs": [], "state": "missing_value", "supportLevel": "unresolved", "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": [] }, "death": { "cardRefs": [], "citationRefs": [], "evidenceRefs": [], "requiresPinpoint": false, "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [], "sourceRefs": [], "state": "not_applicable", "supportLevel": null, "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": [] }, "flags": { "cardRefs": [], "citationRefs": [], "evidenceRefs": [], "items": {}, "requiresPinpoint": false, "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [], "sourceRefs": [], "state": "not_applicable", "supportLevel": null, "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": [] }, "hukm": { "cardRefs": [], "citationRefs": [], "evidenceRefs": [], "requiresPinpoint": false, "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [], "sourceRefs": [], "state": "not_applicable", "supportLevel": null, "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": [] }, "label": { "cardRefs": [], "citationRefs": [ "cit-musannaf-37771" ], "evidenceRefs": [ "cit-musannaf-37771" ], "requiresPinpoint": false, "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [ "cit-musannaf-37771" ], "sourceRefs": [ "source-musannaf-ibn-abi-shayba-hawab-37771" ], "state": "exact", "supportLevel": "exact", "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": [] }, "sub": { "cardRefs": [ "05_cards/evidences/hadith-hawab-tabaqat-al-khabar-wa-ziyadat-al-idana.md" ], "citationRefs": [ "cit-musannaf-37771", "cit-card-analysis" ], "evidenceRefs": [ "cit-musannaf-37771", "cit-card-analysis" ], "requiresPinpoint": true, "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [ "cit-musannaf-37771", "cit-card-analysis" ], "sourceRefs": [ "source-musannaf-ibn-abi-shayba-hawab-37771" ], "state": "incomplete", "supportLevel": "card_scope", "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": [] } }, "flags": [], "hukm": null, "id": "abu_usama", "kind": "rawi", "label": "أبو أسامة", "sub": "فرعه لا يمر بعبد الرحمن بن صالح" }, { "card": null, "city": null, "coverage": { "applicableFields": 3, "exactFields": 2, "status": "partial", "unresolvedFields": 1 }, "death": null, "evidenceRefs": { "identity": [ "cit-abdrahman-dhakhira-4409" ], "sub": [ "cit-abdrahman-dhakhira-4409" ] }, "fieldCoverage": { "card": { "cardRefs": [], "citationRefs": [], "evidenceRefs": [], "requiresPinpoint": false, "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [], "sourceRefs": [], "state": "not_applicable", "supportLevel": null, "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": [] }, "city": { "cardRefs": [], "citationRefs": [], "evidenceRefs": [], "requiresPinpoint": true, "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [], "sourceRefs": [], "state": "missing_value", "supportLevel": "unresolved", "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": [] }, "death": { "cardRefs": [], "citationRefs": [], "evidenceRefs": [], "requiresPinpoint": false, "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [], "sourceRefs": [], "state": "not_applicable", "supportLevel": null, "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": [] }, "flags": { "cardRefs": [], "citationRefs": [], "evidenceRefs": [], "items": {}, "requiresPinpoint": false, "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [], "sourceRefs": [], "state": "not_applicable", "supportLevel": null, "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": [] }, "hukm": { "cardRefs": [], "citationRefs": [], "evidenceRefs": [], "requiresPinpoint": false, "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [], "sourceRefs": [], "state": "not_applicable", "supportLevel": null, "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": [] }, "label": { "cardRefs": [], "citationRefs": [ "cit-abdrahman-dhakhira-4409" ], "evidenceRefs": [ "cit-abdrahman-dhakhira-4409" ], "requiresPinpoint": false, "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [ "cit-abdrahman-dhakhira-4409" ], "sourceRefs": [ "source-dossier-scans-tadif-hawab-20p" ], "state": "exact", "supportLevel": "exact", "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": [] }, "sub": { "cardRefs": [], "citationRefs": [ "cit-abdrahman-dhakhira-4409" ], "evidenceRefs": [ "cit-abdrahman-dhakhira-4409" ], "requiresPinpoint": false, "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [ "cit-abdrahman-dhakhira-4409" ], "sourceRefs": [ "source-dossier-scans-tadif-hawab-20p" ], "state": "exact", "supportLevel": "exact", "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": [] } }, "flags": [], "hukm": null, "id": "muhammad_ibn_fudayl", "kind": "rawi", "label": "محمد بن فضيل", "sub": "عن إسماعيل، وعنه عبد الرحمن في هذا الفرع" }, { "card": "05_cards/evidences/hadith-hawab-tabaqat-al-khabar-wa-ziyadat-al-idana.md", "city": "kufa", "coverage": { "applicableFields": 5, "exactFields": 4, "status": "partial", "unresolvedFields": 1 }, "death": null, "evidenceRefs": { "card": [ "cit-card-analysis" ], "city": [ "cit-abdrahman-jawzi-1420", "cit-abdrahman-dhakhira-4409" ], "flags": { "ghuluw": [ "cit-abdrahman-dhakhira-4409" ], "jarh": [ "cit-abdrahman-jawzi-1420", "cit-abdrahman-dhakhira-4409" ] }, "identity": [ "cit-abdrahman-jawzi-1420", "cit-abdrahman-dhakhira-4409" ], "sub": [ "cit-abdrahman-jawzi-1420", "cit-abdrahman-dhakhira-4409" ] }, "fieldCoverage": { "card": { "cardRefs": [ "05_cards/evidences/hadith-hawab-tabaqat-al-khabar-wa-ziyadat-al-idana.md" ], "citationRefs": [ "cit-card-analysis" ], "evidenceRefs": [ "cit-card-analysis" ], "requiresPinpoint": true, "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [ "cit-card-analysis" ], "sourceRefs": [], "state": "incomplete", "supportLevel": "card_scope", "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": [] }, "city": { "cardRefs": [], "citationRefs": [ "cit-abdrahman-jawzi-1420", "cit-abdrahman-dhakhira-4409" ], "evidenceRefs": [ "cit-abdrahman-jawzi-1420", "cit-abdrahman-dhakhira-4409" ], "requiresPinpoint": false, "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [ "cit-abdrahman-jawzi-1420", "cit-abdrahman-dhakhira-4409" ], "sourceRefs": [ "source-dossier-scans-tadif-hawab-20p" ], "state": "exact", "supportLevel": "exact", "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": [] }, "death": { "cardRefs": [], "citationRefs": [], "evidenceRefs": [], "requiresPinpoint": false, "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [], "sourceRefs": [], "state": "not_applicable", "supportLevel": null, "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": [] }, "flags": { "cardRefs": [], "citationRefs": [ "cit-abdrahman-jawzi-1420", "cit-abdrahman-dhakhira-4409" ], "evidenceRefs": [ "cit-abdrahman-jawzi-1420", "cit-abdrahman-dhakhira-4409" ], "items": { "ghuluw": { "cardRefs": [], "citationRefs": [ "cit-abdrahman-dhakhira-4409" ], "evidenceRefs": [ "cit-abdrahman-dhakhira-4409" ], "requiresPinpoint": false, "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [ "cit-abdrahman-dhakhira-4409" ], "sourceRefs": [ "source-dossier-scans-tadif-hawab-20p" ], "state": "exact", "supportLevel": "exact", "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": [] }, "jarh": { "cardRefs": [], "citationRefs": [ "cit-abdrahman-jawzi-1420", "cit-abdrahman-dhakhira-4409" ], "evidenceRefs": [ "cit-abdrahman-jawzi-1420", "cit-abdrahman-dhakhira-4409" ], "requiresPinpoint": false, "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [ "cit-abdrahman-jawzi-1420", "cit-abdrahman-dhakhira-4409" ], "sourceRefs": [ "source-dossier-scans-tadif-hawab-20p" ], "state": "exact", "supportLevel": "exact", "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": [] } }, "requiresPinpoint": false, "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [ "cit-abdrahman-jawzi-1420", "cit-abdrahman-dhakhira-4409" ], "sourceRefs": [ "source-dossier-scans-tadif-hawab-20p" ], "state": "exact", "supportLevel": "exact", "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": [] }, "hukm": { "cardRefs": [], "citationRefs": [], "evidenceRefs": [], "requiresPinpoint": false, "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [], "sourceRefs": [], "state": "not_applicable", "supportLevel": null, "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": [] }, "label": { "cardRefs": [], "citationRefs": [ "cit-abdrahman-jawzi-1420", "cit-abdrahman-dhakhira-4409" ], "evidenceRefs": [ "cit-abdrahman-jawzi-1420", "cit-abdrahman-dhakhira-4409" ], "requiresPinpoint": false, "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [ "cit-abdrahman-jawzi-1420", "cit-abdrahman-dhakhira-4409" ], "sourceRefs": [ "source-dossier-scans-tadif-hawab-20p" ], "state": "exact", "supportLevel": "exact", "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": [] }, "sub": { "cardRefs": [], "citationRefs": [ "cit-abdrahman-jawzi-1420", "cit-abdrahman-dhakhira-4409" ], "evidenceRefs": [ "cit-abdrahman-jawzi-1420", "cit-abdrahman-dhakhira-4409" ], "requiresPinpoint": false, "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [ "cit-abdrahman-jawzi-1420", "cit-abdrahman-dhakhira-4409" ], "sourceRefs": [ "source-dossier-scans-tadif-hawab-20p" ], "state": "exact", "supportLevel": "exact", "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": [] } }, "flags": [ "jarh", "ghuluw" ], "hukm": null, "id": "abd_al_rahman_ibn_salih", "kind": "rawi", "label": "عبد الرحمن بن صالح الأزدي", "sub": "كوفي؛ جرحه موسى بن هارون وابن عدي، ووصفه ابن القيسراني بالتشيع الغالي" }, { "card": null, "city": null, "coverage": { "applicableFields": 2, "exactFields": 1, "status": "partial", "unresolvedFields": 1 }, "death": null, "evidenceRefs": { "identity": [ "cit-ibnabbas-ilal-2787" ] }, "fieldCoverage": { "card": { "cardRefs": [], "citationRefs": [], "evidenceRefs": [], "requiresPinpoint": false, "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [], "sourceRefs": [], "state": "not_applicable", "supportLevel": null, "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": [] }, "city": { "cardRefs": [], "citationRefs": [], "evidenceRefs": [], "requiresPinpoint": true, "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [], "sourceRefs": [], "state": "missing_value", "supportLevel": "unresolved", "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": [] }, "death": { "cardRefs": [], "citationRefs": [], "evidenceRefs": [], "requiresPinpoint": false, "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [], "sourceRefs": [], "state": "not_applicable", "supportLevel": null, "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": [] }, "flags": { "cardRefs": [], "citationRefs": [], "evidenceRefs": [], "items": {}, "requiresPinpoint": false, "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [], "sourceRefs": [], "state": "not_applicable", "supportLevel": null, "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": [] }, "hukm": { "cardRefs": [], "citationRefs": [], "evidenceRefs": [], "requiresPinpoint": false, "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [], "sourceRefs": [], "state": "not_applicable", "supportLevel": null, "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": [] }, "label": { "cardRefs": [], "citationRefs": [ "cit-ibnabbas-ilal-2787" ], "evidenceRefs": [ "cit-ibnabbas-ilal-2787" ], "requiresPinpoint": false, "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [ "cit-ibnabbas-ilal-2787" ], "sourceRefs": [ "source-dossier-scans-tadif-hawab-20p" ], "state": "exact", "supportLevel": "exact", "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": [] }, "sub": { "cardRefs": [], "citationRefs": [], "evidenceRefs": [], "requiresPinpoint": false, "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [], "sourceRefs": [], "state": "not_applicable", "supportLevel": null, "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": [] } }, "flags": [], "hukm": null, "id": "ikrima", "kind": "rawi", "label": "عكرمة", "sub": null }, { "card": null, "city": null, "coverage": { "applicableFields": 3, "exactFields": 2, "status": "partial", "unresolvedFields": 1 }, "death": null, "evidenceRefs": { "identity": [ "cit-ibnabbas-ilal-2787" ], "sub": [ "cit-ibnabbas-ilal-2787" ] }, "fieldCoverage": { "card": { "cardRefs": [], "citationRefs": [], "evidenceRefs": [], "requiresPinpoint": false, "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [], "sourceRefs": [], "state": "not_applicable", "supportLevel": null, "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": [] }, "city": { "cardRefs": [], "citationRefs": [], "evidenceRefs": [], "requiresPinpoint": true, "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [], "sourceRefs": [], "state": "missing_value", "supportLevel": "unresolved", "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": [] }, "death": { "cardRefs": [], "citationRefs": [], "evidenceRefs": [], "requiresPinpoint": false, "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [], "sourceRefs": [], "state": "not_applicable", "supportLevel": null, "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": [] }, "flags": { "cardRefs": [], "citationRefs": [], "evidenceRefs": [], "items": {}, "requiresPinpoint": false, "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [], "sourceRefs": [], "state": "not_applicable", "supportLevel": null, "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": [] }, "hukm": { "cardRefs": [], "citationRefs": [], "evidenceRefs": [], "requiresPinpoint": false, "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [], "sourceRefs": [], "state": "not_applicable", "supportLevel": null, "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": [] }, "label": { "cardRefs": [], "citationRefs": [ "cit-ibnabbas-ilal-2787" ], "evidenceRefs": [ "cit-ibnabbas-ilal-2787" ], "requiresPinpoint": false, "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [ "cit-ibnabbas-ilal-2787" ], "sourceRefs": [ "source-dossier-scans-tadif-hawab-20p" ], "state": "exact", "supportLevel": "exact", "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": [] }, "sub": { "cardRefs": [], "citationRefs": [ "cit-ibnabbas-ilal-2787" ], "evidenceRefs": [ "cit-ibnabbas-ilal-2787" ], "requiresPinpoint": false, "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [ "cit-ibnabbas-ilal-2787" ], "sourceRefs": [ "source-dossier-scans-tadif-hawab-20p" ], "state": "exact", "supportLevel": "exact", "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": [] } }, "flags": [], "hukm": null, "id": "isam_ibn_qudama", "kind": "madar", "label": "عصام بن قدامة", "sub": "مدار الطريق؛ نص الناقدان على تفرد هذا الوجه ونكارته" }, { "card": null, "city": null, "coverage": { "applicableFields": 2, "exactFields": 1, "status": "partial", "unresolvedFields": 1 }, "death": null, "evidenceRefs": { "identity": [ "cit-ibnabbas-ilal-2787" ] }, "fieldCoverage": { "card": { "cardRefs": [], "citationRefs": [], "evidenceRefs": [], "requiresPinpoint": false, "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [], "sourceRefs": [], "state": "not_applicable", "supportLevel": null, "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": [] }, "city": { "cardRefs": [], "citationRefs": [], "evidenceRefs": [], "requiresPinpoint": true, "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [], "sourceRefs": [], "state": "missing_value", "supportLevel": "unresolved", "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": [] }, "death": { "cardRefs": [], "citationRefs": [], "evidenceRefs": [], "requiresPinpoint": false, "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [], "sourceRefs": [], "state": "not_applicable", "supportLevel": null, "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": [] }, "flags": { "cardRefs": [], "citationRefs": [], "evidenceRefs": [], "items": {}, "requiresPinpoint": false, "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [], "sourceRefs": [], "state": "not_applicable", "supportLevel": null, "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": [] }, "hukm": { "cardRefs": [], "citationRefs": [], "evidenceRefs": [], "requiresPinpoint": false, "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [], "sourceRefs": [], "state": "not_applicable", "supportLevel": null, "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": [] }, "label": { "cardRefs": [], "citationRefs": [ "cit-ibnabbas-ilal-2787" ], "evidenceRefs": [ "cit-ibnabbas-ilal-2787" ], "requiresPinpoint": false, "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [ "cit-ibnabbas-ilal-2787" ], "sourceRefs": [ "source-dossier-scans-tadif-hawab-20p" ], "state": "exact", "supportLevel": "exact", "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": [] }, "sub": { "cardRefs": [], "citationRefs": [], "evidenceRefs": [], "requiresPinpoint": false, "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [], "sourceRefs": [], "state": "not_applicable", "supportLevel": null, "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": [] } }, "flags": [], "hukm": null, "id": "uqba_ibn_khalid", "kind": "rawi", "label": "عقبة بن خالد", "sub": null }, { "card": null, "city": null, "coverage": { "applicableFields": 2, "exactFields": 1, "status": "partial", "unresolvedFields": 1 }, "death": null, "evidenceRefs": { "identity": [ "cit-ibnabbas-ilal-2787" ] }, "fieldCoverage": { "card": { "cardRefs": [], "citationRefs": [], "evidenceRefs": [], "requiresPinpoint": false, "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [], "sourceRefs": [], "state": "not_applicable", "supportLevel": null, "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": [] }, "city": { "cardRefs": [], "citationRefs": [], "evidenceRefs": [], "requiresPinpoint": true, "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [], "sourceRefs": [], "state": "missing_value", "supportLevel": "unresolved", "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": [] }, "death": { "cardRefs": [], "citationRefs": [], "evidenceRefs": [], "requiresPinpoint": false, "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [], "sourceRefs": [], "state": "not_applicable", "supportLevel": null, "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": [] }, "flags": { "cardRefs": [], "citationRefs": [], "evidenceRefs": [], "items": {}, "requiresPinpoint": false, "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [], "sourceRefs": [], "state": "not_applicable", "supportLevel": null, "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": [] }, "hukm": { "cardRefs": [], "citationRefs": [], "evidenceRefs": [], "requiresPinpoint": false, "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [], "sourceRefs": [], "state": "not_applicable", "supportLevel": null, "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": [] }, "label": { "cardRefs": [], "citationRefs": [ "cit-ibnabbas-ilal-2787" ], "evidenceRefs": [ "cit-ibnabbas-ilal-2787" ], "requiresPinpoint": false, "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [ "cit-ibnabbas-ilal-2787" ], "sourceRefs": [ "source-dossier-scans-tadif-hawab-20p" ], "state": "exact", "supportLevel": "exact", "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": [] }, "sub": { "cardRefs": [], "citationRefs": [], "evidenceRefs": [], "requiresPinpoint": false, "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [], "sourceRefs": [], "state": "not_applicable", "supportLevel": null, "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": [] } }, "flags": [], "hukm": null, "id": "al_ashajj", "kind": "rawi", "label": "الأشج", "sub": null } ], "pipelineVersion": 7, "provenanceCoverage": { "arguments": 8, "citations": 11, "dependencyHash": "de53a054445e4c9e", "exactHotspots": 37, "illal": 4, "matnVariants": 4, "missingCards": [], "missingSources": [], "narrators": 12, "percentExact": 57.8, "riwayat": 3, "status": "incomplete", "totalHotspots": 64, "transmissions": 15, "unresolvedHotspots": 27 }, "provenanceStatus": "draft", "provenanceVersion": 2, "records": { "cards": [ { "contentHash": "728bf753db356dcf", "exists": true, "id": "evidence-hadith-hawab-tabaqat-al-khabar-wa-ziyadat-al-idana", "path": "05_cards/evidences/hadith-hawab-tabaqat-al-khabar-wa-ziyadat-al-idana.md", "status": "draft", "title": "حديث الحوأب: طبقات الخبر وزيادات الإدانة — التوثيق المسنَد" }, { "contentHash": "021dedb1cff36962", "exists": true, "id": "hawab-qabul-shuhud-wa-matn-thalith-hold", "path": "05_cards/evidences/hawab-qabul-shuhud-wa-matn-thalith-hold.md", "status": "to_verify", "title": "حديث الحوأب: مواد موقوفة لا تدخل البرهان" } ], "sources": [ { "author": "جامع الدوسيه غير مسمى؛ الصور من طبعات محققة مسماة أدناه", "authorDeathHijri": null, "contentHash": "157b093c021f6b39", "exists": true, "id": "source-dossier-scans-tadif-hawab-20p", "path": "04_source_bank/source_dossier_scans_tadif_hawab_20p.md", "status": "draft", "title": "دوسيه مصور: تضعيف حديث «أيتكن تنبحها كلاب الحوأب» وبراءة مروان من دم طلحة (20 صفحة)" }, { "author": "أبو بكر عبد الله بن محمد ابن أبي شيبة", "authorDeathHijri": "235", "contentHash": "6b97aedec5f199f8", "exists": true, "id": "source-musannaf-ibn-abi-shayba-hawab-37771", "path": "04_source_bank/source_musannaf_ibn_abi_shayba_hawab_37771.md", "status": "verified", "title": "الكتاب المصنف في الأحاديث والآثار — خبر الحوأب" } ] }, "riwayat": [ { "chain": [ "nabi", "aisha", "qays", "ismail", "abu_usama", "musannaf_37771" ], "citationRefs": [ "cit-musannaf-37771" ], "evidenceRefs": [ "cit-musannaf-37771" ], "familyId": "family-qays-ismail", "hukm": { "attribution": "ترجيح الدراسة بين توثيق قيس ونقد القطان لهذا الفرد", "citationRefs": [ "cit-musannaf-37771", "cit-qays-specific-criticism", "cit-qays-profile-jamal", "cit-card-analysis" ], "value": "مختلف فيه في حدود المادة المطابقة" }, "hukmCitationRefs": [ "cit-qays-specific-criticism", "cit-qays-profile-jamal", "cit-card-analysis" ], "hukmEvidenceRefs": [ "cit-qays-specific-criticism", "cit-qays-profile-jamal", "cit-card-analysis" ], "id": "riwaya-abu-usama-37771", "ilal": [ { "citationRefs": [ "cit-qays-specific-criticism", "cit-qays-profile-jamal" ], "id": "illa-qays-specific-criticism", "kind": "naqd_fard", "target": "node:qays", "text": "عد يحيى بن سعيد القطان حديث كلاب الحوأب من مناكير قيس، مع بقاء توثيق قيس في عامة حديثه." }, { "citationRefs": [ "cit-musannaf-37771", "cit-qays-profile-jamal", "cit-card-holds" ], "id": "illa-qays-source-unresolved", "kind": "ittisal_hold", "target": "edge:edge-aisha-qays", "text": "الصيغة المطابقة تجعل قيس يحكي المشهد ولا يصرح «سمعت عائشة»؛ وعدم شهوده الجمل لا يكفي وحده للجزم بالإرسال." } ], "illaRefs": [ "illa-qays-specific-criticism", "illa-qays-source-unresolved" ], "label": "نواة قيس في فرع أبي أسامة", "matnRefs": [ "matn-qays-nucleus", "matn-abu-usama-context" ], "matnVariants": [ { "citationRefs": [ "cit-musannaf-37771" ], "id": "matn-qays-nucleus", "role": "nawa", "text": "كيف بإحداكن تنبح عليها كلاب الحوأب" }, { "citationRefs": [ "cit-musannaf-37771" ], "id": "matn-abu-usama-context", "role": "context", "text": "أي ماء هذا؟ قالوا: ماء الحوأب ... ما أظنني إلا راجعة ... بل تقدمين فيراك المسلمون فيصلح الله ذات بينهم" } ], "nodePath": [ "nabi", "aisha", "qays", "ismail", "abu_usama", "musannaf_37771" ] }, { "chain": [ "nabi", "aisha", "qays", "ismail", "muhammad_ibn_fudayl", "abd_al_rahman_ibn_salih", "jawzi_dhakhira" ], "citationRefs": [ "cit-abdrahman-jawzi-1420", "cit-abdrahman-dhakhira-4409" ], "evidenceRefs": [ "cit-abdrahman-jawzi-1420", "cit-abdrahman-dhakhira-4409" ], "familyId": "family-qays-ismail", "hukm": { "attribution": "موسى بن هارون وابن عدي وابن القيسراني", "citationRefs": [ "cit-abdrahman-jawzi-1420", "cit-abdrahman-dhakhira-4409" ], "value": "فرع مجروح بعبد الرحمن بن صالح" }, "hukmCitationRefs": [ "cit-abdrahman-jawzi-1420", "cit-abdrahman-dhakhira-4409" ], "hukmEvidenceRefs": [ "cit-abdrahman-jawzi-1420", "cit-abdrahman-dhakhira-4409" ], "id": "riwaya-abdrahman-1420-4409", "ilal": [ { "citationRefs": [ "cit-abdrahman-jawzi-1420", "cit-abdrahman-dhakhira-4409", "cit-card-analysis" ], "id": "illa-abdrahman-specific-branch", "kind": "jarh", "target": "node:abd_al_rahman_ibn_salih", "text": "الجرح المسمى والتشيع الغالي موثقان في عبد الرحمن، فيقيدان فرعه ولا ينتقلان إلى فرع أبي أسامة." } ], "illaRefs": [ "illa-abdrahman-specific-branch" ], "label": "فرع عبد الرحمن بن صالح بلفظ «ردوني»", "matnRefs": [ "matn-abdrahman-rudduni" ], "matnVariants": [ { "citationRefs": [ "cit-abdrahman-jawzi-1420" ], "id": "matn-abdrahman-rudduni", "role": "variant", "text": "فقالت: ردوني؛ فإني سمعت رسول الله ﷺ يقول: كيف بإحداكن إذا نبحت عليها كلاب الحوأب" } ], "nodePath": [ "nabi", "aisha", "qays", "ismail", "muhammad_ibn_fudayl", "abd_al_rahman_ibn_salih", "jawzi_dhakhira" ] }, { "chain": [ "nabi", "ibn_abbas", "ikrima", "isam_ibn_qudama", "uqba_ibn_khalid", "al_ashajj", "ilal_2787" ], "citationRefs": [ "cit-ibnabbas-ilal-2787" ], "evidenceRefs": [ "cit-ibnabbas-ilal-2787" ], "familyId": "family-ibnabbas-isam", "hukm": { "attribution": "أبو حاتم وأبو زرعة", "citationRefs": [ "cit-ibnabbas-ilal-2787", "cit-ibn-abd-barr-reception" ], "value": "منكر عند أبي حاتم وأبي زرعة؛ مقابل قبول ابن عبد البر منقول في الحاشية" }, "hukmCitationRefs": [ "cit-ibnabbas-ilal-2787" ], "hukmEvidenceRefs": [ "cit-ibnabbas-ilal-2787" ], "id": "riwaya-ibnabbas-2787", "ilal": [ { "citationRefs": [ "cit-ibnabbas-ilal-2787" ], "id": "illa-isam-tafarrud", "kind": "tafarrud", "target": "node:isam_ibn_qudama", "text": "قال أبو حاتم: لم يرو هذا الحديث غير عصام؛ وقال أبو زرعة: لا يروى من طريق غيره." } ], "illaRefs": [ "illa-isam-tafarrud" ], "label": "طريق ابن عباس الموسع", "matnRefs": [ "matn-ibnabbas-expansion" ], "matnVariants": [ { "citationRefs": [ "cit-ibnabbas-ilal-2787" ], "id": "matn-ibnabbas-expansion", "role": "ziyadah", "text": "أيتكن صاحبة الجمل الأدبب، تنبحها كلاب الحوأب، يقتل عن يمينها وشمالها قتلى كثير، ثم تنجو بعدما قد كادت" } ], "nodePath": [ "nabi", "ibn_abbas", "ikrima", "isam_ibn_qudama", "uqba_ibn_khalid", "al_ashajj", "ilal_2787" ] } ], "schemaVersion": 2, "transmissions": [ { "cardRefs": [], "citationRefs": [ "cit-musannaf-37771", "cit-abdrahman-jawzi-1420", "cit-abdrahman-dhakhira-4409" ], "evidenceRefs": { "note": [ "cit-musannaf-37771", "cit-abdrahman-jawzi-1420" ] }, "from": "nabi", "id": "edge-nabi-aisha", "illaRefs": [], "matnRefs": [ "matn-qays-nucleus", "matn-abu-usama-context", "matn-abdrahman-rudduni" ], "note": "إني سمعت رسول الله — داخل كلام عائشة", "requiresPinpoint": false, "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [ "cit-musannaf-37771", "cit-abdrahman-jawzi-1420", "cit-abdrahman-dhakhira-4409" ], "riwayaRefs": [ "riwaya-abu-usama-37771", "riwaya-abdrahman-1420-4409" ], "sourceRefs": [ "source-musannaf-ibn-abi-shayba-hawab-37771", "source-dossier-scans-tadif-hawab-20p" ], "status": "mahfuz", "supportLevel": "exact", "to": "aisha", "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": [] }, { "cardRefs": [ "05_cards/evidences/hawab-qabul-shuhud-wa-matn-thalith-hold.md" ], "citationRefs": [ "cit-musannaf-37771", "cit-qays-specific-criticism", "cit-card-holds", "cit-qays-profile-jamal", "cit-abdrahman-jawzi-1420", "cit-abdrahman-dhakhira-4409" ], "evidenceRefs": { "note": [ "cit-musannaf-37771", "cit-qays-profile-jamal", "cit-card-holds" ], "status": [ "cit-musannaf-37771", "cit-qays-specific-criticism", "cit-card-holds" ] }, "from": "aisha", "id": "edge-aisha-qays", "illaRefs": [ "illa-qays-source-unresolved" ], "matnRefs": [ "matn-qays-nucleus", "matn-abu-usama-context", "matn-abdrahman-rudduni" ], "note": "قال: لما بلغت عائشة — حكاية بلا تصريح بالسماع", "requiresPinpoint": true, "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [ "cit-musannaf-37771", "cit-qays-specific-criticism", "cit-card-holds", "cit-qays-profile-jamal", "cit-abdrahman-jawzi-1420", "cit-abdrahman-dhakhira-4409" ], "riwayaRefs": [ "riwaya-abu-usama-37771", "riwaya-abdrahman-1420-4409" ], "sourceRefs": [ "source-musannaf-ibn-abi-shayba-hawab-37771", "source-dossier-scans-tadif-hawab-20p" ], "status": "disputed", "supportLevel": "card_scope", "to": "qays", "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": [] }, { "cardRefs": [], "citationRefs": [ "cit-musannaf-37771", "cit-abdrahman-dhakhira-4409", "cit-abdrahman-jawzi-1420", "cit-qays-specific-criticism", "cit-qays-profile-jamal" ], "evidenceRefs": { "note": [ "cit-musannaf-37771", "cit-abdrahman-dhakhira-4409" ] }, "from": "qays", "id": "edge-qays-ismail", "illaRefs": [ "illa-qays-specific-criticism" ], "matnRefs": [ "matn-qays-nucleus", "matn-abu-usama-context", "matn-abdrahman-rudduni" ], "note": "عن قيس", "requiresPinpoint": false, "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [ "cit-musannaf-37771", "cit-abdrahman-dhakhira-4409", "cit-abdrahman-jawzi-1420", "cit-qays-specific-criticism", "cit-qays-profile-jamal" ], "riwayaRefs": [ "riwaya-abu-usama-37771", "riwaya-abdrahman-1420-4409" ], "sourceRefs": [ "source-musannaf-ibn-abi-shayba-hawab-37771", "source-dossier-scans-tadif-hawab-20p" ], "status": "mahfuz", "supportLevel": "exact", "to": "ismail", "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": [] }, { "cardRefs": [], "citationRefs": [ "cit-musannaf-37771" ], "evidenceRefs": { "note": [ "cit-musannaf-37771" ] }, "from": "ismail", "id": "edge-ismail-abu-usama", "illaRefs": [], "matnRefs": [ "matn-qays-nucleus", "matn-abu-usama-context" ], "note": "حدثنا إسماعيل", "requiresPinpoint": false, "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [ "cit-musannaf-37771" ], "riwayaRefs": [ "riwaya-abu-usama-37771" ], "sourceRefs": [ "source-musannaf-ibn-abi-shayba-hawab-37771" ], "status": "mahfuz", "supportLevel": "exact", "to": "abu_usama", "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": [] }, { "cardRefs": [], "citationRefs": [ "cit-musannaf-37771" ], "evidenceRefs": { "note": [ "cit-musannaf-37771" ] }, "from": "abu_usama", "id": "edge-abu-usama-musannaf", "illaRefs": [], "matnRefs": [ "matn-qays-nucleus", "matn-abu-usama-context" ], "note": "حدثنا أبو أسامة", "requiresPinpoint": false, "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [ "cit-musannaf-37771" ], "riwayaRefs": [ "riwaya-abu-usama-37771" ], "sourceRefs": [ "source-musannaf-ibn-abi-shayba-hawab-37771" ], "status": "mahfuz", "supportLevel": "exact", "to": "musannaf_37771", "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": [] }, { "cardRefs": [], "citationRefs": [ "cit-abdrahman-dhakhira-4409", "cit-abdrahman-jawzi-1420" ], "evidenceRefs": { "note": [ "cit-abdrahman-dhakhira-4409" ] }, "from": "ismail", "id": "edge-ismail-muhammad-fudayl", "illaRefs": [], "matnRefs": [ "matn-abdrahman-rudduni" ], "note": "محمد بن فضيل عن إسماعيل", "requiresPinpoint": false, "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [ "cit-abdrahman-dhakhira-4409", "cit-abdrahman-jawzi-1420" ], "riwayaRefs": [ "riwaya-abdrahman-1420-4409" ], "sourceRefs": [ "source-dossier-scans-tadif-hawab-20p" ], "status": "mahfuz", "supportLevel": "exact", "to": "muhammad_ibn_fudayl", "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": [] }, { "cardRefs": [ "05_cards/evidences/hadith-hawab-tabaqat-al-khabar-wa-ziyadat-al-idana.md" ], "citationRefs": [ "cit-abdrahman-jawzi-1420", "cit-abdrahman-dhakhira-4409", "cit-card-analysis" ], "evidenceRefs": { "note": [ "cit-abdrahman-dhakhira-4409", "cit-card-analysis" ], "status": [ "cit-abdrahman-jawzi-1420", "cit-abdrahman-dhakhira-4409" ] }, "from": "muhammad_ibn_fudayl", "id": "edge-muhammad-fudayl-abdrahman", "illaRefs": [ "illa-abdrahman-specific-branch" ], "matnRefs": [ "matn-abdrahman-rudduni" ], "note": "عن محمد بن فضيل", "requiresPinpoint": true, "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [ "cit-abdrahman-jawzi-1420", "cit-abdrahman-dhakhira-4409", "cit-card-analysis" ], "riwayaRefs": [ "riwaya-abdrahman-1420-4409" ], "sourceRefs": [ "source-dossier-scans-tadif-hawab-20p" ], "status": "weak", "supportLevel": "card_scope", "to": "abd_al_rahman_ibn_salih", "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": [] }, { "cardRefs": [ "05_cards/evidences/hadith-hawab-tabaqat-al-khabar-wa-ziyadat-al-idana.md" ], "citationRefs": [ "cit-abdrahman-jawzi-1420", "cit-abdrahman-dhakhira-4409", "cit-card-analysis" ], "evidenceRefs": { "note": [ "cit-abdrahman-jawzi-1420", "cit-abdrahman-dhakhira-4409" ], "status": [ "cit-abdrahman-jawzi-1420", "cit-abdrahman-dhakhira-4409" ] }, "from": "abd_al_rahman_ibn_salih", "id": "edge-abdrahman-books", "illaRefs": [ "illa-abdrahman-specific-branch" ], "matnRefs": [ "matn-abdrahman-rudduni" ], "note": "إحالة تخريج؛ طبقات عليا مطوية", "requiresPinpoint": true, "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [ "cit-abdrahman-jawzi-1420", "cit-abdrahman-dhakhira-4409", "cit-card-analysis" ], "riwayaRefs": [ "riwaya-abdrahman-1420-4409" ], "sourceRefs": [ "source-dossier-scans-tadif-hawab-20p" ], "status": "weak", "supportLevel": "card_scope", "to": "jawzi_dhakhira", "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": [] }, { "cardRefs": [], "citationRefs": [ "cit-ibnabbas-ilal-2787" ], "evidenceRefs": { "note": [ "cit-ibnabbas-ilal-2787" ] }, "from": "nabi", "id": "edge-nabi-ibnabbas", "illaRefs": [], "matnRefs": [ "matn-ibnabbas-expansion" ], "note": "قال لبعض نسائه، من رواية ابن عباس", "requiresPinpoint": false, "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [ "cit-ibnabbas-ilal-2787" ], "riwayaRefs": [ "riwaya-ibnabbas-2787" ], "sourceRefs": [ "source-dossier-scans-tadif-hawab-20p" ], "status": "mahfuz", "supportLevel": "exact", "to": "ibn_abbas", "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": [] }, { "cardRefs": [], "citationRefs": [ "cit-ibnabbas-ilal-2787" ], "evidenceRefs": { "note": [ "cit-ibnabbas-ilal-2787" ] }, "from": "ibn_abbas", "id": "edge-ibnabbas-ikrima", "illaRefs": [], "matnRefs": [ "matn-ibnabbas-expansion" ], "note": "عن ابن عباس", "requiresPinpoint": false, "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [ "cit-ibnabbas-ilal-2787" ], "riwayaRefs": [ "riwaya-ibnabbas-2787" ], "sourceRefs": [ "source-dossier-scans-tadif-hawab-20p" ], "status": "mahfuz", "supportLevel": "exact", "to": "ikrima", "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": [] }, { "cardRefs": [], "citationRefs": [ "cit-ibnabbas-ilal-2787" ], "evidenceRefs": { "note": [ "cit-ibnabbas-ilal-2787" ], "status": [ "cit-ibnabbas-ilal-2787" ] }, "from": "ikrima", "id": "edge-ikrima-isam", "illaRefs": [ "illa-isam-tafarrud" ], "matnRefs": [ "matn-ibnabbas-expansion" ], "note": "عن عكرمة", "requiresPinpoint": false, "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [ "cit-ibnabbas-ilal-2787" ], "riwayaRefs": [ "riwaya-ibnabbas-2787" ], "sourceRefs": [ "source-dossier-scans-tadif-hawab-20p" ], "status": "weak", "supportLevel": "exact", "to": "isam_ibn_qudama", "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": [] }, { "cardRefs": [], "citationRefs": [ "cit-ibnabbas-ilal-2787" ], "evidenceRefs": { "note": [ "cit-ibnabbas-ilal-2787" ] }, "from": "isam_ibn_qudama", "id": "edge-isam-uqba", "illaRefs": [], "matnRefs": [ "matn-ibnabbas-expansion" ], "note": "عن ابن قدامة — يعني عصاماً", "requiresPinpoint": false, "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [ "cit-ibnabbas-ilal-2787" ], "riwayaRefs": [ "riwaya-ibnabbas-2787" ], "sourceRefs": [ "source-dossier-scans-tadif-hawab-20p" ], "status": "mahfuz", "supportLevel": "exact", "to": "uqba_ibn_khalid", "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": [] }, { "cardRefs": [], "citationRefs": [ "cit-ibnabbas-ilal-2787" ], "evidenceRefs": { "note": [ "cit-ibnabbas-ilal-2787" ] }, "from": "uqba_ibn_khalid", "id": "edge-uqba-ashajj", "illaRefs": [], "matnRefs": [ "matn-ibnabbas-expansion" ], "note": "عن عقبة بن خالد", "requiresPinpoint": false, "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [ "cit-ibnabbas-ilal-2787" ], "riwayaRefs": [ "riwaya-ibnabbas-2787" ], "sourceRefs": [ "source-dossier-scans-tadif-hawab-20p" ], "status": "mahfuz", "supportLevel": "exact", "to": "al_ashajj", "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": [] }, { "cardRefs": [], "citationRefs": [ "cit-ibnabbas-ilal-2787" ], "evidenceRefs": { "note": [ "cit-ibnabbas-ilal-2787" ] }, "from": "al_ashajj", "id": "edge-ashajj-ilal2787", "illaRefs": [], "matnRefs": [ "matn-ibnabbas-expansion" ], "note": "موضع سؤال ابن أبي حاتم عن الحديث", "requiresPinpoint": false, "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [ "cit-ibnabbas-ilal-2787" ], "riwayaRefs": [ "riwaya-ibnabbas-2787" ], "sourceRefs": [ "source-dossier-scans-tadif-hawab-20p" ], "status": "mahfuz", "supportLevel": "exact", "to": "ilal_2787", "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": [] }, { "cardRefs": [ "05_cards/evidences/hawab-qabul-shuhud-wa-matn-thalith-hold.md" ], "citationRefs": [ "cit-card-holds", "cit-witnesses-ibn-arabi" ], "evidenceRefs": { "note": [ "cit-witnesses-ibn-arabi", "cit-card-holds" ], "status": [ "cit-card-holds" ] }, "from": "witnesses_void", "id": "edge-witnesses-unresolved", "illaRefs": [], "matnRefs": [], "note": "إحالة بحثية؛ لا طريق مثبت في المادة", "requiresPinpoint": true, "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [ "cit-card-holds", "cit-witnesses-ibn-arabi" ], "riwayaRefs": [], "sourceRefs": [ "source-dossier-scans-tadif-hawab-20p" ], "status": "munqati", "supportLevel": "card_scope", "to": "witnesses_story", "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": [] } ] }