{ "arguments": [ { "citationRefs": [ "cit-b2-hukm", "cit-b2-hukm-variant", "cit-b5-hukm" ], "evidenceRefs": [ "cit-b2-hukm", "cit-b2-hukm-variant", "cit-b5-hukm" ], "id": "arg-route-scope", "illaRefs": [], "kind": "isnad", "limitations": "الخريطة عينة مقصودة لطريقين؛ لا استقصاء للطرق ولا تصحيح لهذين الإسنادين.", "riwayaRefs": [ "riwaya-b2-1187", "riwaya-b5-5308" ], "scope": "sample", "statement": "ثبت نص نقدي للبخاري في هذين الموضعين؛ الحكم المعروض متصل بإسناد إسماعيل وبجهالة سهم، ولا يعم جميع طرق جملة الموالاة.", "target": "verdict", "targets": [ "riwaya:riwaya-b2-1187", "riwaya:riwaya-b5-5308" ] }, { "citationRefs": [ "cit-b5-matn", "cit-b5-context" ], "evidenceRefs": [ "cit-b5-matn", "cit-b5-context" ], "id": "arg-story-level", "illaRefs": [], "kind": "matn", "limitations": "وجود شاهد للموالاة في طريق مستقل لا يصحح آلياً قصة التوبة أو بقية تفاصيل هذه الرواية.", "riwayaRefs": [ "riwaya-b5-5308" ], "scope": "sample", "statement": "خبر الأولوية والموالاة يرد في حوار أبي سعيد، وتحيط به قصة عن ابن علقمة يعلق عليها ابن شريك.", "targets": [ "riwaya:riwaya-b5-5308" ] } ], "citations": [ { "attribution": null, "cardRef": null, "discovery": null, "id": "cit-b2-report", "kind": "evidence", "label": "قال لي عبيد، قال: حدثنا يونس، سمع إسماعيل، عن جميل بن عامر، أن سالماً حدثه، سمع أباه، سمع النبي ﷺ يقول يوم غدير خم: من كنت مولاه فعلي مولاه.", "limitations": null, "locator": { "display": "التاريخ الكبير، طبعة الدباسي والنحال، ط1، 1440هـ/2019م، 2/92، ت1187، متن الترجمة", "item": 1187, "page": 92, "volume": 2 }, "mode": "quoted", "note": null, "quote": "قال لي عبيد، قال: حدثنا يونس، سمع إسماعيل، عن جميل بن عامر، أن سالماً حدثه، سمع أباه، سمع النبي ﷺ يقول يوم غدير خم: من كنت مولاه فعلي مولاه.", "sourceId": "source-bukhari-ghadir-two-routes-2019", "sourceRef": "source-bukhari-ghadir-two-routes-2019", "speaker": "محمد بن إسماعيل البخاري (ت256هـ)", "summary": null, "url": null, "verification": "verified_scan", "verificationLimits": null }, { "attribution": null, "cardRef": null, "discovery": null, "id": "cit-b2-hukm", "kind": "evidence", "label": "نقد الإسناد المعروض؛ لا يوزع على جميع رجاله ولا على طرق لم تسق هنا.", "limitations": null, "locator": { "display": "التاريخ الكبير، طبعة الدباسي والنحال، ط1، 1440هـ/2019م، 2/92، ت1187، تعقيب المصنف", "item": 1187, "page": 92, "volume": 2 }, "mode": "quoted", "note": null, "quote": "قال أبو عبد الله: في إسناده نظر.", "sourceId": "source-bukhari-ghadir-two-routes-2019", "sourceRef": "source-bukhari-ghadir-two-routes-2019", "speaker": "محمد بن إسماعيل البخاري (ت256هـ)", "summary": "نقد الإسناد المعروض؛ لا يوزع على جميع رجاله ولا على طرق لم تسق هنا.", "url": null, "verification": "verified_scan", "verificationLimits": null }, { "attribution": null, "cardRef": null, "discovery": null, "id": "cit-b2-variants", "kind": "evidence", "label": "اختلاف نسخي في تعيين المروي عنه؛ لا يعد طريقاً مستقلاً.", "limitations": null, "locator": { "display": "التاريخ الكبير، طبعة الدباسي والنحال، ط1، 1440هـ/2019م، 2/92، ت1187، حاشية5", "item": 1187, "page": 92, "volume": 2 }, "mode": "quoted", "note": null, "quote": "في (ك)، (ش)، (ق): سمع من. وقوله: سمع أباه ليس في (ز)، وفي (غ): أخبره أنه سمع أباه أنه.", "sourceId": "source-bukhari-ghadir-two-routes-2019", "sourceRef": "source-bukhari-ghadir-two-routes-2019", "speaker": "جهاز تحقيق الدباسي والنحال", "summary": "اختلاف نسخي في تعيين المروي عنه؛ لا يعد طريقاً مستقلاً.", "url": null, "verification": "verified_scan", "verificationLimits": null }, { "attribution": null, "cardRef": null, "discovery": null, "id": "cit-b2-hukm-variant", "kind": "evidence", "label": "قراءة مقابلة للتعقيب، لا قول ثان مستقل ثبت في موضع آخر.", "limitations": null, "locator": { "display": "التاريخ الكبير، طبعة الدباسي والنحال، ط1، 1440هـ/2019م، 2/92، ت1187، حاشية8", "item": 1187, "page": 92, "volume": 2 }, "mode": "quoted", "note": null, "quote": "في (غ): قال محمد: لم يتابع عن سالم في هذا الحديث.", "sourceId": "source-bukhari-ghadir-two-routes-2019", "sourceRef": "source-bukhari-ghadir-two-routes-2019", "speaker": "جهاز تحقيق الدباسي والنحال", "summary": "قراءة مقابلة للتعقيب، لا قول ثان مستقل ثبت في موضع آخر.", "url": null, "verification": "verified_scan", "verificationLimits": null }, { "attribution": null, "cardRef": null, "discovery": null, "id": "cit-b2-matn", "kind": "evidence", "label": "سمع النبي ﷺ يقول يوم غدير خم: من كنت مولاه فعلي مولاه.", "limitations": null, "locator": { "display": "التاريخ الكبير، طبعة الدباسي والنحال، ط1، 1440هـ/2019م، 2/92، ت1187، المتن المرفوع", "item": 1187, "page": 92, "volume": 2 }, "mode": "quoted", "note": null, "quote": "سمع النبي ﷺ يقول يوم غدير خم: من كنت مولاه فعلي مولاه.", "sourceId": "source-bukhari-ghadir-two-routes-2019", "sourceRef": "source-bukhari-ghadir-two-routes-2019", "speaker": "محمد بن إسماعيل البخاري (ت256هـ)", "summary": null, "url": null, "verification": "verified_scan", "verificationLimits": null }, { "attribution": null, "cardRef": null, "discovery": null, "id": "cit-b2-names", "kind": "evidence", "label": "شهر وأبو نعيم ليسا في سند الخبر المرسوم.", "limitations": null, "locator": { "display": "التاريخ الكبير، طبعة الدباسي والنحال، ط1، 1440هـ/2019م، 2/92، ت1187، عنوان الترجمة والتعريف", "item": 1187, "page": 92, "volume": 2 }, "mode": "quoted", "note": null, "quote": "إسماعيل بن نشيط العامري. سمع شهر بن حوشب، وجميلاً. سمع منه أبو نعيم، ويونس بن بكير.", "sourceId": "source-bukhari-ghadir-two-routes-2019", "sourceRef": "source-bukhari-ghadir-two-routes-2019", "speaker": "محمد بن إسماعيل البخاري (ت256هـ)", "summary": "شهر وأبو نعيم ليسا في سند الخبر المرسوم.", "url": null, "verification": "verified_scan", "verificationLimits": null }, { "attribution": null, "cardRef": null, "discovery": null, "id": "cit-b5-report", "kind": "evidence", "label": "أبو سعيد مصدر المرفوع داخل الحوار؛ ابن علقمة صاحب في القصة، لا واسطة في هذا السند.", "limitations": null, "locator": { "display": "التاريخ الكبير، طبعة الدباسي والنحال، ط1، 1440هـ/2019م، 5/297–298، ت5308، السند وسياق السؤال", "item": 5308, "page": "297–298", "volume": 5 }, "mode": "quoted", "note": null, "quote": "حدثني يوسف بن راشد، حدثنا علي بن قادم الخزاعي، أخبرنا إسرائيل، عن عبد الله بن شريك، عن سهم بن حصين الأسدي: قدمت مكة أنا وعبد الله بن علقمة... يعني أبا سعيد الخدري... قال: نعم... قام النبي ﷺ يوم غدير خم.", "sourceId": "source-bukhari-ghadir-two-routes-2019", "sourceRef": "source-bukhari-ghadir-two-routes-2019", "speaker": "محمد بن إسماعيل البخاري (ت256هـ)", "summary": "أبو سعيد مصدر المرفوع داخل الحوار؛ ابن علقمة صاحب في القصة، لا واسطة في هذا السند.", "url": null, "verification": "verified_scan", "verificationLimits": null }, { "attribution": null, "cardRef": null, "discovery": null, "id": "cit-b5-hukm", "kind": "evidence", "label": "الجهالة خاصة بسهم؛ لا تنسب إلى جميع رجال الطريق.", "limitations": null, "locator": { "display": "التاريخ الكبير، طبعة الدباسي والنحال، ط1، 1440هـ/2019م، 5/298، ت5308، تعقيب المصنف", "item": 5308, "page": 298, "volume": 5 }, "mode": "quoted", "note": null, "quote": "قال أبو عبد الله: وسهم مجهول، ولا يدرى من هو.", "sourceId": "source-bukhari-ghadir-two-routes-2019", "sourceRef": "source-bukhari-ghadir-two-routes-2019", "speaker": "محمد بن إسماعيل البخاري (ت256هـ)", "summary": "الجهالة خاصة بسهم؛ لا تنسب إلى جميع رجال الطريق.", "url": null, "verification": "verified_scan", "verificationLimits": null }, { "attribution": null, "cardRef": null, "discovery": null, "id": "cit-b5-hukm-variant", "kind": "evidence", "label": "اختلاف نسخي يحفظ دون استنتاج حذف مقصود.", "limitations": null, "locator": { "display": "التاريخ الكبير، طبعة الدباسي والنحال، ط1، 1440هـ/2019م، 5/298، ت5308، حاشيتا4–5", "item": 5308, "page": 298, "volume": 5 }, "mode": "quoted", "note": null, "quote": "قوله: من هو ليس في (ق). قوله: قال أبو عبد الله ... من هو ليس في (ث).", "sourceId": "source-bukhari-ghadir-two-routes-2019", "sourceRef": "source-bukhari-ghadir-two-routes-2019", "speaker": "محمد بن إسماعيل البخاري (ت256هـ)", "summary": "اختلاف نسخي يحفظ دون استنتاج حذف مقصود.", "url": null, "verification": "verified_scan", "verificationLimits": null }, { "attribution": null, "cardRef": null, "discovery": null, "id": "cit-b5-matn", "kind": "evidence", "label": "قام النبي ﷺ يوم غدير خم، فأبلغ، فقال: ألست أولى بالمؤمنين من أنفسهم؟ ادن يا علي، فدنا، فرفع يده، ورفع النبي ﷺ يده، حتى نظرت إلى بياض إبطيه، فقال: من كنت مولاه فعلي مولاه. وسمعته أذناي.", "limitations": null, "locator": { "display": "التاريخ الكبير، طبعة الدباسي والنحال، ط1، 1440هـ/2019م، 5/297، ت5308، قول أبي سعيد في المرفوع", "item": 5308, "page": 297, "volume": 5 }, "mode": "quoted", "note": null, "quote": "قام النبي ﷺ يوم غدير خم، فأبلغ، فقال: ألست أولى بالمؤمنين من أنفسهم؟ ادن يا علي، فدنا، فرفع يده، ورفع النبي ﷺ يده، حتى نظرت إلى بياض إبطيه، فقال: من كنت مولاه فعلي مولاه. وسمعته أذناي.", "sourceId": "source-bukhari-ghadir-two-routes-2019", "sourceRef": "source-bukhari-ghadir-two-routes-2019", "speaker": "محمد بن إسماعيل البخاري (ت256هـ)", "summary": null, "url": null, "verification": "verified_scan", "verificationLimits": null }, { "attribution": null, "cardRef": null, "discovery": null, "id": "cit-b5-context", "kind": "evidence", "label": "شاهد جملة الموالاة وحده لا يصحح هذه القصة.", "limitations": null, "locator": { "display": "التاريخ الكبير، طبعة الدباسي والنحال، ط1، 1440هـ/2019م، 5/297–298، ت5308، التعقيب القصصي", "item": 5308, "page": "297–298", "volume": 5 }, "mode": "quoted", "note": null, "quote": "قال ابن شريك: وكان ابن علقمة سباباً لعلي... قال ابن شريك: فقدم عبد الله بن علقمة وسهم، فلما صلينا الفجر، قام ابن علقمة، فقال: أتوب إلى الله من سب علي.", "sourceId": "source-bukhari-ghadir-two-routes-2019", "sourceRef": "source-bukhari-ghadir-two-routes-2019", "speaker": "محمد بن إسماعيل البخاري (ت256هـ)", "summary": "شاهد جملة الموالاة وحده لا يصحح هذه القصة.", "url": null, "verification": "verified_scan", "verificationLimits": null }, { "attribution": null, "cardRef": null, "discovery": null, "id": "cit-nabi-father", "kind": "evidence", "label": "سمع أباه، سمع النبي ﷺ", "limitations": null, "locator": { "display": "التاريخ الكبير، طبعة الدباسي والنحال، ط1، 1440هـ/2019م، 2/92، ت1187، صيغة النقل", "item": 1187, "page": 92, "volume": 2 }, "mode": "quoted", "note": null, "quote": "سمع أباه، سمع النبي ﷺ", "sourceId": "source-bukhari-ghadir-two-routes-2019", "sourceRef": "source-bukhari-ghadir-two-routes-2019", "speaker": "محمد بن إسماعيل البخاري (ت256هـ)", "summary": null, "url": null, "verification": "verified_scan", "verificationLimits": null }, { "attribution": null, "cardRef": null, "discovery": null, "id": "cit-father-salim", "kind": "evidence", "label": "أن سالماً حدثه، سمع أباه", "limitations": null, "locator": { "display": "التاريخ الكبير، طبعة الدباسي والنحال، ط1، 1440هـ/2019م، 2/92، ت1187، صيغة النقل", "item": 1187, "page": 92, "volume": 2 }, "mode": "quoted", "note": null, "quote": "أن سالماً حدثه، سمع أباه", "sourceId": "source-bukhari-ghadir-two-routes-2019", "sourceRef": "source-bukhari-ghadir-two-routes-2019", "speaker": "محمد بن إسماعيل البخاري (ت256هـ)", "summary": null, "url": null, "verification": "verified_scan", "verificationLimits": null }, { "attribution": null, "cardRef": null, "discovery": null, "id": "cit-salim-jamil", "kind": "evidence", "label": "عن جميل بن عامر، أن سالماً حدثه", "limitations": null, "locator": { "display": "التاريخ الكبير، طبعة الدباسي والنحال، ط1، 1440هـ/2019م، 2/92، ت1187، صيغة النقل", "item": 1187, "page": 92, "volume": 2 }, "mode": "quoted", "note": null, "quote": "عن جميل بن عامر، أن سالماً حدثه", "sourceId": "source-bukhari-ghadir-two-routes-2019", "sourceRef": "source-bukhari-ghadir-two-routes-2019", "speaker": "محمد بن إسماعيل البخاري (ت256هـ)", "summary": null, "url": null, "verification": "verified_scan", "verificationLimits": null }, { "attribution": null, "cardRef": null, "discovery": null, "id": "cit-jamil-ismail", "kind": "evidence", "label": "سمع إسماعيل، عن جميل بن عامر", "limitations": null, "locator": { "display": "التاريخ الكبير، طبعة الدباسي والنحال، ط1، 1440هـ/2019م، 2/92، ت1187، صيغة النقل", "item": 1187, "page": 92, "volume": 2 }, "mode": "quoted", "note": null, "quote": "سمع إسماعيل، عن جميل بن عامر", "sourceId": "source-bukhari-ghadir-two-routes-2019", "sourceRef": "source-bukhari-ghadir-two-routes-2019", "speaker": "محمد بن إسماعيل البخاري (ت256هـ)", "summary": null, "url": null, "verification": "verified_scan", "verificationLimits": null }, { "attribution": null, "cardRef": null, "discovery": null, "id": "cit-ismail-yunus", "kind": "evidence", "label": "حدثنا يونس، سمع إسماعيل", "limitations": null, "locator": { "display": "التاريخ الكبير، طبعة الدباسي والنحال، ط1، 1440هـ/2019م، 2/92، ت1187، صيغة النقل", "item": 1187, "page": 92, "volume": 2 }, "mode": "quoted", "note": null, "quote": "حدثنا يونس، سمع إسماعيل", "sourceId": "source-bukhari-ghadir-two-routes-2019", "sourceRef": "source-bukhari-ghadir-two-routes-2019", "speaker": "محمد بن إسماعيل البخاري (ت256هـ)", "summary": null, "url": null, "verification": "verified_scan", "verificationLimits": null }, { "attribution": null, "cardRef": null, "discovery": null, "id": "cit-yunus-ubayd", "kind": "evidence", "label": "قال لي عبيد، قال: حدثنا يونس", "limitations": null, "locator": { "display": "التاريخ الكبير، طبعة الدباسي والنحال، ط1، 1440هـ/2019م، 2/92، ت1187، صيغة النقل", "item": 1187, "page": 92, "volume": 2 }, "mode": "quoted", "note": null, "quote": "قال لي عبيد، قال: حدثنا يونس", "sourceId": "source-bukhari-ghadir-two-routes-2019", "sourceRef": "source-bukhari-ghadir-two-routes-2019", "speaker": "محمد بن إسماعيل البخاري (ت256هـ)", "summary": null, "url": null, "verification": "verified_scan", "verificationLimits": null }, { "attribution": null, "cardRef": null, "discovery": null, "id": "cit-ubayd-bukhari", "kind": "evidence", "label": "قال لي عبيد، قال: حدثنا يونس", "limitations": null, "locator": { "display": "التاريخ الكبير، طبعة الدباسي والنحال، ط1، 1440هـ/2019م، 2/92، ت1187، صيغة النقل", "item": 1187, "page": 92, "volume": 2 }, "mode": "quoted", "note": null, "quote": "قال لي عبيد، قال: حدثنا يونس", "sourceId": "source-bukhari-ghadir-two-routes-2019", "sourceRef": "source-bukhari-ghadir-two-routes-2019", "speaker": "محمد بن إسماعيل البخاري (ت256هـ)", "summary": null, "url": null, "verification": "verified_scan", "verificationLimits": null }, { "attribution": null, "cardRef": null, "discovery": null, "id": "cit-nabi-abu-said", "kind": "evidence", "label": "يعني أبا سعيد الخدري... قال: نعم... قام النبي ﷺ يوم غدير خم", "limitations": null, "locator": { "display": "التاريخ الكبير، طبعة الدباسي والنحال، ط1، 1440هـ/2019م، 5/297، ت5308، صيغة النقل", "item": 5308, "page": 297, "volume": 5 }, "mode": "quoted", "note": null, "quote": "يعني أبا سعيد الخدري... قال: نعم... قام النبي ﷺ يوم غدير خم", "sourceId": "source-bukhari-ghadir-two-routes-2019", "sourceRef": "source-bukhari-ghadir-two-routes-2019", "speaker": "محمد بن إسماعيل البخاري (ت256هـ)", "summary": null, "url": null, "verification": "verified_scan", "verificationLimits": null }, { "attribution": null, "cardRef": null, "discovery": null, "id": "cit-abu-said-sahm", "kind": "evidence", "label": "اسم أبي سعيد وأداء خبره داخل الحوار، لا بعنعنة مصطنعة في صدر السند.", "limitations": null, "locator": { "display": "التاريخ الكبير، طبعة الدباسي والنحال، ط1، 1440هـ/2019م، 5/297، ت5308، صيغة النقل", "item": 5308, "page": 297, "volume": 5 }, "mode": "quoted", "note": null, "quote": "عن سهم بن حصين الأسدي... يعني أبا سعيد الخدري؟ فقلت: هل سمعت لعلي منقبة؟ قال: نعم", "sourceId": "source-bukhari-ghadir-two-routes-2019", "sourceRef": "source-bukhari-ghadir-two-routes-2019", "speaker": "محمد بن إسماعيل البخاري (ت256هـ)", "summary": "اسم أبي سعيد وأداء خبره داخل الحوار، لا بعنعنة مصطنعة في صدر السند.", "url": null, "verification": "verified_scan", "verificationLimits": null }, { "attribution": null, "cardRef": null, "discovery": null, "id": "cit-sahm-abdallah", "kind": "evidence", "label": "عن عبد الله بن شريك، عن سهم بن حصين الأسدي", "limitations": null, "locator": { "display": "التاريخ الكبير، طبعة الدباسي والنحال، ط1، 1440هـ/2019م، 5/297، ت5308، صيغة النقل", "item": 5308, "page": 297, "volume": 5 }, "mode": "quoted", "note": null, "quote": "عن عبد الله بن شريك، عن سهم بن حصين الأسدي", "sourceId": "source-bukhari-ghadir-two-routes-2019", "sourceRef": "source-bukhari-ghadir-two-routes-2019", "speaker": "محمد بن إسماعيل البخاري (ت256هـ)", "summary": null, "url": null, "verification": "verified_scan", "verificationLimits": null }, { "attribution": null, "cardRef": null, "discovery": null, "id": "cit-abdallah-israil", "kind": "evidence", "label": "أخبرنا إسرائيل، عن عبد الله بن شريك", "limitations": null, "locator": { "display": "التاريخ الكبير، طبعة الدباسي والنحال، ط1، 1440هـ/2019م، 5/297، ت5308، صيغة النقل", "item": 5308, "page": 297, "volume": 5 }, "mode": "quoted", "note": null, "quote": "أخبرنا إسرائيل، عن عبد الله بن شريك", "sourceId": "source-bukhari-ghadir-two-routes-2019", "sourceRef": "source-bukhari-ghadir-two-routes-2019", "speaker": "محمد بن إسماعيل البخاري (ت256هـ)", "summary": null, "url": null, "verification": "verified_scan", "verificationLimits": null }, { "attribution": null, "cardRef": null, "discovery": null, "id": "cit-israil-ali", "kind": "evidence", "label": "حدثنا علي بن قادم الخزاعي، أخبرنا إسرائيل", "limitations": null, "locator": { "display": "التاريخ الكبير، طبعة الدباسي والنحال، ط1، 1440هـ/2019م، 5/297، ت5308، صيغة النقل", "item": 5308, "page": 297, "volume": 5 }, "mode": "quoted", "note": null, "quote": "حدثنا علي بن قادم الخزاعي، أخبرنا إسرائيل", "sourceId": "source-bukhari-ghadir-two-routes-2019", "sourceRef": "source-bukhari-ghadir-two-routes-2019", "speaker": "محمد بن إسماعيل البخاري (ت256هـ)", "summary": null, "url": null, "verification": "verified_scan", "verificationLimits": null }, { "attribution": null, "cardRef": null, "discovery": null, "id": "cit-ali-yusuf", "kind": "evidence", "label": "حدثني يوسف بن راشد، حدثنا علي بن قادم الخزاعي", "limitations": null, "locator": { "display": "التاريخ الكبير، طبعة الدباسي والنحال، ط1، 1440هـ/2019م، 5/297، ت5308، صيغة النقل", "item": 5308, "page": 297, "volume": 5 }, "mode": "quoted", "note": null, "quote": "حدثني يوسف بن راشد، حدثنا علي بن قادم الخزاعي", "sourceId": "source-bukhari-ghadir-two-routes-2019", "sourceRef": "source-bukhari-ghadir-two-routes-2019", "speaker": "محمد بن إسماعيل البخاري (ت256هـ)", "summary": null, "url": null, "verification": "verified_scan", "verificationLimits": null }, { "attribution": null, "cardRef": null, "discovery": null, "id": "cit-yusuf-bukhari", "kind": "evidence", "label": "حدثني يوسف بن راشد", "limitations": null, "locator": { "display": "التاريخ الكبير، طبعة الدباسي والنحال، ط1، 1440هـ/2019م، 5/297، ت5308، صيغة النقل", "item": 5308, "page": 297, "volume": 5 }, "mode": "quoted", "note": null, "quote": "حدثني يوسف بن راشد", "sourceId": "source-bukhari-ghadir-two-routes-2019", "sourceRef": "source-bukhari-ghadir-two-routes-2019", "speaker": "محمد بن إسماعيل البخاري (ت256هـ)", "summary": null, "url": null, "verification": "verified_scan", "verificationLimits": null } ], "dependencyHash": "3d079b591c2072f9", "diagnostics": { "errors": [], "warnings": [ "evidenceStatus=incomplete: 11/49 hotspots تحتاج تعيين المصدر والموضع" ] }, "evidenceStatus": "incomplete", "illal": [ { "citationRefs": [ "cit-b2-hukm", "cit-b2-hukm-variant" ], "evidenceRefs": [ "cit-b2-hukm", "cit-b2-hukm-variant" ], "id": "illa-b2-nazar", "kind": "isnad_criticism", "label": "نقد الإسناد ككل", "matnRefs": [], "riwayaRefs": [ "riwaya-b2-1187" ], "subject": { "id": "edge-ubayd-book_b2", "kind": "edge" }, "text": "قال البخاري: في إسناده نظر. وفي قراءة غ: لم يتابع عن سالم في هذا الحديث. وسم هذا الموضع لا يتهم عبيداً أو بقية رجال الطريق جميعاً." }, { "citationRefs": [ "cit-b2-variants" ], "evidenceRefs": [ "cit-b2-variants" ], "id": "illa-salim-variant", "kind": "textual_variant", "label": "اختلاف تسمية آخر الطريق", "matnRefs": [], "riwayaRefs": [ "riwaya-b2-1187" ], "subject": { "id": "edge-salim_father-salim", "kind": "edge" }, "text": "المتن: سمع أباه؛ وفي ك وش وق: سمع من. اختلاف نسخي يحفظ، ولا يعد طريقاً مستقلاً أو انقطاعاً ثابتاً." }, { "citationRefs": [ "cit-b5-hukm", "cit-b5-hukm-variant" ], "evidenceRefs": [ "cit-b5-hukm", "cit-b5-hukm-variant" ], "id": "illa-sahm-majhul", "kind": "jahala", "label": "البخاري يجهّل سهماً", "matnRefs": [], "riwayaRefs": [ "riwaya-b5-5308" ], "subject": { "id": "sahm", "kind": "node" }, "text": "وسهم مجهول، ولا يدرى من هو. لا ينقل هذا الحكم إلى بقية الرجال. في ق تنقص من هو، وفي ث يغيب التعقيب كله." } ], "interactionIndex": { "hotspots": { "argument:arg-route-scope": { "argumentRefs": [ "arg-route-scope" ], "cardRefs": [], "citationRefs": [ "cit-b2-hukm", "cit-b2-hukm-variant", "cit-b5-hukm" ], "evidenceRefs": [ "cit-b2-hukm", "cit-b2-hukm-variant", "cit-b5-hukm" ], "icon": { "kindLabel": "حجة الدراسة", "meaning": "الدعوى وأدلتها وحدودها", "status": "documented", "statusLabel": "إحالة موضعية مقابلة", "summary": "ثبت نص نقدي للبخاري في هذين الموضعين؛ الحكم المعروض متصل بإسناد إسماعيل وبجهالة سهم، ولا يعم جميع طرق جملة الموالاة. — الخريطة عينة مقصودة لطريقين؛ لا استقصاء للطرق ولا تصحيح لهذين الإسنادين." }, "id": "argument:arg-route-scope", "illaRefs": [], "kind": "argument", "label": "ثبت نص نقدي للبخاري في هذين الموضعين؛ الحكم المعروض متصل بإسناد إسماعيل وبجهالة سهم، ولا يعم جميع طرق جملة الموالاة.", "matnRefs": [], "rendered": true, "requiresPinpoint": false, "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [ "cit-b2-hukm", "cit-b2-hukm-variant", "cit-b5-hukm" ], "riwayaRefs": [ "riwaya-b2-1187", "riwaya-b5-5308" ], "sourceRefs": [ "source-bukhari-ghadir-two-routes-2019" ], "supportLevel": "exact", "target": { "argumentId": "arg-route-scope" }, "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": [] }, "argument:arg-story-level": { "argumentRefs": [ "arg-story-level" ], "cardRefs": [], "citationRefs": [ "cit-b5-matn", "cit-b5-context" ], "evidenceRefs": [ "cit-b5-matn", "cit-b5-context" ], "icon": { "kindLabel": "حجة الدراسة", "meaning": "الدعوى وأدلتها وحدودها", "status": "documented", "statusLabel": "إحالة موضعية مقابلة", "summary": "خبر الأولوية والموالاة يرد في حوار أبي سعيد، وتحيط به قصة عن ابن علقمة يعلق عليها ابن شريك. — وجود شاهد للموالاة في طريق مستقل لا يصحح آلياً قصة التوبة أو بقية تفاصيل هذه الرواية." }, "id": "argument:arg-story-level", "illaRefs": [], "kind": "argument", "label": "خبر الأولوية والموالاة يرد في حوار أبي سعيد، وتحيط به قصة عن ابن علقمة يعلق عليها ابن شريك.", "matnRefs": [], "rendered": true, "requiresPinpoint": false, "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [ "cit-b5-matn", "cit-b5-context" ], "riwayaRefs": [ "riwaya-b5-5308" ], "sourceRefs": [ "source-bukhari-ghadir-two-routes-2019" ], "supportLevel": "exact", "target": { "argumentId": "arg-story-level" }, "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": [] }, "city:abdallah_sharik": { "argumentRefs": [], "cardRefs": [], "citationRefs": [], "evidenceRefs": [], "icon": { "kindLabel": "مصر النقل", "meaning": "المصر المسجل ومرجعه؛ البيئة وحدها ليست جرحاً", "status": "missing", "statusLabel": "لم تسجل إحالة موضعية لهذا الحقل", "summary": "عبد الله بن شريك: غير معيّن" }, "id": "city:abdallah_sharik", "illaRefs": [], "kind": "city", "label": "عبد الله بن شريك: غير معيّن", "matnRefs": [], "rendered": true, "requiresPinpoint": true, "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [], "riwayaRefs": [], "sourceRefs": [], "supportLevel": "unresolved", "target": { "field": "city", "nodeId": "abdallah_sharik" }, "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": [] }, "city:ali_qadim": { "argumentRefs": [], "cardRefs": [], "citationRefs": [], "evidenceRefs": [], "icon": { "kindLabel": "مصر النقل", "meaning": "المصر المسجل ومرجعه؛ البيئة وحدها ليست جرحاً", "status": "missing", "statusLabel": "لم تسجل إحالة موضعية لهذا الحقل", "summary": "علي بن قادم الخزاعي: غير معيّن" }, "id": "city:ali_qadim", "illaRefs": [], "kind": "city", "label": "علي بن قادم الخزاعي: غير معيّن", "matnRefs": [], "rendered": true, "requiresPinpoint": true, "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [], "riwayaRefs": [], "sourceRefs": [], "supportLevel": "unresolved", "target": { "field": "city", "nodeId": "ali_qadim" }, "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": [] }, "city:ismail": { "argumentRefs": [], "cardRefs": [], "citationRefs": [], "evidenceRefs": [], "icon": { "kindLabel": "مصر النقل", "meaning": "المصر المسجل ومرجعه؛ البيئة وحدها ليست جرحاً", "status": "missing", "statusLabel": "لم تسجل إحالة موضعية لهذا الحقل", "summary": "إسماعيل بن نشيط العامري: غير معيّن" }, "id": "city:ismail", "illaRefs": [], "kind": "city", "label": "إسماعيل بن نشيط العامري: غير معيّن", "matnRefs": [], "rendered": true, "requiresPinpoint": true, "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [], "riwayaRefs": [], "sourceRefs": [], "supportLevel": "unresolved", "target": { "field": "city", "nodeId": "ismail" }, "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": [] }, "city:israil": { "argumentRefs": [], "cardRefs": [], "citationRefs": [], "evidenceRefs": [], "icon": { "kindLabel": "مصر النقل", "meaning": "المصر المسجل ومرجعه؛ البيئة وحدها ليست جرحاً", "status": "missing", "statusLabel": "لم تسجل إحالة موضعية لهذا الحقل", "summary": "إسرائيل: غير معيّن" }, "id": "city:israil", "illaRefs": [], "kind": "city", "label": "إسرائيل: غير معيّن", "matnRefs": [], "rendered": true, "requiresPinpoint": true, "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [], "riwayaRefs": [], "sourceRefs": [], "supportLevel": "unresolved", "target": { "field": "city", "nodeId": "israil" }, "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": [] }, "city:jamil": { "argumentRefs": [], "cardRefs": [], "citationRefs": [], "evidenceRefs": [], "icon": { "kindLabel": "مصر النقل", "meaning": "المصر المسجل ومرجعه؛ البيئة وحدها ليست جرحاً", "status": "missing", "statusLabel": "لم تسجل إحالة موضعية لهذا الحقل", "summary": "جميل بن عامر: غير معيّن" }, "id": "city:jamil", "illaRefs": [], "kind": "city", "label": "جميل بن عامر: غير معيّن", "matnRefs": [], "rendered": true, "requiresPinpoint": true, "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [], "riwayaRefs": [], "sourceRefs": [], "supportLevel": "unresolved", "target": { "field": "city", "nodeId": "jamil" }, "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": [] }, "city:sahm": { "argumentRefs": [], "cardRefs": [], "citationRefs": [], "evidenceRefs": [], "icon": { "kindLabel": "مصر النقل", "meaning": "المصر المسجل ومرجعه؛ البيئة وحدها ليست جرحاً", "status": "missing", "statusLabel": "لم تسجل إحالة موضعية لهذا الحقل", "summary": "سهم بن حصين الأسدي: غير معيّن" }, "id": "city:sahm", "illaRefs": [], "kind": "city", "label": "سهم بن حصين الأسدي: غير معيّن", "matnRefs": [], "rendered": true, "requiresPinpoint": true, "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [], "riwayaRefs": [], "sourceRefs": [], "supportLevel": "unresolved", "target": { "field": "city", "nodeId": "sahm" }, "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": [] }, "city:salim": { "argumentRefs": [], "cardRefs": [], "citationRefs": [], "evidenceRefs": [], "icon": { "kindLabel": "مصر النقل", "meaning": "المصر المسجل ومرجعه؛ البيئة وحدها ليست جرحاً", "status": "missing", "statusLabel": "لم تسجل إحالة موضعية لهذا الحقل", "summary": "سالم: غير معيّن" }, "id": "city:salim", "illaRefs": [], "kind": "city", "label": "سالم: غير معيّن", "matnRefs": [], "rendered": true, "requiresPinpoint": true, "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [], "riwayaRefs": [], "sourceRefs": [], "supportLevel": "unresolved", "target": { "field": "city", "nodeId": "salim" }, "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": [] }, "city:salim_father": { "argumentRefs": [], "cardRefs": [], "citationRefs": [], "evidenceRefs": [], "icon": { "kindLabel": "مصر النقل", "meaning": "المصر المسجل ومرجعه؛ البيئة وحدها ليست جرحاً", "status": "missing", "statusLabel": "لم تسجل إحالة موضعية لهذا الحقل", "summary": "والد سالم: غير معيّن" }, "id": "city:salim_father", "illaRefs": [], "kind": "city", "label": "والد سالم: غير معيّن", "matnRefs": [], "rendered": true, "requiresPinpoint": true, "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [], "riwayaRefs": [], "sourceRefs": [], "supportLevel": "unresolved", "target": { "field": "city", "nodeId": "salim_father" }, "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": [] }, "city:ubayd": { "argumentRefs": [], "cardRefs": [], "citationRefs": [], "evidenceRefs": [], "icon": { "kindLabel": "مصر النقل", "meaning": "المصر المسجل ومرجعه؛ البيئة وحدها ليست جرحاً", "status": "missing", "statusLabel": "لم تسجل إحالة موضعية لهذا الحقل", "summary": "عبيد: غير معيّن" }, "id": "city:ubayd", "illaRefs": [], "kind": "city", "label": "عبيد: غير معيّن", "matnRefs": [], "rendered": true, "requiresPinpoint": true, "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [], "riwayaRefs": [], "sourceRefs": [], "supportLevel": "unresolved", "target": { "field": "city", "nodeId": "ubayd" }, "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": [] }, "city:yunus": { "argumentRefs": [], "cardRefs": [], "citationRefs": [], "evidenceRefs": [], "icon": { "kindLabel": "مصر النقل", "meaning": "المصر المسجل ومرجعه؛ البيئة وحدها ليست جرحاً", "status": "missing", "statusLabel": "لم تسجل إحالة موضعية لهذا الحقل", "summary": "يونس بن بكير: غير معيّن" }, "id": "city:yunus", "illaRefs": [], "kind": "city", "label": "يونس بن بكير: غير معيّن", "matnRefs": [], "rendered": true, "requiresPinpoint": true, "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [], "riwayaRefs": [], "sourceRefs": [], "supportLevel": "unresolved", "target": { "field": "city", "nodeId": "yunus" }, "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": [] }, "city:yusuf": { "argumentRefs": [], "cardRefs": [], "citationRefs": [], "evidenceRefs": [], "icon": { "kindLabel": "مصر النقل", "meaning": "المصر المسجل ومرجعه؛ البيئة وحدها ليست جرحاً", "status": "missing", "statusLabel": "لم تسجل إحالة موضعية لهذا الحقل", "summary": "يوسف بن راشد: غير معيّن" }, "id": "city:yusuf", "illaRefs": [], "kind": "city", "label": "يوسف بن راشد: غير معيّن", "matnRefs": [], "rendered": true, "requiresPinpoint": true, "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [], "riwayaRefs": [], "sourceRefs": [], "supportLevel": "unresolved", "target": { "field": "city", "nodeId": "yusuf" }, "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": [] }, "edge:edge-abdallah_sharik-israil": { "argumentRefs": [], "cardRefs": [], "citationRefs": [ "cit-abdallah-israil", "cit-b5-report" ], "evidenceRefs": [ "cit-abdallah-israil", "cit-b5-report" ], "icon": { "kindLabel": "حلقة الرواية", "meaning": "صلة النقل بين طرفي السهم والروايات التي تحملها", "status": "documented", "statusLabel": "إحالة موضعية مقابلة", "summary": "عن عبد الله بن شريك" }, "id": "edge:edge-abdallah_sharik-israil", "illaRefs": [], "kind": "edge", "label": "عن عبد الله بن شريك", "matnRefs": [], "rendered": true, "requiresPinpoint": false, "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [ "cit-abdallah-israil", "cit-b5-report" ], "riwayaRefs": [ "riwaya-b5-5308" ], "sourceRefs": [ "source-bukhari-ghadir-two-routes-2019" ], "supportLevel": "exact", "target": { "edgeId": "edge-abdallah_sharik-israil", "from": "abdallah_sharik", "to": "israil" }, "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": [] }, "edge:edge-abu_said-sahm": { "argumentRefs": [], "cardRefs": [], "citationRefs": [ "cit-abu-said-sahm", "cit-b5-hukm", "cit-b5-report", "cit-b5-hukm-variant" ], "evidenceRefs": [ "cit-abu-said-sahm", "cit-b5-hukm", "cit-b5-report", "cit-b5-hukm-variant" ], "icon": { "kindLabel": "حلقة الرواية", "meaning": "صلة النقل بين طرفي السهم والروايات التي تحملها", "status": "documented", "statusLabel": "إحالة موضعية مقابلة", "summary": "سؤال سهم وجواب أبي سعيد" }, "id": "edge:edge-abu_said-sahm", "illaRefs": [ "illa-sahm-majhul" ], "kind": "edge", "label": "سؤال سهم وجواب أبي سعيد", "matnRefs": [], "rendered": true, "requiresPinpoint": false, "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [ "cit-abu-said-sahm", "cit-b5-hukm", "cit-b5-report", "cit-b5-hukm-variant" ], "riwayaRefs": [ "riwaya-b5-5308" ], "sourceRefs": [ "source-bukhari-ghadir-two-routes-2019" ], "supportLevel": "exact", "target": { "edgeId": "edge-abu_said-sahm", "from": "abu_said", "to": "sahm" }, "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": [] }, "edge:edge-ali_qadim-yusuf": { "argumentRefs": [], "cardRefs": [], "citationRefs": [ "cit-ali-yusuf", "cit-b5-report" ], "evidenceRefs": [ "cit-ali-yusuf", "cit-b5-report" ], "icon": { "kindLabel": "حلقة الرواية", "meaning": "صلة النقل بين طرفي السهم والروايات التي تحملها", "status": "documented", "statusLabel": "إحالة موضعية مقابلة", "summary": "حدثنا علي بن قادم" }, "id": "edge:edge-ali_qadim-yusuf", "illaRefs": [], "kind": "edge", "label": "حدثنا علي بن قادم", "matnRefs": [], "rendered": true, "requiresPinpoint": false, "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [ "cit-ali-yusuf", "cit-b5-report" ], "riwayaRefs": [ "riwaya-b5-5308" ], "sourceRefs": [ "source-bukhari-ghadir-two-routes-2019" ], "supportLevel": "exact", "target": { "edgeId": "edge-ali_qadim-yusuf", "from": "ali_qadim", "to": "yusuf" }, "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": [] }, "edge:edge-ismail-yunus": { "argumentRefs": [], "cardRefs": [], "citationRefs": [ "cit-ismail-yunus", "cit-b2-report" ], "evidenceRefs": [ "cit-ismail-yunus", "cit-b2-report" ], "icon": { "kindLabel": "حلقة الرواية", "meaning": "صلة النقل بين طرفي السهم والروايات التي تحملها", "status": "documented", "statusLabel": "إحالة موضعية مقابلة", "summary": "سمع إسماعيل" }, "id": "edge:edge-ismail-yunus", "illaRefs": [], "kind": "edge", "label": "سمع إسماعيل", "matnRefs": [], "rendered": true, "requiresPinpoint": false, "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [ "cit-ismail-yunus", "cit-b2-report" ], "riwayaRefs": [ "riwaya-b2-1187" ], "sourceRefs": [ "source-bukhari-ghadir-two-routes-2019" ], "supportLevel": "exact", "target": { "edgeId": "edge-ismail-yunus", "from": "ismail", "to": "yunus" }, "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": [] }, "edge:edge-israil-ali_qadim": { "argumentRefs": [], "cardRefs": [], "citationRefs": [ "cit-israil-ali", "cit-b5-report" ], "evidenceRefs": [ "cit-israil-ali", "cit-b5-report" ], "icon": { "kindLabel": "حلقة الرواية", "meaning": "صلة النقل بين طرفي السهم والروايات التي تحملها", "status": "documented", "statusLabel": "إحالة موضعية مقابلة", "summary": "أخبرنا إسرائيل" }, "id": "edge:edge-israil-ali_qadim", "illaRefs": [], "kind": "edge", "label": "أخبرنا إسرائيل", "matnRefs": [], "rendered": true, "requiresPinpoint": false, "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [ "cit-israil-ali", "cit-b5-report" ], "riwayaRefs": [ "riwaya-b5-5308" ], "sourceRefs": [ "source-bukhari-ghadir-two-routes-2019" ], "supportLevel": "exact", "target": { "edgeId": "edge-israil-ali_qadim", "from": "israil", "to": "ali_qadim" }, "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": [] }, "edge:edge-jamil-ismail": { "argumentRefs": [], "cardRefs": [], "citationRefs": [ "cit-jamil-ismail", "cit-b2-report" ], "evidenceRefs": [ "cit-jamil-ismail", "cit-b2-report" ], "icon": { "kindLabel": "حلقة الرواية", "meaning": "صلة النقل بين طرفي السهم والروايات التي تحملها", "status": "documented", "statusLabel": "إحالة موضعية مقابلة", "summary": "عن جميل بن عامر" }, "id": "edge:edge-jamil-ismail", "illaRefs": [], "kind": "edge", "label": "عن جميل بن عامر", "matnRefs": [], "rendered": true, "requiresPinpoint": false, "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [ "cit-jamil-ismail", "cit-b2-report" ], "riwayaRefs": [ "riwaya-b2-1187" ], "sourceRefs": [ "source-bukhari-ghadir-two-routes-2019" ], "supportLevel": "exact", "target": { "edgeId": "edge-jamil-ismail", "from": "jamil", "to": "ismail" }, "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": [] }, "edge:edge-nabi-abu_said": { "argumentRefs": [], "cardRefs": [], "citationRefs": [ "cit-nabi-abu-said", "cit-b5-report" ], "evidenceRefs": [ "cit-nabi-abu-said", "cit-b5-report" ], "icon": { "kindLabel": "حلقة الرواية", "meaning": "صلة النقل بين طرفي السهم والروايات التي تحملها", "status": "documented", "statusLabel": "إحالة موضعية مقابلة", "summary": "من «رسول الله ﷺ» إلى «أبو سعيد الخدري»" }, "id": "edge:edge-nabi-abu_said", "illaRefs": [], "kind": "edge", "label": "من «رسول الله ﷺ» إلى «أبو سعيد الخدري»", "matnRefs": [], "rendered": true, "requiresPinpoint": false, "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [ "cit-nabi-abu-said", "cit-b5-report" ], "riwayaRefs": [ "riwaya-b5-5308" ], "sourceRefs": [ "source-bukhari-ghadir-two-routes-2019" ], "supportLevel": "exact", "target": { "edgeId": "edge-nabi-abu_said", "from": "nabi", "to": "abu_said" }, "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": [] }, "edge:edge-nabi-salim_father": { "argumentRefs": [], "cardRefs": [], "citationRefs": [ "cit-nabi-father", "cit-b2-report" ], "evidenceRefs": [ "cit-nabi-father", "cit-b2-report" ], "icon": { "kindLabel": "حلقة الرواية", "meaning": "صلة النقل بين طرفي السهم والروايات التي تحملها", "status": "documented", "statusLabel": "إحالة موضعية مقابلة", "summary": "من «رسول الله ﷺ» إلى «والد سالم»" }, "id": "edge:edge-nabi-salim_father", "illaRefs": [], "kind": "edge", "label": "من «رسول الله ﷺ» إلى «والد سالم»", "matnRefs": [], "rendered": true, "requiresPinpoint": false, "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [ "cit-nabi-father", "cit-b2-report" ], "riwayaRefs": [ "riwaya-b2-1187" ], "sourceRefs": [ "source-bukhari-ghadir-two-routes-2019" ], "supportLevel": "exact", "target": { "edgeId": "edge-nabi-salim_father", "from": "nabi", "to": "salim_father" }, "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": [] }, "edge:edge-sahm-abdallah_sharik": { "argumentRefs": [], "cardRefs": [], "citationRefs": [ "cit-sahm-abdallah", "cit-b5-report" ], "evidenceRefs": [ "cit-sahm-abdallah", "cit-b5-report" ], "icon": { "kindLabel": "حلقة الرواية", "meaning": "صلة النقل بين طرفي السهم والروايات التي تحملها", "status": "documented", "statusLabel": "إحالة موضعية مقابلة", "summary": "عن سهم بن حصين" }, "id": "edge:edge-sahm-abdallah_sharik", "illaRefs": [], "kind": "edge", "label": "عن سهم بن حصين", "matnRefs": [], "rendered": true, "requiresPinpoint": false, "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [ "cit-sahm-abdallah", "cit-b5-report" ], "riwayaRefs": [ "riwaya-b5-5308" ], "sourceRefs": [ "source-bukhari-ghadir-two-routes-2019" ], "supportLevel": "exact", "target": { "edgeId": "edge-sahm-abdallah_sharik", "from": "sahm", "to": "abdallah_sharik" }, "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": [] }, "edge:edge-salim-jamil": { "argumentRefs": [], "cardRefs": [], "citationRefs": [ "cit-salim-jamil", "cit-b2-report" ], "evidenceRefs": [ "cit-salim-jamil", "cit-b2-report" ], "icon": { "kindLabel": "حلقة الرواية", "meaning": "صلة النقل بين طرفي السهم والروايات التي تحملها", "status": "documented", "statusLabel": "إحالة موضعية مقابلة", "summary": "أن سالماً حدثه" }, "id": "edge:edge-salim-jamil", "illaRefs": [], "kind": "edge", "label": "أن سالماً حدثه", "matnRefs": [], "rendered": true, "requiresPinpoint": false, "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [ "cit-salim-jamil", "cit-b2-report" ], "riwayaRefs": [ "riwaya-b2-1187" ], "sourceRefs": [ "source-bukhari-ghadir-two-routes-2019" ], "supportLevel": "exact", "target": { "edgeId": "edge-salim-jamil", "from": "salim", "to": "jamil" }, "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": [] }, "edge:edge-salim_father-salim": { "argumentRefs": [], "cardRefs": [], "citationRefs": [ "cit-father-salim", "cit-b2-variants", "cit-b2-report" ], "evidenceRefs": [ "cit-father-salim", "cit-b2-variants", "cit-b2-report" ], "icon": { "kindLabel": "حلقة الرواية", "meaning": "صلة النقل بين طرفي السهم والروايات التي تحملها", "status": "documented", "statusLabel": "إحالة موضعية مقابلة", "summary": "سمع أباه" }, "id": "edge:edge-salim_father-salim", "illaRefs": [ "illa-salim-variant" ], "kind": "edge", "label": "سمع أباه", "matnRefs": [], "rendered": true, "requiresPinpoint": false, "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [ "cit-father-salim", "cit-b2-variants", "cit-b2-report" ], "riwayaRefs": [ "riwaya-b2-1187" ], "sourceRefs": [ "source-bukhari-ghadir-two-routes-2019" ], "supportLevel": "exact", "target": { "edgeId": "edge-salim_father-salim", "from": "salim_father", "to": "salim" }, "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": [] }, "edge:edge-ubayd-book_b2": { "argumentRefs": [], "cardRefs": [], "citationRefs": [ "cit-ubayd-bukhari", "cit-b2-hukm", "cit-b2-report", "cit-b2-hukm-variant" ], "evidenceRefs": [ "cit-ubayd-bukhari", "cit-b2-hukm", "cit-b2-report", "cit-b2-hukm-variant" ], "icon": { "kindLabel": "حلقة الرواية", "meaning": "صلة النقل بين طرفي السهم والروايات التي تحملها", "status": "documented", "statusLabel": "إحالة موضعية مقابلة", "summary": "قال لي عبيد؛ الإسناد محل نظر" }, "id": "edge:edge-ubayd-book_b2", "illaRefs": [ "illa-b2-nazar" ], "kind": "edge", "label": "قال لي عبيد؛ الإسناد محل نظر", "matnRefs": [], "rendered": true, "requiresPinpoint": false, "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [ "cit-ubayd-bukhari", "cit-b2-hukm", "cit-b2-report", "cit-b2-hukm-variant" ], "riwayaRefs": [ "riwaya-b2-1187" ], "sourceRefs": [ "source-bukhari-ghadir-two-routes-2019" ], "supportLevel": "exact", "target": { "edgeId": "edge-ubayd-book_b2", "from": "ubayd", "to": "book_b2" }, "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": [] }, "edge:edge-yunus-ubayd": { "argumentRefs": [], "cardRefs": [], "citationRefs": [ "cit-yunus-ubayd", "cit-b2-report" ], "evidenceRefs": [ "cit-yunus-ubayd", "cit-b2-report" ], "icon": { "kindLabel": "حلقة الرواية", "meaning": "صلة النقل بين طرفي السهم والروايات التي تحملها", "status": "documented", "statusLabel": "إحالة موضعية مقابلة", "summary": "حدثنا يونس" }, "id": "edge:edge-yunus-ubayd", "illaRefs": [], "kind": "edge", "label": "حدثنا يونس", "matnRefs": [], "rendered": true, "requiresPinpoint": false, "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [ "cit-yunus-ubayd", "cit-b2-report" ], "riwayaRefs": [ "riwaya-b2-1187" ], "sourceRefs": [ "source-bukhari-ghadir-two-routes-2019" ], "supportLevel": "exact", "target": { "edgeId": "edge-yunus-ubayd", "from": "yunus", "to": "ubayd" }, "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": [] }, "edge:edge-yusuf-book_b5": { "argumentRefs": [], "cardRefs": [], "citationRefs": [ "cit-yusuf-bukhari", "cit-b5-report" ], "evidenceRefs": [ "cit-yusuf-bukhari", "cit-b5-report" ], "icon": { "kindLabel": "حلقة الرواية", "meaning": "صلة النقل بين طرفي السهم والروايات التي تحملها", "status": "documented", "statusLabel": "إحالة موضعية مقابلة", "summary": "حدثني يوسف بن راشد" }, "id": "edge:edge-yusuf-book_b5", "illaRefs": [], "kind": "edge", "label": "حدثني يوسف بن راشد", "matnRefs": [], "rendered": true, "requiresPinpoint": false, "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [ "cit-yusuf-bukhari", "cit-b5-report" ], "riwayaRefs": [ "riwaya-b5-5308" ], "sourceRefs": [ "source-bukhari-ghadir-two-routes-2019" ], "supportLevel": "exact", "target": { "edgeId": "edge-yusuf-book_b5", "from": "yusuf", "to": "book_b5" }, "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": [] }, "hukm:sahm": { "argumentRefs": [], "cardRefs": [], "citationRefs": [ "cit-b5-hukm" ], "evidenceRefs": [ "cit-b5-hukm" ], "icon": { "kindLabel": "حكم الراوي", "meaning": "الحكم المنسوب إلى ناقد؛ لا يدل لون الأيقونة على رتبة الراوي", "status": "documented", "statusLabel": "إحالة موضعية مقابلة", "summary": "سهم بن حصين الأسدي: مجهول" }, "id": "hukm:sahm", "illaRefs": [], "kind": "hukm", "label": "سهم بن حصين الأسدي: مجهول", "matnRefs": [], "rendered": true, "requiresPinpoint": false, "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [ "cit-b5-hukm" ], "riwayaRefs": [], "sourceRefs": [ "source-bukhari-ghadir-two-routes-2019" ], "supportLevel": "exact", "target": { "field": "hukm", "nodeId": "sahm" }, "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": [] }, "illa:illa-b2-nazar": { "argumentRefs": [], "cardRefs": [], "citationRefs": [ "cit-b2-hukm", "cit-b2-hukm-variant" ], "evidenceRefs": [ "cit-b2-hukm", "cit-b2-hukm-variant" ], "icon": { "kindLabel": "مسألة نقدية", "meaning": "العلة أو الاعتراض بنطاقه ومصدره", "status": "documented", "statusLabel": "إحالة موضعية مقابلة", "summary": "قال البخاري: في إسناده نظر. وفي قراءة غ: لم يتابع عن سالم في هذا الحديث. وسم هذا الموضع لا يتهم عبيداً أو بقية رجال الطريق جميعاً." }, "id": "illa:illa-b2-nazar", "illaRefs": [ "illa-b2-nazar" ], "kind": "illa", "label": "نقد الإسناد ككل", "matnRefs": [], "rendered": true, "requiresPinpoint": false, "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [ "cit-b2-hukm", "cit-b2-hukm-variant" ], "riwayaRefs": [ "riwaya-b2-1187" ], "sourceRefs": [ "source-bukhari-ghadir-two-routes-2019" ], "supportLevel": "exact", "target": { "id": "edge-ubayd-book_b2", "kind": "edge" }, "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": [] }, "illa:illa-sahm-majhul": { "argumentRefs": [], "cardRefs": [], "citationRefs": [ "cit-b5-hukm", "cit-b5-hukm-variant" ], "evidenceRefs": [ "cit-b5-hukm", "cit-b5-hukm-variant" ], "icon": { "kindLabel": "مسألة نقدية", "meaning": "العلة أو الاعتراض بنطاقه ومصدره", "status": "documented", "statusLabel": "إحالة موضعية مقابلة", "summary": "وسهم مجهول، ولا يدرى من هو. لا ينقل هذا الحكم إلى بقية الرجال. في ق تنقص من هو، وفي ث يغيب التعقيب كله." }, "id": "illa:illa-sahm-majhul", "illaRefs": [ "illa-sahm-majhul" ], "kind": "illa", "label": "البخاري يجهّل سهماً", "matnRefs": [], "rendered": true, "requiresPinpoint": false, "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [ "cit-b5-hukm", "cit-b5-hukm-variant" ], "riwayaRefs": [ "riwaya-b5-5308" ], "sourceRefs": [ "source-bukhari-ghadir-two-routes-2019" ], "supportLevel": "exact", "target": { "id": "sahm", "kind": "node" }, "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": [] }, "illa:illa-salim-variant": { "argumentRefs": [], "cardRefs": [], "citationRefs": [ "cit-b2-variants" ], "evidenceRefs": [ "cit-b2-variants" ], "icon": { "kindLabel": "مسألة نقدية", "meaning": "العلة أو الاعتراض بنطاقه ومصدره", "status": "documented", "statusLabel": "إحالة موضعية مقابلة", "summary": "المتن: سمع أباه؛ وفي ك وش وق: سمع من. اختلاف نسخي يحفظ، ولا يعد طريقاً مستقلاً أو انقطاعاً ثابتاً." }, "id": "illa:illa-salim-variant", "illaRefs": [ "illa-salim-variant" ], "kind": "illa", "label": "اختلاف تسمية آخر الطريق", "matnRefs": [], "rendered": true, "requiresPinpoint": false, "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [ "cit-b2-variants" ], "riwayaRefs": [ "riwaya-b2-1187" ], "sourceRefs": [ "source-bukhari-ghadir-two-routes-2019" ], "supportLevel": "exact", "target": { "id": "edge-salim_father-salim", "kind": "edge" }, "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": [] }, "matn:matn-b2": { "argumentRefs": [], "cardRefs": [], "citationRefs": [ "cit-b2-matn" ], "evidenceRefs": [ "cit-b2-matn" ], "icon": { "kindLabel": "لفظ المتن", "meaning": "النص أو الزيادة بلفظها وموضعها", "status": "documented", "statusLabel": "إحالة موضعية مقابلة", "summary": "سمع النبي ﷺ يقول يوم غدير خم: «من كنت مولاه فعلي مولاه»." }, "id": "matn:matn-b2", "illaRefs": [], "kind": "matn", "label": "الموالاة ونسبتها إلى يوم غدير خم", "matnRefs": [ "matn-b2" ], "rendered": true, "requiresPinpoint": false, "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [ "cit-b2-matn" ], "riwayaRefs": [ "riwaya-b2-1187" ], "sourceRefs": [ "source-bukhari-ghadir-two-routes-2019" ], "supportLevel": "exact", "target": { "id": "book_b2", "kind": "node" }, "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": [] }, "matn:matn-b5": { "argumentRefs": [], "cardRefs": [], "citationRefs": [ "cit-b5-report", "cit-b5-matn", "cit-b5-context" ], "evidenceRefs": [ "cit-b5-report", "cit-b5-matn", "cit-b5-context" ], "icon": { "kindLabel": "لفظ المتن", "meaning": "النص أو الزيادة بلفظها وموضعها", "status": "documented", "statusLabel": "إحالة موضعية مقابلة", "summary": "قدمت مكة أنا وعبد الله بن علقمة — قال ابن شريك: وكان ابن علقمة سباباً لعلي — فقلت: هل لك في هذا، يعني أبا سعيد الخدري؟ فقلت: هل سمعت لعلي منقبة؟ قال: نعم، فإذا حدثتك فسل المهاجرين والأنصار وقريشاً؛ قام النبي ﷺ يوم غدير خم، فأبلغ، فقال: «ألست أولى بالمؤمنين من أنفسهم؟ ادن يا علي»، فدنا، فرفع يده، ورفع النبي ﷺ يده، حتى نظرت إلى بياض إبطيه، فقال: «من كنت مولاه فعلي مولاه». وسمعته أذناي، قال ابن شريك: فقدم عبد الله بن علقمة وسهم، فلما صلينا الفجر، قام ابن علقمة، فقال: أتوب إلى الله من سب علي." }, "id": "matn:matn-b5", "illaRefs": [], "kind": "matn", "label": "رواية أبي سعيد وقصة ابن علقمة", "matnRefs": [ "matn-b5" ], "rendered": true, "requiresPinpoint": false, "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [ "cit-b5-report", "cit-b5-matn", "cit-b5-context" ], "riwayaRefs": [ "riwaya-b5-5308" ], "sourceRefs": [ "source-bukhari-ghadir-two-routes-2019" ], "supportLevel": "exact", "target": { "id": "book_b5", "kind": "node" }, "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": [] }, "node:abdallah_sharik": { "argumentRefs": [], "cardRefs": [], "citationRefs": [ "cit-b5-report" ], "evidenceRefs": [ "cit-b5-report" ], "icon": { "kindLabel": "الراوي أو العقدة", "meaning": "تعريف العنصر ونص بياناته", "status": "documented", "statusLabel": "إحالة موضعية مقابلة", "summary": "عبد الله بن شريك" }, "id": "node:abdallah_sharik", "illaRefs": [], "kind": "node", "label": "عبد الله بن شريك", "matnRefs": [], "rendered": true, "requiresPinpoint": false, "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [ "cit-b5-report" ], "riwayaRefs": [], "sourceRefs": [ "source-bukhari-ghadir-two-routes-2019" ], "supportLevel": "exact", "target": { "field": "identity", "nodeId": "abdallah_sharik" }, "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": [] }, "node:abu_said": { "argumentRefs": [], "cardRefs": [], "citationRefs": [ "cit-b5-report" ], "evidenceRefs": [ "cit-b5-report" ], "icon": { "kindLabel": "الراوي أو العقدة", "meaning": "تعريف العنصر ونص بياناته", "status": "documented", "statusLabel": "إحالة موضعية مقابلة", "summary": "أبو سعيد الخدري" }, "id": "node:abu_said", "illaRefs": [], "kind": "node", "label": "أبو سعيد الخدري", "matnRefs": [], "rendered": true, "requiresPinpoint": false, "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [ "cit-b5-report" ], "riwayaRefs": [], "sourceRefs": [ "source-bukhari-ghadir-two-routes-2019" ], "supportLevel": "exact", "target": { "field": "identity", "nodeId": "abu_said" }, "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": [] }, "node:ali_qadim": { "argumentRefs": [], "cardRefs": [], "citationRefs": [ "cit-b5-report" ], "evidenceRefs": [ "cit-b5-report" ], "icon": { "kindLabel": "الراوي أو العقدة", "meaning": "تعريف العنصر ونص بياناته", "status": "documented", "statusLabel": "إحالة موضعية مقابلة", "summary": "علي بن قادم الخزاعي" }, "id": "node:ali_qadim", "illaRefs": [], "kind": "node", "label": "علي بن قادم الخزاعي", "matnRefs": [], "rendered": true, "requiresPinpoint": false, "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [ "cit-b5-report" ], "riwayaRefs": [], "sourceRefs": [ "source-bukhari-ghadir-two-routes-2019" ], "supportLevel": "exact", "target": { "field": "identity", "nodeId": "ali_qadim" }, "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": [] }, "node:book_b2": { "argumentRefs": [], "cardRefs": [], "citationRefs": [ "cit-b2-report", "cit-b2-hukm" ], "evidenceRefs": [ "cit-b2-report", "cit-b2-hukm" ], "icon": { "kindLabel": "الراوي أو العقدة", "meaning": "تعريف العنصر ونص بياناته", "status": "documented", "statusLabel": "إحالة موضعية مقابلة", "summary": "البخاري: ج2، ص92، ت1187 — «في إسناده نظر»" }, "id": "node:book_b2", "illaRefs": [], "kind": "node", "label": "البخاري: ج2، ص92، ت1187", "matnRefs": [], "rendered": true, "requiresPinpoint": false, "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [ "cit-b2-report", "cit-b2-hukm" ], "riwayaRefs": [], "sourceRefs": [ "source-bukhari-ghadir-two-routes-2019" ], "supportLevel": "exact", "target": { "field": "identity", "nodeId": "book_b2" }, "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": [] }, "node:book_b5": { "argumentRefs": [], "cardRefs": [], "citationRefs": [ "cit-b5-report", "cit-b5-hukm" ], "evidenceRefs": [ "cit-b5-report", "cit-b5-hukm" ], "icon": { "kindLabel": "الراوي أو العقدة", "meaning": "تعريف العنصر ونص بياناته", "status": "documented", "statusLabel": "إحالة موضعية مقابلة", "summary": "البخاري: ج5، ص297–298 — ت5308: «وسهم مجهول»" }, "id": "node:book_b5", "illaRefs": [], "kind": "node", "label": "البخاري: ج5، ص297–298", "matnRefs": [], "rendered": true, "requiresPinpoint": false, "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [ "cit-b5-report", "cit-b5-hukm" ], "riwayaRefs": [], "sourceRefs": [ "source-bukhari-ghadir-two-routes-2019" ], "supportLevel": "exact", "target": { "field": "identity", "nodeId": "book_b5" }, "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": [] }, "node:ismail": { "argumentRefs": [], "cardRefs": [], "citationRefs": [ "cit-b2-names" ], "evidenceRefs": [ "cit-b2-names" ], "icon": { "kindLabel": "الراوي أو العقدة", "meaning": "تعريف العنصر ونص بياناته", "status": "documented", "statusLabel": "إحالة موضعية مقابلة", "summary": "إسماعيل بن نشيط العامري" }, "id": "node:ismail", "illaRefs": [], "kind": "node", "label": "إسماعيل بن نشيط العامري", "matnRefs": [], "rendered": true, "requiresPinpoint": false, "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [ "cit-b2-names" ], "riwayaRefs": [], "sourceRefs": [ "source-bukhari-ghadir-two-routes-2019" ], "supportLevel": "exact", "target": { "field": "identity", "nodeId": "ismail" }, "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": [] }, "node:israil": { "argumentRefs": [], "cardRefs": [], "citationRefs": [ "cit-b5-report" ], "evidenceRefs": [ "cit-b5-report" ], "icon": { "kindLabel": "الراوي أو العقدة", "meaning": "تعريف العنصر ونص بياناته", "status": "documented", "statusLabel": "إحالة موضعية مقابلة", "summary": "إسرائيل" }, "id": "node:israil", "illaRefs": [], "kind": "node", "label": "إسرائيل", "matnRefs": [], "rendered": true, "requiresPinpoint": false, "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [ "cit-b5-report" ], "riwayaRefs": [], "sourceRefs": [ "source-bukhari-ghadir-two-routes-2019" ], "supportLevel": "exact", "target": { "field": "identity", "nodeId": "israil" }, "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": [] }, "node:jamil": { "argumentRefs": [], "cardRefs": [], "citationRefs": [ "cit-b2-report" ], "evidenceRefs": [ "cit-b2-report" ], "icon": { "kindLabel": "الراوي أو العقدة", "meaning": "تعريف العنصر ونص بياناته", "status": "documented", "statusLabel": "إحالة موضعية مقابلة", "summary": "جميل بن عامر" }, "id": "node:jamil", "illaRefs": [], "kind": "node", "label": "جميل بن عامر", "matnRefs": [], "rendered": true, "requiresPinpoint": false, "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [ "cit-b2-report" ], "riwayaRefs": [], "sourceRefs": [ "source-bukhari-ghadir-two-routes-2019" ], "supportLevel": "exact", "target": { "field": "identity", "nodeId": "jamil" }, "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": [] }, "node:nabi": { "argumentRefs": [], "cardRefs": [], "citationRefs": [ "cit-b2-matn" ], "evidenceRefs": [ "cit-b2-matn" ], "icon": { "kindLabel": "الراوي أو العقدة", "meaning": "تعريف العنصر ونص بياناته", "status": "documented", "statusLabel": "إحالة موضعية مقابلة", "summary": "رسول الله ﷺ" }, "id": "node:nabi", "illaRefs": [], "kind": "node", "label": "رسول الله ﷺ", "matnRefs": [], "rendered": true, "requiresPinpoint": false, "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [ "cit-b2-matn" ], "riwayaRefs": [], "sourceRefs": [ "source-bukhari-ghadir-two-routes-2019" ], "supportLevel": "exact", "target": { "field": "identity", "nodeId": "nabi" }, "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": [] }, "node:sahm": { "argumentRefs": [], "cardRefs": [], "citationRefs": [ "cit-b5-report", "cit-b5-hukm", "cit-b5-hukm-variant" ], "evidenceRefs": [ "cit-b5-report", "cit-b5-hukm", "cit-b5-hukm-variant" ], "icon": { "kindLabel": "الراوي أو العقدة", "meaning": "تعريف العنصر ونص بياناته", "status": "documented", "statusLabel": "إحالة موضعية مقابلة", "summary": "سهم بن حصين الأسدي — البخاري: «وسهم مجهول»" }, "id": "node:sahm", "illaRefs": [ "illa-sahm-majhul" ], "kind": "node", "label": "سهم بن حصين الأسدي", "matnRefs": [], "rendered": true, "requiresPinpoint": false, "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [ "cit-b5-report", "cit-b5-hukm", "cit-b5-hukm-variant" ], "riwayaRefs": [], "sourceRefs": [ "source-bukhari-ghadir-two-routes-2019" ], "supportLevel": "exact", "target": { "field": "identity", "nodeId": "sahm" }, "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": [] }, "node:salim": { "argumentRefs": [], "cardRefs": [], "citationRefs": [ "cit-b2-report" ], "evidenceRefs": [ "cit-b2-report" ], "icon": { "kindLabel": "الراوي أو العقدة", "meaning": "تعريف العنصر ونص بياناته", "status": "documented", "statusLabel": "إحالة موضعية مقابلة", "summary": "سالم" }, "id": "node:salim", "illaRefs": [], "kind": "node", "label": "سالم", "matnRefs": [], "rendered": true, "requiresPinpoint": false, "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [ "cit-b2-report" ], "riwayaRefs": [], "sourceRefs": [ "source-bukhari-ghadir-two-routes-2019" ], "supportLevel": "exact", "target": { "field": "identity", "nodeId": "salim" }, "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": [] }, "node:salim_father": { "argumentRefs": [], "cardRefs": [], "citationRefs": [ "cit-b2-report", "cit-b2-variants" ], "evidenceRefs": [ "cit-b2-report", "cit-b2-variants" ], "icon": { "kindLabel": "الراوي أو العقدة", "meaning": "تعريف العنصر ونص بياناته", "status": "documented", "statusLabel": "إحالة موضعية مقابلة", "summary": "والد سالم — «سمع أباه»؛ وفي نسخ «سمع من»" }, "id": "node:salim_father", "illaRefs": [], "kind": "node", "label": "والد سالم", "matnRefs": [], "rendered": true, "requiresPinpoint": false, "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [ "cit-b2-report", "cit-b2-variants" ], "riwayaRefs": [], "sourceRefs": [ "source-bukhari-ghadir-two-routes-2019" ], "supportLevel": "exact", "target": { "field": "identity", "nodeId": "salim_father" }, "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": [] }, "node:ubayd": { "argumentRefs": [], "cardRefs": [], "citationRefs": [ "cit-b2-report" ], "evidenceRefs": [ "cit-b2-report" ], "icon": { "kindLabel": "الراوي أو العقدة", "meaning": "تعريف العنصر ونص بياناته", "status": "documented", "statusLabel": "إحالة موضعية مقابلة", "summary": "عبيد" }, "id": "node:ubayd", "illaRefs": [], "kind": "node", "label": "عبيد", "matnRefs": [], "rendered": true, "requiresPinpoint": false, "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [ "cit-b2-report" ], "riwayaRefs": [], "sourceRefs": [ "source-bukhari-ghadir-two-routes-2019" ], "supportLevel": "exact", "target": { "field": "identity", "nodeId": "ubayd" }, "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": [] }, "node:yunus": { "argumentRefs": [], "cardRefs": [], "citationRefs": [ "cit-b2-names" ], "evidenceRefs": [ "cit-b2-names" ], "icon": { "kindLabel": "الراوي أو العقدة", "meaning": "تعريف العنصر ونص بياناته", "status": "documented", "statusLabel": "إحالة موضعية مقابلة", "summary": "يونس بن بكير" }, "id": "node:yunus", "illaRefs": [], "kind": "node", "label": "يونس بن بكير", "matnRefs": [], "rendered": true, "requiresPinpoint": false, "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [ "cit-b2-names" ], "riwayaRefs": [], "sourceRefs": [ "source-bukhari-ghadir-two-routes-2019" ], "supportLevel": "exact", "target": { "field": "identity", "nodeId": "yunus" }, "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": [] }, "node:yusuf": { "argumentRefs": [], "cardRefs": [], "citationRefs": [ "cit-b5-report" ], "evidenceRefs": [ "cit-b5-report" ], "icon": { "kindLabel": "الراوي أو العقدة", "meaning": "تعريف العنصر ونص بياناته", "status": "documented", "statusLabel": "إحالة موضعية مقابلة", "summary": "يوسف بن راشد" }, "id": "node:yusuf", "illaRefs": [], "kind": "node", "label": "يوسف بن راشد", "matnRefs": [], "rendered": true, "requiresPinpoint": false, "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [ "cit-b5-report" ], "riwayaRefs": [], "sourceRefs": [ "source-bukhari-ghadir-two-routes-2019" ], "supportLevel": "exact", "target": { "field": "identity", "nodeId": "yusuf" }, "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": [] }, "verdict": { "argumentRefs": [ "arg-route-scope" ], "cardRefs": [], "citationRefs": [ "cit-b2-hukm", "cit-b5-hukm", "cit-b2-hukm-variant" ], "evidenceRefs": [ "cit-b2-hukm", "cit-b5-hukm", "cit-b2-hukm-variant" ], "icon": { "kindLabel": "خلاصة الدراسة", "meaning": "النتيجة المنسوبة إلى الدراسة وحدود الاستدلال", "status": "documented", "statusLabel": "إحالة موضعية مقابلة", "summary": "ثبت نص نقدي للبخاري في هذين الموضعين؛ الحكم المعروض متصل بإسناد إسماعيل وبجهالة سهم، ولا يعم جميع طرق جملة الموالاة. — الخريطة عينة مقصودة لطريقين؛ لا استقصاء للطرق ولا تصحيح لهذين الإسنادين." }, "id": "verdict", "illaRefs": [], "kind": "verdict", "label": "الرسم لا يصحح السندين؛ نقدهما لا يحكم سائر الطرق", "matnRefs": [], "rendered": true, "requiresPinpoint": false, "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [ "cit-b2-hukm", "cit-b5-hukm", "cit-b2-hukm-variant" ], "riwayaRefs": [], "sourceRefs": [ "source-bukhari-ghadir-two-routes-2019" ], "supportLevel": "exact", "target": { "field": "verdict" }, "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": [] } }, "order": [ "node:nabi", "node:salim_father", "city:salim_father", "node:abu_said", "node:salim", "city:salim", "node:sahm", "hukm:sahm", "city:sahm", "node:jamil", "city:jamil", "node:abdallah_sharik", "city:abdallah_sharik", "node:ismail", "city:ismail", "node:israil", "city:israil", "node:yunus", "city:yunus", "node:ali_qadim", "city:ali_qadim", "node:ubayd", "city:ubayd", "node:yusuf", "city:yusuf", "node:book_b2", "node:book_b5", "edge:edge-nabi-salim_father", "edge:edge-salim_father-salim", "edge:edge-salim-jamil", "edge:edge-jamil-ismail", "edge:edge-ismail-yunus", "edge:edge-yunus-ubayd", "edge:edge-ubayd-book_b2", "edge:edge-nabi-abu_said", "edge:edge-abu_said-sahm", "edge:edge-sahm-abdallah_sharik", "edge:edge-abdallah_sharik-israil", "edge:edge-israil-ali_qadim", "edge:edge-ali_qadim-yusuf", "edge:edge-yusuf-book_b5", "illa:illa-b2-nazar", "illa:illa-salim-variant", "illa:illa-sahm-majhul", "matn:matn-b2", "matn:matn-b5", "verdict", "argument:arg-route-scope", "argument:arg-story-level" ] }, "map": { "chapter": "02_manuscript/bab_04_factory_riwaya/13b3_hadith_al_ghadir_min_al_nawat_ila_al_sakk_al_siyasi.md", "dependencyHash": "3d079b591c2072f9", "id": "hadith_ghadir_bukhari_two_routes", "ref": "isnad:hadith_ghadir_bukhari_two_routes@v1", "sourceFile": "08_assets/isnad/hadith_ghadir_bukhari_two_routes.json", "sourceHash": "eecad41818e0e206", "version": 1 }, "matnVariants": [ { "citationRefs": [ "cit-b2-matn" ], "evidenceRefs": [ "cit-b2-matn" ], "id": "matn-b2", "label": "الموالاة ونسبتها إلى يوم غدير خم", "riwayaRefs": [ "riwaya-b2-1187" ], "role": "nawa", "subject": { "id": "book_b2", "kind": "node" }, "text": "سمع النبي ﷺ يقول يوم غدير خم: «من كنت مولاه فعلي مولاه»." }, { "citationRefs": [ "cit-b5-report", "cit-b5-matn", "cit-b5-context" ], "evidenceRefs": [ "cit-b5-report", "cit-b5-matn", "cit-b5-context" ], "id": "matn-b5", "label": "رواية أبي سعيد وقصة ابن علقمة", "riwayaRefs": [ "riwaya-b5-5308" ], "role": "context", "subject": { "id": "book_b5", "kind": "node" }, "text": "قدمت مكة أنا وعبد الله بن علقمة — قال ابن شريك: وكان ابن علقمة سباباً لعلي — فقلت: هل لك في هذا، يعني أبا سعيد الخدري؟ فقلت: هل سمعت لعلي منقبة؟ قال: نعم، فإذا حدثتك فسل المهاجرين والأنصار وقريشاً؛ قام النبي ﷺ يوم غدير خم، فأبلغ، فقال: «ألست أولى بالمؤمنين من أنفسهم؟ ادن يا علي»، فدنا، فرفع يده، ورفع النبي ﷺ يده، حتى نظرت إلى بياض إبطيه، فقال: «من كنت مولاه فعلي مولاه». وسمعته أذناي، قال ابن شريك: فقدم عبد الله بن علقمة وسهم، فلما صلينا الفجر، قام ابن علقمة، فقال: أتوب إلى الله من سب علي." } ], "narrators": [ { "card": null, "city": null, "coverage": { "applicableFields": 1, "exactFields": 1, "status": "complete", "unresolvedFields": 0 }, "death": null, "evidenceRefs": { "identity": [ "cit-b2-matn" ] }, "fieldCoverage": { "card": { "cardRefs": [], "citationRefs": [], "evidenceRefs": [], "requiresPinpoint": false, "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [], "sourceRefs": [], "state": "not_applicable", "supportLevel": null, "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": [] }, "city": { "cardRefs": [], "citationRefs": [], "evidenceRefs": [], "requiresPinpoint": false, "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [], "sourceRefs": [], "state": "not_applicable", "supportLevel": null, "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": [] }, "death": { "cardRefs": [], "citationRefs": [], "evidenceRefs": [], "requiresPinpoint": false, "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [], "sourceRefs": [], "state": "not_applicable", "supportLevel": null, "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": [] }, "flags": { "cardRefs": [], "citationRefs": [], "evidenceRefs": [], "items": {}, "requiresPinpoint": false, "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [], "sourceRefs": [], "state": "not_applicable", "supportLevel": null, "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": [] }, "hukm": { "cardRefs": [], "citationRefs": [], "evidenceRefs": [], "requiresPinpoint": false, "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [], "sourceRefs": [], "state": "not_applicable", "supportLevel": null, "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": [] }, "label": { "cardRefs": [], "citationRefs": [ "cit-b2-matn" ], "evidenceRefs": [ "cit-b2-matn" ], "requiresPinpoint": false, "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [ "cit-b2-matn" ], "sourceRefs": [ "source-bukhari-ghadir-two-routes-2019" ], "state": "exact", "supportLevel": "exact", "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": [] }, "sub": { "cardRefs": [], "citationRefs": [], "evidenceRefs": [], "requiresPinpoint": false, "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [], "sourceRefs": [], "state": "not_applicable", "supportLevel": null, "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": [] } }, "flags": [], "hukm": null, "id": "nabi", "kind": "nabi", "label": "رسول الله ﷺ", "sub": null }, { "card": null, "city": null, "coverage": { "applicableFields": 3, "exactFields": 2, "status": "partial", "unresolvedFields": 1 }, "death": null, "evidenceRefs": { "identity": [ "cit-b2-report" ], "sub": [ "cit-b2-variants" ] }, "fieldCoverage": { "card": { "cardRefs": [], "citationRefs": [], "evidenceRefs": [], "requiresPinpoint": false, "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [], "sourceRefs": [], "state": "not_applicable", "supportLevel": null, "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": [] }, "city": { "cardRefs": [], "citationRefs": [], "evidenceRefs": [], "requiresPinpoint": true, "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [], "sourceRefs": [], "state": "missing_value", "supportLevel": "unresolved", "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": [] }, "death": { "cardRefs": [], "citationRefs": [], "evidenceRefs": [], "requiresPinpoint": false, "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [], "sourceRefs": [], "state": "not_applicable", "supportLevel": null, "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": [] }, "flags": { "cardRefs": [], "citationRefs": [], "evidenceRefs": [], "items": {}, "requiresPinpoint": false, "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [], "sourceRefs": [], "state": "not_applicable", "supportLevel": null, "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": [] }, "hukm": { "cardRefs": [], "citationRefs": [], "evidenceRefs": [], "requiresPinpoint": false, "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [], "sourceRefs": [], "state": "not_applicable", "supportLevel": null, "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": [] }, "label": { "cardRefs": [], "citationRefs": [ "cit-b2-report" ], "evidenceRefs": [ "cit-b2-report" ], "requiresPinpoint": false, "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [ "cit-b2-report" ], "sourceRefs": [ "source-bukhari-ghadir-two-routes-2019" ], "state": "exact", "supportLevel": "exact", "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": [] }, "sub": { "cardRefs": [], "citationRefs": [ "cit-b2-variants" ], "evidenceRefs": [ "cit-b2-variants" ], "requiresPinpoint": false, "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [ "cit-b2-variants" ], "sourceRefs": [ "source-bukhari-ghadir-two-routes-2019" ], "state": "exact", "supportLevel": "exact", "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": [] } }, "flags": [], "hukm": null, "id": "salim_father", "kind": "rawi", "label": "والد سالم", "sub": "«سمع أباه»؛ وفي نسخ «سمع من»" }, { "card": null, "city": null, "coverage": { "applicableFields": 1, "exactFields": 1, "status": "complete", "unresolvedFields": 0 }, "death": null, "evidenceRefs": { "identity": [ "cit-b5-report" ] }, "fieldCoverage": { "card": { "cardRefs": [], "citationRefs": [], "evidenceRefs": [], "requiresPinpoint": false, "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [], "sourceRefs": [], "state": "not_applicable", "supportLevel": null, "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": [] }, "city": { "cardRefs": [], "citationRefs": [], "evidenceRefs": [], "requiresPinpoint": false, "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [], "sourceRefs": [], "state": "not_applicable", "supportLevel": null, "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": [] }, "death": { "cardRefs": [], "citationRefs": [], "evidenceRefs": [], "requiresPinpoint": false, "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [], "sourceRefs": [], "state": "not_applicable", "supportLevel": null, "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": [] }, "flags": { "cardRefs": [], "citationRefs": [], "evidenceRefs": [], "items": {}, "requiresPinpoint": false, "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [], "sourceRefs": [], "state": "not_applicable", "supportLevel": null, "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": [] }, "hukm": { "cardRefs": [], "citationRefs": [], "evidenceRefs": [], "requiresPinpoint": false, "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [], "sourceRefs": [], "state": "not_applicable", "supportLevel": null, "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": [] }, "label": { "cardRefs": [], "citationRefs": [ "cit-b5-report" ], "evidenceRefs": [ "cit-b5-report" ], "requiresPinpoint": false, "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [ "cit-b5-report" ], "sourceRefs": [ "source-bukhari-ghadir-two-routes-2019" ], "state": "exact", "supportLevel": "exact", "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": [] }, "sub": { "cardRefs": [], "citationRefs": [], "evidenceRefs": [], "requiresPinpoint": false, "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [], "sourceRefs": [], "state": "not_applicable", "supportLevel": null, "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": [] } }, "flags": [], "hukm": null, "id": "abu_said", "kind": "sahabi", "label": "أبو سعيد الخدري", "sub": null }, { "card": null, "city": null, "coverage": { "applicableFields": 2, "exactFields": 1, "status": "partial", "unresolvedFields": 1 }, "death": null, "evidenceRefs": { "identity": [ "cit-b2-report" ] }, "fieldCoverage": { "card": { "cardRefs": [], "citationRefs": [], "evidenceRefs": [], "requiresPinpoint": false, "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [], "sourceRefs": [], "state": "not_applicable", "supportLevel": null, "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": [] }, "city": { "cardRefs": [], "citationRefs": [], "evidenceRefs": [], "requiresPinpoint": true, "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [], "sourceRefs": [], "state": "missing_value", "supportLevel": "unresolved", "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": [] }, "death": { "cardRefs": [], "citationRefs": [], "evidenceRefs": [], "requiresPinpoint": false, "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [], "sourceRefs": [], "state": "not_applicable", "supportLevel": null, "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": [] }, "flags": { "cardRefs": [], "citationRefs": [], "evidenceRefs": [], "items": {}, "requiresPinpoint": false, "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [], "sourceRefs": [], "state": "not_applicable", "supportLevel": null, "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": [] }, "hukm": { "cardRefs": [], "citationRefs": [], "evidenceRefs": [], "requiresPinpoint": false, "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [], "sourceRefs": [], "state": "not_applicable", "supportLevel": null, "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": [] }, "label": { "cardRefs": [], "citationRefs": [ "cit-b2-report" ], "evidenceRefs": [ "cit-b2-report" ], "requiresPinpoint": false, "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [ "cit-b2-report" ], "sourceRefs": [ "source-bukhari-ghadir-two-routes-2019" ], "state": "exact", "supportLevel": "exact", "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": [] }, "sub": { "cardRefs": [], "citationRefs": [], "evidenceRefs": [], "requiresPinpoint": false, "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [], "sourceRefs": [], "state": "not_applicable", "supportLevel": null, "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": [] } }, "flags": [], "hukm": null, "id": "salim", "kind": "rawi", "label": "سالم", "sub": null }, { "card": null, "city": null, "coverage": { "applicableFields": 4, "exactFields": 3, "status": "partial", "unresolvedFields": 1 }, "death": null, "evidenceRefs": { "hukm": [ "cit-b5-hukm" ], "identity": [ "cit-b5-report" ], "sub": [ "cit-b5-hukm" ] }, "fieldCoverage": { "card": { "cardRefs": [], "citationRefs": [], "evidenceRefs": [], "requiresPinpoint": false, "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [], "sourceRefs": [], "state": "not_applicable", "supportLevel": null, "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": [] }, "city": { "cardRefs": [], "citationRefs": [], "evidenceRefs": [], "requiresPinpoint": true, "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [], "sourceRefs": [], "state": "missing_value", "supportLevel": "unresolved", "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": [] }, "death": { "cardRefs": [], "citationRefs": [], "evidenceRefs": [], "requiresPinpoint": false, "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [], "sourceRefs": [], "state": "not_applicable", "supportLevel": null, "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": [] }, "flags": { "cardRefs": [], "citationRefs": [], "evidenceRefs": [], "items": {}, "requiresPinpoint": false, "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [], "sourceRefs": [], "state": "not_applicable", "supportLevel": null, "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": [] }, "hukm": { "cardRefs": [], "citationRefs": [ "cit-b5-hukm" ], "evidenceRefs": [ "cit-b5-hukm" ], "requiresPinpoint": false, "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [ "cit-b5-hukm" ], "sourceRefs": [ "source-bukhari-ghadir-two-routes-2019" ], "state": "exact", "supportLevel": "exact", "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": [] }, "label": { "cardRefs": [], "citationRefs": [ "cit-b5-report" ], "evidenceRefs": [ "cit-b5-report" ], "requiresPinpoint": false, "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [ "cit-b5-report" ], "sourceRefs": [ "source-bukhari-ghadir-two-routes-2019" ], "state": "exact", "supportLevel": "exact", "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": [] }, "sub": { "cardRefs": [], "citationRefs": [ "cit-b5-hukm" ], "evidenceRefs": [ "cit-b5-hukm" ], "requiresPinpoint": false, "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [ "cit-b5-hukm" ], "sourceRefs": [ "source-bukhari-ghadir-two-routes-2019" ], "state": "exact", "supportLevel": "exact", "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": [] } }, "flags": [], "hukm": "majhul", "id": "sahm", "kind": "rawi", "label": "سهم بن حصين الأسدي", "sub": "البخاري: «وسهم مجهول»" }, { "card": null, "city": null, "coverage": { "applicableFields": 2, "exactFields": 1, "status": "partial", "unresolvedFields": 1 }, "death": null, "evidenceRefs": { "identity": [ "cit-b2-report" ] }, "fieldCoverage": { "card": { "cardRefs": [], "citationRefs": [], "evidenceRefs": [], "requiresPinpoint": false, "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [], "sourceRefs": [], "state": "not_applicable", "supportLevel": null, "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": [] }, "city": { "cardRefs": [], "citationRefs": [], "evidenceRefs": [], "requiresPinpoint": true, "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [], "sourceRefs": [], "state": "missing_value", "supportLevel": "unresolved", "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": [] }, "death": { "cardRefs": [], "citationRefs": [], "evidenceRefs": [], "requiresPinpoint": false, "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [], "sourceRefs": [], "state": "not_applicable", "supportLevel": null, "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": [] }, "flags": { "cardRefs": [], "citationRefs": [], "evidenceRefs": [], "items": {}, "requiresPinpoint": false, "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [], "sourceRefs": [], "state": "not_applicable", "supportLevel": null, "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": [] }, "hukm": { "cardRefs": [], "citationRefs": [], "evidenceRefs": [], "requiresPinpoint": false, "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [], "sourceRefs": [], "state": "not_applicable", "supportLevel": null, "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": [] }, "label": { "cardRefs": [], "citationRefs": [ "cit-b2-report" ], "evidenceRefs": [ "cit-b2-report" ], "requiresPinpoint": false, "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [ "cit-b2-report" ], "sourceRefs": [ "source-bukhari-ghadir-two-routes-2019" ], "state": "exact", "supportLevel": "exact", "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": [] }, "sub": { "cardRefs": [], "citationRefs": [], "evidenceRefs": [], "requiresPinpoint": false, "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [], "sourceRefs": [], "state": "not_applicable", "supportLevel": null, "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": [] } }, "flags": [], "hukm": null, "id": "jamil", "kind": "rawi", "label": "جميل بن عامر", "sub": null }, { "card": null, "city": null, "coverage": { "applicableFields": 2, "exactFields": 1, "status": "partial", "unresolvedFields": 1 }, "death": null, "evidenceRefs": { "identity": [ "cit-b5-report" ] }, "fieldCoverage": { "card": { "cardRefs": [], "citationRefs": [], "evidenceRefs": [], "requiresPinpoint": false, "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [], "sourceRefs": [], "state": "not_applicable", "supportLevel": null, "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": [] }, "city": { "cardRefs": [], "citationRefs": [], "evidenceRefs": [], "requiresPinpoint": true, "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [], "sourceRefs": [], "state": "missing_value", "supportLevel": "unresolved", "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": [] }, "death": { "cardRefs": [], "citationRefs": [], "evidenceRefs": [], "requiresPinpoint": false, "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [], "sourceRefs": [], "state": "not_applicable", "supportLevel": null, "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": [] }, "flags": { "cardRefs": [], "citationRefs": [], "evidenceRefs": [], "items": {}, "requiresPinpoint": false, "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [], "sourceRefs": [], "state": "not_applicable", "supportLevel": null, "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": [] }, "hukm": { "cardRefs": [], "citationRefs": [], "evidenceRefs": [], "requiresPinpoint": false, "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [], "sourceRefs": [], "state": "not_applicable", "supportLevel": null, "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": [] }, "label": { "cardRefs": [], "citationRefs": [ "cit-b5-report" ], "evidenceRefs": [ "cit-b5-report" ], "requiresPinpoint": false, "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [ "cit-b5-report" ], "sourceRefs": [ "source-bukhari-ghadir-two-routes-2019" ], "state": "exact", "supportLevel": "exact", "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": [] }, "sub": { "cardRefs": [], "citationRefs": [], "evidenceRefs": [], "requiresPinpoint": false, "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [], "sourceRefs": [], "state": "not_applicable", "supportLevel": null, "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": [] } }, "flags": [], "hukm": null, "id": "abdallah_sharik", "kind": "rawi", "label": "عبد الله بن شريك", "sub": null }, { "card": null, "city": null, "coverage": { "applicableFields": 2, "exactFields": 1, "status": "partial", "unresolvedFields": 1 }, "death": null, "evidenceRefs": { "identity": [ "cit-b2-names" ] }, "fieldCoverage": { "card": { "cardRefs": [], "citationRefs": [], "evidenceRefs": [], "requiresPinpoint": false, "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [], "sourceRefs": [], "state": "not_applicable", "supportLevel": null, "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": [] }, "city": { "cardRefs": [], "citationRefs": [], "evidenceRefs": [], "requiresPinpoint": true, "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [], "sourceRefs": [], "state": "missing_value", "supportLevel": "unresolved", "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": [] }, "death": { "cardRefs": [], "citationRefs": [], "evidenceRefs": [], "requiresPinpoint": false, "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [], "sourceRefs": [], "state": "not_applicable", "supportLevel": null, "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": [] }, "flags": { "cardRefs": [], "citationRefs": [], "evidenceRefs": [], "items": {}, "requiresPinpoint": false, "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [], "sourceRefs": [], "state": "not_applicable", "supportLevel": null, "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": [] }, "hukm": { "cardRefs": [], "citationRefs": [], "evidenceRefs": [], "requiresPinpoint": false, "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [], "sourceRefs": [], "state": "not_applicable", "supportLevel": null, "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": [] }, "label": { "cardRefs": [], "citationRefs": [ "cit-b2-names" ], "evidenceRefs": [ "cit-b2-names" ], "requiresPinpoint": false, "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [ "cit-b2-names" ], "sourceRefs": [ "source-bukhari-ghadir-two-routes-2019" ], "state": "exact", "supportLevel": "exact", "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": [] }, "sub": { "cardRefs": [], "citationRefs": [], "evidenceRefs": [], "requiresPinpoint": false, "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [], "sourceRefs": [], "state": "not_applicable", "supportLevel": null, "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": [] } }, "flags": [], "hukm": null, "id": "ismail", "kind": "rawi", "label": "إسماعيل بن نشيط العامري", "sub": null }, { "card": null, "city": null, "coverage": { "applicableFields": 2, "exactFields": 1, "status": "partial", "unresolvedFields": 1 }, "death": null, "evidenceRefs": { "identity": [ "cit-b5-report" ] }, "fieldCoverage": { "card": { "cardRefs": [], "citationRefs": [], "evidenceRefs": [], "requiresPinpoint": false, "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [], "sourceRefs": [], "state": "not_applicable", "supportLevel": null, "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": [] }, "city": { "cardRefs": [], "citationRefs": [], "evidenceRefs": [], "requiresPinpoint": true, "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [], "sourceRefs": [], "state": "missing_value", "supportLevel": "unresolved", "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": [] }, "death": { "cardRefs": [], "citationRefs": [], "evidenceRefs": [], "requiresPinpoint": false, "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [], "sourceRefs": [], "state": "not_applicable", "supportLevel": null, "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": [] }, "flags": { "cardRefs": [], "citationRefs": [], "evidenceRefs": [], "items": {}, "requiresPinpoint": false, "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [], "sourceRefs": [], "state": "not_applicable", "supportLevel": null, "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": [] }, "hukm": { "cardRefs": [], "citationRefs": [], "evidenceRefs": [], "requiresPinpoint": false, "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [], "sourceRefs": [], "state": "not_applicable", "supportLevel": null, "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": [] }, "label": { "cardRefs": [], "citationRefs": [ "cit-b5-report" ], "evidenceRefs": [ "cit-b5-report" ], "requiresPinpoint": false, "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [ "cit-b5-report" ], "sourceRefs": [ "source-bukhari-ghadir-two-routes-2019" ], "state": "exact", "supportLevel": "exact", "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": [] }, "sub": { "cardRefs": [], "citationRefs": [], "evidenceRefs": [], "requiresPinpoint": false, "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [], "sourceRefs": [], "state": "not_applicable", "supportLevel": null, "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": [] } }, "flags": [], "hukm": null, "id": "israil", "kind": "rawi", "label": "إسرائيل", "sub": null }, { "card": null, "city": null, "coverage": { "applicableFields": 2, "exactFields": 1, "status": "partial", "unresolvedFields": 1 }, "death": null, "evidenceRefs": { "identity": [ "cit-b2-names" ] }, "fieldCoverage": { "card": { "cardRefs": [], "citationRefs": [], "evidenceRefs": [], "requiresPinpoint": false, "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [], "sourceRefs": [], "state": "not_applicable", "supportLevel": null, "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": [] }, "city": { "cardRefs": [], "citationRefs": [], "evidenceRefs": [], "requiresPinpoint": true, "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [], "sourceRefs": [], "state": "missing_value", "supportLevel": "unresolved", "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": [] }, "death": { "cardRefs": [], "citationRefs": [], "evidenceRefs": [], "requiresPinpoint": false, "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [], "sourceRefs": [], "state": "not_applicable", "supportLevel": null, "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": [] }, "flags": { "cardRefs": [], "citationRefs": [], "evidenceRefs": [], "items": {}, "requiresPinpoint": false, "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [], "sourceRefs": [], "state": "not_applicable", "supportLevel": null, "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": [] }, "hukm": { "cardRefs": [], "citationRefs": [], "evidenceRefs": [], "requiresPinpoint": false, "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [], "sourceRefs": [], "state": "not_applicable", "supportLevel": null, "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": [] }, "label": { "cardRefs": [], "citationRefs": [ "cit-b2-names" ], "evidenceRefs": [ "cit-b2-names" ], "requiresPinpoint": false, "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [ "cit-b2-names" ], "sourceRefs": [ "source-bukhari-ghadir-two-routes-2019" ], "state": "exact", "supportLevel": "exact", "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": [] }, "sub": { "cardRefs": [], "citationRefs": [], "evidenceRefs": [], "requiresPinpoint": false, "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [], "sourceRefs": [], "state": "not_applicable", "supportLevel": null, "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": [] } }, "flags": [], "hukm": null, "id": "yunus", "kind": "rawi", "label": "يونس بن بكير", "sub": null }, { "card": null, "city": null, "coverage": { "applicableFields": 2, "exactFields": 1, "status": "partial", "unresolvedFields": 1 }, "death": null, "evidenceRefs": { "identity": [ "cit-b5-report" ] }, "fieldCoverage": { "card": { "cardRefs": [], "citationRefs": [], "evidenceRefs": [], "requiresPinpoint": false, "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [], "sourceRefs": [], "state": "not_applicable", "supportLevel": null, "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": [] }, "city": { "cardRefs": [], "citationRefs": [], "evidenceRefs": [], "requiresPinpoint": true, "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [], "sourceRefs": [], "state": "missing_value", "supportLevel": "unresolved", "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": [] }, "death": { "cardRefs": [], "citationRefs": [], "evidenceRefs": [], "requiresPinpoint": false, "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [], "sourceRefs": [], "state": "not_applicable", "supportLevel": null, "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": [] }, "flags": { "cardRefs": [], "citationRefs": [], "evidenceRefs": [], "items": {}, "requiresPinpoint": false, "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [], "sourceRefs": [], "state": "not_applicable", "supportLevel": null, "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": [] }, "hukm": { "cardRefs": [], "citationRefs": [], "evidenceRefs": [], "requiresPinpoint": false, "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [], "sourceRefs": [], "state": "not_applicable", "supportLevel": null, "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": [] }, "label": { "cardRefs": [], "citationRefs": [ "cit-b5-report" ], "evidenceRefs": [ "cit-b5-report" ], "requiresPinpoint": false, "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [ "cit-b5-report" ], "sourceRefs": [ "source-bukhari-ghadir-two-routes-2019" ], "state": "exact", "supportLevel": "exact", "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": [] }, "sub": { "cardRefs": [], "citationRefs": [], "evidenceRefs": [], "requiresPinpoint": false, "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [], "sourceRefs": [], "state": "not_applicable", "supportLevel": null, "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": [] } }, "flags": [], "hukm": null, "id": "ali_qadim", "kind": "rawi", "label": "علي بن قادم الخزاعي", "sub": null }, { "card": null, "city": null, "coverage": { "applicableFields": 2, "exactFields": 1, "status": "partial", "unresolvedFields": 1 }, "death": null, "evidenceRefs": { "identity": [ "cit-b2-report" ] }, "fieldCoverage": { "card": { "cardRefs": [], "citationRefs": [], "evidenceRefs": [], "requiresPinpoint": false, "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [], "sourceRefs": [], "state": "not_applicable", "supportLevel": null, "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": [] }, "city": { "cardRefs": [], "citationRefs": [], "evidenceRefs": [], "requiresPinpoint": true, "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [], "sourceRefs": [], "state": "missing_value", "supportLevel": "unresolved", "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": [] }, "death": { "cardRefs": [], "citationRefs": [], "evidenceRefs": [], "requiresPinpoint": false, "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [], "sourceRefs": [], "state": "not_applicable", "supportLevel": null, "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": [] }, "flags": { "cardRefs": [], "citationRefs": [], "evidenceRefs": [], "items": {}, "requiresPinpoint": false, "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [], "sourceRefs": [], "state": "not_applicable", "supportLevel": null, "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": [] }, "hukm": { "cardRefs": [], "citationRefs": [], "evidenceRefs": [], "requiresPinpoint": false, "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [], "sourceRefs": [], "state": "not_applicable", "supportLevel": null, "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": [] }, "label": { "cardRefs": [], "citationRefs": [ "cit-b2-report" ], "evidenceRefs": [ "cit-b2-report" ], "requiresPinpoint": false, "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [ "cit-b2-report" ], "sourceRefs": [ "source-bukhari-ghadir-two-routes-2019" ], "state": "exact", "supportLevel": "exact", "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": [] }, "sub": { "cardRefs": [], "citationRefs": [], "evidenceRefs": [], "requiresPinpoint": false, "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [], "sourceRefs": [], "state": "not_applicable", "supportLevel": null, "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": [] } }, "flags": [], "hukm": null, "id": "ubayd", "kind": "rawi", "label": "عبيد", "sub": null }, { "card": null, "city": null, "coverage": { "applicableFields": 2, "exactFields": 1, "status": "partial", "unresolvedFields": 1 }, "death": null, "evidenceRefs": { "identity": [ "cit-b5-report" ] }, "fieldCoverage": { "card": { "cardRefs": [], "citationRefs": [], "evidenceRefs": [], "requiresPinpoint": false, "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [], "sourceRefs": [], "state": "not_applicable", "supportLevel": null, "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": [] }, "city": { "cardRefs": [], "citationRefs": [], "evidenceRefs": [], "requiresPinpoint": true, "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [], "sourceRefs": [], "state": "missing_value", "supportLevel": "unresolved", "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": [] }, "death": { "cardRefs": [], "citationRefs": [], "evidenceRefs": [], "requiresPinpoint": false, "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [], "sourceRefs": [], "state": "not_applicable", "supportLevel": null, "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": [] }, "flags": { "cardRefs": [], "citationRefs": [], "evidenceRefs": [], "items": {}, "requiresPinpoint": false, "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [], "sourceRefs": [], "state": "not_applicable", "supportLevel": null, "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": [] }, "hukm": { "cardRefs": [], "citationRefs": [], "evidenceRefs": [], "requiresPinpoint": false, "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [], "sourceRefs": [], "state": "not_applicable", "supportLevel": null, "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": [] }, "label": { "cardRefs": [], "citationRefs": [ "cit-b5-report" ], "evidenceRefs": [ "cit-b5-report" ], "requiresPinpoint": false, "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [ "cit-b5-report" ], "sourceRefs": [ "source-bukhari-ghadir-two-routes-2019" ], "state": "exact", "supportLevel": "exact", "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": [] }, "sub": { "cardRefs": [], "citationRefs": [], "evidenceRefs": [], "requiresPinpoint": false, "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [], "sourceRefs": [], "state": "not_applicable", "supportLevel": null, "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": [] } }, "flags": [], "hukm": null, "id": "yusuf", "kind": "rawi", "label": "يوسف بن راشد", "sub": null } ], "pipelineVersion": 7, "provenanceCoverage": { "arguments": 2, "citations": 25, "dependencyHash": "3d079b591c2072f9", "exactHotspots": 38, "illal": 3, "matnVariants": 2, "missingCards": [], "missingSources": [], "narrators": 13, "percentExact": 77.6, "riwayat": 2, "status": "incomplete", "totalHotspots": 49, "transmissions": 14, "unresolvedHotspots": 11 }, "provenanceStatus": "draft", "provenanceVersion": 2, "records": { "cards": [ { "contentHash": "c8fe008078c2a801", "exists": true, "id": "evidence-hadith-al-ghadir-nawa-tabaqat-al-ziyadah", "path": "05_cards/evidences/hadith-al-ghadir-nawa-tabaqat-al-ziyadah.md", "status": "verified_with_limits", "title": "حديث الغدير: النواة وطبقات الزيادة" } ], "sources": [ { "author": "محمد بن إسماعيل البخاري", "authorDeathHijri": "256", "contentHash": "cac74842a6d6c4c7", "exists": true, "id": "source-bukhari-ghadir-two-routes-2019", "path": "04_source_bank/source-bukhari-ghadir-two-routes-2019.md", "status": "verified_with_limits", "title": "التاريخ الكبير — نقد طريقي إسماعيل بن نشيط وسهم بن حصين في الموالاة" } ] }, "riwayat": [ { "chain": [ "nabi", "salim_father", "salim", "jamil", "ismail", "yunus", "ubayd", "book_b2" ], "citationRefs": [ "cit-b2-report" ], "evidenceRefs": [ "cit-b2-report" ], "familyId": "family-ismail-jamil-salim", "hukm": "البخاري: في إسناده نظر", "hukmCitationRefs": [ "cit-b2-hukm" ], "hukmEvidenceRefs": [ "cit-b2-hukm" ], "id": "riwaya-b2-1187", "illaRefs": [], "label": "طريق إسماعيل بن نشيط • التاريخ الكبير2/92 ت1187", "matnRefs": [ "matn-b2" ], "nodePath": [ "nabi", "salim_father", "salim", "jamil", "ismail", "yunus", "ubayd", "book_b2" ], "textualVariants": [ { "citationRefs": [ "cit-b2-variants", "cit-b2-hukm-variant" ], "text": "سمع من بدل سمع أباه في ك وش وق؛ وقراءة غ: لم يتابع عن سالم في هذا الحديث." } ] }, { "chain": [ "nabi", "abu_said", "sahm", "abdallah_sharik", "israil", "ali_qadim", "yusuf", "book_b5" ], "citationRefs": [ "cit-b5-report" ], "evidenceRefs": [ "cit-b5-report" ], "familyId": "family-sahm-abu-said", "hukm": "البخاري: وسهم مجهول ولا يدرى من هو", "hukmCitationRefs": [ "cit-b5-hukm" ], "hukmEvidenceRefs": [ "cit-b5-hukm" ], "id": "riwaya-b5-5308", "illaRefs": [], "label": "طريق سهم بن حصين • التاريخ الكبير5/297–298 ت5308", "matnRefs": [ "matn-b5" ], "nodePath": [ "nabi", "abu_said", "sahm", "abdallah_sharik", "israil", "ali_qadim", "yusuf", "book_b5" ], "textualVariants": [ { "citationRefs": [ "cit-b5-hukm-variant" ], "text": "من هو ليست في ق؛ والتعقيب كله ليس في ث." } ] } ], "schemaVersion": 2, "transmissions": [ { "cardRefs": [], "citationRefs": [ "cit-nabi-father", "cit-b2-report" ], "evidenceRefs": { "note": [ "cit-nabi-father" ] }, "from": "nabi", "id": "edge-nabi-salim_father", "illaRefs": [], "matnRefs": [], "note": null, "requiresPinpoint": false, "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [ "cit-nabi-father", "cit-b2-report" ], "riwayaRefs": [ "riwaya-b2-1187" ], "sourceRefs": [ "source-bukhari-ghadir-two-routes-2019" ], "status": "mahfuz", "supportLevel": "exact", "to": "salim_father", "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": [] }, { "cardRefs": [], "citationRefs": [ "cit-father-salim", "cit-b2-variants", "cit-b2-report" ], "evidenceRefs": { "note": [ "cit-father-salim" ], "status": [ "cit-b2-variants" ] }, "from": "salim_father", "id": "edge-salim_father-salim", "illaRefs": [ "illa-salim-variant" ], "matnRefs": [], "note": "سمع أباه", "requiresPinpoint": false, "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [ "cit-father-salim", "cit-b2-variants", "cit-b2-report" ], "riwayaRefs": [ "riwaya-b2-1187" ], "sourceRefs": [ "source-bukhari-ghadir-two-routes-2019" ], "status": "disputed", "supportLevel": "exact", "to": "salim", "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": [] }, { "cardRefs": [], "citationRefs": [ "cit-salim-jamil", "cit-b2-report" ], "evidenceRefs": { "note": [ "cit-salim-jamil" ] }, "from": "salim", "id": "edge-salim-jamil", "illaRefs": [], "matnRefs": [], "note": "أن سالماً حدثه", "requiresPinpoint": false, "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [ "cit-salim-jamil", "cit-b2-report" ], "riwayaRefs": [ "riwaya-b2-1187" ], "sourceRefs": [ "source-bukhari-ghadir-two-routes-2019" ], "status": "mahfuz", "supportLevel": "exact", "to": "jamil", "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": [] }, { "cardRefs": [], "citationRefs": [ "cit-jamil-ismail", "cit-b2-report" ], "evidenceRefs": { "note": [ "cit-jamil-ismail" ] }, "from": "jamil", "id": "edge-jamil-ismail", "illaRefs": [], "matnRefs": [], "note": "عن جميل بن عامر", "requiresPinpoint": false, "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [ "cit-jamil-ismail", "cit-b2-report" ], "riwayaRefs": [ "riwaya-b2-1187" ], "sourceRefs": [ "source-bukhari-ghadir-two-routes-2019" ], "status": "mahfuz", "supportLevel": "exact", "to": "ismail", "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": [] }, { "cardRefs": [], "citationRefs": [ "cit-ismail-yunus", "cit-b2-report" ], "evidenceRefs": { "note": [ "cit-ismail-yunus" ] }, "from": "ismail", "id": "edge-ismail-yunus", "illaRefs": [], "matnRefs": [], "note": "سمع إسماعيل", "requiresPinpoint": false, "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [ "cit-ismail-yunus", "cit-b2-report" ], "riwayaRefs": [ "riwaya-b2-1187" ], "sourceRefs": [ "source-bukhari-ghadir-two-routes-2019" ], "status": "mahfuz", "supportLevel": "exact", "to": "yunus", "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": [] }, { "cardRefs": [], "citationRefs": [ "cit-yunus-ubayd", "cit-b2-report" ], "evidenceRefs": { "note": [ "cit-yunus-ubayd" ] }, "from": "yunus", "id": "edge-yunus-ubayd", "illaRefs": [], "matnRefs": [], "note": "حدثنا يونس", "requiresPinpoint": false, "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [ "cit-yunus-ubayd", "cit-b2-report" ], "riwayaRefs": [ "riwaya-b2-1187" ], "sourceRefs": [ "source-bukhari-ghadir-two-routes-2019" ], "status": "mahfuz", "supportLevel": "exact", "to": "ubayd", "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": [] }, { "cardRefs": [], "citationRefs": [ "cit-ubayd-bukhari", "cit-b2-hukm", "cit-b2-report", "cit-b2-hukm-variant" ], "evidenceRefs": { "note": [ "cit-ubayd-bukhari", "cit-b2-hukm" ], "status": [ "cit-b2-hukm" ] }, "from": "ubayd", "id": "edge-ubayd-book_b2", "illaRefs": [ "illa-b2-nazar" ], "matnRefs": [], "note": "قال لي عبيد؛ الإسناد محل نظر", "requiresPinpoint": false, "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [ "cit-ubayd-bukhari", "cit-b2-hukm", "cit-b2-report", "cit-b2-hukm-variant" ], "riwayaRefs": [ "riwaya-b2-1187" ], "sourceRefs": [ "source-bukhari-ghadir-two-routes-2019" ], "status": "weak", "supportLevel": "exact", "to": "book_b2", "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": [] }, { "cardRefs": [], "citationRefs": [ "cit-nabi-abu-said", "cit-b5-report" ], "evidenceRefs": { "note": [ "cit-nabi-abu-said" ] }, "from": "nabi", "id": "edge-nabi-abu_said", "illaRefs": [], "matnRefs": [], "note": null, "requiresPinpoint": false, "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [ "cit-nabi-abu-said", "cit-b5-report" ], "riwayaRefs": [ "riwaya-b5-5308" ], "sourceRefs": [ "source-bukhari-ghadir-two-routes-2019" ], "status": "mahfuz", "supportLevel": "exact", "to": "abu_said", "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": [] }, { "cardRefs": [], "citationRefs": [ "cit-abu-said-sahm", "cit-b5-hukm", "cit-b5-report", "cit-b5-hukm-variant" ], "evidenceRefs": { "note": [ "cit-abu-said-sahm" ], "status": [ "cit-b5-hukm" ] }, "from": "abu_said", "id": "edge-abu_said-sahm", "illaRefs": [ "illa-sahm-majhul" ], "matnRefs": [], "note": "سؤال سهم وجواب أبي سعيد", "requiresPinpoint": false, "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [ "cit-abu-said-sahm", "cit-b5-hukm", "cit-b5-report", "cit-b5-hukm-variant" ], "riwayaRefs": [ "riwaya-b5-5308" ], "sourceRefs": [ "source-bukhari-ghadir-two-routes-2019" ], "status": "weak", "supportLevel": "exact", "to": "sahm", "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": [] }, { "cardRefs": [], "citationRefs": [ "cit-sahm-abdallah", "cit-b5-report" ], "evidenceRefs": { "note": [ "cit-sahm-abdallah" ] }, "from": "sahm", "id": "edge-sahm-abdallah_sharik", "illaRefs": [], "matnRefs": [], "note": "عن سهم بن حصين", "requiresPinpoint": false, "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [ "cit-sahm-abdallah", "cit-b5-report" ], "riwayaRefs": [ "riwaya-b5-5308" ], "sourceRefs": [ "source-bukhari-ghadir-two-routes-2019" ], "status": "mahfuz", "supportLevel": "exact", "to": "abdallah_sharik", "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": [] }, { "cardRefs": [], "citationRefs": [ "cit-abdallah-israil", "cit-b5-report" ], "evidenceRefs": { "note": [ "cit-abdallah-israil" ] }, "from": "abdallah_sharik", "id": "edge-abdallah_sharik-israil", "illaRefs": [], "matnRefs": [], "note": "عن عبد الله بن شريك", "requiresPinpoint": false, "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [ "cit-abdallah-israil", "cit-b5-report" ], "riwayaRefs": [ "riwaya-b5-5308" ], "sourceRefs": [ "source-bukhari-ghadir-two-routes-2019" ], "status": "mahfuz", "supportLevel": "exact", "to": "israil", "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": [] }, { "cardRefs": [], "citationRefs": [ "cit-israil-ali", "cit-b5-report" ], "evidenceRefs": { "note": [ "cit-israil-ali" ] }, "from": "israil", "id": "edge-israil-ali_qadim", "illaRefs": [], "matnRefs": [], "note": "أخبرنا إسرائيل", "requiresPinpoint": false, "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [ "cit-israil-ali", "cit-b5-report" ], "riwayaRefs": [ "riwaya-b5-5308" ], "sourceRefs": [ "source-bukhari-ghadir-two-routes-2019" ], "status": "mahfuz", "supportLevel": "exact", "to": "ali_qadim", "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": [] }, { "cardRefs": [], "citationRefs": [ "cit-ali-yusuf", "cit-b5-report" ], "evidenceRefs": { "note": [ "cit-ali-yusuf" ] }, "from": "ali_qadim", "id": "edge-ali_qadim-yusuf", "illaRefs": [], "matnRefs": [], "note": "حدثنا علي بن قادم", "requiresPinpoint": false, "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [ "cit-ali-yusuf", "cit-b5-report" ], "riwayaRefs": [ "riwaya-b5-5308" ], "sourceRefs": [ "source-bukhari-ghadir-two-routes-2019" ], "status": "mahfuz", "supportLevel": "exact", "to": "yusuf", "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": [] }, { "cardRefs": [], "citationRefs": [ "cit-yusuf-bukhari", "cit-b5-report" ], "evidenceRefs": { "note": [ "cit-yusuf-bukhari" ] }, "from": "yusuf", "id": "edge-yusuf-book_b5", "illaRefs": [], "matnRefs": [], "note": "حدثني يوسف بن راشد", "requiresPinpoint": false, "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [ "cit-yusuf-bukhari", "cit-b5-report" ], "riwayaRefs": [ "riwaya-b5-5308" ], "sourceRefs": [ "source-bukhari-ghadir-two-routes-2019" ], "status": "mahfuz", "supportLevel": "exact", "to": "book_b5", "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": [] } ] }