{ "arguments": [ { "citationRefs": [ "c-k721", "c-k721-note", "c-k722", "c-k722-note" ], "evidenceRefs": [ "c-k721", "c-k721-note", "c-k722", "c-k722-note" ], "id": "a-critical-attribution", "illaRefs": [], "kind": "isnad", "limitations": "عدم معرفة المحقق ليس نفياً لوجود الرجل مطلقاً؛ وفرق إسماعيل الصفار/بن الفضل يحتاج مقابلة الأصل.", "riwayaRefs": [], "scope": "sample", "statement": "نقد نسبة الحكاية يسبق نسبة حكمها إلى النقاد؛ لا يحمل لفظ العدد أو النفي قيد الطرق الكوفية المفصلة.", "targets": [ "riwaya:r721", "riwaya:r722" ] }, { "citationRefs": [ "c-k721", "c-rajab494" ], "evidenceRefs": [ "c-k721", "c-rajab494" ], "id": "a-name-variant", "illaRefs": [], "kind": "isnad", "limitations": "لا توحيد للرجلين ولا تصحيح آلي باختيار اسم معروف؛ لم تفحص مخطوطات العلل.", "riwayaRefs": [], "scope": "sample", "statement": "اسم ناقل المجلس مختلف: إسماعيل بن الفضل في الخلال721، وإسماعيل الصفار في نقل ابن رجب.", "targets": [ "node:ismail" ] }, { "citationRefs": [ "c-yaqub-hashiya", "c-rajab-yaqub" ], "evidenceRefs": [ "c-yaqub-hashiya", "c-rajab-yaqub" ], "id": "a-counterquote", "illaRefs": [], "kind": "isnad", "limitations": "لا تاريخ يثبت أنها آخر قول أحمد؛ الموضعان ناقلان للحكاية لا شاهدان على مجلسين مستقلين.", "riwayaRefs": [], "scope": "sample", "statement": "حكاية يعقوب المقابلة يجب إظهارها مع تمييز ألفاظ السماع داخلها من تحقيق وصولها إلى أصل يعقوب.", "targets": [ "riwaya:r-yaqub-hashiya", "riwaya:r-yaqub-rajab" ] }, { "citationRefs": [ "c-murad", "c-fath", "c-khalid-outside" ], "evidenceRefs": [ "c-murad", "c-fath", "c-khalid-outside" ], "id": "a-textual-not-stemma", "illaRefs": [], "kind": "matn", "limitations": "سبب الاختلاف وأول ظهوره واستقلال الشهود باق في HOLD_BUKHARI_STEMMA؛ بعض الإحالات جرد لم يقابل ثانية.", "riwayaRefs": [], "scope": "sample", "statement": "فرع مراد ملّا وشهادات ابن حجر وجرد خالد خارج البخاري مواد مقارنة؛ لا ترسم هنا شجرة مخطوطات أو سماعاً مباشراً لكريمة من الفربري.", "targets": [ "riwaya:r-murad", "riwaya:r-fath", "riwaya:r-khalid" ] }, { "citationRefs": [ "c-muslim", "c-muslim2236" ], "evidenceRefs": [ "c-muslim", "c-muslim2236" ], "id": "a-source-roots", "illaRefs": [], "kind": "isnad", "limitations": "الروابط هنا مواضع مقارنة، والسلاسل التفصيلية في مصدرها؛ لا حكم تواتر ولا إعفاء من التحقيق لاسم الصحيح.", "riwayaRefs": [], "scope": "sample", "statement": "نقد فرع أم سلمة لا يسقط أصل أبي قتادة بلا علة تخصه؛ اختلاف الأصول لا يحسم بمجرد التجاور في الباب.", "targets": [ "riwaya:r-muslim" ] }, { "citationRefs": [ "c-yala-context" ], "evidenceRefs": [ "c-yala-context" ], "id": "a-yala-context", "illaRefs": [], "kind": "matn", "limitations": "وجود القياس لا يثبت مقدماته التاريخية ولا يلزم الكتاب باختياره؛ لا يتمم السطر المقطوع من416.", "riwayaRefs": [], "scope": "sample", "statement": "نقل أبي يعلى للتضعيف يقع مع حجة فقهية تصوب قتال علي، فلا يستعار شاهداً مخالفاً لمذهبه بحذف السياق.", "targets": [ "node:abu_yala" ] }, { "citationRefs": [ "c-humaydi-43", "c-humaydi-48", "c-humaydi-45" ], "evidenceRefs": [ "c-humaydi-43", "c-humaydi-48", "c-humaydi-45" ], "id": "a-humaydi-claims", "illaRefs": [], "kind": "matn", "limitations": "قراءة محددة الصفحات من PDF الأصلي؛ لا اتهام لباعث المؤلف، ولا إسقاط لجميع اعتراضاته أو تصحيح لكل أخبار المقتل.", "riwayaRefs": [], "scope": "sample", "statement": "الحميدي يصحح حكايتي النفي ويعمم غياب اللفظ؛ نسبة قصد صيانة الصحابة للبخاري واستنتاج وفاة عمار من سكناه يحتاجان دليلاً خاصاً.", "targets": [ "node:humaydi_2025" ] } ], "citations": [ { "attribution": null, "cardRef": null, "discovery": null, "id": "c-k721", "kind": "evidence", "label": "أخبرني إسماعيل بن الفضل قال: سمعت أبا أمية محمد بن إبراهيم يقول: سمعت في حلقة أحمد بن حنبل ويحيى بن معين وأبو خيثمة والمعيطي ذكروا: يقتل عمار الفئة الباغية، فقالوا: ما فيه حديث صحيح.", "limitations": null, "locator": { "display": "السنة، تحقيق الزهراني،2/463،ح721" }, "mode": "quoted", "note": "قوبل متن الصورة؛ يعرض الرسم طريق هذه النسخة لا توحيداً له مع قراءة إسماعيل الصفار عند ابن رجب.", "quote": "أخبرني إسماعيل بن الفضل قال: سمعت أبا أمية محمد بن إبراهيم يقول: سمعت في حلقة أحمد بن حنبل ويحيى بن معين وأبو خيثمة والمعيطي ذكروا: يقتل عمار الفئة الباغية، فقالوا: ما فيه حديث صحيح.", "sourceId": "source-al-sunna-al-khallal-zahrani", "sourceRef": "source-al-sunna-al-khallal-zahrani", "speaker": null, "summary": null, "url": null, "verification": "verified_scan", "verificationLimits": null }, { "attribution": null, "cardRef": null, "discovery": null, "id": "c-k721-note", "kind": "evidence", "label": "لم أتوصل إلى معرفته.", "limitations": null, "locator": { "display": "السنة،2/463،حاشية1 على ح721" }, "mode": "quoted", "note": "قول المحقق في إسماعيل بن الفضل بالاسم المطبوع؛ لا يعمم على اسم الصفار المختلف دون تحقيق.", "quote": "لم أتوصل إلى معرفته.", "sourceId": "source-al-sunna-al-khallal-zahrani", "sourceRef": "source-al-sunna-al-khallal-zahrani", "speaker": null, "summary": null, "url": null, "verification": "verified_scan", "verificationLimits": null }, { "attribution": null, "cardRef": null, "discovery": null, "id": "c-k722", "kind": "evidence", "label": "سمعت محمد بن عبد الله بن إبراهيم قال: سمعت أبي يقول: سمعت أحمد بن حنبل يقول: روي في تقتل عمار الفئة الباغية ثمانية وعشرون حديثاً ليس فيها حديث صحيح.", "limitations": null, "locator": { "display": "السنة، تحقيق الزهراني،2/463،ح722" }, "mode": "quoted", "note": "العدد لا يحدد أصولاً صحابية مستقلة أو بلداً؛ لا قيد للطرق الكوفية المفصلة في النص.", "quote": "سمعت محمد بن عبد الله بن إبراهيم قال: سمعت أبي يقول: سمعت أحمد بن حنبل يقول: روي في تقتل عمار الفئة الباغية ثمانية وعشرون حديثاً ليس فيها حديث صحيح.", "sourceId": "source-al-sunna-al-khallal-zahrani", "sourceRef": "source-al-sunna-al-khallal-zahrani", "speaker": null, "summary": null, "url": null, "verification": "verified_scan", "verificationLimits": null }, { "attribution": null, "cardRef": null, "discovery": null, "id": "c-k722-note", "kind": "evidence", "label": "لم أجد ترجمتهما.", "limitations": null, "locator": { "display": "السنة،2/463،حاشيتا5–6 على ح722" }, "mode": "quoted", "note": "حكم محقق الطبعة على محمد بن عبد الله بن إبراهيم وأبيه؛ ثبوت التعليق غير استيفاء تخريج هويتيهما من جميع المصادر.", "quote": "لم أجد ترجمتهما.", "sourceId": "source-al-sunna-al-khallal-zahrani", "sourceRef": "source-al-sunna-al-khallal-zahrani", "speaker": null, "summary": null, "url": null, "verification": "verified_scan", "verificationLimits": null }, { "attribution": null, "cardRef": null, "discovery": null, "id": "c-yala-matn", "kind": "evidence", "label": "قيل: هذا الحديث قد ضعفه أحمد فقال أبو بكر الخلال: سمعت محمد بن عبد الله بن إبراهيم يقول: سمعت أبي يقول: سمعت أحمد بن حنبل... وقال أبو أمية محمد بن إبراهيم: سمعت في حلقة أحمد بن حنبل...", "limitations": null, "locator": { "display": "كتاب الإمامة، طبعة مسك،ص416،المتن وحواشي2 و10" }, "mode": "quoted", "note": "نقل أبي يعلى عن الخلال مختصر؛ نقاط الحذف اختصار هنا.706–707 في طبعة المبسوط يقابلهما721–722 في طبعة الزهراني؛ لا أربعة أصول. الصورة تقفل الصفحة لا جميع بيانات حقوق النشر.", "quote": "قيل: هذا الحديث قد ضعفه أحمد فقال أبو بكر الخلال: سمعت محمد بن عبد الله بن إبراهيم يقول: سمعت أبي يقول: سمعت أحمد بن حنبل... وقال أبو أمية محمد بن إبراهيم: سمعت في حلقة أحمد بن حنبل...", "sourceId": "source-kitab-al-imama-abu-yala-misk-ammar", "sourceRef": "source-kitab-al-imama-abu-yala-misk-ammar", "speaker": null, "summary": null, "url": null, "verification": "verified_scan", "verificationLimits": null }, { "attribution": null, "cardRef": null, "discovery": null, "id": "c-yala-context", "kind": "evidence", "label": "c-yala-context", "limitations": null, "locator": { "display": "كتاب الإمامة،طبعة مسك،ص415–416،السياق الكامل" }, "mode": "derived", "note": "يحتج أبو يعلى لإصابة علي في الطاعة والقياس على الخوارج ومانعي الزكاة. وحكاية تأويل البغي بالطلب تبدأ بوقيل؛ لا يصح تقديمه مخطئاً لعلي بحذف السياق. آخر416 مقطوع عند باشروا فلا تكمل الجملة التالية.", "quote": null, "sourceId": "source-kitab-al-imama-abu-yala-misk-ammar", "sourceRef": "source-kitab-al-imama-abu-yala-misk-ammar", "speaker": null, "summary": null, "url": null, "verification": "verified_scan", "verificationLimits": null }, { "attribution": null, "cardRef": null, "discovery": null, "id": "c-yaqub-hashiya", "kind": "evidence", "label": "قال ابن الفراء: وذكر يعقوب بن شيبة في الجزء الأول من مسند عمار: سمعت أحمد بن حنبل سئل عن حديث النبي صلى الله عليه وسلم في عمار: تقتلك الفئة الباغية، فقال أحمد: كما قال رسول الله صلى الله عليه وسلم: قتلته الفئة الباغية، وقال: في هذا غير حديث صحيح عن النبي صلى الله عليه وسلم، وكره أن يتكلم في هذا بأكثر من هذا.", "limitations": null, "locator": { "display": "كتاب الإمامة،ص416،حاشية3 عن حاشية المبسوط1/376" }, "mode": "quoted", "note": "سماع أحمد داخل حكاية عن يعقوب؛ لم يقابل هنا أصل مسند يعقوب أو طريق وصول الحكاية إليه. لا سماع لأبي يعلى من أحمد ولا تاريخ لآخر قول.", "quote": "قال ابن الفراء: وذكر يعقوب بن شيبة في الجزء الأول من مسند عمار: سمعت أحمد بن حنبل سئل عن حديث النبي صلى الله عليه وسلم في عمار: تقتلك الفئة الباغية، فقال أحمد: كما قال رسول الله صلى الله عليه وسلم: قتلته الفئة الباغية، وقال: في هذا غير حديث صحيح عن النبي صلى الله عليه وسلم، وكره أن يتكلم في هذا بأكثر من هذا.", "sourceId": "source-kitab-al-imama-abu-yala-misk-ammar", "sourceRef": "source-kitab-al-imama-abu-yala-misk-ammar", "speaker": null, "summary": null, "url": null, "verification": "verified_scan", "verificationLimits": null }, { "attribution": null, "cardRef": null, "discovery": null, "id": "c-rajab494", "kind": "evidence", "label": "فذكر الخلال في كتاب العلل: ثنا إسماعيل الصفار: سمعت أبا أمية الطرسوسي يقول: سمعت في حلقة أحمد بن حنبل...", "limitations": null, "locator": { "display": "فتح الباري لابن رجب،دار ابن الجوزي،ط1،1417هـ،2/494" }, "mode": "quoted", "note": "قوبلت الصورة كاملة؛ اسم الصفار هنا يختلف عن بن الفضل في الخلال721. يحكي ابن رجب أيضاً نقل العدد ثم يقول إسناد غير معروف وينقل حكاية يعقوب المقابلة. لا يثبت هذا مقابلة أصل العلل أو حسم الاسمين.", "quote": "فذكر الخلال في كتاب العلل: ثنا إسماعيل الصفار: سمعت أبا أمية الطرسوسي يقول: سمعت في حلقة أحمد بن حنبل...", "sourceId": "source-ibn-rajab-ammar-khandaq-ibn-al-jawzi-1417", "sourceRef": "source-ibn-rajab-ammar-khandaq-ibn-al-jawzi-1417", "speaker": null, "summary": null, "url": null, "verification": "verified_scan", "verificationLimits": null }, { "attribution": null, "cardRef": null, "discovery": null, "id": "c-rajab-yaqub", "kind": "evidence", "label": "قال يعقوب بن شيبة السدوسي في مسنده من مسند عمار: سمعت أحمد بن حنبل سئل عن حديث النبي صلى الله عليه وسلم في عمار... وقال: في هذا غير حديث صحيح عن النبي صلى الله عليه وسلم، وكره أن يتكلم في هذا بأكثر من هذا.", "limitations": null, "locator": { "display": "فتح الباري لابن رجب،2/494،حكاية يعقوب" }, "mode": "quoted", "note": "حكاية مصنف بلفظ السماع في داخلها؛ لم يقفل وصولها إلى يعقوب. الحذف هنا معلن لا دمج لشهادتين.", "quote": "قال يعقوب بن شيبة السدوسي في مسنده من مسند عمار: سمعت أحمد بن حنبل سئل عن حديث النبي صلى الله عليه وسلم في عمار... وقال: في هذا غير حديث صحيح عن النبي صلى الله عليه وسلم، وكره أن يتكلم في هذا بأكثر من هذا.", "sourceId": "source-ibn-rajab-ammar-khandaq-ibn-al-jawzi-1417", "sourceRef": "source-ibn-rajab-ammar-khandaq-ibn-al-jawzi-1417", "speaker": null, "summary": null, "url": null, "verification": "verified_scan", "verificationLimits": null }, { "attribution": null, "cardRef": null, "discovery": null, "id": "c-muslim", "kind": "evidence", "label": "c-muslim", "limitations": null, "locator": { "display": "صحيح مسلم،ترقيم عبد الباقي،4/2235–2236،ح2915–2916" }, "mode": "derived", "note": "أصل أبي قتادة في2915 يمر بأبي سعيد وأبي نضرة وأبي مسلمة وشعبة؛ وفرعا أم سلمة في2916 يلتقيان في خيرة، ثم سعيد أو الحسن. قوبلت2236 بصرياً؛2235 من سجل المصدر لا معاينة جديدة. السهم هنا إحالة إلى نص الكتاب لا اتصال مختصر يخفي الوسائط.", "quote": null, "sourceId": "source-sahih-muslim-abd-al-baqi", "sourceRef": "source-sahih-muslim-abd-al-baqi", "speaker": null, "summary": null, "url": null, "verification": "discovery_only", "verificationLimits": null }, { "attribution": null, "cardRef": null, "discovery": null, "id": "c-muslim2236", "kind": "evidence", "label": "غير أن في حديث النضر: أخبرني من هو خير مني: أبو قتادة. وفي حديث خالد بن الحارث قال: أراه يعني أبا قتادة.", "limitations": null, "locator": { "display": "صحيح مسلم،4/2236،ح2916 وأعلى الصفحة من2915" }, "mode": "quoted", "note": "قوبلت الصورة؛ وفيها سعيد عن أمه وأم سلمة وفرع ابن عون عن الحسن عن أمه، وليست فروع خيرة أصولاً صحابية متعددة.", "quote": "غير أن في حديث النضر: أخبرني من هو خير مني: أبو قتادة. وفي حديث خالد بن الحارث قال: أراه يعني أبا قتادة.", "sourceId": "source-sahih-muslim-abd-al-baqi", "sourceRef": "source-sahih-muslim-abd-al-baqi", "speaker": null, "summary": null, "url": null, "verification": "verified_scan", "verificationLimits": null }, { "attribution": null, "cardRef": null, "discovery": null, "id": "c-murad", "kind": "evidence", "label": "c-murad", "limitations": null, "locator": { "display": "مراد ملّا577،الورقتان16أ و92ب،موضعا447 و2812" }, "mode": "derived", "note": "بحسب سجل المصدر والبطاقة المقابلة: غياب جملة القتل في هذا الشاهد؛ لم تعد معاينة الورقتين في هذه الجولة، ولا يحسم الغياب سبب الاختلاف أو تاريخ الإدراج.", "quote": null, "sourceId": "source-sahih-bukhari-murad-molla-577-facsimile", "sourceRef": "source-sahih-bukhari-murad-molla-577-facsimile", "speaker": null, "summary": null, "url": null, "verification": "discovery_only", "verificationLimits": null }, { "attribution": null, "cardRef": null, "discovery": null, "id": "c-fath", "kind": "evidence", "label": "ولكن وقع في رواية ابن السكن وكريمة وغيرهما وكذا ثبت في نسخة الصغاني التي ذكر أنه قابلها على نسخة الفربري التي بخطه... ويظهر لي أن البخاري حذفها عمداً وذلك لنكتة خفية.", "limitations": null, "locator": { "display": "فتح الباري لابن حجر،المكتبة السلفية،1/542" }, "mode": "quoted", "note": "العبارتان ظاهرتان في الجزء المكشوف من الصورة؛ وسط الصفحة محجوب بالغلاف الملصق. الأولى شهادة نقل، والثانية تفسير ابن حجر، لا تصريح البخاري. لا دعوى معاينة جميع نسخ الإثبات.", "quote": "ولكن وقع في رواية ابن السكن وكريمة وغيرهما وكذا ثبت في نسخة الصغاني التي ذكر أنه قابلها على نسخة الفربري التي بخطه... ويظهر لي أن البخاري حذفها عمداً وذلك لنكتة خفية.", "sourceId": "source-fath-al-bari-ghulat-ali-maktaba-salafiyya", "sourceRef": "source-fath-al-bari-ghulat-ali-maktaba-salafiyya", "speaker": null, "summary": null, "url": null, "verification": "verified_scan", "verificationLimits": null }, { "attribution": null, "cardRef": null, "discovery": null, "id": "c-khalid-outside", "kind": "evidence", "label": "c-khalid-outside", "limitations": null, "locator": { "display": "دلائل النبوة،ج2،ص546–548؛ جرد بطاقة اختلاف النسخ" }, "mode": "derived", "note": "تسمي البطاقة طريق عبد العزيز بن المختار وطريق عبد الوهاب عن خالد عن عكرمة عن أبي سعيد خارج البخاري. هذه إحالة جرد لم تعد مقابلة أسانيده وصفحاته هنا؛ سجل الطبعة1408 قابل548–549 ولا تقلب إحالة البطاقة1405 إلى مطابقة جديدة.", "quote": null, "sourceId": "source-bayhaqi-ammar-khandaq-qalaji-1408", "sourceRef": "source-bayhaqi-ammar-khandaq-qalaji-1408", "speaker": null, "summary": null, "url": null, "verification": "discovery_only", "verificationLimits": null }, { "attribution": null, "cardRef": null, "discovery": null, "id": "c-humaydi-43", "kind": "evidence", "label": "c-humaydi-43", "limitations": null, "locator": { "display": "رسالة الحميدي،ط1،1447/2025،ص43–44" }, "mode": "derived", "note": "قوبلت الصفحتان وحواشيهما: يصحح المؤلف حكايتي نفي الصحة ويحيل إلى706–707، ويفضل رواية النفي. هذا حكمه لا حكم الخريطة، ولا يخصص عبارته بالطرق الكوفية المطولة.", "quote": null, "sourceId": "source-humaydi-tadeef-hadith-ammar-2025", "sourceRef": "source-humaydi-tadeef-hadith-ammar-2025", "speaker": null, "summary": null, "url": null, "verification": "verified_scan", "verificationLimits": null }, { "attribution": null, "cardRef": null, "discovery": null, "id": "c-humaydi-48", "kind": "evidence", "label": "c-humaydi-48", "limitations": null, "locator": { "display": "رسالة الحميدي،ص48 و51" }, "mode": "derived", "note": "قوبلت الصفحتان: يعمم نفي الجملة عن الصحيح وينسب إلى البخاري تركها صيانة للصحابة؛ يذكر نقولات إثبات ثم يخطئها. نسبة الباعث إليه لا تثبته عن البخاري.", "quote": null, "sourceId": "source-humaydi-tadeef-hadith-ammar-2025", "sourceRef": "source-humaydi-tadeef-hadith-ammar-2025", "speaker": null, "summary": null, "url": null, "verification": "verified_scan", "verificationLimits": null }, { "attribution": null, "cardRef": null, "discovery": null, "id": "c-humaydi-45", "kind": "evidence", "label": "c-humaydi-45", "limitations": null, "locator": { "display": "رسالة الحميدي،ص45 ح1 وص47 وحاشيتها" }, "mode": "derived", "note": "قوبلت المواضع: ينفي قتل عمار بصفين ويستنتج وفاته بالمدينة من إقامته فيها؛ وينفي مشاركة الأسماء التي عددها مع تسمية علي ومعاوية قائدين. نقد هذا الاستنتاج مستقل عن صحة الحديث؛ لا نسبة باعث نفسي للمؤلف.", "quote": null, "sourceId": "source-humaydi-tadeef-hadith-ammar-2025", "sourceRef": "source-humaydi-tadeef-hadith-ammar-2025", "speaker": null, "summary": null, "url": null, "verification": "verified_scan", "verificationLimits": null } ], "dependencyHash": "09c8c03aa9e2adf5", "diagnostics": { "errors": [], "warnings": [ "evidenceStatus=incomplete: 23/62 hotspots تحتاج تعيين المصدر والموضع" ] }, "evidenceStatus": "incomplete", "illal": [], "interactionIndex": { "hotspots": { "argument:a-counterquote": { "argumentRefs": [ "a-counterquote" ], "cardRefs": [], "citationRefs": [ "c-yaqub-hashiya", "c-rajab-yaqub" ], "evidenceRefs": [ "c-yaqub-hashiya", "c-rajab-yaqub" ], "icon": { "kindLabel": "حجة الدراسة", "meaning": "الدعوى وأدلتها وحدودها", "status": "documented", "statusLabel": "إحالة موضعية مقابلة", "summary": "حكاية يعقوب المقابلة يجب إظهارها مع تمييز ألفاظ السماع داخلها من تحقيق وصولها إلى أصل يعقوب. — لا تاريخ يثبت أنها آخر قول أحمد؛ الموضعان ناقلان للحكاية لا شاهدان على مجلسين مستقلين." }, "id": "argument:a-counterquote", "illaRefs": [], "kind": "argument", "label": "حكاية يعقوب المقابلة يجب إظهارها مع تمييز ألفاظ السماع داخلها من تحقيق وصولها إلى أصل يعقوب.", "matnRefs": [], "rendered": true, "requiresPinpoint": false, "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [ "c-yaqub-hashiya", "c-rajab-yaqub" ], "riwayaRefs": [], "sourceRefs": [ "source-kitab-al-imama-abu-yala-misk-ammar", "source-ibn-rajab-ammar-khandaq-ibn-al-jawzi-1417" ], "supportLevel": "exact", "target": { "argumentId": "a-counterquote" }, "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": [] }, "argument:a-critical-attribution": { "argumentRefs": [ "a-critical-attribution" ], "cardRefs": [], "citationRefs": [ "c-k721", "c-k721-note", "c-k722", "c-k722-note" ], "evidenceRefs": [ "c-k721", "c-k721-note", "c-k722", "c-k722-note" ], "icon": { "kindLabel": "حجة الدراسة", "meaning": "الدعوى وأدلتها وحدودها", "status": "documented", "statusLabel": "إحالة موضعية مقابلة", "summary": "نقد نسبة الحكاية يسبق نسبة حكمها إلى النقاد؛ لا يحمل لفظ العدد أو النفي قيد الطرق الكوفية المفصلة. — عدم معرفة المحقق ليس نفياً لوجود الرجل مطلقاً؛ وفرق إسماعيل الصفار/بن الفضل يحتاج مقابلة الأصل." }, "id": "argument:a-critical-attribution", "illaRefs": [], "kind": "argument", "label": "نقد نسبة الحكاية يسبق نسبة حكمها إلى النقاد؛ لا يحمل لفظ العدد أو النفي قيد الطرق الكوفية المفصلة.", "matnRefs": [], "rendered": true, "requiresPinpoint": false, "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [ "c-k721", "c-k721-note", "c-k722", "c-k722-note" ], "riwayaRefs": [], "sourceRefs": [ "source-al-sunna-al-khallal-zahrani" ], "supportLevel": "exact", "target": { "argumentId": "a-critical-attribution" }, "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": [] }, "argument:a-humaydi-claims": { "argumentRefs": [ "a-humaydi-claims" ], "cardRefs": [], "citationRefs": [ "c-humaydi-43", "c-humaydi-48", "c-humaydi-45" ], "evidenceRefs": [ "c-humaydi-43", "c-humaydi-48", "c-humaydi-45" ], "icon": { "kindLabel": "حجة الدراسة", "meaning": "الدعوى وأدلتها وحدودها", "status": "documented", "statusLabel": "إحالة موضعية مقابلة", "summary": "الحميدي يصحح حكايتي النفي ويعمم غياب اللفظ؛ نسبة قصد صيانة الصحابة للبخاري واستنتاج وفاة عمار من سكناه يحتاجان دليلاً خاصاً. — قراءة محددة الصفحات من PDF الأصلي؛ لا اتهام لباعث المؤلف، ولا إسقاط لجميع اعتراضاته أو تصحيح لكل أخبار المقتل." }, "id": "argument:a-humaydi-claims", "illaRefs": [], "kind": "argument", "label": "الحميدي يصحح حكايتي النفي ويعمم غياب اللفظ؛ نسبة قصد صيانة الصحابة للبخاري واستنتاج وفاة عمار من سكناه يحتاجان دليلاً خاصاً.", "matnRefs": [], "rendered": true, "requiresPinpoint": false, "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [ "c-humaydi-43", "c-humaydi-48", "c-humaydi-45" ], "riwayaRefs": [], "sourceRefs": [ "source-humaydi-tadeef-hadith-ammar-2025" ], "supportLevel": "exact", "target": { "argumentId": "a-humaydi-claims" }, "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": [] }, "argument:a-name-variant": { "argumentRefs": [ "a-name-variant" ], "cardRefs": [], "citationRefs": [ "c-k721", "c-rajab494" ], "evidenceRefs": [ "c-k721", "c-rajab494" ], "icon": { "kindLabel": "حجة الدراسة", "meaning": "الدعوى وأدلتها وحدودها", "status": "documented", "statusLabel": "إحالة موضعية مقابلة", "summary": "اسم ناقل المجلس مختلف: إسماعيل بن الفضل في الخلال721، وإسماعيل الصفار في نقل ابن رجب. — لا توحيد للرجلين ولا تصحيح آلي باختيار اسم معروف؛ لم تفحص مخطوطات العلل." }, "id": "argument:a-name-variant", "illaRefs": [], "kind": "argument", "label": "اسم ناقل المجلس مختلف: إسماعيل بن الفضل في الخلال721، وإسماعيل الصفار في نقل ابن رجب.", "matnRefs": [], "rendered": true, "requiresPinpoint": false, "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [ "c-k721", "c-rajab494" ], "riwayaRefs": [], "sourceRefs": [ "source-al-sunna-al-khallal-zahrani", "source-ibn-rajab-ammar-khandaq-ibn-al-jawzi-1417" ], "supportLevel": "exact", "target": { "argumentId": "a-name-variant" }, "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": [] }, "argument:a-source-roots": { "argumentRefs": [ "a-source-roots" ], "cardRefs": [], "citationRefs": [ "c-muslim", "c-muslim2236" ], "evidenceRefs": [ "c-muslim", "c-muslim2236" ], "icon": { "kindLabel": "حجة الدراسة", "meaning": "الدعوى وأدلتها وحدودها", "status": "needs_review", "statusLabel": "الإحالة موجودة؛ توثيق الحقل يحتاج استكمالاً", "summary": "نقد فرع أم سلمة لا يسقط أصل أبي قتادة بلا علة تخصه؛ اختلاف الأصول لا يحسم بمجرد التجاور في الباب. — الروابط هنا مواضع مقارنة، والسلاسل التفصيلية في مصدرها؛ لا حكم تواتر ولا إعفاء من التحقيق لاسم الصحيح." }, "id": "argument:a-source-roots", "illaRefs": [], "kind": "argument", "label": "نقد فرع أم سلمة لا يسقط أصل أبي قتادة بلا علة تخصه؛ اختلاف الأصول لا يحسم بمجرد التجاور في الباب.", "matnRefs": [], "rendered": true, "requiresPinpoint": true, "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [ "c-muslim", "c-muslim2236" ], "riwayaRefs": [], "sourceRefs": [ "source-sahih-muslim-abd-al-baqi" ], "supportLevel": "map_scope", "target": { "argumentId": "a-source-roots" }, "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": [] }, "argument:a-textual-not-stemma": { "argumentRefs": [ "a-textual-not-stemma" ], "cardRefs": [], "citationRefs": [ "c-murad", "c-fath", "c-khalid-outside" ], "evidenceRefs": [ "c-murad", "c-fath", "c-khalid-outside" ], "icon": { "kindLabel": "حجة الدراسة", "meaning": "الدعوى وأدلتها وحدودها", "status": "needs_review", "statusLabel": "الإحالة موجودة؛ توثيق الحقل يحتاج استكمالاً", "summary": "فرع مراد ملّا وشهادات ابن حجر وجرد خالد خارج البخاري مواد مقارنة؛ لا ترسم هنا شجرة مخطوطات أو سماعاً مباشراً لكريمة من الفربري. — سبب الاختلاف وأول ظهوره واستقلال الشهود باق في HOLD_BUKHARI_STEMMA؛ بعض الإحالات جرد لم يقابل ثانية." }, "id": "argument:a-textual-not-stemma", "illaRefs": [], "kind": "argument", "label": "فرع مراد ملّا وشهادات ابن حجر وجرد خالد خارج البخاري مواد مقارنة؛ لا ترسم هنا شجرة مخطوطات أو سماعاً مباشراً لكريمة من الفربري.", "matnRefs": [], "rendered": true, "requiresPinpoint": true, "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [ "c-murad", "c-fath", "c-khalid-outside" ], "riwayaRefs": [], "sourceRefs": [ "source-sahih-bukhari-murad-molla-577-facsimile", "source-fath-al-bari-ghulat-ali-maktaba-salafiyya", "source-bayhaqi-ammar-khandaq-qalaji-1408" ], "supportLevel": "map_scope", "target": { "argumentId": "a-textual-not-stemma" }, "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": [] }, "argument:a-yala-context": { "argumentRefs": [ "a-yala-context" ], "cardRefs": [], "citationRefs": [ "c-yala-context" ], "evidenceRefs": [ "c-yala-context" ], "icon": { "kindLabel": "حجة الدراسة", "meaning": "الدعوى وأدلتها وحدودها", "status": "documented", "statusLabel": "إحالة موضعية مقابلة", "summary": "نقل أبي يعلى للتضعيف يقع مع حجة فقهية تصوب قتال علي، فلا يستعار شاهداً مخالفاً لمذهبه بحذف السياق. — وجود القياس لا يثبت مقدماته التاريخية ولا يلزم الكتاب باختياره؛ لا يتمم السطر المقطوع من416." }, "id": "argument:a-yala-context", "illaRefs": [], "kind": "argument", "label": "نقل أبي يعلى للتضعيف يقع مع حجة فقهية تصوب قتال علي، فلا يستعار شاهداً مخالفاً لمذهبه بحذف السياق.", "matnRefs": [], "rendered": true, "requiresPinpoint": false, "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [ "c-yala-context" ], "riwayaRefs": [], "sourceRefs": [ "source-kitab-al-imama-abu-yala-misk-ammar" ], "supportLevel": "exact", "target": { "argumentId": "a-yala-context" }, "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": [] }, "city:ahmad": { "argumentRefs": [], "cardRefs": [], "citationRefs": [], "evidenceRefs": [], "icon": { "kindLabel": "مصر النقل", "meaning": "المصر المسجل ومرجعه؛ البيئة وحدها ليست جرحاً", "status": "missing", "statusLabel": "لم تسجل إحالة موضعية لهذا الحقل", "summary": "أحمد بن حنبل: غير معيّن" }, "id": "city:ahmad", "illaRefs": [], "kind": "city", "label": "أحمد بن حنبل: غير معيّن", "matnRefs": [], "rendered": true, "requiresPinpoint": true, "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [], "riwayaRefs": [], "sourceRefs": [], "supportLevel": "unresolved", "target": { "field": "city", "nodeId": "ahmad" }, "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": [] }, "city:al_khallal": { "argumentRefs": [], "cardRefs": [], "citationRefs": [], "evidenceRefs": [], "icon": { "kindLabel": "مصر النقل", "meaning": "المصر المسجل ومرجعه؛ البيئة وحدها ليست جرحاً", "status": "missing", "statusLabel": "لم تسجل إحالة موضعية لهذا الحقل", "summary": "أبو بكر الخلال: غير معيّن" }, "id": "city:al_khallal", "illaRefs": [], "kind": "city", "label": "أبو بكر الخلال: غير معيّن", "matnRefs": [], "rendered": true, "requiresPinpoint": true, "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [], "riwayaRefs": [], "sourceRefs": [], "supportLevel": "unresolved", "target": { "field": "city", "nodeId": "al_khallal" }, "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": [] }, "city:father_muhammad": { "argumentRefs": [], "cardRefs": [], "citationRefs": [], "evidenceRefs": [], "icon": { "kindLabel": "مصر النقل", "meaning": "المصر المسجل ومرجعه؛ البيئة وحدها ليست جرحاً", "status": "missing", "statusLabel": "لم تسجل إحالة موضعية لهذا الحقل", "summary": "والد محمد بن عبد الله: غير معيّن" }, "id": "city:father_muhammad", "illaRefs": [], "kind": "city", "label": "والد محمد بن عبد الله: غير معيّن", "matnRefs": [], "rendered": true, "requiresPinpoint": true, "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [], "riwayaRefs": [], "sourceRefs": [], "supportLevel": "unresolved", "target": { "field": "city", "nodeId": "father_muhammad" }, "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": [] }, "city:ismail": { "argumentRefs": [], "cardRefs": [], "citationRefs": [], "evidenceRefs": [], "icon": { "kindLabel": "مصر النقل", "meaning": "المصر المسجل ومرجعه؛ البيئة وحدها ليست جرحاً", "status": "missing", "statusLabel": "لم تسجل إحالة موضعية لهذا الحقل", "summary": "إسماعيل بن الفضل: غير معيّن" }, "id": "city:ismail", "illaRefs": [], "kind": "city", "label": "إسماعيل بن الفضل: غير معيّن", "matnRefs": [], "rendered": true, "requiresPinpoint": true, "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [], "riwayaRefs": [], "sourceRefs": [], "supportLevel": "unresolved", "target": { "field": "city", "nodeId": "ismail" }, "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": [] }, "city:muhammad": { "argumentRefs": [], "cardRefs": [], "citationRefs": [], "evidenceRefs": [], "icon": { "kindLabel": "مصر النقل", "meaning": "المصر المسجل ومرجعه؛ البيئة وحدها ليست جرحاً", "status": "missing", "statusLabel": "لم تسجل إحالة موضعية لهذا الحقل", "summary": "محمد بن عبد الله بن إبراهيم: غير معيّن" }, "id": "city:muhammad", "illaRefs": [], "kind": "city", "label": "محمد بن عبد الله بن إبراهيم: غير معيّن", "matnRefs": [], "rendered": true, "requiresPinpoint": true, "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [], "riwayaRefs": [], "sourceRefs": [], "supportLevel": "unresolved", "target": { "field": "city", "nodeId": "muhammad" }, "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": [] }, "city:tarsusi": { "argumentRefs": [], "cardRefs": [], "citationRefs": [], "evidenceRefs": [], "icon": { "kindLabel": "مصر النقل", "meaning": "المصر المسجل ومرجعه؛ البيئة وحدها ليست جرحاً", "status": "missing", "statusLabel": "لم تسجل إحالة موضعية لهذا الحقل", "summary": "أبو أمية محمد بن إبراهيم: غير معيّن" }, "id": "city:tarsusi", "illaRefs": [], "kind": "city", "label": "أبو أمية محمد بن إبراهيم: غير معيّن", "matnRefs": [], "rendered": true, "requiresPinpoint": true, "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [], "riwayaRefs": [], "sourceRefs": [], "supportLevel": "unresolved", "target": { "field": "city", "nodeId": "tarsusi" }, "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": [] }, "city:yaqub_shaybah": { "argumentRefs": [], "cardRefs": [], "citationRefs": [], "evidenceRefs": [], "icon": { "kindLabel": "مصر النقل", "meaning": "المصر المسجل ومرجعه؛ البيئة وحدها ليست جرحاً", "status": "missing", "statusLabel": "لم تسجل إحالة موضعية لهذا الحقل", "summary": "يعقوب بن شيبة في الحكاية: غير معيّن" }, "id": "city:yaqub_shaybah", "illaRefs": [], "kind": "city", "label": "يعقوب بن شيبة في الحكاية: غير معيّن", "matnRefs": [], "rendered": true, "requiresPinpoint": true, "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [], "riwayaRefs": [], "sourceRefs": [], "supportLevel": "unresolved", "target": { "field": "city", "nodeId": "yaqub_shaybah" }, "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": [] }, "edge:e-ahmad-father": { "argumentRefs": [], "cardRefs": [], "citationRefs": [ "c-k722", "c-k722-note" ], "evidenceRefs": [ "c-k722", "c-k722-note" ], "icon": { "kindLabel": "حلقة الرواية", "meaning": "صلة النقل بين طرفي السهم والروايات التي تحملها", "status": "documented", "statusLabel": "إحالة موضعية مقابلة", "summary": "سمعت" }, "id": "edge:e-ahmad-father", "illaRefs": [], "kind": "edge", "label": "سمعت", "matnRefs": [ "m-r722" ], "rendered": true, "requiresPinpoint": false, "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [ "c-k722", "c-k722-note" ], "riwayaRefs": [ "r722" ], "sourceRefs": [ "source-al-sunna-al-khallal-zahrani" ], "supportLevel": "exact", "target": { "edgeId": "e-ahmad-father", "from": "ahmad", "to": "father_muhammad" }, "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": [] }, "edge:e-ahmad-yaqub": { "argumentRefs": [], "cardRefs": [], "citationRefs": [ "c-yaqub-hashiya", "c-rajab-yaqub" ], "evidenceRefs": [ "c-yaqub-hashiya", "c-rajab-yaqub" ], "icon": { "kindLabel": "حلقة الرواية", "meaning": "صلة النقل بين طرفي السهم والروايات التي تحملها", "status": "documented", "statusLabel": "إحالة موضعية مقابلة", "summary": "سمعت (في الحكاية)" }, "id": "edge:e-ahmad-yaqub", "illaRefs": [], "kind": "edge", "label": "سمعت (في الحكاية)", "matnRefs": [ "m-r-yaqub-hashiya", "m-r-yaqub-rajab" ], "rendered": true, "requiresPinpoint": false, "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [ "c-yaqub-hashiya", "c-rajab-yaqub" ], "riwayaRefs": [ "r-yaqub-hashiya", "r-yaqub-rajab" ], "sourceRefs": [ "source-kitab-al-imama-abu-yala-misk-ammar", "source-ibn-rajab-ammar-khandaq-ibn-al-jawzi-1417" ], "supportLevel": "exact", "target": { "edgeId": "e-ahmad-yaqub", "from": "ahmad", "to": "yaqub_shaybah" }, "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": [] }, "edge:e-council-tarsusi": { "argumentRefs": [], "cardRefs": [], "citationRefs": [ "c-k721", "c-k721-note" ], "evidenceRefs": [ "c-k721", "c-k721-note" ], "icon": { "kindLabel": "حلقة الرواية", "meaning": "صلة النقل بين طرفي السهم والروايات التي تحملها", "status": "documented", "statusLabel": "إحالة موضعية مقابلة", "summary": "سمعت في حلقة" }, "id": "edge:e-council-tarsusi", "illaRefs": [], "kind": "edge", "label": "سمعت في حلقة", "matnRefs": [ "m-r721" ], "rendered": true, "requiresPinpoint": false, "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [ "c-k721", "c-k721-note" ], "riwayaRefs": [ "r721" ], "sourceRefs": [ "source-al-sunna-al-khallal-zahrani" ], "supportLevel": "exact", "target": { "edgeId": "e-council-tarsusi", "from": "halqat_baghdad", "to": "tarsusi" }, "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": [] }, "edge:e-father-muhammad": { "argumentRefs": [], "cardRefs": [], "citationRefs": [ "c-k722", "c-k722-note" ], "evidenceRefs": [ "c-k722", "c-k722-note" ], "icon": { "kindLabel": "حلقة الرواية", "meaning": "صلة النقل بين طرفي السهم والروايات التي تحملها", "status": "documented", "statusLabel": "إحالة موضعية مقابلة", "summary": "سمعت أبي" }, "id": "edge:e-father-muhammad", "illaRefs": [], "kind": "edge", "label": "سمعت أبي", "matnRefs": [ "m-r722" ], "rendered": true, "requiresPinpoint": false, "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [ "c-k722", "c-k722-note" ], "riwayaRefs": [ "r722" ], "sourceRefs": [ "source-al-sunna-al-khallal-zahrani" ], "supportLevel": "exact", "target": { "edgeId": "e-father-muhammad", "from": "father_muhammad", "to": "muhammad" }, "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": [] }, "edge:e-ismail-khallal": { "argumentRefs": [], "cardRefs": [], "citationRefs": [ "c-k721", "c-k721-note" ], "evidenceRefs": [ "c-k721", "c-k721-note" ], "icon": { "kindLabel": "حلقة الرواية", "meaning": "صلة النقل بين طرفي السهم والروايات التي تحملها", "status": "documented", "statusLabel": "إحالة موضعية مقابلة", "summary": "أخبرني" }, "id": "edge:e-ismail-khallal", "illaRefs": [], "kind": "edge", "label": "أخبرني", "matnRefs": [ "m-r721" ], "rendered": true, "requiresPinpoint": false, "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [ "c-k721", "c-k721-note" ], "riwayaRefs": [ "r721" ], "sourceRefs": [ "source-al-sunna-al-khallal-zahrani" ], "supportLevel": "exact", "target": { "edgeId": "e-ismail-khallal", "from": "ismail", "to": "al_khallal" }, "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": [] }, "edge:e-khallal-humaydi": { "argumentRefs": [], "cardRefs": [], "citationRefs": [ "c-humaydi-43" ], "evidenceRefs": [ "c-humaydi-43" ], "icon": { "kindLabel": "حلقة الرواية", "meaning": "صلة النقل بين طرفي السهم والروايات التي تحملها", "status": "documented", "statusLabel": "إحالة موضعية مقابلة", "summary": "نقل مصنف؛ لا سماع" }, "id": "edge:e-khallal-humaydi", "illaRefs": [], "kind": "edge", "label": "نقل مصنف؛ لا سماع", "matnRefs": [ "m-r-humaydi-reception" ], "rendered": true, "requiresPinpoint": false, "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [ "c-humaydi-43" ], "riwayaRefs": [ "r-humaydi-reception" ], "sourceRefs": [ "source-humaydi-tadeef-hadith-ammar-2025" ], "supportLevel": "exact", "target": { "edgeId": "e-khallal-humaydi", "from": "al_khallal", "to": "humaydi_2025" }, "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": [] }, "edge:e-khallal-yala": { "argumentRefs": [], "cardRefs": [], "citationRefs": [ "c-yala-matn", "c-yala-context" ], "evidenceRefs": [ "c-yala-matn", "c-yala-context" ], "icon": { "kindLabel": "حلقة الرواية", "meaning": "صلة النقل بين طرفي السهم والروايات التي تحملها", "status": "documented", "statusLabel": "إحالة موضعية مقابلة", "summary": "نقل مصنف؛ لا سماع" }, "id": "edge:e-khallal-yala", "illaRefs": [], "kind": "edge", "label": "نقل مصنف؛ لا سماع", "matnRefs": [ "m-r-yala-reception" ], "rendered": true, "requiresPinpoint": false, "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [ "c-yala-matn", "c-yala-context" ], "riwayaRefs": [ "r-yala-reception" ], "sourceRefs": [ "source-kitab-al-imama-abu-yala-misk-ammar" ], "supportLevel": "exact", "target": { "edgeId": "e-khallal-yala", "from": "al_khallal", "to": "abu_yala" }, "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": [] }, "edge:e-muhammad-khallal": { "argumentRefs": [], "cardRefs": [], "citationRefs": [ "c-k722", "c-k722-note" ], "evidenceRefs": [ "c-k722", "c-k722-note" ], "icon": { "kindLabel": "حلقة الرواية", "meaning": "صلة النقل بين طرفي السهم والروايات التي تحملها", "status": "documented", "statusLabel": "إحالة موضعية مقابلة", "summary": "سمعت" }, "id": "edge:e-muhammad-khallal", "illaRefs": [], "kind": "edge", "label": "سمعت", "matnRefs": [ "m-r722" ], "rendered": true, "requiresPinpoint": false, "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [ "c-k722", "c-k722-note" ], "riwayaRefs": [ "r722" ], "sourceRefs": [ "source-al-sunna-al-khallal-zahrani" ], "supportLevel": "exact", "target": { "edgeId": "e-muhammad-khallal", "from": "muhammad", "to": "al_khallal" }, "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": [] }, "edge:e-r-fath": { "argumentRefs": [], "cardRefs": [], "citationRefs": [ "c-fath" ], "evidenceRefs": [ "c-fath" ], "icon": { "kindLabel": "حلقة الرواية", "meaning": "صلة النقل بين طرفي السهم والروايات التي تحملها", "status": "documented", "statusLabel": "إحالة موضعية مقابلة", "summary": "موضع نص؛ لا سماع" }, "id": "edge:e-r-fath", "illaRefs": [], "kind": "edge", "label": "موضع نص؛ لا سماع", "matnRefs": [ "m-r-fath" ], "rendered": true, "requiresPinpoint": false, "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [ "c-fath" ], "riwayaRefs": [ "r-fath" ], "sourceRefs": [ "source-fath-al-bari-ghulat-ali-maktaba-salafiyya" ], "supportLevel": "exact", "target": { "edgeId": "e-r-fath", "from": "fath_statement", "to": "fath_book" }, "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": [] }, "edge:e-r-khalid": { "argumentRefs": [], "cardRefs": [], "citationRefs": [ "c-khalid-outside" ], "evidenceRefs": [ "c-khalid-outside" ], "icon": { "kindLabel": "حلقة الرواية", "meaning": "صلة النقل بين طرفي السهم والروايات التي تحملها", "status": "needs_review", "statusLabel": "الإحالة موجودة؛ توثيق الحقل يحتاج استكمالاً", "summary": "موضع نص؛ لا سماع" }, "id": "edge:e-r-khalid", "illaRefs": [], "kind": "edge", "label": "موضع نص؛ لا سماع", "matnRefs": [ "m-r-khalid" ], "rendered": true, "requiresPinpoint": true, "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [ "c-khalid-outside" ], "riwayaRefs": [ "r-khalid" ], "sourceRefs": [ "source-bayhaqi-ammar-khandaq-qalaji-1408" ], "supportLevel": "map_scope", "target": { "edgeId": "e-r-khalid", "from": "khalid_kharij", "to": "bayhaqi_book" }, "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": [] }, "edge:e-r-murad": { "argumentRefs": [], "cardRefs": [], "citationRefs": [ "c-murad" ], "evidenceRefs": [ "c-murad" ], "icon": { "kindLabel": "حلقة الرواية", "meaning": "صلة النقل بين طرفي السهم والروايات التي تحملها", "status": "needs_review", "statusLabel": "الإحالة موجودة؛ توثيق الحقل يحتاج استكمالاً", "summary": "موضع نص؛ لا سماع" }, "id": "edge:e-r-murad", "illaRefs": [], "kind": "edge", "label": "موضع نص؛ لا سماع", "matnRefs": [ "m-r-murad" ], "rendered": true, "requiresPinpoint": true, "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [ "c-murad" ], "riwayaRefs": [ "r-murad" ], "sourceRefs": [ "source-sahih-bukhari-murad-molla-577-facsimile" ], "supportLevel": "map_scope", "target": { "edgeId": "e-r-murad", "from": "murad_reading", "to": "murad_molla" }, "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": [] }, "edge:e-r-muslim": { "argumentRefs": [], "cardRefs": [], "citationRefs": [ "c-muslim", "c-muslim2236" ], "evidenceRefs": [ "c-muslim", "c-muslim2236" ], "icon": { "kindLabel": "حلقة الرواية", "meaning": "صلة النقل بين طرفي السهم والروايات التي تحملها", "status": "needs_review", "statusLabel": "الإحالة موجودة؛ توثيق الحقل يحتاج استكمالاً", "summary": "موضع نص؛ لا سماع" }, "id": "edge:e-r-muslim", "illaRefs": [], "kind": "edge", "label": "موضع نص؛ لا سماع", "matnRefs": [ "m-r-muslim" ], "rendered": true, "requiresPinpoint": true, "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [ "c-muslim", "c-muslim2236" ], "riwayaRefs": [ "r-muslim" ], "sourceRefs": [ "source-sahih-muslim-abd-al-baqi" ], "supportLevel": "map_scope", "target": { "edgeId": "e-r-muslim", "from": "muslim_roots", "to": "muslim_sahih" }, "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": [] }, "edge:e-tarsusi-ismail": { "argumentRefs": [], "cardRefs": [], "citationRefs": [ "c-k721", "c-k721-note" ], "evidenceRefs": [ "c-k721", "c-k721-note" ], "icon": { "kindLabel": "حلقة الرواية", "meaning": "صلة النقل بين طرفي السهم والروايات التي تحملها", "status": "documented", "statusLabel": "إحالة موضعية مقابلة", "summary": "سمعت" }, "id": "edge:e-tarsusi-ismail", "illaRefs": [], "kind": "edge", "label": "سمعت", "matnRefs": [ "m-r721" ], "rendered": true, "requiresPinpoint": false, "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [ "c-k721", "c-k721-note" ], "riwayaRefs": [ "r721" ], "sourceRefs": [ "source-al-sunna-al-khallal-zahrani" ], "supportLevel": "exact", "target": { "edgeId": "e-tarsusi-ismail", "from": "tarsusi", "to": "ismail" }, "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": [] }, "edge:e-yaqub-hashiya": { "argumentRefs": [], "cardRefs": [], "citationRefs": [ "c-yaqub-hashiya" ], "evidenceRefs": [ "c-yaqub-hashiya" ], "icon": { "kindLabel": "حلقة الرواية", "meaning": "صلة النقل بين طرفي السهم والروايات التي تحملها", "status": "documented", "statusLabel": "إحالة موضعية مقابلة", "summary": "نقل حاشية؛ لا سماع" }, "id": "edge:e-yaqub-hashiya", "illaRefs": [], "kind": "edge", "label": "نقل حاشية؛ لا سماع", "matnRefs": [ "m-r-yaqub-hashiya" ], "rendered": true, "requiresPinpoint": false, "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [ "c-yaqub-hashiya" ], "riwayaRefs": [ "r-yaqub-hashiya" ], "sourceRefs": [ "source-kitab-al-imama-abu-yala-misk-ammar" ], "supportLevel": "exact", "target": { "edgeId": "e-yaqub-hashiya", "from": "yaqub_shaybah", "to": "hashiya_yala" }, "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": [] }, "edge:e-yaqub-rajab": { "argumentRefs": [], "cardRefs": [], "citationRefs": [ "c-rajab-yaqub" ], "evidenceRefs": [ "c-rajab-yaqub" ], "icon": { "kindLabel": "حلقة الرواية", "meaning": "صلة النقل بين طرفي السهم والروايات التي تحملها", "status": "documented", "statusLabel": "إحالة موضعية مقابلة", "summary": "حكاية؛ لا سماع" }, "id": "edge:e-yaqub-rajab", "illaRefs": [], "kind": "edge", "label": "حكاية؛ لا سماع", "matnRefs": [ "m-r-yaqub-rajab" ], "rendered": true, "requiresPinpoint": false, "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [ "c-rajab-yaqub" ], "riwayaRefs": [ "r-yaqub-rajab" ], "sourceRefs": [ "source-ibn-rajab-ammar-khandaq-ibn-al-jawzi-1417" ], "supportLevel": "exact", "target": { "edgeId": "e-yaqub-rajab", "from": "yaqub_shaybah", "to": "ibn_rajab" }, "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": [] }, "matn:fath_statement": { "argumentRefs": [], "cardRefs": [], "citationRefs": [ "c-fath" ], "evidenceRefs": [ "c-fath" ], "icon": { "kindLabel": "لفظ المتن", "meaning": "النص أو الزيادة بلفظها وموضعها", "status": "documented", "statusLabel": "إحالة موضعية مقابلة", "summary": "شهادات إثبات الجملة" }, "id": "matn:fath_statement", "illaRefs": [], "kind": "matn", "label": "شهادات إثبات الجملة", "matnRefs": [], "rendered": true, "requiresPinpoint": false, "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [ "c-fath" ], "riwayaRefs": [], "sourceRefs": [ "source-fath-al-bari-ghulat-ali-maktaba-salafiyya" ], "supportLevel": "exact", "target": { "field": "matn", "nodeId": "fath_statement" }, "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": [] }, "matn:m-r-fath": { "argumentRefs": [], "cardRefs": [], "citationRefs": [ "c-fath" ], "evidenceRefs": [ "c-fath" ], "icon": { "kindLabel": "لفظ المتن", "meaning": "النص أو الزيادة بلفظها وموضعها", "status": "documented", "statusLabel": "إحالة موضعية مقابلة", "summary": "نقل وقوع الجملة في رواية ابن السكن وكريمة ونسخة الصغاني." }, "id": "matn:m-r-fath", "illaRefs": [], "kind": "matn", "label": "نقل وقوع الجملة في رواية ابن السكن وكريمة ونسخة الصغاني.", "matnRefs": [ "m-r-fath" ], "rendered": true, "requiresPinpoint": false, "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [ "c-fath" ], "riwayaRefs": [ "r-fath" ], "sourceRefs": [ "source-fath-al-bari-ghulat-ali-maktaba-salafiyya" ], "supportLevel": "exact", "target": { "matnId": "m-r-fath" }, "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": [] }, "matn:m-r-humaydi-reception": { "argumentRefs": [], "cardRefs": [], "citationRefs": [ "c-humaydi-43" ], "evidenceRefs": [ "c-humaydi-43" ], "icon": { "kindLabel": "لفظ المتن", "meaning": "النص أو الزيادة بلفظها وموضعها", "status": "documented", "statusLabel": "إحالة موضعية مقابلة", "summary": "يفضل المؤلف رواية النفي ويصحح حكايتيه." }, "id": "matn:m-r-humaydi-reception", "illaRefs": [], "kind": "matn", "label": "يفضل المؤلف رواية النفي ويصحح حكايتيه.", "matnRefs": [ "m-r-humaydi-reception" ], "rendered": true, "requiresPinpoint": false, "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [ "c-humaydi-43" ], "riwayaRefs": [ "r-humaydi-reception" ], "sourceRefs": [ "source-humaydi-tadeef-hadith-ammar-2025" ], "supportLevel": "exact", "target": { "matnId": "m-r-humaydi-reception" }, "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": [] }, "matn:m-r-khalid": { "argumentRefs": [], "cardRefs": [], "citationRefs": [ "c-khalid-outside" ], "evidenceRefs": [ "c-khalid-outside" ], "icon": { "kindLabel": "لفظ المتن", "meaning": "النص أو الزيادة بلفظها وموضعها", "status": "needs_review", "statusLabel": "الإحالة موجودة؛ توثيق الحقل يحتاج استكمالاً", "summary": "الجملة مذكورة في فرعي عبد العزيز وعبد الوهاب بحسب الجرد المنقول." }, "id": "matn:m-r-khalid", "illaRefs": [], "kind": "matn", "label": "الجملة مذكورة في فرعي عبد العزيز وعبد الوهاب بحسب الجرد المنقول.", "matnRefs": [ "m-r-khalid" ], "rendered": true, "requiresPinpoint": true, "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [ "c-khalid-outside" ], "riwayaRefs": [ "r-khalid" ], "sourceRefs": [ "source-bayhaqi-ammar-khandaq-qalaji-1408" ], "supportLevel": "map_scope", "target": { "matnId": "m-r-khalid" }, "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": [] }, "matn:m-r-murad": { "argumentRefs": [], "cardRefs": [], "citationRefs": [ "c-murad" ], "evidenceRefs": [ "c-murad" ], "icon": { "kindLabel": "لفظ المتن", "meaning": "النص أو الزيادة بلفظها وموضعها", "status": "needs_review", "statusLabel": "الإحالة موجودة؛ توثيق الحقل يحتاج استكمالاً", "summary": "جملة القتل غير مذكورة في الموضعين بحسب سجل المعاينة." }, "id": "matn:m-r-murad", "illaRefs": [], "kind": "matn", "label": "جملة القتل غير مذكورة في الموضعين بحسب سجل المعاينة.", "matnRefs": [ "m-r-murad" ], "rendered": true, "requiresPinpoint": true, "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [ "c-murad" ], "riwayaRefs": [ "r-murad" ], "sourceRefs": [ "source-sahih-bukhari-murad-molla-577-facsimile" ], "supportLevel": "map_scope", "target": { "matnId": "m-r-murad" }, "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": [] }, "matn:m-r-muslim": { "argumentRefs": [], "cardRefs": [], "citationRefs": [ "c-muslim", "c-muslim2236" ], "evidenceRefs": [ "c-muslim", "c-muslim2236" ], "icon": { "kindLabel": "لفظ المتن", "meaning": "النص أو الزيادة بلفظها وموضعها", "status": "needs_review", "statusLabel": "الإحالة موجودة؛ توثيق الحقل يحتاج استكمالاً", "summary": "تقتلك فئة باغية؛ تقتلك الفئة الباغية؛ تقتل عماراً الفئة الباغية." }, "id": "matn:m-r-muslim", "illaRefs": [], "kind": "matn", "label": "تقتلك فئة باغية؛ تقتلك الفئة الباغية؛ تقتل عماراً الفئة الباغية.", "matnRefs": [ "m-r-muslim" ], "rendered": true, "requiresPinpoint": true, "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [ "c-muslim", "c-muslim2236" ], "riwayaRefs": [ "r-muslim" ], "sourceRefs": [ "source-sahih-muslim-abd-al-baqi" ], "supportLevel": "map_scope", "target": { "matnId": "m-r-muslim" }, "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": [] }, "matn:m-r-yala-reception": { "argumentRefs": [], "cardRefs": [], "citationRefs": [ "c-yala-matn", "c-yala-context" ], "evidenceRefs": [ "c-yala-matn", "c-yala-context" ], "icon": { "kindLabel": "لفظ المتن", "meaning": "النص أو الزيادة بلفظها وموضعها", "status": "documented", "statusLabel": "إحالة موضعية مقابلة", "summary": "قال أبو بكر الخلال... وقال أبو أمية..." }, "id": "matn:m-r-yala-reception", "illaRefs": [], "kind": "matn", "label": "قال أبو بكر الخلال... وقال أبو أمية...", "matnRefs": [ "m-r-yala-reception" ], "rendered": true, "requiresPinpoint": false, "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [ "c-yala-matn", "c-yala-context" ], "riwayaRefs": [ "r-yala-reception" ], "sourceRefs": [ "source-kitab-al-imama-abu-yala-misk-ammar" ], "supportLevel": "exact", "target": { "matnId": "m-r-yala-reception" }, "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": [] }, "matn:m-r-yaqub-hashiya": { "argumentRefs": [], "cardRefs": [], "citationRefs": [ "c-yaqub-hashiya" ], "evidenceRefs": [ "c-yaqub-hashiya" ], "icon": { "kindLabel": "لفظ المتن", "meaning": "النص أو الزيادة بلفظها وموضعها", "status": "documented", "statusLabel": "إحالة موضعية مقابلة", "summary": "في هذا غير حديث صحيح عن النبي صلى الله عليه وسلم." }, "id": "matn:m-r-yaqub-hashiya", "illaRefs": [], "kind": "matn", "label": "في هذا غير حديث صحيح عن النبي صلى الله عليه وسلم.", "matnRefs": [ "m-r-yaqub-hashiya" ], "rendered": true, "requiresPinpoint": false, "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [ "c-yaqub-hashiya" ], "riwayaRefs": [ "r-yaqub-hashiya" ], "sourceRefs": [ "source-kitab-al-imama-abu-yala-misk-ammar" ], "supportLevel": "exact", "target": { "matnId": "m-r-yaqub-hashiya" }, "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": [] }, "matn:m-r-yaqub-rajab": { "argumentRefs": [], "cardRefs": [], "citationRefs": [ "c-rajab-yaqub" ], "evidenceRefs": [ "c-rajab-yaqub" ], "icon": { "kindLabel": "لفظ المتن", "meaning": "النص أو الزيادة بلفظها وموضعها", "status": "documented", "statusLabel": "إحالة موضعية مقابلة", "summary": "في هذا غير حديث صحيح عن النبي صلى الله عليه وسلم." }, "id": "matn:m-r-yaqub-rajab", "illaRefs": [], "kind": "matn", "label": "في هذا غير حديث صحيح عن النبي صلى الله عليه وسلم.", "matnRefs": [ "m-r-yaqub-rajab" ], "rendered": true, "requiresPinpoint": false, "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [ "c-rajab-yaqub" ], "riwayaRefs": [ "r-yaqub-rajab" ], "sourceRefs": [ "source-ibn-rajab-ammar-khandaq-ibn-al-jawzi-1417" ], "supportLevel": "exact", "target": { "matnId": "m-r-yaqub-rajab" }, "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": [] }, "matn:m-r721": { "argumentRefs": [], "cardRefs": [], "citationRefs": [ "c-k721", "c-k721-note" ], "evidenceRefs": [ "c-k721", "c-k721-note" ], "icon": { "kindLabel": "لفظ المتن", "meaning": "النص أو الزيادة بلفظها وموضعها", "status": "documented", "statusLabel": "إحالة موضعية مقابلة", "summary": "ما فيه حديث صحيح." }, "id": "matn:m-r721", "illaRefs": [], "kind": "matn", "label": "ما فيه حديث صحيح.", "matnRefs": [ "m-r721" ], "rendered": true, "requiresPinpoint": false, "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [ "c-k721", "c-k721-note" ], "riwayaRefs": [ "r721" ], "sourceRefs": [ "source-al-sunna-al-khallal-zahrani" ], "supportLevel": "exact", "target": { "matnId": "m-r721" }, "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": [] }, "matn:m-r722": { "argumentRefs": [], "cardRefs": [], "citationRefs": [ "c-k722", "c-k722-note" ], "evidenceRefs": [ "c-k722", "c-k722-note" ], "icon": { "kindLabel": "لفظ المتن", "meaning": "النص أو الزيادة بلفظها وموضعها", "status": "documented", "statusLabel": "إحالة موضعية مقابلة", "summary": "روي في تقتل عمار الفئة الباغية ثمانية وعشرون حديثاً ليس فيها حديث صحيح." }, "id": "matn:m-r722", "illaRefs": [], "kind": "matn", "label": "روي في تقتل عمار الفئة الباغية ثمانية وعشرون حديثاً ليس فيها حديث صحيح.", "matnRefs": [ "m-r722" ], "rendered": true, "requiresPinpoint": false, "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [ "c-k722", "c-k722-note" ], "riwayaRefs": [ "r722" ], "sourceRefs": [ "source-al-sunna-al-khallal-zahrani" ], "supportLevel": "exact", "target": { "matnId": "m-r722" }, "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": [] }, "matn:murad_reading": { "argumentRefs": [], "cardRefs": [], "citationRefs": [ "c-murad" ], "evidenceRefs": [ "c-murad" ], "icon": { "kindLabel": "لفظ المتن", "meaning": "النص أو الزيادة بلفظها وموضعها", "status": "needs_review", "statusLabel": "الإحالة موجودة؛ توثيق الحقل يحتاج استكمالاً", "summary": "غياب جملة القتل" }, "id": "matn:murad_reading", "illaRefs": [], "kind": "matn", "label": "غياب جملة القتل", "matnRefs": [], "rendered": true, "requiresPinpoint": true, "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [ "c-murad" ], "riwayaRefs": [], "sourceRefs": [ "source-sahih-bukhari-murad-molla-577-facsimile" ], "supportLevel": "map_scope", "target": { "field": "matn", "nodeId": "murad_reading" }, "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": [] }, "node:abu_yala": { "argumentRefs": [], "cardRefs": [], "citationRefs": [ "c-yala-matn", "c-yala-context" ], "evidenceRefs": [ "c-yala-matn", "c-yala-context" ], "icon": { "kindLabel": "الراوي أو العقدة", "meaning": "تعريف العنصر ونص بياناته", "status": "documented", "statusLabel": "إحالة موضعية مقابلة", "summary": "متن أبي يعلى:415–416 — ينقل عن الخلال؛ وحجته الفقهية تصوب قتال علي" }, "id": "node:abu_yala", "illaRefs": [], "kind": "node", "label": "متن أبي يعلى:415–416", "matnRefs": [], "rendered": true, "requiresPinpoint": false, "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [ "c-yala-matn", "c-yala-context" ], "riwayaRefs": [], "sourceRefs": [ "source-kitab-al-imama-abu-yala-misk-ammar" ], "supportLevel": "exact", "target": { "field": "identity", "nodeId": "abu_yala" }, "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": [] }, "node:ahmad": { "argumentRefs": [], "cardRefs": [], "citationRefs": [ "c-k722", "c-yaqub-hashiya" ], "evidenceRefs": [ "c-k722", "c-yaqub-hashiya" ], "icon": { "kindLabel": "الراوي أو العقدة", "meaning": "تعريف العنصر ونص بياناته", "status": "documented", "statusLabel": "إحالة موضعية مقابلة", "summary": "أحمد بن حنبل — يحكى عنه النفي والتصحيح؛ الترتيب الزمني غير مثبت" }, "id": "node:ahmad", "illaRefs": [], "kind": "node", "label": "أحمد بن حنبل", "matnRefs": [], "rendered": true, "requiresPinpoint": false, "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [ "c-k722", "c-yaqub-hashiya" ], "riwayaRefs": [], "sourceRefs": [ "source-al-sunna-al-khallal-zahrani", "source-kitab-al-imama-abu-yala-misk-ammar" ], "supportLevel": "exact", "target": { "field": "identity", "nodeId": "ahmad" }, "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": [] }, "node:al_khallal": { "argumentRefs": [], "cardRefs": [], "citationRefs": [ "c-k721", "c-k722" ], "evidenceRefs": [ "c-k721", "c-k722" ], "icon": { "kindLabel": "الراوي أو العقدة", "meaning": "تعريف العنصر ونص بياناته", "status": "documented", "statusLabel": "إحالة موضعية مقابلة", "summary": "أبو بكر الخلال — نقلا السنة721–722،2/463؛ بصيغتي أخبرني وسمعت" }, "id": "node:al_khallal", "illaRefs": [], "kind": "node", "label": "أبو بكر الخلال", "matnRefs": [], "rendered": true, "requiresPinpoint": false, "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [ "c-k721", "c-k722" ], "riwayaRefs": [], "sourceRefs": [ "source-al-sunna-al-khallal-zahrani" ], "supportLevel": "exact", "target": { "field": "identity", "nodeId": "al_khallal" }, "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": [] }, "node:bayhaqi_book": { "argumentRefs": [], "cardRefs": [], "citationRefs": [ "c-khalid-outside" ], "evidenceRefs": [ "c-khalid-outside" ], "icon": { "kindLabel": "الراوي أو العقدة", "meaning": "تعريف العنصر ونص بياناته", "status": "needs_review", "statusLabel": "الإحالة موجودة؛ توثيق الحقل يحتاج استكمالاً", "summary": "الدلائل2/546–548 — إحالة جرد؛ لم تعد مقابلة هذين الفرعين هنا" }, "id": "node:bayhaqi_book", "illaRefs": [], "kind": "node", "label": "الدلائل2/546–548", "matnRefs": [], "rendered": true, "requiresPinpoint": true, "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [ "c-khalid-outside" ], "riwayaRefs": [], "sourceRefs": [ "source-bayhaqi-ammar-khandaq-qalaji-1408" ], "supportLevel": "map_scope", "target": { "field": "identity", "nodeId": "bayhaqi_book" }, "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": [] }, "node:fath_book": { "argumentRefs": [], "cardRefs": [], "citationRefs": [ "c-fath" ], "evidenceRefs": [ "c-fath" ], "icon": { "kindLabel": "الراوي أو العقدة", "meaning": "تعريف العنصر ونص بياناته", "status": "documented", "statusLabel": "إحالة موضعية مقابلة", "summary": "ابن حجر:الفتح1/542 — يفصل النقل عن تفسيره لحذف البخاري" }, "id": "node:fath_book", "illaRefs": [], "kind": "node", "label": "ابن حجر:الفتح1/542", "matnRefs": [], "rendered": true, "requiresPinpoint": false, "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [ "c-fath" ], "riwayaRefs": [], "sourceRefs": [ "source-fath-al-bari-ghulat-ali-maktaba-salafiyya" ], "supportLevel": "exact", "target": { "field": "identity", "nodeId": "fath_book" }, "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": [] }, "node:fath_statement": { "argumentRefs": [], "cardRefs": [], "citationRefs": [ "c-fath" ], "evidenceRefs": [ "c-fath" ], "icon": { "kindLabel": "الراوي أو العقدة", "meaning": "تعريف العنصر ونص بياناته", "status": "documented", "statusLabel": "إحالة موضعية مقابلة", "summary": "شهادات إثبات الجملة — ابن السكن وكريمة والصغاني بحسب ابن حجر؛ لا معاينة لكل نسخة" }, "id": "node:fath_statement", "illaRefs": [], "kind": "node", "label": "شهادات إثبات الجملة", "matnRefs": [], "rendered": true, "requiresPinpoint": false, "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [ "c-fath" ], "riwayaRefs": [], "sourceRefs": [ "source-fath-al-bari-ghulat-ali-maktaba-salafiyya" ], "supportLevel": "exact", "target": { "field": "identity", "nodeId": "fath_statement" }, "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": [] }, "node:father_muhammad": { "argumentRefs": [], "cardRefs": [], "citationRefs": [ "c-k722", "c-k722-note" ], "evidenceRefs": [ "c-k722", "c-k722-note" ], "icon": { "kindLabel": "الراوي أو العقدة", "meaning": "تعريف العنصر ونص بياناته", "status": "documented", "statusLabel": "إحالة موضعية مقابلة", "summary": "والد محمد بن عبد الله — لم يجد المحقق ترجمة له" }, "id": "node:father_muhammad", "illaRefs": [], "kind": "node", "label": "والد محمد بن عبد الله", "matnRefs": [], "rendered": true, "requiresPinpoint": false, "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [ "c-k722", "c-k722-note" ], "riwayaRefs": [], "sourceRefs": [ "source-al-sunna-al-khallal-zahrani" ], "supportLevel": "exact", "target": { "field": "identity", "nodeId": "father_muhammad" }, "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": [] }, "node:halqat_baghdad": { "argumentRefs": [], "cardRefs": [], "citationRefs": [ "c-k721", "c-k721-note", "c-rajab494" ], "evidenceRefs": [ "c-k721", "c-k721-note", "c-rajab494" ], "icon": { "kindLabel": "الراوي أو العقدة", "meaning": "تعريف العنصر ونص بياناته", "status": "documented", "statusLabel": "إحالة موضعية مقابلة", "summary": "حلقة النقاد في الحكاية — أحمد وابن معين وأبو خيثمة والمعيطي؛ نسبة معلولة لا إجماع" }, "id": "node:halqat_baghdad", "illaRefs": [], "kind": "node", "label": "حلقة النقاد في الحكاية", "matnRefs": [], "rendered": true, "requiresPinpoint": false, "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [ "c-k721", "c-k721-note", "c-rajab494" ], "riwayaRefs": [], "sourceRefs": [ "source-al-sunna-al-khallal-zahrani", "source-ibn-rajab-ammar-khandaq-ibn-al-jawzi-1417" ], "supportLevel": "exact", "target": { "field": "identity", "nodeId": "halqat_baghdad" }, "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": [] }, "node:hashiya_yala": { "argumentRefs": [], "cardRefs": [], "citationRefs": [ "c-yaqub-hashiya" ], "evidenceRefs": [ "c-yaqub-hashiya" ], "icon": { "kindLabel": "الراوي أو العقدة", "meaning": "تعريف العنصر ونص بياناته", "status": "documented", "statusLabel": "إحالة موضعية مقابلة", "summary": "حاشية محقق أبي يعلى:416 — عن حاشية المبسوط؛ ليست متن أبي يعلى" }, "id": "node:hashiya_yala", "illaRefs": [], "kind": "node", "label": "حاشية محقق أبي يعلى:416", "matnRefs": [], "rendered": true, "requiresPinpoint": false, "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [ "c-yaqub-hashiya" ], "riwayaRefs": [], "sourceRefs": [ "source-kitab-al-imama-abu-yala-misk-ammar" ], "supportLevel": "exact", "target": { "field": "identity", "nodeId": "hashiya_yala" }, "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": [] }, "node:humaydi_2025": { "argumentRefs": [], "cardRefs": [], "citationRefs": [ "c-humaydi-43" ], "evidenceRefs": [ "c-humaydi-43" ], "icon": { "kindLabel": "الراوي أو العقدة", "meaning": "تعريف العنصر ونص بياناته", "status": "documented", "statusLabel": "إحالة موضعية مقابلة", "summary": "الحميدي:رسالة2025 — تصحيح حكايات النفي لا يغني عن نقد وسائطها" }, "id": "node:humaydi_2025", "illaRefs": [], "kind": "node", "label": "الحميدي:رسالة2025", "matnRefs": [], "rendered": true, "requiresPinpoint": false, "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [ "c-humaydi-43" ], "riwayaRefs": [], "sourceRefs": [ "source-humaydi-tadeef-hadith-ammar-2025" ], "supportLevel": "exact", "target": { "field": "identity", "nodeId": "humaydi_2025" }, "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": [] }, "node:ibn_rajab": { "argumentRefs": [], "cardRefs": [], "citationRefs": [ "c-rajab494", "c-rajab-yaqub" ], "evidenceRefs": [ "c-rajab494", "c-rajab-yaqub" ], "icon": { "kindLabel": "الراوي أو العقدة", "meaning": "تعريف العنصر ونص بياناته", "status": "documented", "statusLabel": "إحالة موضعية مقابلة", "summary": "ابن رجب:فتح الباري2/494 — يحفظ فرق اسم الناقل وحكاية التصحيح المقابلة" }, "id": "node:ibn_rajab", "illaRefs": [], "kind": "node", "label": "ابن رجب:فتح الباري2/494", "matnRefs": [], "rendered": true, "requiresPinpoint": false, "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [ "c-rajab494", "c-rajab-yaqub" ], "riwayaRefs": [], "sourceRefs": [ "source-ibn-rajab-ammar-khandaq-ibn-al-jawzi-1417" ], "supportLevel": "exact", "target": { "field": "identity", "nodeId": "ibn_rajab" }, "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": [] }, "node:ismail": { "argumentRefs": [], "cardRefs": [], "citationRefs": [ "c-k721", "c-k721-note", "c-rajab494" ], "evidenceRefs": [ "c-k721", "c-k721-note", "c-rajab494" ], "icon": { "kindLabel": "الراوي أو العقدة", "meaning": "تعريف العنصر ونص بياناته", "status": "documented", "statusLabel": "إحالة موضعية مقابلة", "summary": "إسماعيل بن الفضل — لم يعرفه المحقق؛ الاسم عند ابن رجب: إسماعيل الصفار" }, "id": "node:ismail", "illaRefs": [], "kind": "node", "label": "إسماعيل بن الفضل", "matnRefs": [], "rendered": true, "requiresPinpoint": false, "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [ "c-k721", "c-k721-note", "c-rajab494" ], "riwayaRefs": [], "sourceRefs": [ "source-al-sunna-al-khallal-zahrani", "source-ibn-rajab-ammar-khandaq-ibn-al-jawzi-1417" ], "supportLevel": "exact", "target": { "field": "identity", "nodeId": "ismail" }, "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": [] }, "node:khalid_kharij": { "argumentRefs": [], "cardRefs": [], "citationRefs": [ "c-khalid-outside" ], "evidenceRefs": [ "c-khalid-outside" ], "icon": { "kindLabel": "الراوي أو العقدة", "meaning": "تعريف العنصر ونص بياناته", "status": "needs_review", "statusLabel": "الإحالة موجودة؛ توثيق الحقل يحتاج استكمالاً", "summary": "جرد فرعي خالد خارج البخاري — عن عكرمة عن أبي سعيد؛ مقابلة الفروع التفصيلية باقية" }, "id": "node:khalid_kharij", "illaRefs": [], "kind": "node", "label": "جرد فرعي خالد خارج البخاري", "matnRefs": [], "rendered": true, "requiresPinpoint": true, "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [ "c-khalid-outside" ], "riwayaRefs": [], "sourceRefs": [ "source-bayhaqi-ammar-khandaq-qalaji-1408" ], "supportLevel": "map_scope", "target": { "field": "identity", "nodeId": "khalid_kharij" }, "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": [] }, "node:muhammad": { "argumentRefs": [], "cardRefs": [], "citationRefs": [ "c-k722", "c-k722-note" ], "evidenceRefs": [ "c-k722", "c-k722-note" ], "icon": { "kindLabel": "الراوي أو العقدة", "meaning": "تعريف العنصر ونص بياناته", "status": "documented", "statusLabel": "إحالة موضعية مقابلة", "summary": "محمد بن عبد الله بن إبراهيم — لم يجد المحقق ترجمته؛ لا تعيين بابن المنادي" }, "id": "node:muhammad", "illaRefs": [], "kind": "node", "label": "محمد بن عبد الله بن إبراهيم", "matnRefs": [], "rendered": true, "requiresPinpoint": false, "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [ "c-k722", "c-k722-note" ], "riwayaRefs": [], "sourceRefs": [ "source-al-sunna-al-khallal-zahrani" ], "supportLevel": "exact", "target": { "field": "identity", "nodeId": "muhammad" }, "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": [] }, "node:murad_molla": { "argumentRefs": [], "cardRefs": [], "citationRefs": [ "c-murad" ], "evidenceRefs": [ "c-murad" ], "icon": { "kindLabel": "الراوي أو العقدة", "meaning": "تعريف العنصر ونص بياناته", "status": "needs_review", "statusLabel": "الإحالة موجودة؛ توثيق الحقل يحتاج استكمالاً", "summary": "مراد ملّا577:16أ و92ب — موضعا كتاب؛ ليسا أصلين صحابيين" }, "id": "node:murad_molla", "illaRefs": [], "kind": "node", "label": "مراد ملّا577:16أ و92ب", "matnRefs": [], "rendered": true, "requiresPinpoint": true, "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [ "c-murad" ], "riwayaRefs": [], "sourceRefs": [ "source-sahih-bukhari-murad-molla-577-facsimile" ], "supportLevel": "map_scope", "target": { "field": "identity", "nodeId": "murad_molla" }, "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": [] }, "node:murad_reading": { "argumentRefs": [], "cardRefs": [], "citationRefs": [ "c-murad" ], "evidenceRefs": [ "c-murad" ], "icon": { "kindLabel": "الراوي أو العقدة", "meaning": "تعريف العنصر ونص بياناته", "status": "needs_review", "statusLabel": "الإحالة موجودة؛ توثيق الحقل يحتاج استكمالاً", "summary": "غياب جملة القتل — شهادة فرع مراد ملّا؛ سبب الاختلاف غير مقفل" }, "id": "node:murad_reading", "illaRefs": [], "kind": "node", "label": "غياب جملة القتل", "matnRefs": [], "rendered": true, "requiresPinpoint": true, "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [ "c-murad" ], "riwayaRefs": [], "sourceRefs": [ "source-sahih-bukhari-murad-molla-577-facsimile" ], "supportLevel": "map_scope", "target": { "field": "identity", "nodeId": "murad_reading" }, "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": [] }, "node:muslim_roots": { "argumentRefs": [], "cardRefs": [], "citationRefs": [ "c-muslim", "c-muslim2236" ], "evidenceRefs": [ "c-muslim", "c-muslim2236" ], "icon": { "kindLabel": "الراوي أو العقدة", "meaning": "تعريف العنصر ونص بياناته", "status": "needs_review", "statusLabel": "الإحالة موجودة؛ توثيق الحقل يحتاج استكمالاً", "summary": "أصلا أبي قتادة وأم سلمة — مقارنة أصول؛ لا اختصار لسند متصل ولا حكم تواتر" }, "id": "node:muslim_roots", "illaRefs": [], "kind": "node", "label": "أصلا أبي قتادة وأم سلمة", "matnRefs": [], "rendered": true, "requiresPinpoint": true, "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [ "c-muslim", "c-muslim2236" ], "riwayaRefs": [], "sourceRefs": [ "source-sahih-muslim-abd-al-baqi" ], "supportLevel": "map_scope", "target": { "field": "identity", "nodeId": "muslim_roots" }, "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": [] }, "node:muslim_sahih": { "argumentRefs": [], "cardRefs": [], "citationRefs": [ "c-muslim", "c-muslim2236" ], "evidenceRefs": [ "c-muslim", "c-muslim2236" ], "icon": { "kindLabel": "الراوي أو العقدة", "meaning": "تعريف العنصر ونص بياناته", "status": "needs_review", "statusLabel": "الإحالة موجودة؛ توثيق الحقل يحتاج استكمالاً", "summary": "صحيح مسلم:2915–2916 — اختلاف فروع أم سلمة لا ينتقل بلا دليل إلى أصل أبي قتادة" }, "id": "node:muslim_sahih", "illaRefs": [], "kind": "node", "label": "صحيح مسلم:2915–2916", "matnRefs": [], "rendered": true, "requiresPinpoint": true, "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [ "c-muslim", "c-muslim2236" ], "riwayaRefs": [], "sourceRefs": [ "source-sahih-muslim-abd-al-baqi" ], "supportLevel": "map_scope", "target": { "field": "identity", "nodeId": "muslim_sahih" }, "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": [] }, "node:tarsusi": { "argumentRefs": [], "cardRefs": [], "citationRefs": [ "c-k721" ], "evidenceRefs": [ "c-k721" ], "icon": { "kindLabel": "الراوي أو العقدة", "meaning": "تعريف العنصر ونص بياناته", "status": "documented", "statusLabel": "إحالة موضعية مقابلة", "summary": "أبو أمية محمد بن إبراهيم — يحكي ما سمعه في الحلقة" }, "id": "node:tarsusi", "illaRefs": [], "kind": "node", "label": "أبو أمية محمد بن إبراهيم", "matnRefs": [], "rendered": true, "requiresPinpoint": false, "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [ "c-k721" ], "riwayaRefs": [], "sourceRefs": [ "source-al-sunna-al-khallal-zahrani" ], "supportLevel": "exact", "target": { "field": "identity", "nodeId": "tarsusi" }, "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": [] }, "node:yaqub_shaybah": { "argumentRefs": [], "cardRefs": [], "citationRefs": [ "c-yaqub-hashiya", "c-rajab-yaqub" ], "evidenceRefs": [ "c-yaqub-hashiya", "c-rajab-yaqub" ], "icon": { "kindLabel": "الراوي أو العقدة", "meaning": "تعريف العنصر ونص بياناته", "status": "documented", "statusLabel": "إحالة موضعية مقابلة", "summary": "يعقوب بن شيبة في الحكاية — لفظ السماع داخل نقل؛ الوصول إلى أصله غير مقفل" }, "id": "node:yaqub_shaybah", "illaRefs": [], "kind": "node", "label": "يعقوب بن شيبة في الحكاية", "matnRefs": [], "rendered": true, "requiresPinpoint": false, "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [ "c-yaqub-hashiya", "c-rajab-yaqub" ], "riwayaRefs": [], "sourceRefs": [ "source-kitab-al-imama-abu-yala-misk-ammar", "source-ibn-rajab-ammar-khandaq-ibn-al-jawzi-1417" ], "supportLevel": "exact", "target": { "field": "identity", "nodeId": "yaqub_shaybah" }, "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": [] }, "verdict": { "argumentRefs": [], "cardRefs": [], "citationRefs": [ "c-k721-note", "c-k722-note", "c-yaqub-hashiya", "c-rajab494", "c-muslim", "c-murad", "c-fath" ], "evidenceRefs": [ "c-k721-note", "c-k722-note", "c-yaqub-hashiya", "c-rajab494", "c-muslim", "c-murad", "c-fath" ], "icon": { "kindLabel": "خلاصة الدراسة", "meaning": "النتيجة المنسوبة إلى الدراسة وحدود الاستدلال", "status": "needs_review", "statusLabel": "الإحالة موجودة؛ توثيق الحقل يحتاج استكمالاً", "summary": "حكايتا النفي معلولتان في النقل المعروض، ولهما نقل مقابل وفرق اسم لم يحسم. اختلاف النسخ ونقد الأصول بحثان مستقلان؛ لا إجماع بغداد ولا تواتر يستخرج من هذا الرسم." }, "id": "verdict", "illaRefs": [], "kind": "verdict", "label": "حكايتا النفي معلولتان في النقل المعروض، ولهما نقل مقابل وفرق اسم لم يحسم. اختلاف النسخ ونقد الأصول بحثان مستقلان؛ لا إجماع بغداد ولا تواتر يستخرج من هذا الرسم.", "matnRefs": [], "rendered": true, "requiresPinpoint": true, "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [ "c-k721-note", "c-k722-note", "c-yaqub-hashiya", "c-rajab494", "c-muslim", "c-murad", "c-fath" ], "riwayaRefs": [], "sourceRefs": [ "source-al-sunna-al-khallal-zahrani", "source-kitab-al-imama-abu-yala-misk-ammar", "source-ibn-rajab-ammar-khandaq-ibn-al-jawzi-1417", "source-sahih-muslim-abd-al-baqi", "source-sahih-bukhari-murad-molla-577-facsimile", "source-fath-al-bari-ghulat-ali-maktaba-salafiyya" ], "supportLevel": "map_scope", "target": { "field": "verdict" }, "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": [] } }, "order": [ "node:halqat_baghdad", "node:ahmad", "city:ahmad", "node:tarsusi", "city:tarsusi", "node:ismail", "city:ismail", "node:father_muhammad", "city:father_muhammad", "node:muhammad", "city:muhammad", "node:al_khallal", "city:al_khallal", "node:yaqub_shaybah", "city:yaqub_shaybah", "node:hashiya_yala", "node:ibn_rajab", "node:abu_yala", "node:muslim_roots", "node:muslim_sahih", "node:murad_reading", "matn:murad_reading", "node:murad_molla", "node:fath_statement", "matn:fath_statement", "node:fath_book", "node:khalid_kharij", "node:bayhaqi_book", "node:humaydi_2025", "edge:e-council-tarsusi", "edge:e-tarsusi-ismail", "edge:e-ismail-khallal", "edge:e-ahmad-father", "edge:e-father-muhammad", "edge:e-muhammad-khallal", "edge:e-ahmad-yaqub", "edge:e-yaqub-hashiya", "edge:e-yaqub-rajab", "edge:e-khallal-yala", "edge:e-khallal-humaydi", "edge:e-r-muslim", "edge:e-r-murad", "edge:e-r-fath", "edge:e-r-khalid", "matn:m-r721", "matn:m-r722", "matn:m-r-yaqub-hashiya", "matn:m-r-yaqub-rajab", "matn:m-r-yala-reception", "matn:m-r-humaydi-reception", "matn:m-r-muslim", "matn:m-r-murad", "matn:m-r-fath", "matn:m-r-khalid", "verdict", "argument:a-critical-attribution", "argument:a-name-variant", "argument:a-counterquote", "argument:a-textual-not-stemma", "argument:a-source-roots", "argument:a-yala-context", "argument:a-humaydi-claims" ] }, "map": { "chapter": "02_manuscript/bab_03_uthmaniyya_alawiyya/07_nasf_usturat_al_bughat_ibn_taymiyyah.md", "dependencyHash": "09c8c03aa9e2adf5", "id": "hadith_ammar_naqd_baghdad", "ref": "isnad:hadith_ammar_naqd_baghdad@v3", "sourceFile": "08_assets/isnad/hadith_ammar_naqd_baghdad.json", "sourceHash": "28e8bc10eed87c2e", "version": 3 }, "matnVariants": [ { "citationRefs": [ "c-k721", "c-k721-note" ], "evidenceRefs": [ "c-k721", "c-k721-note" ], "id": "m-r721", "riwayaRefs": [ "r721" ], "role": "nawa", "subject": null, "text": "ما فيه حديث صحيح." }, { "citationRefs": [ "c-k722", "c-k722-note" ], "evidenceRefs": [ "c-k722", "c-k722-note" ], "id": "m-r722", "riwayaRefs": [ "r722" ], "role": "nawa", "subject": null, "text": "روي في تقتل عمار الفئة الباغية ثمانية وعشرون حديثاً ليس فيها حديث صحيح." }, { "citationRefs": [ "c-yaqub-hashiya" ], "evidenceRefs": [ "c-yaqub-hashiya" ], "id": "m-r-yaqub-hashiya", "riwayaRefs": [ "r-yaqub-hashiya" ], "role": "nawa", "subject": null, "text": "في هذا غير حديث صحيح عن النبي صلى الله عليه وسلم." }, { "citationRefs": [ "c-rajab-yaqub" ], "evidenceRefs": [ "c-rajab-yaqub" ], "id": "m-r-yaqub-rajab", "riwayaRefs": [ "r-yaqub-rajab" ], "role": "nawa", "subject": null, "text": "في هذا غير حديث صحيح عن النبي صلى الله عليه وسلم." }, { "citationRefs": [ "c-yala-matn", "c-yala-context" ], "evidenceRefs": [ "c-yala-matn", "c-yala-context" ], "id": "m-r-yala-reception", "riwayaRefs": [ "r-yala-reception" ], "role": "nawa", "subject": null, "text": "قال أبو بكر الخلال... وقال أبو أمية..." }, { "citationRefs": [ "c-humaydi-43" ], "evidenceRefs": [ "c-humaydi-43" ], "id": "m-r-humaydi-reception", "riwayaRefs": [ "r-humaydi-reception" ], "role": "nawa", "subject": null, "text": "يفضل المؤلف رواية النفي ويصحح حكايتيه." }, { "citationRefs": [ "c-muslim", "c-muslim2236" ], "evidenceRefs": [ "c-muslim", "c-muslim2236" ], "id": "m-r-muslim", "riwayaRefs": [ "r-muslim" ], "role": "nawa", "subject": null, "text": "تقتلك فئة باغية؛ تقتلك الفئة الباغية؛ تقتل عماراً الفئة الباغية." }, { "citationRefs": [ "c-murad" ], "evidenceRefs": [ "c-murad" ], "id": "m-r-murad", "riwayaRefs": [ "r-murad" ], "role": "nawa", "subject": null, "text": "جملة القتل غير مذكورة في الموضعين بحسب سجل المعاينة." }, { "citationRefs": [ "c-fath" ], "evidenceRefs": [ "c-fath" ], "id": "m-r-fath", "riwayaRefs": [ "r-fath" ], "role": "nawa", "subject": null, "text": "نقل وقوع الجملة في رواية ابن السكن وكريمة ونسخة الصغاني." }, { "citationRefs": [ "c-khalid-outside" ], "evidenceRefs": [ "c-khalid-outside" ], "id": "m-r-khalid", "riwayaRefs": [ "r-khalid" ], "role": "nawa", "subject": null, "text": "الجملة مذكورة في فرعي عبد العزيز وعبد الوهاب بحسب الجرد المنقول." } ], "narrators": [ { "card": null, "city": null, "coverage": { "applicableFields": 3, "exactFields": 2, "status": "partial", "unresolvedFields": 1 }, "death": null, "evidenceRefs": { "identity": [ "c-k722", "c-yaqub-hashiya" ], "sub": [ "c-k722", "c-yaqub-hashiya" ] }, "fieldCoverage": { "card": { "cardRefs": [], "citationRefs": [], "evidenceRefs": [], "requiresPinpoint": false, "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [], "sourceRefs": [], "state": "not_applicable", "supportLevel": null, "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": [] }, "city": { "cardRefs": [], "citationRefs": [], "evidenceRefs": [], "requiresPinpoint": true, "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [], "sourceRefs": [], "state": "missing_value", "supportLevel": "unresolved", "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": [] }, "death": { "cardRefs": [], "citationRefs": [], "evidenceRefs": [], "requiresPinpoint": false, "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [], "sourceRefs": [], "state": "not_applicable", "supportLevel": null, "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": [] }, "flags": { "cardRefs": [], "citationRefs": [], "evidenceRefs": [], "items": {}, "requiresPinpoint": false, "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [], "sourceRefs": [], "state": "not_applicable", "supportLevel": null, "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": [] }, "hukm": { "cardRefs": [], "citationRefs": [], "evidenceRefs": [], "requiresPinpoint": false, "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [], "sourceRefs": [], "state": "not_applicable", "supportLevel": null, "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": [] }, "label": { "cardRefs": [], "citationRefs": [ "c-k722", "c-yaqub-hashiya" ], "evidenceRefs": [ "c-k722", "c-yaqub-hashiya" ], "requiresPinpoint": false, "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [ "c-k722", "c-yaqub-hashiya" ], "sourceRefs": [ "source-al-sunna-al-khallal-zahrani", "source-kitab-al-imama-abu-yala-misk-ammar" ], "state": "exact", "supportLevel": "exact", "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": [] }, "sub": { "cardRefs": [], "citationRefs": [ "c-k722", "c-yaqub-hashiya" ], "evidenceRefs": [ "c-k722", "c-yaqub-hashiya" ], "requiresPinpoint": false, "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [ "c-k722", "c-yaqub-hashiya" ], "sourceRefs": [ "source-al-sunna-al-khallal-zahrani", "source-kitab-al-imama-abu-yala-misk-ammar" ], "state": "exact", "supportLevel": "exact", "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": [] } }, "flags": [], "hukm": null, "id": "ahmad", "kind": "rawi", "label": "أحمد بن حنبل", "sub": "يحكى عنه النفي والتصحيح؛ الترتيب الزمني غير مثبت" }, { "card": null, "city": null, "coverage": { "applicableFields": 3, "exactFields": 2, "status": "partial", "unresolvedFields": 1 }, "death": null, "evidenceRefs": { "identity": [ "c-k721" ], "sub": [ "c-k721" ] }, "fieldCoverage": { "card": { "cardRefs": [], "citationRefs": [], "evidenceRefs": [], "requiresPinpoint": false, "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [], "sourceRefs": [], "state": "not_applicable", "supportLevel": null, "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": [] }, "city": { "cardRefs": [], "citationRefs": [], "evidenceRefs": [], "requiresPinpoint": true, "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [], "sourceRefs": [], "state": "missing_value", "supportLevel": "unresolved", "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": [] }, "death": { "cardRefs": [], "citationRefs": [], "evidenceRefs": [], "requiresPinpoint": false, "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [], "sourceRefs": [], "state": "not_applicable", "supportLevel": null, "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": [] }, "flags": { "cardRefs": [], "citationRefs": [], "evidenceRefs": [], "items": {}, "requiresPinpoint": false, "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [], "sourceRefs": [], "state": "not_applicable", "supportLevel": null, "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": [] }, "hukm": { "cardRefs": [], "citationRefs": [], "evidenceRefs": [], "requiresPinpoint": false, "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [], "sourceRefs": [], "state": "not_applicable", "supportLevel": null, "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": [] }, "label": { "cardRefs": [], "citationRefs": [ "c-k721" ], "evidenceRefs": [ "c-k721" ], "requiresPinpoint": false, "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [ "c-k721" ], "sourceRefs": [ "source-al-sunna-al-khallal-zahrani" ], "state": "exact", "supportLevel": "exact", "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": [] }, "sub": { "cardRefs": [], "citationRefs": [ "c-k721" ], "evidenceRefs": [ "c-k721" ], "requiresPinpoint": false, "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [ "c-k721" ], "sourceRefs": [ "source-al-sunna-al-khallal-zahrani" ], "state": "exact", "supportLevel": "exact", "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": [] } }, "flags": [], "hukm": null, "id": "tarsusi", "kind": "rawi", "label": "أبو أمية محمد بن إبراهيم", "sub": "يحكي ما سمعه في الحلقة" }, { "card": null, "city": null, "coverage": { "applicableFields": 3, "exactFields": 2, "status": "partial", "unresolvedFields": 1 }, "death": null, "evidenceRefs": { "identity": [ "c-k721" ], "sub": [ "c-k721-note", "c-rajab494" ] }, "fieldCoverage": { "card": { "cardRefs": [], "citationRefs": [], "evidenceRefs": [], "requiresPinpoint": false, "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [], "sourceRefs": [], "state": "not_applicable", "supportLevel": null, "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": [] }, "city": { "cardRefs": [], "citationRefs": [], "evidenceRefs": [], "requiresPinpoint": true, "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [], "sourceRefs": [], "state": "missing_value", "supportLevel": "unresolved", "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": [] }, "death": { "cardRefs": [], "citationRefs": [], "evidenceRefs": [], "requiresPinpoint": false, "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [], "sourceRefs": [], "state": "not_applicable", "supportLevel": null, "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": [] }, "flags": { "cardRefs": [], "citationRefs": [], "evidenceRefs": [], "items": {}, "requiresPinpoint": false, "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [], "sourceRefs": [], "state": "not_applicable", "supportLevel": null, "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": [] }, "hukm": { "cardRefs": [], "citationRefs": [], "evidenceRefs": [], "requiresPinpoint": false, "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [], "sourceRefs": [], "state": "not_applicable", "supportLevel": null, "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": [] }, "label": { "cardRefs": [], "citationRefs": [ "c-k721" ], "evidenceRefs": [ "c-k721" ], "requiresPinpoint": false, "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [ "c-k721" ], "sourceRefs": [ "source-al-sunna-al-khallal-zahrani" ], "state": "exact", "supportLevel": "exact", "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": [] }, "sub": { "cardRefs": [], "citationRefs": [ "c-k721-note", "c-rajab494" ], "evidenceRefs": [ "c-k721-note", "c-rajab494" ], "requiresPinpoint": false, "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [ "c-k721-note", "c-rajab494" ], "sourceRefs": [ "source-al-sunna-al-khallal-zahrani", "source-ibn-rajab-ammar-khandaq-ibn-al-jawzi-1417" ], "state": "exact", "supportLevel": "exact", "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": [] } }, "flags": [], "hukm": null, "id": "ismail", "kind": "rawi", "label": "إسماعيل بن الفضل", "sub": "لم يعرفه المحقق؛ الاسم عند ابن رجب: إسماعيل الصفار" }, { "card": null, "city": null, "coverage": { "applicableFields": 3, "exactFields": 2, "status": "partial", "unresolvedFields": 1 }, "death": null, "evidenceRefs": { "identity": [ "c-k722" ], "sub": [ "c-k722-note" ] }, "fieldCoverage": { "card": { "cardRefs": [], "citationRefs": [], "evidenceRefs": [], "requiresPinpoint": false, "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [], "sourceRefs": [], "state": "not_applicable", "supportLevel": null, "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": [] }, "city": { "cardRefs": [], "citationRefs": [], "evidenceRefs": [], "requiresPinpoint": true, "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [], "sourceRefs": [], "state": "missing_value", "supportLevel": "unresolved", "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": [] }, "death": { "cardRefs": [], "citationRefs": [], "evidenceRefs": [], "requiresPinpoint": false, "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [], "sourceRefs": [], "state": "not_applicable", "supportLevel": null, "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": [] }, "flags": { "cardRefs": [], "citationRefs": [], "evidenceRefs": [], "items": {}, "requiresPinpoint": false, "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [], "sourceRefs": [], "state": "not_applicable", "supportLevel": null, "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": [] }, "hukm": { "cardRefs": [], "citationRefs": [], "evidenceRefs": [], "requiresPinpoint": false, "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [], "sourceRefs": [], "state": "not_applicable", "supportLevel": null, "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": [] }, "label": { "cardRefs": [], "citationRefs": [ "c-k722" ], "evidenceRefs": [ "c-k722" ], "requiresPinpoint": false, "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [ "c-k722" ], "sourceRefs": [ "source-al-sunna-al-khallal-zahrani" ], "state": "exact", "supportLevel": "exact", "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": [] }, "sub": { "cardRefs": [], "citationRefs": [ "c-k722-note" ], "evidenceRefs": [ "c-k722-note" ], "requiresPinpoint": false, "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [ "c-k722-note" ], "sourceRefs": [ "source-al-sunna-al-khallal-zahrani" ], "state": "exact", "supportLevel": "exact", "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": [] } }, "flags": [], "hukm": null, "id": "father_muhammad", "kind": "rawi", "label": "والد محمد بن عبد الله", "sub": "لم يجد المحقق ترجمة له" }, { "card": null, "city": null, "coverage": { "applicableFields": 3, "exactFields": 2, "status": "partial", "unresolvedFields": 1 }, "death": null, "evidenceRefs": { "identity": [ "c-k722" ], "sub": [ "c-k722-note" ] }, "fieldCoverage": { "card": { "cardRefs": [], "citationRefs": [], "evidenceRefs": [], "requiresPinpoint": false, "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [], "sourceRefs": [], "state": "not_applicable", "supportLevel": null, "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": [] }, "city": { "cardRefs": [], "citationRefs": [], "evidenceRefs": [], "requiresPinpoint": true, "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [], "sourceRefs": [], "state": "missing_value", "supportLevel": "unresolved", "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": [] }, "death": { "cardRefs": [], "citationRefs": [], "evidenceRefs": [], "requiresPinpoint": false, "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [], "sourceRefs": [], "state": "not_applicable", "supportLevel": null, "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": [] }, "flags": { "cardRefs": [], "citationRefs": [], "evidenceRefs": [], "items": {}, "requiresPinpoint": false, "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [], "sourceRefs": [], "state": "not_applicable", "supportLevel": null, "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": [] }, "hukm": { "cardRefs": [], "citationRefs": [], "evidenceRefs": [], "requiresPinpoint": false, "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [], "sourceRefs": [], "state": "not_applicable", "supportLevel": null, "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": [] }, "label": { "cardRefs": [], "citationRefs": [ "c-k722" ], "evidenceRefs": [ "c-k722" ], "requiresPinpoint": false, "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [ "c-k722" ], "sourceRefs": [ "source-al-sunna-al-khallal-zahrani" ], "state": "exact", "supportLevel": "exact", "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": [] }, "sub": { "cardRefs": [], "citationRefs": [ "c-k722-note" ], "evidenceRefs": [ "c-k722-note" ], "requiresPinpoint": false, "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [ "c-k722-note" ], "sourceRefs": [ "source-al-sunna-al-khallal-zahrani" ], "state": "exact", "supportLevel": "exact", "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": [] } }, "flags": [], "hukm": null, "id": "muhammad", "kind": "rawi", "label": "محمد بن عبد الله بن إبراهيم", "sub": "لم يجد المحقق ترجمته؛ لا تعيين بابن المنادي" }, { "card": null, "city": null, "coverage": { "applicableFields": 3, "exactFields": 2, "status": "partial", "unresolvedFields": 1 }, "death": null, "evidenceRefs": { "identity": [ "c-k721", "c-k722" ], "sub": [ "c-k721", "c-k722" ] }, "fieldCoverage": { "card": { "cardRefs": [], "citationRefs": [], "evidenceRefs": [], "requiresPinpoint": false, "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [], "sourceRefs": [], "state": "not_applicable", "supportLevel": null, "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": [] }, "city": { "cardRefs": [], "citationRefs": [], "evidenceRefs": [], "requiresPinpoint": true, "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [], "sourceRefs": [], "state": "missing_value", "supportLevel": "unresolved", "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": [] }, "death": { "cardRefs": [], "citationRefs": [], "evidenceRefs": [], "requiresPinpoint": false, "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [], "sourceRefs": [], "state": "not_applicable", "supportLevel": null, "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": [] }, "flags": { "cardRefs": [], "citationRefs": [], "evidenceRefs": [], "items": {}, "requiresPinpoint": false, "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [], "sourceRefs": [], "state": "not_applicable", "supportLevel": null, "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": [] }, "hukm": { "cardRefs": [], "citationRefs": [], "evidenceRefs": [], "requiresPinpoint": false, "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [], "sourceRefs": [], "state": "not_applicable", "supportLevel": null, "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": [] }, "label": { "cardRefs": [], "citationRefs": [ "c-k721", "c-k722" ], "evidenceRefs": [ "c-k721", "c-k722" ], "requiresPinpoint": false, "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [ "c-k721", "c-k722" ], "sourceRefs": [ "source-al-sunna-al-khallal-zahrani" ], "state": "exact", "supportLevel": "exact", "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": [] }, "sub": { "cardRefs": [], "citationRefs": [ "c-k721", "c-k722" ], "evidenceRefs": [ "c-k721", "c-k722" ], "requiresPinpoint": false, "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [ "c-k721", "c-k722" ], "sourceRefs": [ "source-al-sunna-al-khallal-zahrani" ], "state": "exact", "supportLevel": "exact", "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": [] } }, "flags": [], "hukm": null, "id": "al_khallal", "kind": "rawi", "label": "أبو بكر الخلال", "sub": "نقلا السنة721–722،2/463؛ بصيغتي أخبرني وسمعت" }, { "card": null, "city": null, "coverage": { "applicableFields": 3, "exactFields": 2, "status": "partial", "unresolvedFields": 1 }, "death": null, "evidenceRefs": { "identity": [ "c-yaqub-hashiya", "c-rajab-yaqub" ], "sub": [ "c-yaqub-hashiya", "c-rajab-yaqub" ] }, "fieldCoverage": { "card": { "cardRefs": [], "citationRefs": [], "evidenceRefs": [], "requiresPinpoint": false, "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [], "sourceRefs": [], "state": "not_applicable", "supportLevel": null, "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": [] }, "city": { "cardRefs": [], "citationRefs": [], "evidenceRefs": [], "requiresPinpoint": true, "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [], "sourceRefs": [], "state": "missing_value", "supportLevel": "unresolved", "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": [] }, "death": { "cardRefs": [], "citationRefs": [], "evidenceRefs": [], "requiresPinpoint": false, "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [], "sourceRefs": [], "state": "not_applicable", "supportLevel": null, "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": [] }, "flags": { "cardRefs": [], "citationRefs": [], "evidenceRefs": [], "items": {}, "requiresPinpoint": false, "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [], "sourceRefs": [], "state": "not_applicable", "supportLevel": null, "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": [] }, "hukm": { "cardRefs": [], "citationRefs": [], "evidenceRefs": [], "requiresPinpoint": false, "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [], "sourceRefs": [], "state": "not_applicable", "supportLevel": null, "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": [] }, "label": { "cardRefs": [], "citationRefs": [ "c-yaqub-hashiya", "c-rajab-yaqub" ], "evidenceRefs": [ "c-yaqub-hashiya", "c-rajab-yaqub" ], "requiresPinpoint": false, "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [ "c-yaqub-hashiya", "c-rajab-yaqub" ], "sourceRefs": [ "source-kitab-al-imama-abu-yala-misk-ammar", "source-ibn-rajab-ammar-khandaq-ibn-al-jawzi-1417" ], "state": "exact", "supportLevel": "exact", "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": [] }, "sub": { "cardRefs": [], "citationRefs": [ "c-yaqub-hashiya", "c-rajab-yaqub" ], "evidenceRefs": [ "c-yaqub-hashiya", "c-rajab-yaqub" ], "requiresPinpoint": false, "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [ "c-yaqub-hashiya", "c-rajab-yaqub" ], "sourceRefs": [ "source-kitab-al-imama-abu-yala-misk-ammar", "source-ibn-rajab-ammar-khandaq-ibn-al-jawzi-1417" ], "state": "exact", "supportLevel": "exact", "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": [] } }, "flags": [], "hukm": null, "id": "yaqub_shaybah", "kind": "rawi", "label": "يعقوب بن شيبة في الحكاية", "sub": "لفظ السماع داخل نقل؛ الوصول إلى أصله غير مقفل" } ], "pipelineVersion": 7, "provenanceCoverage": { "arguments": 7, "citations": 17, "dependencyHash": "09c8c03aa9e2adf5", "exactHotspots": 39, "illal": 0, "matnVariants": 10, "missingCards": [], "missingSources": [], "narrators": 7, "percentExact": 62.9, "riwayat": 10, "status": "incomplete", "totalHotspots": 62, "transmissions": 15, "unresolvedHotspots": 23 }, "provenanceStatus": "draft", "provenanceVersion": 2, "records": { "cards": [ { "contentHash": "f8e16b1350f47a3f", "exists": true, "id": "evidence-ammar-murad-molla-muslim-abdallah-amr-isnad", "path": "05_cards/evidences/ammar-murad-molla-muslim-abdallah-amr-isnad.md", "status": "verified_with_limits", "title": "مراد ملّا وعلل الطرق وخبر عبد الله بن عمرو: طبقات إثبات لا حكم واحد" }, { "contentHash": "be730912418ea7f3", "exists": true, "id": "evidence-hadith-ammar-ikhtilaf-nusakh-wazifa-siyasiyya", "path": "05_cards/evidences/hadith-ammar-ikhtilaf-nusakh-wazifa-siyasiyya.md", "status": "verified_with_limits", "title": "حديث عمّار: اختلاف النسخ وحدود التلقي" }, { "contentHash": "e6212379d99ca0a1", "exists": true, "id": "evidence-abu-yala-ammar-siyaq-al-taawil-wa-qital", "path": "05_cards/evidences/abu-yala-ammar-siyaq-al-taawil-wa-qital.md", "status": "verified_with_limits", "title": "أبو يعلى: التأويل وحكاية التضعيف داخل بناء فقهي يصحح القتال" }, { "contentHash": "3bce877f9e041621", "exists": true, "id": "evidence-hadith-ammar-tarikh-al-tadif-tabaqat-al-naql", "path": "05_cards/evidences/hadith-ammar-tarikh-al-tadif-tabaqat-al-naql.md", "status": "verified_with_limits", "title": "تاريخ تضعيف حديث عمّار: اعتراض مثبت لا إجماع على الإبطال" }, { "contentHash": "b2a7938cc6829974", "exists": true, "id": "evidence-ibn-taymiyya-thubut-ammar-wa-qital-fitna-four-layers", "path": "05_cards/evidences/ibn-taymiyya-thubut-ammar-wa-qital-fitna-four-layers.md", "status": "verified", "title": "ابن تيمية: ثبوت حديث عمّار لا يساوي وجوب كل قتال" }, { "contentHash": "1c4df8225c3a9073", "exists": true, "id": "evidence-naqd-tadeef-hadith-ammar-fawzi-al-humaydi", "path": "05_cards/evidences/evidence-naqd-tadeef-hadith-ammar-fawzi-al-humaydi.md", "status": "verified_with_limits", "title": "رسالة الحميدي في حديث عمّار: أين تحمل المقدمة النتيجة، وأين تنقطع؟" } ], "sources": [ { "author": "أبو بكر أحمد بن محمد بن هارون الخلال", "authorDeathHijri": "311", "contentHash": "d215c59275dd768d", "exists": true, "id": "source-al-sunna-al-khallal-zahrani", "path": "04_source_bank/source_al_sunna_al_khallal_zahrani.md", "status": "verified", "title": "السنة" }, { "author": "محمد بن الحسين بن محمد بن خلف أبو يعلى ابن الفراء البغدادي الحنبلي", "authorDeathHijri": "458", "contentHash": "9618892d53b51cb5", "exists": true, "id": "source-kitab-al-imama-abu-yala-misk-ammar", "path": "04_source_bank/source-kitab-al-imama-abu-yala-misk-ammar.md", "status": "verified_with_limits", "title": "كتاب الإمامة: إثبات إمامة الخلفاء الأربعة" }, { "author": "عبد الرحمن بن أحمد ابن رجب الحنبلي", "authorDeathHijri": "795", "contentHash": "b1c5c863742e60e5", "exists": true, "id": "source-ibn-rajab-ammar-khandaq-ibn-al-jawzi-1417", "path": "04_source_bank/source-ibn-rajab-ammar-khandaq-ibn-al-jawzi-1417.md", "status": "verified_with_limits", "title": "فتح الباري لابن رجب — نقد مناسبة حديث عمّار وحكايات التصحيح والتضعيف" }, { "author": "مسلم بن الحجاج النيسابوري", "authorDeathHijri": "261", "contentHash": "29d842a00eaf524f", "exists": true, "id": "source-sahih-muslim-abd-al-baqi", "path": "04_source_bank/source_sahih_muslim_abd_al_baqi.md", "status": "verified", "title": "صحيح مسلم" }, { "author": "محمد بن إسماعيل البخاري", "authorDeathHijri": "256", "contentHash": "18326bb17e78b120", "exists": true, "id": "source-sahih-bukhari-murad-molla-577-facsimile", "path": "04_source_bank/source_sahih_bukhari_murad_molla_577_facsimile.md", "status": "verified", "title": "الجامع الصحيح — نسخة مراد ملّا 577 (طبعة طبق الأصل)" }, { "author": "أحمد بن علي ابن حجر العسقلاني", "authorDeathHijri": "852", "contentHash": "75116b80fd99259d", "exists": true, "id": "source-fath-al-bari-ghulat-ali-maktaba-salafiyya", "path": "04_source_bank/source_fath_al_bari_ghulat_ali_maktaba_salafiyya.md", "status": "verified", "title": "فتح الباري بشرح صحيح البخاري" }, { "author": "أحمد بن الحسين البيهقي", "authorDeathHijri": "458", "contentHash": "dfee40ea0abdb8da", "exists": true, "id": "source-bayhaqi-ammar-khandaq-qalaji-1408", "path": "04_source_bank/source-bayhaqi-ammar-khandaq-qalaji-1408.md", "status": "verified_with_limits", "title": "دلائل النبوة للبيهقي — احتمال الوهم في ذكر الخندق أو تكرر القول" }, { "author": "فوزي بن عبد الله بن محمد الحميدي الأثري", "authorDeathHijri": "معاصر", "contentHash": "482cef561e3ed056", "exists": true, "id": "source-humaydi-tadeef-hadith-ammar-2025", "path": "04_source_bank/source-humaydi-tadeef-hadith-ammar-2025.md", "status": "verified_with_limits", "title": "جزء فيه ضعف حديث عمار بن ياسر: تقتلك الفئة الباغية" } ] }, "riwayat": [ { "chain": [ "halqat_baghdad", "tarsusi", "ismail", "al_khallal" ], "citationRefs": [ "c-k721", "c-k721-note" ], "evidenceRefs": [ "c-k721", "c-k721-note" ], "familyId": "family-council", "hukm": { "attribution": "تحرير الخريطة في حدود الشاهد المسمى؛ ليس تصحيحاً مستقلاً", "citationRefs": [ "c-k721", "c-k721-note" ], "value": "ضعف نسبة المجلس بحسب علة المحقق في اسم هذه النسخة؛ فرق اسم ابن رجب محفوظ" }, "hukmCitationRefs": [], "hukmEvidenceRefs": [], "id": "r721", "illaRefs": [], "label": "حكاية المجلس في الخلال721", "matnRefs": [ "m-r721" ], "matnVariants": [ { "citationRefs": [ "c-k721", "c-k721-note" ], "id": "m-r721", "role": "nawa", "text": "ما فيه حديث صحيح." } ], "nodePath": [ "halqat_baghdad", "tarsusi", "ismail", "al_khallal" ] }, { "chain": [ "ahmad", "father_muhammad", "muhammad", "al_khallal" ], "citationRefs": [ "c-k722", "c-k722-note" ], "evidenceRefs": [ "c-k722", "c-k722-note" ], "familyId": "family-count28", "hukm": { "attribution": "تحرير الخريطة في حدود الشاهد المسمى؛ ليس تصحيحاً مستقلاً", "citationRefs": [ "c-k722", "c-k722-note" ], "value": "نسبة معلولة بجهالة الناقل وأبيه في التحقيق المقروء؛ لا تخصيص بالطرق الكوفية" }, "hukmCitationRefs": [], "hukmEvidenceRefs": [], "id": "r722", "illaRefs": [], "label": "حكاية الثمانية والعشرين في الخلال722", "matnRefs": [ "m-r722" ], "matnVariants": [ { "citationRefs": [ "c-k722", "c-k722-note" ], "id": "m-r722", "role": "nawa", "text": "روي في تقتل عمار الفئة الباغية ثمانية وعشرون حديثاً ليس فيها حديث صحيح." } ], "nodePath": [ "ahmad", "father_muhammad", "muhammad", "al_khallal" ] }, { "chain": [ "ahmad", "yaqub_shaybah", "hashiya_yala" ], "citationRefs": [ "c-yaqub-hashiya" ], "evidenceRefs": [ "c-yaqub-hashiya" ], "familyId": "family-yaqub", "hukm": { "attribution": "تحرير الخريطة في حدود الشاهد المسمى؛ ليس تصحيحاً مستقلاً", "citationRefs": [ "c-yaqub-hashiya" ], "value": "نقل مقابل؛ أصل الوصول إلى يعقوب غير مستوفى، ولا تاريخ لآخر قول" }, "hukmCitationRefs": [], "hukmEvidenceRefs": [], "id": "r-yaqub-hashiya", "illaRefs": [], "label": "حكاية يعقوب في حاشية أبي يعلى", "matnRefs": [ "m-r-yaqub-hashiya" ], "matnVariants": [ { "citationRefs": [ "c-yaqub-hashiya" ], "id": "m-r-yaqub-hashiya", "role": "nawa", "text": "في هذا غير حديث صحيح عن النبي صلى الله عليه وسلم." } ], "nodePath": [ "ahmad", "yaqub_shaybah", "hashiya_yala" ] }, { "chain": [ "ahmad", "yaqub_shaybah", "ibn_rajab" ], "citationRefs": [ "c-rajab-yaqub" ], "evidenceRefs": [ "c-rajab-yaqub" ], "familyId": "family-yaqub", "hukm": { "attribution": "تحرير الخريطة في حدود الشاهد المسمى؛ ليس تصحيحاً مستقلاً", "citationRefs": [ "c-rajab-yaqub" ], "value": "موضع نقل آخر للحكاية نفسها؛ لا أصل مستقل ولا اكتمال وصول" }, "hukmCitationRefs": [], "hukmEvidenceRefs": [], "id": "r-yaqub-rajab", "illaRefs": [], "label": "حكاية يعقوب عند ابن رجب", "matnRefs": [ "m-r-yaqub-rajab" ], "matnVariants": [ { "citationRefs": [ "c-rajab-yaqub" ], "id": "m-r-yaqub-rajab", "role": "nawa", "text": "في هذا غير حديث صحيح عن النبي صلى الله عليه وسلم." } ], "nodePath": [ "ahmad", "yaqub_shaybah", "ibn_rajab" ] }, { "chain": [ "al_khallal", "abu_yala" ], "citationRefs": [ "c-yala-matn", "c-yala-context" ], "evidenceRefs": [ "c-yala-matn", "c-yala-context" ], "familyId": "family-khallal-reception", "hukm": { "attribution": "تحرير الخريطة في حدود الشاهد المسمى؛ ليس تصحيحاً مستقلاً", "citationRefs": [ "c-yala-matn", "c-yala-context" ], "value": "رابط نقل مصنف؛ ليس طريقاً ثالثاً ولا سماعاً مباشراً" }, "hukmCitationRefs": [], "hukmEvidenceRefs": [], "id": "r-yala-reception", "illaRefs": [], "label": "نقل أبي يعلى لحكايتي الخلال", "matnRefs": [ "m-r-yala-reception" ], "matnVariants": [ { "citationRefs": [ "c-yala-matn", "c-yala-context" ], "id": "m-r-yala-reception", "role": "nawa", "text": "قال أبو بكر الخلال... وقال أبو أمية..." } ], "nodePath": [ "al_khallal", "abu_yala" ] }, { "chain": [ "al_khallal", "humaydi_2025" ], "citationRefs": [ "c-humaydi-43" ], "evidenceRefs": [ "c-humaydi-43" ], "familyId": "family-khallal-reception", "hukm": { "attribution": "تحرير الخريطة في حدود الشاهد المسمى؛ ليس تصحيحاً مستقلاً", "citationRefs": [ "c-humaydi-43" ], "value": "شهادة على حجة المؤلف المعاصر؛ لا ترقية لأسانيد النقل" }, "hukmCitationRefs": [], "hukmEvidenceRefs": [], "id": "r-humaydi-reception", "illaRefs": [], "label": "استعمال الحميدي لحكايتي النفي", "matnRefs": [ "m-r-humaydi-reception" ], "matnVariants": [ { "citationRefs": [ "c-humaydi-43" ], "id": "m-r-humaydi-reception", "role": "nawa", "text": "يفضل المؤلف رواية النفي ويصحح حكايتيه." } ], "nodePath": [ "al_khallal", "humaydi_2025" ] }, { "chain": [ "muslim_roots", "muslim_sahih" ], "citationRefs": [ "c-muslim", "c-muslim2236" ], "evidenceRefs": [ "c-muslim", "c-muslim2236" ], "familyId": "family-muslim-comparison", "hukm": { "attribution": "تحرير الخريطة في حدود الشاهد المسمى؛ ليس تصحيحاً مستقلاً", "citationRefs": [ "c-muslim", "c-muslim2236" ], "value": "مقارنة أصول ومواضع لا عد لطرق مكتملة في هذا الرسم" }, "hukmCitationRefs": [], "hukmEvidenceRefs": [], "id": "r-muslim", "illaRefs": [], "label": "موضعا أصل أبي قتادة وأم سلمة", "matnRefs": [ "m-r-muslim" ], "matnVariants": [ { "citationRefs": [ "c-muslim", "c-muslim2236" ], "id": "m-r-muslim", "role": "nawa", "text": "تقتلك فئة باغية؛ تقتلك الفئة الباغية؛ تقتل عماراً الفئة الباغية." } ], "nodePath": [ "muslim_roots", "muslim_sahih" ] }, { "chain": [ "murad_reading", "murad_molla" ], "citationRefs": [ "c-murad" ], "evidenceRefs": [ "c-murad" ], "familyId": "family-murad-witness", "hukm": { "attribution": "تحرير الخريطة في حدود الشاهد المسمى؛ ليس تصحيحاً مستقلاً", "citationRefs": [ "c-murad" ], "value": "غياب مقيد بالشاهد؛ السبب وتاريخ الاختلاف غير محققين" }, "hukmCitationRefs": [], "hukmEvidenceRefs": [], "id": "r-murad", "illaRefs": [], "label": "شاهد الغياب في مراد ملّا", "matnRefs": [ "m-r-murad" ], "matnVariants": [ { "citationRefs": [ "c-murad" ], "id": "m-r-murad", "role": "nawa", "text": "جملة القتل غير مذكورة في الموضعين بحسب سجل المعاينة." } ], "nodePath": [ "murad_reading", "murad_molla" ] }, { "chain": [ "fath_statement", "fath_book" ], "citationRefs": [ "c-fath" ], "evidenceRefs": [ "c-fath" ], "familyId": "family-fath-witness", "hukm": { "attribution": "تحرير الخريطة في حدود الشاهد المسمى؛ ليس تصحيحاً مستقلاً", "citationRefs": [ "c-fath" ], "value": "نقل مصنف عن شواهد؛ ليست معاينة لهذه المخطوطات جميعاً" }, "hukmCitationRefs": [], "hukmEvidenceRefs": [], "id": "r-fath", "illaRefs": [], "label": "شهادة ابن حجر على الإثبات", "matnRefs": [ "m-r-fath" ], "matnVariants": [ { "citationRefs": [ "c-fath" ], "id": "m-r-fath", "role": "nawa", "text": "نقل وقوع الجملة في رواية ابن السكن وكريمة ونسخة الصغاني." } ], "nodePath": [ "fath_statement", "fath_book" ] }, { "chain": [ "khalid_kharij", "bayhaqi_book" ], "citationRefs": [ "c-khalid-outside" ], "evidenceRefs": [ "c-khalid-outside" ], "familyId": "family-khalid-comparison", "hukm": { "attribution": "تحرير الخريطة في حدود الشاهد المسمى؛ ليس تصحيحاً مستقلاً", "citationRefs": [ "c-khalid-outside" ], "value": "مقابلة الأسانيد والألفاظ التفصيلية باقية؛ لا يعد الفرعان أصلين صحابيين" }, "hukmCitationRefs": [], "hukmEvidenceRefs": [], "id": "r-khalid", "illaRefs": [], "label": "جرد فرعين لخالد خارج البخاري", "matnRefs": [ "m-r-khalid" ], "matnVariants": [ { "citationRefs": [ "c-khalid-outside" ], "id": "m-r-khalid", "role": "nawa", "text": "الجملة مذكورة في فرعي عبد العزيز وعبد الوهاب بحسب الجرد المنقول." } ], "nodePath": [ "khalid_kharij", "bayhaqi_book" ] } ], "schemaVersion": 2, "transmissions": [ { "cardRefs": [], "citationRefs": [ "c-k721", "c-k721-note" ], "evidenceRefs": { "note": [ "c-k721" ] }, "from": "halqat_baghdad", "id": "e-council-tarsusi", "illaRefs": [], "matnRefs": [ "m-r721" ], "note": "سمعت في حلقة", "requiresPinpoint": false, "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [ "c-k721", "c-k721-note" ], "riwayaRefs": [ "r721" ], "sourceRefs": [ "source-al-sunna-al-khallal-zahrani" ], "status": "mahfuz", "supportLevel": "exact", "to": "tarsusi", "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": [] }, { "cardRefs": [], "citationRefs": [ "c-k721", "c-k721-note" ], "evidenceRefs": { "note": [ "c-k721" ] }, "from": "tarsusi", "id": "e-tarsusi-ismail", "illaRefs": [], "matnRefs": [ "m-r721" ], "note": "سمعت", "requiresPinpoint": false, "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [ "c-k721", "c-k721-note" ], "riwayaRefs": [ "r721" ], "sourceRefs": [ "source-al-sunna-al-khallal-zahrani" ], "status": "mahfuz", "supportLevel": "exact", "to": "ismail", "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": [] }, { "cardRefs": [], "citationRefs": [ "c-k721", "c-k721-note" ], "evidenceRefs": { "note": [ "c-k721", "c-k721-note" ], "status": [ "c-k721", "c-k721-note" ] }, "from": "ismail", "id": "e-ismail-khallal", "illaRefs": [], "matnRefs": [ "m-r721" ], "note": "أخبرني", "requiresPinpoint": false, "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [ "c-k721", "c-k721-note" ], "riwayaRefs": [ "r721" ], "sourceRefs": [ "source-al-sunna-al-khallal-zahrani" ], "status": "disputed", "supportLevel": "exact", "to": "al_khallal", "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": [] }, { "cardRefs": [], "citationRefs": [ "c-k722", "c-k722-note" ], "evidenceRefs": { "note": [ "c-k722", "c-k722-note" ], "status": [ "c-k722", "c-k722-note" ] }, "from": "ahmad", "id": "e-ahmad-father", "illaRefs": [], "matnRefs": [ "m-r722" ], "note": "سمعت", "requiresPinpoint": false, "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [ "c-k722", "c-k722-note" ], "riwayaRefs": [ "r722" ], "sourceRefs": [ "source-al-sunna-al-khallal-zahrani" ], "status": "disputed", "supportLevel": "exact", "to": "father_muhammad", "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": [] }, { "cardRefs": [], "citationRefs": [ "c-k722", "c-k722-note" ], "evidenceRefs": { "note": [ "c-k722", "c-k722-note" ], "status": [ "c-k722", "c-k722-note" ] }, "from": "father_muhammad", "id": "e-father-muhammad", "illaRefs": [], "matnRefs": [ "m-r722" ], "note": "سمعت أبي", "requiresPinpoint": false, "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [ "c-k722", "c-k722-note" ], "riwayaRefs": [ "r722" ], "sourceRefs": [ "source-al-sunna-al-khallal-zahrani" ], "status": "disputed", "supportLevel": "exact", "to": "muhammad", "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": [] }, { "cardRefs": [], "citationRefs": [ "c-k722", "c-k722-note" ], "evidenceRefs": { "note": [ "c-k722", "c-k722-note" ], "status": [ "c-k722", "c-k722-note" ] }, "from": "muhammad", "id": "e-muhammad-khallal", "illaRefs": [], "matnRefs": [ "m-r722" ], "note": "سمعت", "requiresPinpoint": false, "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [ "c-k722", "c-k722-note" ], "riwayaRefs": [ "r722" ], "sourceRefs": [ "source-al-sunna-al-khallal-zahrani" ], "status": "disputed", "supportLevel": "exact", "to": "al_khallal", "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": [] }, { "cardRefs": [], "citationRefs": [ "c-yaqub-hashiya", "c-rajab-yaqub" ], "evidenceRefs": { "note": [ "c-yaqub-hashiya", "c-rajab-yaqub", "c-rajab-yaqub" ], "status": [ "c-yaqub-hashiya", "c-rajab-yaqub", "c-rajab-yaqub" ] }, "from": "ahmad", "id": "e-ahmad-yaqub", "illaRefs": [], "matnRefs": [ "m-r-yaqub-hashiya", "m-r-yaqub-rajab" ], "note": "سمعت (في الحكاية)", "requiresPinpoint": false, "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [ "c-yaqub-hashiya", "c-rajab-yaqub" ], "riwayaRefs": [ "r-yaqub-hashiya", "r-yaqub-rajab" ], "sourceRefs": [ "source-kitab-al-imama-abu-yala-misk-ammar", "source-ibn-rajab-ammar-khandaq-ibn-al-jawzi-1417" ], "status": "disputed", "supportLevel": "exact", "to": "yaqub_shaybah", "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": [] }, { "cardRefs": [], "citationRefs": [ "c-yaqub-hashiya" ], "evidenceRefs": { "note": [ "c-yaqub-hashiya" ], "status": [ "c-yaqub-hashiya" ] }, "from": "yaqub_shaybah", "id": "e-yaqub-hashiya", "illaRefs": [], "matnRefs": [ "m-r-yaqub-hashiya" ], "note": "نقل حاشية؛ لا سماع", "requiresPinpoint": false, "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [ "c-yaqub-hashiya" ], "riwayaRefs": [ "r-yaqub-hashiya" ], "sourceRefs": [ "source-kitab-al-imama-abu-yala-misk-ammar" ], "status": "disputed", "supportLevel": "exact", "to": "hashiya_yala", "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": [] }, { "cardRefs": [], "citationRefs": [ "c-rajab-yaqub" ], "evidenceRefs": { "note": [ "c-rajab-yaqub" ], "status": [ "c-rajab-yaqub" ] }, "from": "yaqub_shaybah", "id": "e-yaqub-rajab", "illaRefs": [], "matnRefs": [ "m-r-yaqub-rajab" ], "note": "حكاية؛ لا سماع", "requiresPinpoint": false, "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [ "c-rajab-yaqub" ], "riwayaRefs": [ "r-yaqub-rajab" ], "sourceRefs": [ "source-ibn-rajab-ammar-khandaq-ibn-al-jawzi-1417" ], "status": "disputed", "supportLevel": "exact", "to": "ibn_rajab", "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": [] }, { "cardRefs": [], "citationRefs": [ "c-yala-matn", "c-yala-context" ], "evidenceRefs": { "note": [ "c-yala-matn" ] }, "from": "al_khallal", "id": "e-khallal-yala", "illaRefs": [], "matnRefs": [ "m-r-yala-reception" ], "note": "نقل مصنف؛ لا سماع", "requiresPinpoint": false, "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [ "c-yala-matn", "c-yala-context" ], "riwayaRefs": [ "r-yala-reception" ], "sourceRefs": [ "source-kitab-al-imama-abu-yala-misk-ammar" ], "status": "mahfuz", "supportLevel": "exact", "to": "abu_yala", "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": [] }, { "cardRefs": [], "citationRefs": [ "c-humaydi-43" ], "evidenceRefs": { "note": [ "c-humaydi-43" ] }, "from": "al_khallal", "id": "e-khallal-humaydi", "illaRefs": [], "matnRefs": [ "m-r-humaydi-reception" ], "note": "نقل مصنف؛ لا سماع", "requiresPinpoint": false, "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [ "c-humaydi-43" ], "riwayaRefs": [ "r-humaydi-reception" ], "sourceRefs": [ "source-humaydi-tadeef-hadith-ammar-2025" ], "status": "mahfuz", "supportLevel": "exact", "to": "humaydi_2025", "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": [] }, { "cardRefs": [], "citationRefs": [ "c-muslim", "c-muslim2236" ], "evidenceRefs": { "note": [ "c-muslim", "c-muslim2236" ] }, "from": "muslim_roots", "id": "e-r-muslim", "illaRefs": [], "matnRefs": [ "m-r-muslim" ], "note": "موضع نص؛ لا سماع", "requiresPinpoint": true, "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [ "c-muslim", "c-muslim2236" ], "riwayaRefs": [ "r-muslim" ], "sourceRefs": [ "source-sahih-muslim-abd-al-baqi" ], "status": "mahfuz", "supportLevel": "map_scope", "to": "muslim_sahih", "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": [] }, { "cardRefs": [], "citationRefs": [ "c-murad" ], "evidenceRefs": { "note": [ "c-murad" ] }, "from": "murad_reading", "id": "e-r-murad", "illaRefs": [], "matnRefs": [ "m-r-murad" ], "note": "موضع نص؛ لا سماع", "requiresPinpoint": true, "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [ "c-murad" ], "riwayaRefs": [ "r-murad" ], "sourceRefs": [ "source-sahih-bukhari-murad-molla-577-facsimile" ], "status": "mahfuz", "supportLevel": "map_scope", "to": "murad_molla", "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": [] }, { "cardRefs": [], "citationRefs": [ "c-fath" ], "evidenceRefs": { "note": [ "c-fath" ] }, "from": "fath_statement", "id": "e-r-fath", "illaRefs": [], "matnRefs": [ "m-r-fath" ], "note": "موضع نص؛ لا سماع", "requiresPinpoint": false, "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [ "c-fath" ], "riwayaRefs": [ "r-fath" ], "sourceRefs": [ "source-fath-al-bari-ghulat-ali-maktaba-salafiyya" ], "status": "mahfuz", "supportLevel": "exact", "to": "fath_book", "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": [] }, { "cardRefs": [], "citationRefs": [ "c-khalid-outside" ], "evidenceRefs": { "note": [ "c-khalid-outside" ] }, "from": "khalid_kharij", "id": "e-r-khalid", "illaRefs": [], "matnRefs": [ "m-r-khalid" ], "note": "موضع نص؛ لا سماع", "requiresPinpoint": true, "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [ "c-khalid-outside" ], "riwayaRefs": [ "r-khalid" ], "sourceRefs": [ "source-bayhaqi-ammar-khandaq-qalaji-1408" ], "status": "mahfuz", "supportLevel": "map_scope", "to": "bayhaqi_book", "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": [] } ] }