{ "arguments": [ { "citationRefs": [ "cit-musannaf-32655-isnad-matn", "cit-musannaf-32655-hukm" ], "evidenceRefs": [ "cit-musannaf-32655-isnad-matn", "cit-musannaf-32655-hukm" ], "id": "arg-32655-reaches-walid-not-event", "illaRefs": [], "kind": "isnad", "limitations": "حكم المحقق موثق كما هو؛ التقييد منصب على الحلقة التي لم يسمها المتن، لا على صحة طبقات الطريق المسماة.", "riwayaRefs": [], "statement": "يبلغ الطريق قول الوليد كما حكاه سليمان التيمي، ثم يقف: لا يذكر النص ناقلاً من مجلس الزبير إلى الوليد، فلا يثبت به وحده الإكراه المادي بوصفه واقعة مقفلة.", "targets": [ "edge:edge-event-to-walid", "node:al_walid_ibn_abd_al_malik", "riwaya:riwaya-musannaf-32655" ] }, { "citationRefs": [ "cit-musannaf-32655-isnad-matn" ], "evidenceRefs": [ "cit-musannaf-32655-isnad-matn" ], "id": "arg-32655-preserve-printed-name", "illaRefs": [], "kind": "matn", "limitations": "الخريطة لا تنفي إمكان التصحيف، لكنها لا تثبت تصحيحاً لم توثقه مادة هذه الجولة.", "riwayaRefs": [], "statement": "الاسم المثبت في الطبعة والصورة «جبلة بن حكيم»؛ فلا يحول إلى «حكيم بن جبلة» من طريق التشابه أو من خبر سيف بن عمر بلا حجة مستقلة.", "targets": [ "matn:matn-32655-printed-name", "riwaya:riwaya-musannaf-32655" ] }, { "citationRefs": [ "cit-musannaf-32655-isnad-matn" ], "evidenceRefs": [ "cit-musannaf-32655-isnad-matn" ], "id": "arg-32655-quarantine-description", "illaRefs": [], "kind": "matn", "limitations": "وظيفة الوصف في الاستدلال صفر، ولا يستخرج منه حكم على رجل أو مصر أو جماعة.", "riwayaRefs": [], "statement": "الوصف الخصومي جاء داخل القول المنسوب إلى الوليد؛ نقله لإكمال صورة المتن لا يحوله إلى حكم رجالي أو عقدي تتبناه الخريطة أو الكتاب.", "targets": [ "matn:matn-32655-contentious-description", "riwaya:riwaya-musannaf-32655" ] }, { "citationRefs": [ "cit-musannaf-32655-isnad-matn" ], "evidenceRefs": [ "cit-musannaf-32655-isnad-matn" ], "id": "arg-32655-single-family-environment", "illaRefs": [], "kind": "isnad", "limitations": "لم توثق هذه الجولة أمصار رجال الطريق ولا أنسابهم ولا مواقفهم الشخصية، فتركت حقول city وhukm وflags خالية ولم يدع البحث استقصاء جميع المصادر.", "riwayaRefs": [], "scope": "sample", "statement": "العينة المحققة في هذه الخريطة أسرة طريق واحدة تنتهي إلى قول الوليد، ولا تضم شاهداً مستقلاً على الواقعة؛ فالتفرد في العينة موجب لطلب المتابعة لا جرحاً بقبيلة أو مصر.", "targets": [ "riwaya:riwaya-musannaf-32655" ] }, { "citationRefs": [ "cit-musannaf-32655-variant-footnote", "cit-musannaf-32655-isnad-matn" ], "evidenceRefs": [ "cit-musannaf-32655-variant-footnote", "cit-musannaf-32655-isnad-matn" ], "id": "arg-32655-variant-not-body", "illaRefs": [], "kind": "matn", "limitations": "اللفظ السابق الذي زاد الفاء خطأ في النقل، لا شاهد نسخة؛ محفوظ في أرشيف الإصدار1.", "riwayaRefs": [], "scope": "sample", "statement": "المتن المطبوع: قتلناك. الحاشية عن أ،ط،هـ: قاتلناك، بلا فاء. تصحيح القراءة لا يصل رابط الواقعة ولا يغير حكم الطريق المنسوب إلى المحقق.", "targets": [] } ], "citations": [ { "attribution": "عبد الله بن محمد ابن أبي شيبة (ت235هـ)", "cardRef": null, "discovery": null, "id": "cit-musannaf-32655-isnad-matn", "kind": "isnad_matn_context", "label": "بنية طريق ح32655 ومتنه", "limitations": null, "locator": { "display": "مصنف ابن أبي شيبة، تحقيق الشثري، ج17، ص134، ح32655", "hadithNo": 32655, "page": 134, "volume": 17 }, "mode": "quoted", "note": "متن الطبعة «جبلة بن حكيم»؛ وأثبتت حاشية النسخ قراءة «حليم» في بعض الأصول، ولم تثبت «حكيم بن جبلة». واللفظ المطبوع في التهديد «قتلناك».", "quote": "قال التيمي: وقال وليد بن عبد الملك: إن منافقاً من منافقي أهل العراق، جبلة بن حكيم، قال للزبير: إنك قد بايعت. فقال الزبير: إن السيف وضع على عنقي، فقيل لي: بايع وإلا قتلناك. قال: فبايعت", "sourceId": "source-musannaf-ibn-abi-shayba-bayat-zubayr-32655", "sourceRef": "source-musannaf-ibn-abi-shayba-bayat-zubayr-32655", "speaker": null, "summary": "ورد ح32655 عقب سند ح32654، وافتتح بـ«قال التيمي»؛ فظاهر السياق رجوعه إلى سليمان التيمي. يرويه عنه ابنه معتمر، ويرويه أبو أسامة عن معتمر. يبلغ الخبر قول الوليد، ولا يسمّي ناقلاً من مجلس الزبير إلى الوليد.", "url": null, "verification": "verified_scan", "verificationLimits": null }, { "attribution": "سعد بن ناصر بن عبد العزيز الشثري، محقق الطبعة", "cardRef": null, "discovery": null, "id": "cit-musannaf-32655-hukm", "kind": "hukm", "label": "حكم محقق طبعة الشثري على ح32655", "limitations": null, "locator": { "display": "مصنف ابن أبي شيبة، تحقيق الشثري، ج17، ص134، ح32655، حاشية المحقق رقم 17", "hadithNo": 32655, "note": "حاشية المحقق رقم 17", "page": 134, "volume": 17 }, "mode": "quoted", "note": null, "quote": "صحيح", "sourceId": "source-musannaf-ibn-abi-shayba-bayat-zubayr-32655", "sourceRef": "source-musannaf-ibn-abi-shayba-bayat-zubayr-32655", "speaker": null, "summary": null, "url": null, "verification": "verified_scan", "verificationLimits": null }, { "attribution": null, "cardRef": null, "discovery": null, "id": "cit-musannaf-32655-variant-footnote", "kind": "evidence", "label": "في أ، ط، هـ: (قاتلناك).", "limitations": null, "locator": { "display": "مصنف ابن أبي شيبة،تحقيق الشثري،ج17ص134،ح32655،حاشية16" }, "mode": "quoted", "note": "قوبلت الصورة المحلية والاقتصاص المكبر مباشرة؛ بلا فاء. متن الطبعة قتلناك، وقراءة الحاشية قاتلناك، ولا تدمجان.", "quote": "في أ، ط، هـ: (قاتلناك).", "sourceId": "source-musannaf-ibn-abi-shayba-bayat-zubayr-32655", "sourceRef": "source-musannaf-ibn-abi-shayba-bayat-zubayr-32655", "speaker": null, "summary": null, "url": null, "verification": "verified_scan", "verificationLimits": null } ], "dependencyHash": "677d3e45f5f41a24", "diagnostics": { "errors": [], "warnings": [ "evidenceStatus=incomplete: 4/26 hotspots تحتاج تعيين المصدر والموضع" ] }, "evidenceStatus": "incomplete", "illal": [ { "citationRefs": [ "cit-musannaf-32655-isnad-matn", "cit-musannaf-32655-hukm" ], "evidenceRefs": [ "cit-musannaf-32655-isnad-matn", "cit-musannaf-32655-hukm" ], "id": "illa-32655-missing-event-link", "kind": "انقطاع رابط الواقعة", "label": "لا ناقل مسمى من مجلس الزبير إلى الوليد", "limitations": "هذا قيد في اتصال الدعوى بالواقعة، لا جرح في سليمان التيمي ولا في الوليد، ولا تكذيب لمضمون القول.", "matnRefs": [ "matn-32655-performance-formula", "matn-32655-sword-claim" ], "riwayaRefs": [ "riwaya-musannaf-32655" ], "statement": "يعزو سليمان التيمي القول إلى الوليد بن عبد الملك، لكن النص لا يسمّي من نقل إلى الوليد حوار الزبير في مجلس البيعة ولا يصف الوليد بأنه شهده؛ لذلك لا يسد تصحيح المحقق فراغ الوصول إلى الواقعة.", "subject": { "id": "edge-event-to-walid", "kind": "edge" }, "target": "edge:edge-event-to-walid" } ], "interactionIndex": { "hotspots": { "argument:arg-32655-preserve-printed-name": { "argumentRefs": [ "arg-32655-preserve-printed-name" ], "cardRefs": [], "citationRefs": [ "cit-musannaf-32655-isnad-matn" ], "evidenceRefs": [ "cit-musannaf-32655-isnad-matn" ], "icon": { "kindLabel": "حجة الدراسة", "meaning": "الدعوى وأدلتها وحدودها", "status": "documented", "statusLabel": "إحالة موضعية مقابلة", "summary": "الاسم المثبت في الطبعة والصورة «جبلة بن حكيم»؛ فلا يحول إلى «حكيم بن جبلة» من طريق التشابه أو من خبر سيف بن عمر بلا حجة مستقلة. — الخريطة لا تنفي إمكان التصحيف، لكنها لا تثبت تصحيحاً لم توثقه مادة هذه الجولة." }, "id": "argument:arg-32655-preserve-printed-name", "illaRefs": [], "kind": "argument", "label": "الاسم المثبت في الطبعة والصورة «جبلة بن حكيم»؛ فلا يحول إلى «حكيم بن جبلة» من طريق التشابه أو من خبر سيف بن عمر بلا حجة مستقلة.", "matnRefs": [], "rendered": true, "requiresPinpoint": false, "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [ "cit-musannaf-32655-isnad-matn" ], "riwayaRefs": [], "sourceRefs": [ "source-musannaf-ibn-abi-shayba-bayat-zubayr-32655" ], "supportLevel": "exact", "target": { "argumentId": "arg-32655-preserve-printed-name" }, "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": [] }, "argument:arg-32655-quarantine-description": { "argumentRefs": [ "arg-32655-quarantine-description" ], "cardRefs": [], "citationRefs": [ "cit-musannaf-32655-isnad-matn" ], "evidenceRefs": [ "cit-musannaf-32655-isnad-matn" ], "icon": { "kindLabel": "حجة الدراسة", "meaning": "الدعوى وأدلتها وحدودها", "status": "documented", "statusLabel": "إحالة موضعية مقابلة", "summary": "الوصف الخصومي جاء داخل القول المنسوب إلى الوليد؛ نقله لإكمال صورة المتن لا يحوله إلى حكم رجالي أو عقدي تتبناه الخريطة أو الكتاب. — وظيفة الوصف في الاستدلال صفر، ولا يستخرج منه حكم على رجل أو مصر أو جماعة." }, "id": "argument:arg-32655-quarantine-description", "illaRefs": [], "kind": "argument", "label": "الوصف الخصومي جاء داخل القول المنسوب إلى الوليد؛ نقله لإكمال صورة المتن لا يحوله إلى حكم رجالي أو عقدي تتبناه الخريطة أو الكتاب.", "matnRefs": [], "rendered": true, "requiresPinpoint": false, "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [ "cit-musannaf-32655-isnad-matn" ], "riwayaRefs": [], "sourceRefs": [ "source-musannaf-ibn-abi-shayba-bayat-zubayr-32655" ], "supportLevel": "exact", "target": { "argumentId": "arg-32655-quarantine-description" }, "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": [] }, "argument:arg-32655-reaches-walid-not-event": { "argumentRefs": [ "arg-32655-reaches-walid-not-event" ], "cardRefs": [], "citationRefs": [ "cit-musannaf-32655-isnad-matn", "cit-musannaf-32655-hukm" ], "evidenceRefs": [ "cit-musannaf-32655-isnad-matn", "cit-musannaf-32655-hukm" ], "icon": { "kindLabel": "حجة الدراسة", "meaning": "الدعوى وأدلتها وحدودها", "status": "documented", "statusLabel": "إحالة موضعية مقابلة", "summary": "يبلغ الطريق قول الوليد كما حكاه سليمان التيمي، ثم يقف: لا يذكر النص ناقلاً من مجلس الزبير إلى الوليد، فلا يثبت به وحده الإكراه المادي بوصفه واقعة مقفلة. — حكم المحقق موثق كما هو؛ التقييد منصب على الحلقة التي لم يسمها المتن، لا على صحة طبقات الطريق المسماة." }, "id": "argument:arg-32655-reaches-walid-not-event", "illaRefs": [], "kind": "argument", "label": "يبلغ الطريق قول الوليد كما حكاه سليمان التيمي، ثم يقف: لا يذكر النص ناقلاً من مجلس الزبير إلى الوليد، فلا يثبت به وحده الإكراه المادي بوصفه واقعة مقفلة.", "matnRefs": [], "rendered": true, "requiresPinpoint": false, "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [ "cit-musannaf-32655-isnad-matn", "cit-musannaf-32655-hukm" ], "riwayaRefs": [], "sourceRefs": [ "source-musannaf-ibn-abi-shayba-bayat-zubayr-32655" ], "supportLevel": "exact", "target": { "argumentId": "arg-32655-reaches-walid-not-event" }, "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": [] }, "argument:arg-32655-single-family-environment": { "argumentRefs": [ "arg-32655-single-family-environment" ], "cardRefs": [], "citationRefs": [ "cit-musannaf-32655-isnad-matn" ], "evidenceRefs": [ "cit-musannaf-32655-isnad-matn" ], "icon": { "kindLabel": "حجة الدراسة", "meaning": "الدعوى وأدلتها وحدودها", "status": "documented", "statusLabel": "إحالة موضعية مقابلة", "summary": "العينة المحققة في هذه الخريطة أسرة طريق واحدة تنتهي إلى قول الوليد، ولا تضم شاهداً مستقلاً على الواقعة؛ فالتفرد في العينة موجب لطلب المتابعة لا جرحاً بقبيلة أو مصر. — لم توثق هذه الجولة أمصار رجال الطريق ولا أنسابهم ولا مواقفهم الشخصية، فتركت حقول city وhukm وflags خالية ولم يدع البحث استقصاء جميع المصادر." }, "id": "argument:arg-32655-single-family-environment", "illaRefs": [], "kind": "argument", "label": "العينة المحققة في هذه الخريطة أسرة طريق واحدة تنتهي إلى قول الوليد، ولا تضم شاهداً مستقلاً على الواقعة؛ فالتفرد في العينة موجب لطلب المتابعة لا جرحاً بقبيلة أو مصر.", "matnRefs": [], "rendered": true, "requiresPinpoint": false, "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [ "cit-musannaf-32655-isnad-matn" ], "riwayaRefs": [], "sourceRefs": [ "source-musannaf-ibn-abi-shayba-bayat-zubayr-32655" ], "supportLevel": "exact", "target": { "argumentId": "arg-32655-single-family-environment" }, "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": [] }, "argument:arg-32655-variant-not-body": { "argumentRefs": [ "arg-32655-variant-not-body" ], "cardRefs": [], "citationRefs": [ "cit-musannaf-32655-variant-footnote", "cit-musannaf-32655-isnad-matn" ], "evidenceRefs": [ "cit-musannaf-32655-variant-footnote", "cit-musannaf-32655-isnad-matn" ], "icon": { "kindLabel": "حجة الدراسة", "meaning": "الدعوى وأدلتها وحدودها", "status": "documented", "statusLabel": "إحالة موضعية مقابلة", "summary": "المتن المطبوع: قتلناك. الحاشية عن أ،ط،هـ: قاتلناك، بلا فاء. تصحيح القراءة لا يصل رابط الواقعة ولا يغير حكم الطريق المنسوب إلى المحقق. — اللفظ السابق الذي زاد الفاء خطأ في النقل، لا شاهد نسخة؛ محفوظ في أرشيف الإصدار1." }, "id": "argument:arg-32655-variant-not-body", "illaRefs": [], "kind": "argument", "label": "المتن المطبوع: قتلناك. الحاشية عن أ،ط،هـ: قاتلناك، بلا فاء. تصحيح القراءة لا يصل رابط الواقعة ولا يغير حكم الطريق المنسوب إلى المحقق.", "matnRefs": [], "rendered": true, "requiresPinpoint": false, "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [ "cit-musannaf-32655-variant-footnote", "cit-musannaf-32655-isnad-matn" ], "riwayaRefs": [], "sourceRefs": [ "source-musannaf-ibn-abi-shayba-bayat-zubayr-32655" ], "supportLevel": "exact", "target": { "argumentId": "arg-32655-variant-not-body" }, "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": [] }, "city:abu_usama": { "argumentRefs": [], "cardRefs": [], "citationRefs": [], "evidenceRefs": [], "icon": { "kindLabel": "مصر النقل", "meaning": "المصر المسجل ومرجعه؛ البيئة وحدها ليست جرحاً", "status": "missing", "statusLabel": "لم تسجل إحالة موضعية لهذا الحقل", "summary": "أبو أسامة: غير معيّن" }, "id": "city:abu_usama", "illaRefs": [], "kind": "city", "label": "أبو أسامة: غير معيّن", "matnRefs": [], "rendered": true, "requiresPinpoint": true, "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [], "riwayaRefs": [], "sourceRefs": [], "supportLevel": "unresolved", "target": { "field": "city", "nodeId": "abu_usama" }, "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": [] }, "city:al_walid_ibn_abd_al_malik": { "argumentRefs": [], "cardRefs": [], "citationRefs": [], "evidenceRefs": [], "icon": { "kindLabel": "مصر النقل", "meaning": "المصر المسجل ومرجعه؛ البيئة وحدها ليست جرحاً", "status": "missing", "statusLabel": "لم تسجل إحالة موضعية لهذا الحقل", "summary": "الوليد بن عبد الملك: غير معيّن" }, "id": "city:al_walid_ibn_abd_al_malik", "illaRefs": [], "kind": "city", "label": "الوليد بن عبد الملك: غير معيّن", "matnRefs": [], "rendered": true, "requiresPinpoint": true, "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [], "riwayaRefs": [], "sourceRefs": [], "supportLevel": "unresolved", "target": { "field": "city", "nodeId": "al_walid_ibn_abd_al_malik" }, "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": [] }, "city:mutamir_ibn_sulayman": { "argumentRefs": [], "cardRefs": [], "citationRefs": [], "evidenceRefs": [], "icon": { "kindLabel": "مصر النقل", "meaning": "المصر المسجل ومرجعه؛ البيئة وحدها ليست جرحاً", "status": "missing", "statusLabel": "لم تسجل إحالة موضعية لهذا الحقل", "summary": "معتمر بن سليمان: غير معيّن" }, "id": "city:mutamir_ibn_sulayman", "illaRefs": [], "kind": "city", "label": "معتمر بن سليمان: غير معيّن", "matnRefs": [], "rendered": true, "requiresPinpoint": true, "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [], "riwayaRefs": [], "sourceRefs": [], "supportLevel": "unresolved", "target": { "field": "city", "nodeId": "mutamir_ibn_sulayman" }, "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": [] }, "city:sulayman_al_taymi": { "argumentRefs": [], "cardRefs": [], "citationRefs": [], "evidenceRefs": [], "icon": { "kindLabel": "مصر النقل", "meaning": "المصر المسجل ومرجعه؛ البيئة وحدها ليست جرحاً", "status": "missing", "statusLabel": "لم تسجل إحالة موضعية لهذا الحقل", "summary": "سليمان التيمي: غير معيّن" }, "id": "city:sulayman_al_taymi", "illaRefs": [], "kind": "city", "label": "سليمان التيمي: غير معيّن", "matnRefs": [], "rendered": true, "requiresPinpoint": true, "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [], "riwayaRefs": [], "sourceRefs": [], "supportLevel": "unresolved", "target": { "field": "city", "nodeId": "sulayman_al_taymi" }, "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": [] }, "edge:edge-abu-usama-to-musannaf": { "argumentRefs": [], "cardRefs": [], "citationRefs": [ "cit-musannaf-32655-isnad-matn", "cit-musannaf-32655-hukm" ], "evidenceRefs": [ "cit-musannaf-32655-isnad-matn", "cit-musannaf-32655-hukm" ], "icon": { "kindLabel": "حلقة الرواية", "meaning": "صلة النقل بين طرفي السهم والروايات التي تحملها", "status": "documented", "statusLabel": "إحالة موضعية مقابلة", "summary": "حدثنا أبو أسامة" }, "id": "edge:edge-abu-usama-to-musannaf", "illaRefs": [], "kind": "edge", "label": "حدثنا أبو أسامة", "matnRefs": [ "matn-32655-performance-formula", "matn-32655-contentious-description", "matn-32655-printed-name", "matn-32655-sword-claim" ], "rendered": true, "requiresPinpoint": false, "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [ "cit-musannaf-32655-isnad-matn", "cit-musannaf-32655-hukm" ], "riwayaRefs": [ "riwaya-musannaf-32655" ], "sourceRefs": [ "source-musannaf-ibn-abi-shayba-bayat-zubayr-32655" ], "supportLevel": "exact", "target": { "edgeId": "edge-abu-usama-to-musannaf", "from": "abu_usama", "to": "musannaf_32655" }, "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": [] }, "edge:edge-event-to-walid": { "argumentRefs": [], "cardRefs": [], "citationRefs": [ "cit-musannaf-32655-isnad-matn", "cit-musannaf-32655-hukm" ], "evidenceRefs": [ "cit-musannaf-32655-isnad-matn", "cit-musannaf-32655-hukm" ], "icon": { "kindLabel": "حلقة الرواية", "meaning": "صلة النقل بين طرفي السهم والروايات التي تحملها", "status": "documented", "statusLabel": "إحالة موضعية مقابلة", "summary": "لا ناقل مسمى من مجلس الزبير إلى الوليد" }, "id": "edge:edge-event-to-walid", "illaRefs": [ "illa-32655-missing-event-link" ], "kind": "edge", "label": "لا ناقل مسمى من مجلس الزبير إلى الوليد", "matnRefs": [ "matn-32655-performance-formula", "matn-32655-contentious-description", "matn-32655-printed-name", "matn-32655-sword-claim" ], "rendered": true, "requiresPinpoint": false, "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [ "cit-musannaf-32655-isnad-matn", "cit-musannaf-32655-hukm" ], "riwayaRefs": [ "riwaya-musannaf-32655" ], "sourceRefs": [ "source-musannaf-ibn-abi-shayba-bayat-zubayr-32655" ], "supportLevel": "exact", "target": { "edgeId": "edge-event-to-walid", "from": "void_zubayr_event_link", "to": "al_walid_ibn_abd_al_malik" }, "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": [] }, "edge:edge-mutamir-to-abu-usama": { "argumentRefs": [], "cardRefs": [], "citationRefs": [ "cit-musannaf-32655-isnad-matn", "cit-musannaf-32655-hukm" ], "evidenceRefs": [ "cit-musannaf-32655-isnad-matn", "cit-musannaf-32655-hukm" ], "icon": { "kindLabel": "حلقة الرواية", "meaning": "صلة النقل بين طرفي السهم والروايات التي تحملها", "status": "documented", "statusLabel": "إحالة موضعية مقابلة", "summary": "حدثنا معتمر" }, "id": "edge:edge-mutamir-to-abu-usama", "illaRefs": [], "kind": "edge", "label": "حدثنا معتمر", "matnRefs": [ "matn-32655-performance-formula", "matn-32655-contentious-description", "matn-32655-printed-name", "matn-32655-sword-claim" ], "rendered": true, "requiresPinpoint": false, "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [ "cit-musannaf-32655-isnad-matn", "cit-musannaf-32655-hukm" ], "riwayaRefs": [ "riwaya-musannaf-32655" ], "sourceRefs": [ "source-musannaf-ibn-abi-shayba-bayat-zubayr-32655" ], "supportLevel": "exact", "target": { "edgeId": "edge-mutamir-to-abu-usama", "from": "mutamir_ibn_sulayman", "to": "abu_usama" }, "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": [] }, "edge:edge-taymi-to-mutamir": { "argumentRefs": [], "cardRefs": [], "citationRefs": [ "cit-musannaf-32655-isnad-matn", "cit-musannaf-32655-hukm" ], "evidenceRefs": [ "cit-musannaf-32655-isnad-matn", "cit-musannaf-32655-hukm" ], "icon": { "kindLabel": "حلقة الرواية", "meaning": "صلة النقل بين طرفي السهم والروايات التي تحملها", "status": "documented", "statusLabel": "إحالة موضعية مقابلة", "summary": "عن أبيه" }, "id": "edge:edge-taymi-to-mutamir", "illaRefs": [], "kind": "edge", "label": "عن أبيه", "matnRefs": [ "matn-32655-performance-formula", "matn-32655-contentious-description", "matn-32655-printed-name", "matn-32655-sword-claim" ], "rendered": true, "requiresPinpoint": false, "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [ "cit-musannaf-32655-isnad-matn", "cit-musannaf-32655-hukm" ], "riwayaRefs": [ "riwaya-musannaf-32655" ], "sourceRefs": [ "source-musannaf-ibn-abi-shayba-bayat-zubayr-32655" ], "supportLevel": "exact", "target": { "edgeId": "edge-taymi-to-mutamir", "from": "sulayman_al_taymi", "to": "mutamir_ibn_sulayman" }, "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": [] }, "edge:edge-walid-to-taymi": { "argumentRefs": [], "cardRefs": [], "citationRefs": [ "cit-musannaf-32655-isnad-matn", "cit-musannaf-32655-hukm" ], "evidenceRefs": [ "cit-musannaf-32655-isnad-matn", "cit-musannaf-32655-hukm" ], "icon": { "kindLabel": "حلقة الرواية", "meaning": "صلة النقل بين طرفي السهم والروايات التي تحملها", "status": "documented", "statusLabel": "إحالة موضعية مقابلة", "summary": "وقال وليد بن عبد الملك" }, "id": "edge:edge-walid-to-taymi", "illaRefs": [], "kind": "edge", "label": "وقال وليد بن عبد الملك", "matnRefs": [ "matn-32655-performance-formula", "matn-32655-contentious-description", "matn-32655-printed-name", "matn-32655-sword-claim" ], "rendered": true, "requiresPinpoint": false, "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [ "cit-musannaf-32655-isnad-matn", "cit-musannaf-32655-hukm" ], "riwayaRefs": [ "riwaya-musannaf-32655" ], "sourceRefs": [ "source-musannaf-ibn-abi-shayba-bayat-zubayr-32655" ], "supportLevel": "exact", "target": { "edgeId": "edge-walid-to-taymi", "from": "al_walid_ibn_abd_al_malik", "to": "sulayman_al_taymi" }, "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": [] }, "illa:illa-32655-missing-event-link": { "argumentRefs": [], "cardRefs": [], "citationRefs": [ "cit-musannaf-32655-isnad-matn", "cit-musannaf-32655-hukm" ], "evidenceRefs": [ "cit-musannaf-32655-isnad-matn", "cit-musannaf-32655-hukm" ], "icon": { "kindLabel": "مسألة نقدية", "meaning": "العلة أو الاعتراض بنطاقه ومصدره", "status": "documented", "statusLabel": "إحالة موضعية مقابلة", "summary": "يعزو سليمان التيمي القول إلى الوليد بن عبد الملك، لكن النص لا يسمّي من نقل إلى الوليد حوار الزبير في مجلس البيعة ولا يصف الوليد بأنه شهده؛ لذلك لا يسد تصحيح المحقق فراغ الوصول إلى الواقعة. — هذا قيد في اتصال الدعوى بالواقعة، لا جرح في سليمان التيمي ولا في الوليد، ولا تكذيب لمضمون القول." }, "id": "illa:illa-32655-missing-event-link", "illaRefs": [ "illa-32655-missing-event-link" ], "kind": "illa", "label": "لا ناقل مسمى من مجلس الزبير إلى الوليد", "matnRefs": [], "rendered": true, "requiresPinpoint": false, "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [ "cit-musannaf-32655-isnad-matn", "cit-musannaf-32655-hukm" ], "riwayaRefs": [ "riwaya-musannaf-32655" ], "sourceRefs": [ "source-musannaf-ibn-abi-shayba-bayat-zubayr-32655" ], "supportLevel": "exact", "target": { "id": "edge-event-to-walid", "kind": "edge" }, "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": [] }, "matn:matn-32655-contentious-description": { "argumentRefs": [], "cardRefs": [], "citationRefs": [ "cit-musannaf-32655-isnad-matn" ], "evidenceRefs": [ "cit-musannaf-32655-isnad-matn" ], "icon": { "kindLabel": "لفظ المتن", "meaning": "النص أو الزيادة بلفظها وموضعها", "status": "documented", "statusLabel": "إحالة موضعية مقابلة", "summary": "إن منافقاً من منافقي أهل العراق" }, "id": "matn:matn-32655-contentious-description", "illaRefs": [], "kind": "matn", "label": "وصف داخل قول الوليد؛ ليس حكماً للخريطة", "matnRefs": [ "matn-32655-contentious-description" ], "rendered": true, "requiresPinpoint": false, "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [ "cit-musannaf-32655-isnad-matn" ], "riwayaRefs": [ "riwaya-musannaf-32655" ], "sourceRefs": [ "source-musannaf-ibn-abi-shayba-bayat-zubayr-32655" ], "supportLevel": "exact", "target": { "matnId": "matn-32655-contentious-description" }, "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": [] }, "matn:matn-32655-performance-formula": { "argumentRefs": [], "cardRefs": [], "citationRefs": [ "cit-musannaf-32655-isnad-matn" ], "evidenceRefs": [ "cit-musannaf-32655-isnad-matn" ], "icon": { "kindLabel": "لفظ المتن", "meaning": "النص أو الزيادة بلفظها وموضعها", "status": "documented", "statusLabel": "إحالة موضعية مقابلة", "summary": "قال التيمي: وقال وليد بن عبد الملك" }, "id": "matn:matn-32655-performance-formula", "illaRefs": [], "kind": "matn", "label": "صيغة التيمي في نسبة القول", "matnRefs": [ "matn-32655-performance-formula" ], "rendered": true, "requiresPinpoint": false, "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [ "cit-musannaf-32655-isnad-matn" ], "riwayaRefs": [ "riwaya-musannaf-32655" ], "sourceRefs": [ "source-musannaf-ibn-abi-shayba-bayat-zubayr-32655" ], "supportLevel": "exact", "target": { "matnId": "matn-32655-performance-formula" }, "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": [] }, "matn:matn-32655-printed-name": { "argumentRefs": [], "cardRefs": [], "citationRefs": [ "cit-musannaf-32655-isnad-matn" ], "evidenceRefs": [ "cit-musannaf-32655-isnad-matn" ], "icon": { "kindLabel": "لفظ المتن", "meaning": "النص أو الزيادة بلفظها وموضعها", "status": "documented", "statusLabel": "إحالة موضعية مقابلة", "summary": "جبلة بن حكيم" }, "id": "matn:matn-32655-printed-name", "illaRefs": [], "kind": "matn", "label": "الاسم المطبوع بلا تصحيح افتراضي", "matnRefs": [ "matn-32655-printed-name" ], "rendered": true, "requiresPinpoint": false, "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [ "cit-musannaf-32655-isnad-matn" ], "riwayaRefs": [ "riwaya-musannaf-32655" ], "sourceRefs": [ "source-musannaf-ibn-abi-shayba-bayat-zubayr-32655" ], "supportLevel": "exact", "target": { "matnId": "matn-32655-printed-name" }, "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": [] }, "matn:matn-32655-sword-claim": { "argumentRefs": [], "cardRefs": [], "citationRefs": [ "cit-musannaf-32655-isnad-matn" ], "evidenceRefs": [ "cit-musannaf-32655-isnad-matn" ], "icon": { "kindLabel": "لفظ المتن", "meaning": "النص أو الزيادة بلفظها وموضعها", "status": "documented", "statusLabel": "إحالة موضعية مقابلة", "summary": "إن السيف وضع على عنقي، فقيل لي: بايع وإلا قتلناك. قال: فبايعت" }, "id": "matn:matn-32655-sword-claim", "illaRefs": [], "kind": "matn", "label": "دعوى الإكراه المنسوبة إلى الزبير داخل قول الوليد", "matnRefs": [ "matn-32655-sword-claim" ], "rendered": true, "requiresPinpoint": false, "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [ "cit-musannaf-32655-isnad-matn" ], "riwayaRefs": [ "riwaya-musannaf-32655" ], "sourceRefs": [ "source-musannaf-ibn-abi-shayba-bayat-zubayr-32655" ], "supportLevel": "exact", "target": { "matnId": "matn-32655-sword-claim" }, "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": [] }, "node:abu_usama": { "argumentRefs": [], "cardRefs": [], "citationRefs": [ "cit-musannaf-32655-isnad-matn" ], "evidenceRefs": [ "cit-musannaf-32655-isnad-matn" ], "icon": { "kindLabel": "الراوي أو العقدة", "meaning": "تعريف العنصر ونص بياناته", "status": "documented", "statusLabel": "إحالة موضعية مقابلة", "summary": "أبو أسامة — شيخ ابن أبي شيبة في السند السابق الذي عطف عليه ح32655" }, "id": "node:abu_usama", "illaRefs": [], "kind": "node", "label": "أبو أسامة", "matnRefs": [], "rendered": true, "requiresPinpoint": false, "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [ "cit-musannaf-32655-isnad-matn" ], "riwayaRefs": [], "sourceRefs": [ "source-musannaf-ibn-abi-shayba-bayat-zubayr-32655" ], "supportLevel": "exact", "target": { "field": "identity", "nodeId": "abu_usama" }, "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": [] }, "node:al_walid_ibn_abd_al_malik": { "argumentRefs": [], "cardRefs": [], "citationRefs": [ "cit-musannaf-32655-isnad-matn" ], "evidenceRefs": [ "cit-musannaf-32655-isnad-matn" ], "icon": { "kindLabel": "الراوي أو العقدة", "meaning": "تعريف العنصر ونص بياناته", "status": "documented", "statusLabel": "إحالة موضعية مقابلة", "summary": "الوليد بن عبد الملك — القائل المسمى؛ لا يقدمه النص شاهداً لمجلس الزبير" }, "id": "node:al_walid_ibn_abd_al_malik", "illaRefs": [], "kind": "node", "label": "الوليد بن عبد الملك", "matnRefs": [], "rendered": true, "requiresPinpoint": false, "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [ "cit-musannaf-32655-isnad-matn" ], "riwayaRefs": [], "sourceRefs": [ "source-musannaf-ibn-abi-shayba-bayat-zubayr-32655" ], "supportLevel": "exact", "target": { "field": "identity", "nodeId": "al_walid_ibn_abd_al_malik" }, "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": [] }, "node:musannaf_32655": { "argumentRefs": [], "cardRefs": [], "citationRefs": [ "cit-musannaf-32655-isnad-matn", "cit-musannaf-32655-hukm" ], "evidenceRefs": [ "cit-musannaf-32655-isnad-matn", "cit-musannaf-32655-hukm" ], "icon": { "kindLabel": "الراوي أو العقدة", "meaning": "تعريف العنصر ونص بياناته", "status": "documented", "statusLabel": "إحالة موضعية مقابلة", "summary": "مصنف ابن أبي شيبة، ح32655 — ج17، ص134؛ حكم المحقق المطبوع: صحيح" }, "id": "node:musannaf_32655", "illaRefs": [], "kind": "node", "label": "مصنف ابن أبي شيبة، ح32655", "matnRefs": [], "rendered": true, "requiresPinpoint": false, "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [ "cit-musannaf-32655-isnad-matn", "cit-musannaf-32655-hukm" ], "riwayaRefs": [], "sourceRefs": [ "source-musannaf-ibn-abi-shayba-bayat-zubayr-32655" ], "supportLevel": "exact", "target": { "field": "identity", "nodeId": "musannaf_32655" }, "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": [] }, "node:mutamir_ibn_sulayman": { "argumentRefs": [], "cardRefs": [], "citationRefs": [ "cit-musannaf-32655-isnad-matn" ], "evidenceRefs": [ "cit-musannaf-32655-isnad-matn" ], "icon": { "kindLabel": "الراوي أو العقدة", "meaning": "تعريف العنصر ونص بياناته", "status": "documented", "statusLabel": "إحالة موضعية مقابلة", "summary": "معتمر بن سليمان — يروي عن أبيه في السند السابق الذي عطف عليه ح32655" }, "id": "node:mutamir_ibn_sulayman", "illaRefs": [], "kind": "node", "label": "معتمر بن سليمان", "matnRefs": [], "rendered": true, "requiresPinpoint": false, "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [ "cit-musannaf-32655-isnad-matn" ], "riwayaRefs": [], "sourceRefs": [ "source-musannaf-ibn-abi-shayba-bayat-zubayr-32655" ], "supportLevel": "exact", "target": { "field": "identity", "nodeId": "mutamir_ibn_sulayman" }, "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": [] }, "node:sulayman_al_taymi": { "argumentRefs": [], "cardRefs": [], "citationRefs": [ "cit-musannaf-32655-isnad-matn" ], "evidenceRefs": [ "cit-musannaf-32655-isnad-matn" ], "icon": { "kindLabel": "الراوي أو العقدة", "meaning": "تعريف العنصر ونص بياناته", "status": "documented", "statusLabel": "إحالة موضعية مقابلة", "summary": "سليمان التيمي — «قال التيمي: وقال وليد بن عبد الملك»" }, "id": "node:sulayman_al_taymi", "illaRefs": [], "kind": "node", "label": "سليمان التيمي", "matnRefs": [], "rendered": true, "requiresPinpoint": false, "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [ "cit-musannaf-32655-isnad-matn" ], "riwayaRefs": [], "sourceRefs": [ "source-musannaf-ibn-abi-shayba-bayat-zubayr-32655" ], "supportLevel": "exact", "target": { "field": "identity", "nodeId": "sulayman_al_taymi" }, "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": [] }, "node:void_zubayr_event_link": { "argumentRefs": [], "cardRefs": [], "citationRefs": [ "cit-musannaf-32655-isnad-matn" ], "evidenceRefs": [ "cit-musannaf-32655-isnad-matn" ], "icon": { "kindLabel": "الراوي أو العقدة", "meaning": "تعريف العنصر ونص بياناته", "status": "documented", "statusLabel": "إحالة موضعية مقابلة", "summary": "مجلس الزبير — لا ناقل مسمى — الفراغ بين الواقعة وقول الوليد هو محل التوقف" }, "id": "node:void_zubayr_event_link", "illaRefs": [], "kind": "node", "label": "مجلس الزبير — لا ناقل مسمى", "matnRefs": [], "rendered": true, "requiresPinpoint": false, "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [ "cit-musannaf-32655-isnad-matn" ], "riwayaRefs": [], "sourceRefs": [ "source-musannaf-ibn-abi-shayba-bayat-zubayr-32655" ], "supportLevel": "exact", "target": { "field": "identity", "nodeId": "void_zubayr_event_link" }, "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": [] }, "verdict": { "argumentRefs": [], "cardRefs": [], "citationRefs": [ "cit-musannaf-32655-isnad-matn" ], "evidenceRefs": [ "cit-musannaf-32655-isnad-matn" ], "icon": { "kindLabel": "خلاصة الدراسة", "meaning": "النتيجة المنسوبة إلى الدراسة وحدود الاستدلال", "status": "documented", "statusLabel": "إحالة موضعية مقابلة", "summary": "يحفظ ح32655 قول الوليد بن عبد الملك وفيه دعوى أن الزبير بايع بعد وضع السيف على عنقه؛ لكن النص لا يسمّي ناقلاً من مجلس الزبير إلى الوليد، فلا يثبت بهذا الطريق وحده الإكراه بوصفه واقعة مقفلة، ولا تصحح «جبلة بن حكيم» إلى «حكيم بن جبلة» بلا حجة" }, "id": "verdict", "illaRefs": [], "kind": "verdict", "label": "يحفظ ح32655 قول الوليد بن عبد الملك وفيه دعوى أن الزبير بايع بعد وضع السيف على عنقه؛ لكن النص لا يسمّي ناقلاً من مجلس الزبير إلى الوليد، فلا يثبت بهذا الطريق وحده الإكراه بوصفه واقعة مقفلة، ولا تصحح «جبلة بن حكيم» إلى «حكيم بن جبلة» بلا حجة", "matnRefs": [], "rendered": true, "requiresPinpoint": false, "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [ "cit-musannaf-32655-isnad-matn" ], "riwayaRefs": [], "sourceRefs": [ "source-musannaf-ibn-abi-shayba-bayat-zubayr-32655" ], "supportLevel": "exact", "target": { "field": "verdict" }, "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": [] } }, "order": [ "node:void_zubayr_event_link", "node:al_walid_ibn_abd_al_malik", "city:al_walid_ibn_abd_al_malik", "node:sulayman_al_taymi", "city:sulayman_al_taymi", "node:mutamir_ibn_sulayman", "city:mutamir_ibn_sulayman", "node:abu_usama", "city:abu_usama", "node:musannaf_32655", "edge:edge-event-to-walid", "edge:edge-walid-to-taymi", "edge:edge-taymi-to-mutamir", "edge:edge-mutamir-to-abu-usama", "edge:edge-abu-usama-to-musannaf", "illa:illa-32655-missing-event-link", "matn:matn-32655-performance-formula", "matn:matn-32655-contentious-description", "matn:matn-32655-printed-name", "matn:matn-32655-sword-claim", "verdict", "argument:arg-32655-reaches-walid-not-event", "argument:arg-32655-preserve-printed-name", "argument:arg-32655-quarantine-description", "argument:arg-32655-single-family-environment", "argument:arg-32655-variant-not-body" ] }, "map": { "chapter": "02_manuscript/bab_04_factory_riwaya/14b_bayat_talha_wa_zubayr_wa_naqd_jafar.md", "dependencyHash": "677d3e45f5f41a24", "id": "athar_bayat_zubayr_sayf", "ref": "isnad:athar_bayat_zubayr_sayf@v3", "sourceFile": "08_assets/isnad/athar_bayat_zubayr_sayf.json", "sourceHash": "782de5612f396722", "version": 3 }, "matnVariants": [ { "citationRefs": [ "cit-musannaf-32655-isnad-matn" ], "evidenceRefs": [ "cit-musannaf-32655-isnad-matn" ], "id": "matn-32655-performance-formula", "label": "صيغة التيمي في نسبة القول", "riwayaRefs": [ "riwaya-musannaf-32655" ], "role": "context", "subject": null, "text": "قال التيمي: وقال وليد بن عبد الملك" }, { "citationRefs": [ "cit-musannaf-32655-isnad-matn" ], "evidenceRefs": [ "cit-musannaf-32655-isnad-matn" ], "id": "matn-32655-contentious-description", "label": "وصف داخل قول الوليد؛ ليس حكماً للخريطة", "riwayaRefs": [ "riwaya-musannaf-32655" ], "role": "context", "subject": null, "text": "إن منافقاً من منافقي أهل العراق" }, { "citationRefs": [ "cit-musannaf-32655-isnad-matn" ], "evidenceRefs": [ "cit-musannaf-32655-isnad-matn" ], "id": "matn-32655-printed-name", "label": "الاسم المطبوع بلا تصحيح افتراضي", "riwayaRefs": [ "riwaya-musannaf-32655" ], "role": "context", "subject": null, "text": "جبلة بن حكيم" }, { "citationRefs": [ "cit-musannaf-32655-isnad-matn" ], "evidenceRefs": [ "cit-musannaf-32655-isnad-matn" ], "id": "matn-32655-sword-claim", "label": "دعوى الإكراه المنسوبة إلى الزبير داخل قول الوليد", "riwayaRefs": [ "riwaya-musannaf-32655" ], "role": "variant", "subject": null, "text": "إن السيف وضع على عنقي، فقيل لي: بايع وإلا قتلناك. قال: فبايعت" } ], "narrators": [ { "card": null, "city": null, "coverage": { "applicableFields": 3, "exactFields": 2, "status": "partial", "unresolvedFields": 1 }, "death": null, "evidenceRefs": { "identity": [ "cit-musannaf-32655-isnad-matn" ], "sub": [ "cit-musannaf-32655-isnad-matn" ] }, "fieldCoverage": { "card": { "cardRefs": [], "citationRefs": [], "evidenceRefs": [], "requiresPinpoint": false, "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [], "sourceRefs": [], "state": "not_applicable", "supportLevel": null, "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": [] }, "city": { "cardRefs": [], "citationRefs": [], "evidenceRefs": [], "requiresPinpoint": true, "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [], "sourceRefs": [], "state": "missing_value", "supportLevel": "unresolved", "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": [] }, "death": { "cardRefs": [], "citationRefs": [], "evidenceRefs": [], "requiresPinpoint": false, "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [], "sourceRefs": [], "state": "not_applicable", "supportLevel": null, "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": [] }, "flags": { "cardRefs": [], "citationRefs": [], "evidenceRefs": [], "items": {}, "requiresPinpoint": false, "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [], "sourceRefs": [], "state": "not_applicable", "supportLevel": null, "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": [] }, "hukm": { "cardRefs": [], "citationRefs": [], "evidenceRefs": [], "requiresPinpoint": false, "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [], "sourceRefs": [], "state": "not_applicable", "supportLevel": null, "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": [] }, "label": { "cardRefs": [], "citationRefs": [ "cit-musannaf-32655-isnad-matn" ], "evidenceRefs": [ "cit-musannaf-32655-isnad-matn" ], "requiresPinpoint": false, "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [ "cit-musannaf-32655-isnad-matn" ], "sourceRefs": [ "source-musannaf-ibn-abi-shayba-bayat-zubayr-32655" ], "state": "exact", "supportLevel": "exact", "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": [] }, "sub": { "cardRefs": [], "citationRefs": [ "cit-musannaf-32655-isnad-matn" ], "evidenceRefs": [ "cit-musannaf-32655-isnad-matn" ], "requiresPinpoint": false, "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [ "cit-musannaf-32655-isnad-matn" ], "sourceRefs": [ "source-musannaf-ibn-abi-shayba-bayat-zubayr-32655" ], "state": "exact", "supportLevel": "exact", "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": [] } }, "flags": [], "hukm": null, "id": "al_walid_ibn_abd_al_malik", "kind": "rawi", "label": "الوليد بن عبد الملك", "sub": "القائل المسمى؛ لا يقدمه النص شاهداً لمجلس الزبير" }, { "card": null, "city": null, "coverage": { "applicableFields": 3, "exactFields": 2, "status": "partial", "unresolvedFields": 1 }, "death": null, "evidenceRefs": { "identity": [ "cit-musannaf-32655-isnad-matn" ], "sub": [ "cit-musannaf-32655-isnad-matn" ] }, "fieldCoverage": { "card": { "cardRefs": [], "citationRefs": [], "evidenceRefs": [], "requiresPinpoint": false, "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [], "sourceRefs": [], "state": "not_applicable", "supportLevel": null, "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": [] }, "city": { "cardRefs": [], "citationRefs": [], "evidenceRefs": [], "requiresPinpoint": true, "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [], "sourceRefs": [], "state": "missing_value", "supportLevel": "unresolved", "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": [] }, "death": { "cardRefs": [], "citationRefs": [], "evidenceRefs": [], "requiresPinpoint": false, "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [], "sourceRefs": [], "state": "not_applicable", "supportLevel": null, "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": [] }, "flags": { "cardRefs": [], "citationRefs": [], "evidenceRefs": [], "items": {}, "requiresPinpoint": false, "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [], "sourceRefs": [], "state": "not_applicable", "supportLevel": null, "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": [] }, "hukm": { "cardRefs": [], "citationRefs": [], "evidenceRefs": [], "requiresPinpoint": false, "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [], "sourceRefs": [], "state": "not_applicable", "supportLevel": null, "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": [] }, "label": { "cardRefs": [], "citationRefs": [ "cit-musannaf-32655-isnad-matn" ], "evidenceRefs": [ "cit-musannaf-32655-isnad-matn" ], "requiresPinpoint": false, "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [ "cit-musannaf-32655-isnad-matn" ], "sourceRefs": [ "source-musannaf-ibn-abi-shayba-bayat-zubayr-32655" ], "state": "exact", "supportLevel": "exact", "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": [] }, "sub": { "cardRefs": [], "citationRefs": [ "cit-musannaf-32655-isnad-matn" ], "evidenceRefs": [ "cit-musannaf-32655-isnad-matn" ], "requiresPinpoint": false, "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [ "cit-musannaf-32655-isnad-matn" ], "sourceRefs": [ "source-musannaf-ibn-abi-shayba-bayat-zubayr-32655" ], "state": "exact", "supportLevel": "exact", "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": [] } }, "flags": [], "hukm": null, "id": "sulayman_al_taymi", "kind": "rawi", "label": "سليمان التيمي", "sub": "«قال التيمي: وقال وليد بن عبد الملك»" }, { "card": null, "city": null, "coverage": { "applicableFields": 3, "exactFields": 2, "status": "partial", "unresolvedFields": 1 }, "death": null, "evidenceRefs": { "identity": [ "cit-musannaf-32655-isnad-matn" ], "sub": [ "cit-musannaf-32655-isnad-matn" ] }, "fieldCoverage": { "card": { "cardRefs": [], "citationRefs": [], "evidenceRefs": [], "requiresPinpoint": false, "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [], "sourceRefs": [], "state": "not_applicable", "supportLevel": null, "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": [] }, "city": { "cardRefs": [], "citationRefs": [], "evidenceRefs": [], "requiresPinpoint": true, "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [], "sourceRefs": [], "state": "missing_value", "supportLevel": "unresolved", "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": [] }, "death": { "cardRefs": [], "citationRefs": [], "evidenceRefs": [], "requiresPinpoint": false, "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [], "sourceRefs": [], "state": "not_applicable", "supportLevel": null, "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": [] }, "flags": { "cardRefs": [], "citationRefs": [], "evidenceRefs": [], "items": {}, "requiresPinpoint": false, "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [], "sourceRefs": [], "state": "not_applicable", "supportLevel": null, "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": [] }, "hukm": { "cardRefs": [], "citationRefs": [], "evidenceRefs": [], "requiresPinpoint": false, "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [], "sourceRefs": [], "state": "not_applicable", "supportLevel": null, "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": [] }, "label": { "cardRefs": [], "citationRefs": [ "cit-musannaf-32655-isnad-matn" ], "evidenceRefs": [ "cit-musannaf-32655-isnad-matn" ], "requiresPinpoint": false, "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [ "cit-musannaf-32655-isnad-matn" ], "sourceRefs": [ "source-musannaf-ibn-abi-shayba-bayat-zubayr-32655" ], "state": "exact", "supportLevel": "exact", "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": [] }, "sub": { "cardRefs": [], "citationRefs": [ "cit-musannaf-32655-isnad-matn" ], "evidenceRefs": [ "cit-musannaf-32655-isnad-matn" ], "requiresPinpoint": false, "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [ "cit-musannaf-32655-isnad-matn" ], "sourceRefs": [ "source-musannaf-ibn-abi-shayba-bayat-zubayr-32655" ], "state": "exact", "supportLevel": "exact", "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": [] } }, "flags": [], "hukm": null, "id": "mutamir_ibn_sulayman", "kind": "rawi", "label": "معتمر بن سليمان", "sub": "يروي عن أبيه في السند السابق الذي عطف عليه ح32655" }, { "card": null, "city": null, "coverage": { "applicableFields": 3, "exactFields": 2, "status": "partial", "unresolvedFields": 1 }, "death": null, "evidenceRefs": { "identity": [ "cit-musannaf-32655-isnad-matn" ], "sub": [ "cit-musannaf-32655-isnad-matn" ] }, "fieldCoverage": { "card": { "cardRefs": [], "citationRefs": [], "evidenceRefs": [], "requiresPinpoint": false, "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [], "sourceRefs": [], "state": "not_applicable", "supportLevel": null, "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": [] }, "city": { "cardRefs": [], "citationRefs": [], "evidenceRefs": [], "requiresPinpoint": true, "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [], "sourceRefs": [], "state": "missing_value", "supportLevel": "unresolved", "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": [] }, "death": { "cardRefs": [], "citationRefs": [], "evidenceRefs": [], "requiresPinpoint": false, "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [], "sourceRefs": [], "state": "not_applicable", "supportLevel": null, "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": [] }, "flags": { "cardRefs": [], "citationRefs": [], "evidenceRefs": [], "items": {}, "requiresPinpoint": false, "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [], "sourceRefs": [], "state": "not_applicable", "supportLevel": null, "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": [] }, "hukm": { "cardRefs": [], "citationRefs": [], "evidenceRefs": [], "requiresPinpoint": false, "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [], "sourceRefs": [], "state": "not_applicable", "supportLevel": null, "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": [] }, "label": { "cardRefs": [], "citationRefs": [ "cit-musannaf-32655-isnad-matn" ], "evidenceRefs": [ "cit-musannaf-32655-isnad-matn" ], "requiresPinpoint": false, "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [ "cit-musannaf-32655-isnad-matn" ], "sourceRefs": [ "source-musannaf-ibn-abi-shayba-bayat-zubayr-32655" ], "state": "exact", "supportLevel": "exact", "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": [] }, "sub": { "cardRefs": [], "citationRefs": [ "cit-musannaf-32655-isnad-matn" ], "evidenceRefs": [ "cit-musannaf-32655-isnad-matn" ], "requiresPinpoint": false, "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [ "cit-musannaf-32655-isnad-matn" ], "sourceRefs": [ "source-musannaf-ibn-abi-shayba-bayat-zubayr-32655" ], "state": "exact", "supportLevel": "exact", "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": [] } }, "flags": [], "hukm": null, "id": "abu_usama", "kind": "rawi", "label": "أبو أسامة", "sub": "شيخ ابن أبي شيبة في السند السابق الذي عطف عليه ح32655" } ], "pipelineVersion": 7, "provenanceCoverage": { "arguments": 5, "citations": 3, "dependencyHash": "677d3e45f5f41a24", "exactHotspots": 22, "illal": 1, "matnVariants": 4, "missingCards": [], "missingSources": [], "narrators": 4, "percentExact": 84.6, "riwayat": 1, "status": "incomplete", "totalHotspots": 26, "transmissions": 5, "unresolvedHotspots": 4 }, "provenanceStatus": "verified_with_limits", "provenanceVersion": 2, "records": { "cards": [ { "contentHash": "ea20b05d4ad67fd8", "exists": true, "id": "evidence-bayat-zubayr-sayf-ala-unq-wa-hadd-al-wusul", "path": "05_cards/evidences/bayat-zubayr-sayf-ala-unq-wa-hadd-al-wusul.md", "status": "verified_with_limits", "title": "أثر بيعة الزبير: دعوى السيف وحدّ الوصول إلى الواقعة" } ], "sources": [ { "author": "أبو بكر عبد الله بن محمد ابن أبي شيبة العبسي الكوفي", "authorDeathHijri": "235", "contentHash": "bb7b9e1dfb249d7d", "exists": true, "id": "source-musannaf-ibn-abi-shayba-bayat-zubayr-32655", "path": "04_source_bank/source_musannaf_ibn_abi_shayba_bayat_zubayr_32655.md", "status": "verified", "title": "المصنف لابن أبي شيبة — خبر بيعة الزبير ح32655" } ] }, "riwayat": [ { "chain": [ "void_zubayr_event_link", "al_walid_ibn_abd_al_malik", "sulayman_al_taymi", "mutamir_ibn_sulayman", "abu_usama", "musannaf_32655" ], "citationRefs": [ "cit-musannaf-32655-isnad-matn", "cit-musannaf-32655-hukm" ], "evidenceRefs": [ "cit-musannaf-32655-isnad-matn", "cit-musannaf-32655-hukm" ], "familyId": "family-zubayr-walid-32655", "hukm": { "attribution": "محقق طبعة الشثري", "citationRefs": [ "cit-musannaf-32655-hukm" ], "value": "صحيح" }, "hukmCitationRefs": [ "cit-musannaf-32655-hukm" ], "hukmEvidenceRefs": [ "cit-musannaf-32655-hukm" ], "id": "riwaya-musannaf-32655", "ilal": [ { "citationRefs": [ "cit-musannaf-32655-isnad-matn", "cit-musannaf-32655-hukm" ], "id": "illa-32655-missing-event-link", "kind": "انقطاع رابط الواقعة", "label": "لا ناقل مسمى من مجلس الزبير إلى الوليد", "limitations": "هذا قيد في اتصال الدعوى بالواقعة، لا جرح في سليمان التيمي ولا في الوليد، ولا تكذيب لمضمون القول.", "matnRefs": [ "matn-32655-performance-formula", "matn-32655-sword-claim" ], "statement": "يعزو سليمان التيمي القول إلى الوليد بن عبد الملك، لكن النص لا يسمّي من نقل إلى الوليد حوار الزبير في مجلس البيعة ولا يصف الوليد بأنه شهده؛ لذلك لا يسد تصحيح المحقق فراغ الوصول إلى الواقعة.", "target": "edge:edge-event-to-walid" } ], "illaRefs": [ "illa-32655-missing-event-link" ], "label": "مصنف ابن أبي شيبة ح32655: قول الوليد ودعوى السيف على عنق الزبير", "matnRefs": [ "matn-32655-performance-formula", "matn-32655-contentious-description", "matn-32655-printed-name", "matn-32655-sword-claim" ], "matnVariants": [ { "citationRefs": [ "cit-musannaf-32655-isnad-matn" ], "id": "matn-32655-performance-formula", "label": "صيغة التيمي في نسبة القول", "role": "context", "text": "قال التيمي: وقال وليد بن عبد الملك" }, { "citationRefs": [ "cit-musannaf-32655-isnad-matn" ], "id": "matn-32655-contentious-description", "label": "وصف داخل قول الوليد؛ ليس حكماً للخريطة", "role": "context", "text": "إن منافقاً من منافقي أهل العراق" }, { "citationRefs": [ "cit-musannaf-32655-isnad-matn" ], "id": "matn-32655-printed-name", "label": "الاسم المطبوع بلا تصحيح افتراضي", "role": "context", "text": "جبلة بن حكيم" }, { "citationRefs": [ "cit-musannaf-32655-isnad-matn" ], "id": "matn-32655-sword-claim", "label": "دعوى الإكراه المنسوبة إلى الزبير داخل قول الوليد", "role": "variant", "text": "إن السيف وضع على عنقي، فقيل لي: بايع وإلا قتلناك. قال: فبايعت" } ], "nodePath": [ "void_zubayr_event_link", "al_walid_ibn_abd_al_malik", "sulayman_al_taymi", "mutamir_ibn_sulayman", "abu_usama", "musannaf_32655" ] } ], "schemaVersion": 2, "transmissions": [ { "cardRefs": [], "citationRefs": [ "cit-musannaf-32655-isnad-matn", "cit-musannaf-32655-hukm" ], "evidenceRefs": { "note": [ "cit-musannaf-32655-isnad-matn" ], "status": [ "cit-musannaf-32655-isnad-matn" ] }, "from": "void_zubayr_event_link", "id": "edge-event-to-walid", "illaRefs": [ "illa-32655-missing-event-link" ], "matnRefs": [ "matn-32655-performance-formula", "matn-32655-contentious-description", "matn-32655-printed-name", "matn-32655-sword-claim" ], "note": "لا ناقل مسمى من مجلس الزبير إلى الوليد", "requiresPinpoint": false, "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [ "cit-musannaf-32655-isnad-matn", "cit-musannaf-32655-hukm" ], "riwayaRefs": [ "riwaya-musannaf-32655" ], "sourceRefs": [ "source-musannaf-ibn-abi-shayba-bayat-zubayr-32655" ], "status": "munqati", "supportLevel": "exact", "to": "al_walid_ibn_abd_al_malik", "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": [] }, { "cardRefs": [], "citationRefs": [ "cit-musannaf-32655-isnad-matn", "cit-musannaf-32655-hukm" ], "evidenceRefs": { "note": [ "cit-musannaf-32655-isnad-matn" ] }, "from": "al_walid_ibn_abd_al_malik", "id": "edge-walid-to-taymi", "illaRefs": [], "matnRefs": [ "matn-32655-performance-formula", "matn-32655-contentious-description", "matn-32655-printed-name", "matn-32655-sword-claim" ], "note": "وقال وليد بن عبد الملك", "requiresPinpoint": false, "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [ "cit-musannaf-32655-isnad-matn", "cit-musannaf-32655-hukm" ], "riwayaRefs": [ "riwaya-musannaf-32655" ], "sourceRefs": [ "source-musannaf-ibn-abi-shayba-bayat-zubayr-32655" ], "status": "mahfuz", "supportLevel": "exact", "to": "sulayman_al_taymi", "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": [] }, { "cardRefs": [], "citationRefs": [ "cit-musannaf-32655-isnad-matn", "cit-musannaf-32655-hukm" ], "evidenceRefs": { "note": [ "cit-musannaf-32655-isnad-matn" ] }, "from": "sulayman_al_taymi", "id": "edge-taymi-to-mutamir", "illaRefs": [], "matnRefs": [ "matn-32655-performance-formula", "matn-32655-contentious-description", "matn-32655-printed-name", "matn-32655-sword-claim" ], "note": "عن أبيه", "requiresPinpoint": false, "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [ "cit-musannaf-32655-isnad-matn", "cit-musannaf-32655-hukm" ], "riwayaRefs": [ "riwaya-musannaf-32655" ], "sourceRefs": [ "source-musannaf-ibn-abi-shayba-bayat-zubayr-32655" ], "status": "mahfuz", "supportLevel": "exact", "to": "mutamir_ibn_sulayman", "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": [] }, { "cardRefs": [], "citationRefs": [ "cit-musannaf-32655-isnad-matn", "cit-musannaf-32655-hukm" ], "evidenceRefs": { "note": [ "cit-musannaf-32655-isnad-matn" ] }, "from": "mutamir_ibn_sulayman", "id": "edge-mutamir-to-abu-usama", "illaRefs": [], "matnRefs": [ "matn-32655-performance-formula", "matn-32655-contentious-description", "matn-32655-printed-name", "matn-32655-sword-claim" ], "note": "حدثنا معتمر", "requiresPinpoint": false, "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [ "cit-musannaf-32655-isnad-matn", "cit-musannaf-32655-hukm" ], "riwayaRefs": [ "riwaya-musannaf-32655" ], "sourceRefs": [ "source-musannaf-ibn-abi-shayba-bayat-zubayr-32655" ], "status": "mahfuz", "supportLevel": "exact", "to": "abu_usama", "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": [] }, { "cardRefs": [], "citationRefs": [ "cit-musannaf-32655-isnad-matn", "cit-musannaf-32655-hukm" ], "evidenceRefs": { "note": [ "cit-musannaf-32655-isnad-matn" ] }, "from": "abu_usama", "id": "edge-abu-usama-to-musannaf", "illaRefs": [], "matnRefs": [ "matn-32655-performance-formula", "matn-32655-contentious-description", "matn-32655-printed-name", "matn-32655-sword-claim" ], "note": "حدثنا أبو أسامة", "requiresPinpoint": false, "resolvedEvidenceRefs": [ "cit-musannaf-32655-isnad-matn", "cit-musannaf-32655-hukm" ], "riwayaRefs": [ "riwaya-musannaf-32655" ], "sourceRefs": [ "source-musannaf-ibn-abi-shayba-bayat-zubayr-32655" ], "status": "mahfuz", "supportLevel": "exact", "to": "musannaf_32655", "unresolvedEvidenceRefs": [] } ] }