{
  "id": "ashara_saeed_ibnzalim_3",
  "ref": "isnad:ashara_saeed_ibnzalim_3@v3",
  "version": 3,
  "updated": "2026-09-18",
  "sourceHash": "f79c49f602cd36cd",
  "generated": "2026-09-25T02:14:07.209Z",
  "evidencePipelineVersion": 7,
  "rendererVersion": "evidence-icons-guide-matns-v2",
  "readingGuideHash": "facc96bcb912a35c",
  "evidenceHash": "758857ed5149f5a3",
  "dependencyHash": "15a592894faf8b79",
  "provenanceStatus": "draft",
  "evidenceStatus": "incomplete",
  "provenanceCoverage": {
    "status": "incomplete",
    "totalHotspots": 64,
    "exactHotspots": 0,
    "unresolvedHotspots": 64,
    "percentExact": 0,
    "citations": 7,
    "riwayat": 4,
    "arguments": 1,
    "illal": 1,
    "matnVariants": 4,
    "narrators": 17,
    "transmissions": 21,
    "dependencyHash": "15a592894faf8b79",
    "missingSources": [],
    "missingCards": []
  },
  "iconCoverage": {
    "policy": "evidence-icons-v1",
    "expected": 64,
    "rendered": 64,
    "missing": [],
    "byKind": {
      "node": 19,
      "city": 16,
      "hukm": 1,
      "edge": 21,
      "illa": 1,
      "matn": 4,
      "verdict": 1,
      "argument": 1
    }
  },
  "title": "هلال وابن ظالم واختلاف الواسطة — 3",
  "subtitle": "الأسانيد والمتون ومصادرها",
  "verdict": "اختيار الدراسة في الأوجه المعروضة: لا يصح الاحتجاج المستقل قبل حسم اختلاف الواسطة؛ نقل عن البخاري ولا يصح، ورجح الدارقطني الواسطة بين هلال وابن ظالم؛ وقال الترمذي حسن صحيح.",
  "theme": "manaqib_qaraba",
  "themeLabel": "المناقب وفضائل القرابة",
  "layout": "tree",
  "chapter": "02_manuscript/bab_08_al_mawsuaa_al_hadithiyya/19_hadith_al_ashara_al_mubashsharin.md",
  "cards": [
    "05_cards/naqd_marwiyat_nusrat_sahaba/ashra_full/saeed_routes.md",
    "05_cards/evidences/evidence-ashara-isnad-1-ibn-zalim-la-yasihh.md"
  ],
  "sources": [
    "source-ashra-shamela-1586",
    "source-ashra-shamela-6007",
    "source-ashra-crit-ibnzalim-bukhari",
    "source-ashra-crit-daraqutni663",
    "source-ashra-crit-tirmidhi3757"
  ],
  "url": "https://hazimat-al-dhakira-library.rcherara.chatgpt.site/asanid/ashara_saeed_ibnzalim_3",
  "qr": {
    "svg": "ashara_saeed_ibnzalim_3.qr.svg",
    "png": "ashara_saeed_ibnzalim_3.qr.png",
    "version": 6,
    "ecl": "M"
  },
  "source": "ashara_saeed_ibnzalim_3.json",
  "evidence": "ashara_saeed_ibnzalim_3.evidence.json",
  "svg": "ashara_saeed_ibnzalim_3.svg",
  "svgDark": "ashara_saeed_ibnzalim_3.dark.svg",
  "raster": [
    "ashara_saeed_ibnzalim_3.w480.png",
    "ashara_saeed_ibnzalim_3.w768.png",
    "ashara_saeed_ibnzalim_3.w1200.png",
    "ashara_saeed_ibnzalim_3.w1600.png",
    "ashara_saeed_ibnzalim_3.w2400.png",
    "ashara_saeed_ibnzalim_3.w2480.png"
  ],
  "rasterEngine": "rsvg-convert",
  "nodes": 19,
  "edges": 21,
  "flagsUsed": [],
  "cityBands": {
    "policy": "rawi-madar-city-or-unknown-v1",
    "eligibleNodes": 16,
    "documentedNodes": 0,
    "unknownNodes": [
      "n_feb3f3df09",
      "n_2b79fe1041",
      "n_75c68cfc0d",
      "n_b214fa85ce",
      "n_2610a3a8d7",
      "n_7b126fc81f",
      "n_7ef4bebcb2",
      "n_af653a0586",
      "n_acc2f1a4a7",
      "n_36e85368ce",
      "n_c8bf42bf22",
      "n_46047dbbcf",
      "n_2d07440723",
      "n_86b1e77066",
      "n_3d450b85fe",
      "n_9d06c50e88"
    ],
    "cities": [
      "unknown"
    ]
  },
  "width": 1101,
  "warnings": [
    "evidenceStatus=incomplete: 64/64 hotspots تحتاج تعيين المصدر والموضع"
  ],
  "history": [
    {
      "version": 1,
      "updated": "2026-09-14",
      "sourceHash": "81dd5f81f0d368a1",
      "dependencyHash": "dc9ddada2a7e1898",
      "evidenceHash": "5c468a0e85f70c9a",
      "evidenceStatus": "incomplete",
      "generated": "2026-09-15T03:41:06.041Z",
      "raster": true,
      "engine": null,
      "note": "حصر الأوجه في المصادر المفحوصة مع حفظ المتون والأسانيد وحدود المقابلة؛ ليس إثبات استيعاب."
    },
    {
      "version": 2,
      "updated": "2026-09-15",
      "sourceHash": "24cbeb5be6f59baa",
      "dependencyHash": "afcd7433627084f5",
      "evidenceHash": "02534aa9b56d5ec5",
      "evidenceStatus": "incomplete",
      "generated": "2026-09-17T01:15:51.745Z",
      "raster": true,
      "engine": null,
      "note": "تحرير 2026-09-15: إثبات نص البخاري (الضعفاء الكبير ترجمة827) وصنيع العقيلي؛ الحكم: لا يصح."
    },
    {
      "version": 3,
      "updated": "2026-09-18",
      "sourceHash": "f79c49f602cd36cd",
      "dependencyHash": "15a592894faf8b79",
      "evidenceHash": "758857ed5149f5a3",
      "evidenceStatus": "incomplete",
      "generated": "2026-09-25T02:14:07.209Z",
      "raster": true,
      "engine": null,
      "note": "حفظ حكم الترمذي حسن صحيح مع نقد البخاري وترجيح الدارقطني وتقييد الاختيار بالأوجه المعروضة."
    }
  ],
  "versionDir": "08_assets/images/isnad/ashara_saeed_ibnzalim_3/versions/v3"
}